Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation [2010] FCA 809

Citation: Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation [2010] FCA 809
Parties: JOSEPH ROE and CYRIL SHAW on behalf of the members of the Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr native title claim group v KIMBERLEY LAND COUNCIL ABORIGINAL CORPORATION
File number: WAD 74 of 2010
Judge: GILMOUR J
Date of judgment: 2 August 2010
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – standing of one only of two named persons as applicant in native title determination application to institute and continue proceedings in name of joint applicant – Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA) ss 61 and 62A – whether in these circumstances the lack of standing may be cured under the provisions of NTA s 84D.
Legislation: Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 3(c), 13, 61, 62A, 66B, 84D, 203BB, 203BC, 213(2), 253
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Part IVA, 33C
Federal Court Rules O 4 r 1, O 19, r 2
Cases cited: Ankamuthi People v State of Queensland (2002) 121 FCR 68 discussed
Butchulla People v State of Queensland (2006) 154 FCR 233 referred to
Johnson on behalf of theBarkandji (Paakantyi) People v Minister For Land and Water Conservation for the State of New South Wales [2003] FCA 981 referred to
Tullock v State of Western Australia [2010] FCA 351 referred to
Date of hearing: 15 June and 15 July 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the First-Named Applicant: Mr M Orlov
Solicitor for the First-Named Applicant: Chalk & Fitzgerald Lawyers
Counsel for the Second-Named Applicant: Mr B Eagle
Solicitor for the Second-Named Applicant: Eagle Partners
Counsel for the Respondent:

Mr V Hugston SC

Solicitor for the Respondent: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 74 of 2010

BETWEEN:

JOSEPH ROE and CYRIL SHAW on behalf of the members of the Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr native title claim group
Applicant

AND:

KIMBERLEY LAND COUNCIL ABORIGINAL CORPORATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

GILMOUR J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 AUGUST 2010

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The motion of Mr Joseph Roe dated 14 May 2010 be dismissed.

2.The amended motion of Mr Joseph Roe dated 13 July 2010 be dismissed.

3.The application be dismissed.

4.Joseph Edward Roe pay the costs of each of Cyril Shaw and the respondent of each of the motions and the application to be taxed.   

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 74 of 2010

BETWEEN:

JOSEPH ROE and CYRIL SHAW on behalf of the members of the Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr native title claim group
Applicant

AND:

KIMBERLEY LAND COUNCIL ABORIGINAL CORPORATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

GILMOUR J

DATE:

2 AUGUST 2010

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 809
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation, the applicant, Joseph Edward Roe, sought to challenge the validity of meetings held by the GJJ and Djaberra Djaberra native title claim groups and the resolutions passed at those meetings. The applicant aimed to declare the meetings and resolutions invalid and sought injunctive relief against the Kimberley Land Council (KLC) to prevent them from acting on behalf of the GJJ claim group. The KLC argued that the proceeding should be dismissed as Joseph Edward Roe had no standing to pursue it as he was only one of two named applicants and could not act alone. The court had to determine whether the lack of standing could be cured under the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The court considered that the Native Title Act granted standing exclusively to the applicant to deal with all matters arising under the NTA in relation to the claimant application. The applicant argued that the word “may” in s 62A was permissive only and did not confer standing exclusively upon the applicant. However, the court rejected this submission, finding that the purpose of s 62A, read together with s 61, was to confer upon the applicant the entitlement to deal with all matters arising under the NTA in relation to the application.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the application, finding that Joseph Edward Roe had no standing to pursue the proceeding as he was only one of two named applicants and could not act alone. The court held that the lack of standing could not be cured under the provisions of the Native Title Act. The court dismissed the motion and the application, and ordered Joseph Edward Roe to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The motion of Mr Joseph Roe dated 14 May 2010 be dismissed.

2. The amended motion of Mr Joseph Roe dated 13 July 2010 be dismissed.

3. The application be dismissed.

4. Joseph Edward Roe pay the costs of each of Cyril Shaw and the respondent of each of the motions and the application to be taxed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

