Walker v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Walker v State of South Australia [2014] FCA 962

Citation: Walker v State of South Australia [2014] FCA 962
Parties: LANCE GILBERT WALKER v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
File number: SAD 162 of 2010
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 5 September 2014
Catchwords:

NATIVE TITLE – determination of native title application – strike out application - claim area overlaps with other existing native title claims - little evidence to support the very large claim area of the native title application – evidence supports a smaller geographical area of the claim area - whether the authorisation process complied with the legislative requirements – people who were part of the claim group were only those present at the meeting and signed a declaration that they were a member of the claim group – resolution did not constitute all apical ancestors of members of the claim group - whether applicant had the proper authorisation to make the native title application – consultation process was deficient – not all the potential claim group participated in the meetings

Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Walker v State of South Australia (No 2) (2013) 215 FCR 254 referred to
Bodney v Bropho (2004) 140 FCR 77 cited
McKenzie v State of South Australia [2005] FCA 22 cited
Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 cited
Harrington-Smith on behalf of the Wongatha People v State of WA (No 9) [2007] FCA 31 cited
Quall v Risk [2001] FCA 378 cited
Landers v State of South Australia (2003) 128 FCR 495 cited
Reid v South Australia [2007] FCA 1479 cited
Roe v Kimberley Land Council Aboriginal Corporation [2010] FCA 809 cited
Far West Coast Native Title Claim v South Australia (No 2) (2012) 204 FCR 542 cited
KK v Western Australia (2013) 217 FCR 115 cited
Dieri People v State of South Australia [2003] FCA 187 cited
Brown v State of South Australia [2009] FCA 206 cited
Bolton on behalf of the Southern Noongar Families v State of Western Australia [2004] FCA 760 cited
Lawson v Minister for Land and Water Conservation [2002] FCA 1517 cited
Kite v State of South Australia [2007] FCA 1662 cited
Risk v National Native Title Tribunal [2000] FCA 1589 cited
Bollison on behalf of Southern Noongan Families v State of Western Australia [2004] FCA 760 distinguished

Date of hearing: 19 July 2013
Date of last submissions: 4 December 2013
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 85
Counsel for the Applicant: The applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the State of South Australia: D O’Leary
Solicitor for the State of South Australia: State of South Australia

Counsel for the Ngarrindjeri People:

S Berg

Solicitor for the Ngarrindjeri People:

Berg Lawyers
Counsel for Local Government Organisations: N Llewellyn-Jones
Solicitor for Local Government Organisations: Norman Waterhouse
Counsel for the Kaurna People: L Carter and…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 962
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Walker v State of South Australia, the Federal Court was asked to decide whether the application for the determination of native title made by Lance Gilbert (Karno) Walker on behalf of the Ramindjeri native title claim group should be dismissed. The Ramindjeri claim encompassed a vast area including Kangaroo Island, the Fleurieu Peninsula, and parts of the mainland stretching from the mouth of the Murray River to the Mount Lofty Ranges. This application overlapped significantly with the claims of the Ngarrindjeri and Kaurna Peoples. The State of South Australia sought to have the application struck out on the grounds that the Ramindjeri claim group is a subgroup of the Ngarrindjeri and that Walker lacked the proper authorisation to bring the claim.

The court had to address whether the Ramindjeri could be recognised as a distinct native title claim group and if Walker was duly authorised to represent them. Furthermore, the court needed to assess the sufficiency of the evidence provided to substantiate the extensive geographical claims. The State argued that the material presented did not adequately support the assertion of native title over the claimed areas, particularly over large sea areas and Kangaroo Island. The court scrutinised the evidence, including historical texts and affidavits, to determine the validity of the Ramindjeri's claim to be a separate entity from the Ngarrindjeri.