It will become apparent, regrettably, in the course of these reasons, that the landscape of this litigation was altered at the instance of Mr Roe, often significantly and usually at the eleventh hour, necessitating a number of adjournments. Concessions earlier made and issues abandoned by counsel for Mr Roe were belatedly re-introduced. This approach to the litigation by Mr Roe has been most unsatisfactory and has added to the time required and costs occasioned in the proceedings. Background Much of the following ‘background’, which is uncontroversial, is taken without attribution at every point from the written submissions of the KLC. The KLC, as such representative body, has been negotiating with Woodside Energy Ltd (Woodside), the State of Western Australia and the Commonwealth on behalf of the GJJ claim group over a proposal to develop a liquid natural gas processing facility (LNG) at James Price Point, within the area of the GJJ claim. The application challenges the validity of two joint meetings of the GJJ and the Djaberra Djaberra (DD) native title claim groups held on 15 February and 15 April 2009 as well as the resolutions passed at those meetings which authorised, amongst other things, the KLC to perform its facilitation and assistance functions under s 203BB of the NTA to represent the claim groups in negotiations relating to an indigenous land use agreement and later, to enter into, on behalf of the GJJ claim group, a Heads of Agreement with Woodside and the State of Western Australia in connection with the LNG facility. The applicant seeks declaratory relief as to that asserted invalidity. It also seeks declaratory relief on various grounds based in alleged conflict of interest and duty to the effect that the KLC was and is precluded from acting on the native title claims for the GJJ and the DD. Finally, it seeks injunctive relief to restrain the KLC from acting on behalf of the GJJ claim group on the native title claim, or in negotiations with any party concerning the LNG facility and from disclosing to any person without relevant consent any legal advice, anthropological evidence or other confidential information relating to the GJJ native title claim. The KLC contends that the substantive proceeding should be dismissed, as does Mr Shaw, on the grounds that Mr Roe has no standing to pursue it as he is only one of two named applicants and cannot act alone. The motion to amend is also opposed by the KLC and Mr Shaw. The first directions hearing At the first directions hearing on 20 April 2010, counsel for Mr Roe informed the Court that:(i)The proceeding was commenced relying on the standing that Mr Roe and Mr Shaw have jointly as the applicant in the Goolarabooloo/Jabirr Jabirr native title claim (WAG 6002 of 1998); (ii)The proceeding seeks relief in relation to and concerns the rights of the Goolarabooloo/Jabirr Jabirr native title claim group; (iii)The law is very clear that in relation to a native title claim the control of the litigation and the conduct of the litigation resides with the applicant, in this case, Mr Shaw and Mr Roe – the members of the native title claim group do not have any role in relation to the conduct of the native title claim; (iv)Mr Shaw has disavowed the proceeding; (v)Mr Roe seeks to continue the proceeding in his own right under s 33C of the FCA Act as a representative proceeding on behalf of the Goolarabooloo/ Jabirr Jabirr native title claim group); and(vi)The members of the Goolarabooloo/Jabirr Jabirr claim group have not given their consent to the proceeding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Joseph Edward Roe have standing to continue the native title claim application on his own behalf after Cyril Shaw disavowed the proceeding?
2. Are the proposed amendments to the application, which introduce new class members, new causes of action, and new issues, permissible under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)?
3. Should the application be dismissed if Mr Roe lacks the necessary standing to pursue it alone?

Held
1. Joseph Edward Roe does not have standing to continue the native title claim application on his own behalf after Cyril Shaw disavowed the proceeding.
2. The proposed amendments to the application, which introduce new class members, new causes of action, and new issues, are not permissible under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).
3. The application should be dismissed due to Mr Roe's lack of the necessary standing to pursue it alone.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, the amended application proposes to introduce new class members, new causes of action and new issues. The KLC submits that if those causes of action are maintainable, which it contends they are not, then they should be the subject of fresh proceedings, or alternatively if the amendment is allowed, Mr Roe should be ordered to immediately pay the costs of the amendment and the costs thrown away by the KLC on an indemnity basis.Consideration There is no question that, subject to the NTA, this Court is conferred with jurisdiction in relation to matters arising under the NTA by virtue of s 213(2). It is my opinion that in relation to the present proceeding both this Court’s jurisdiction, by s 213(2), and standing, by s 62A, are conferred by the NTA. Standing, in effect, by s 62A is granted exclusively to the applicant to deal with all matters arising under the NTA in relation to the claimant application. This proceeding is unequivocally stated to be brought on behalf of the GJJ native title claim group in native title claim WAG 6002/98 and which incorporates WAG 6014/98. A claimant application within the meaning of s 253 of the NTA, by virtue of NTA s 61(1), may only be brought by a person or persons authorised by all the persons (the native title claim group) who, according to their traditional laws and customs, hold the common or group rights and interests comprising the native title claimed. Then, under s 61(2)(c) and (d) relevantly, the person is, or the persons are, jointly, the “applicant” and none of the other members of the native title claim group is the “applicant”. Section 62A(a) provides relevantly that in the case of a claimant application the applicant may deal with all matters arising under the NTA in relation to the application. An application for a determination of native title is a representative proceeding. Mr Roe submitted that s 62A, in its terms, and particularly by use of the word “may” is permissive only but does not confer standing exclusively upon the applicant in respect of dealing with all matters arising under the NTA in relation to the application. I do not accept this submission. One of the main objects of the NTA by s 3(c) is to establish a mechanism for determining claims to native title. An evident purpose of s 62A, read together with s 61, as part of achieving that objective, is to confer upon the applicant, and upon no other members of the native title claim group the entitlement to deal with all matters arising under the NTA in relation to the application. This, in effect, was the view of Drummond J in Ankamuthi People v State of Queensland (2002) 121 FCR 68. There, as in the present case, dissension had developed within the claim group, the Ankamuthi People, such that a large majority of them were unhappy with the way their native title claim was being conducted by their authorised applicants in respect of three native title applications. A notice of discontinuance was filed by a Land Council purportedly on behalf of the Ankamuthi People or at least the great majority of them. Rejecting the validity of the notice his Honour stated at [7]-[8]: 7.The provisions of that Act are clear. Section 61 makes provision for, among other things, a person authorised by all members of the native title claim group to bring an application for determination of native title on behalf of the claim group. Such a proceeding is obviously a representative proceeding. By s 61(2), it is provided that where a person authorised by a claim group to bring an application of native title on behalf of the group makes such an application, that person is the applicant and none of the other members of the claim group is the applicant.8.It is clear enough from that provision that it is only the named applicant who has control of the litigation instituted by the filing of the application for a determination of native title on behalf of the claim group. The other members of the group, so far as the Court is concerned and so long as the applicant remains the applicant in the proceedings, have no authority to take any step in the proceedings. That follows, by implication from s 61(2), from identifying the person who makes the application as the applicant and declaring that no other member of the claim group is the applicant. But if more were needed, it is to be found in s 62A, which explicitly states that to be the position.