After careful consideration, the court found that while there was sufficient evidence to acknowledge the existence of the Ramindjeri as a distinct group, the material provided was insufficient to substantiate the expansive geographical claims of the Ramindjeri application. The court ruled that the claim should be struck out and dismissed the application. This decision hinged on the lack of compelling evidence to support the extensive areas claimed and the determination that the Ramindjeri claim group, while distinct, did not warrant recognition as a separate entity for the purposes of the native title claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This decision concerns the motion of the State of South Australia to strike out this application. For the reasons given below, I have decided to accede to that motion. Accordingly, I order that the application be dismissed.BACKGROUND The application by Lance Gilbert (Karno) Walker made on 22 October 2010, and amended on 20 January 2011, was made under s 61 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (the NT Act) for the determination of native title held by the Ramindjeri native title claim group (the Ramindjeri claim). I shall refer to the application as amended as the Ramindjeri application or the Ramindjeri claim. The Ramindjeri claim covered Kangaroo Island and surrounding waters and the Fleurieu Peninsula and surrounding waters extending east to the mouth of the Murray River and north in the St Vincent Gulf to Outer Harbour. It then ran roughly diagonally down through the northern suburbs of Adelaide and then east to the Mount Lofty Ranges. It then ran roughly along the western side of those Ranges to about Clarendon and then roughly south south-east following natural physical features of the geography through Mount Compass to Goolwa and the Murray River Mouth. Consequently, the Ramindjeri claim area overlaps with significant parts of the Ngarrindjeri native title claim south of Adelaide (SAD 6027 of 1998) and of the Kaurna Peoples native title claim over the Adelaide plains (SAD 6001 of 2000). Both of those claims were registered on the Native Title Registry of the National Native Title Tribunal (NNTT). The Ramindjeri claim was not accepted for registration by the Native Title Registrar of the NNTT. The State contended that the Ramindjeri claim should be struck out because it cannot succeed on the following bases:(1)on the material, the Ramindjeri claim group is a subgroup of the Ngarrindjeri claim group, and so is not a native title claim group capable in its own right of being recognised as the holders of native title; and(2)Mr Walker in any event is not properly authorised under s 251B of the NT Act to bring the claim on behalf of the identified Ramindjeri claim group. I will consider each of those issues separately. Before doing so, there are some other matters which should be referred to.THE CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE I note that, in the first place, I dealt with an issue about which Mr Walker gave notice, together with a notice under s 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), concerning the status of the Court to entertain the State’s strike out application. Mr Walker contended that the Ramindjeri have never ceded sovereignty to the Crown “in any form nor guise nor capacity”. Consequently, he appeared to contend, from that assertion, that neither the Crown in right of the Commonwealth of Australia nor the Crown in right of the State of South Australia have sufficient sovereignty to make laws with respect to the Ramindjeri without their consent or acquiescence. The next step was to assert that the Ramindjeri, as a sovereign people, are not subject to the laws of the then colony of South Australia, as vested by the Imperial Parliament, nor the laws of the Commonwealth or of the State. He thus contended that neither the Commonwealth nor the State can validly pass laws which regulate or affect the laws, rights, culture, heritage, lands, men, women or children of the Ramindjeri.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As to the authorisation process; it added that the Box Factory Meeting was notified by notice in The Advertiser, but otherwise appears to contain much the same information expressed in a slightly different way. The advertisement is attached to the affidavit, but its date of publication is not specified or apparent. From other evidence, it was given on 19 November 2009. It invites all persons who identify as Ramindjeri and who wish to participate in considering whether to make a claim on behalf of the Ramindjeri in relation to the area specified in the Ramindjeri application (with a map showing the extensive area proposed to be claimed) to attend. The business was to “determine the process (whether traditional or otherwise) to decide whether to make the proposed claim, and to use that process to decide whether to make such a claim and who to authorise to make it.THE SUBSEQUENT EVIDENCE The State has provided a Table of names and other personal details entitled “Ramindjeri Public Meeting” which Mr Walker provided, and which he said was prepared at the Box Factory Meeting. It was also given by Mr Walker a DVD recording the meeting, and it has prepared a transcript of the meeting from that recording. Those materials were also produced. The Table has columns for name, contact details, “Your Country”, and “Your Ramindjeri Connection”. There were 55 persons who apparently put their names to the list. The “Your Country” column was entered by 40 of them (including by using ditto marks). The entries and number of responses are:Ramindjeri 6Yaraldi 1Coorong 10Ramindjeri/Ngarrindjeri 2Kaurna 5Kogatha 1Narungga 1Yaraldjeri/Ramindjeri 2Peramangk 3Murray Mouth/Goolwa Coorong/Raukkan/Lakes/River Murray 2And Fleurieu Peninsula 1Asper Ngarrindjeri Native Title Claim 6 The transcript of the Box Factory Meeting runs to seven pages. It does not record those present, or its starting or closing times. It started with an address by Mr Walker. It is not necessary to record all its content. Mr Walker referred to the historical evidence (presumably that provided with the Ramindjeri application) supporting the proposed claim, and said he had been authorised:… by Mr Walker extended family and others … to speak on and act on behalf of the Ramindjeri native title cultural matters as the primary (sic) being ratified in wording by numerous heads of families, Ramindjeri families. The Chair of the meeting then suggested that the meeting resolve that only those persons who have completed and signed the declaration (referred to at [36]) be entitled to vote. After some questions, he asked if the meeting accepted that. It is recorded that there were: “(No objections)”. The Chair then sought approval of the meeting that the Ramindjeri claim native title group:… be identified as the persons who have signed the declaration as attendees together with members of their immediate family.He asked if the meeting wished to resolve that. Again the transcript records “(No objections)” and the Chair saying: “That’s carried”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The two later affidavits dispute the status of the Ngarrindjeri claim, and more substantially the affidavit of 4 November 2013 includes some further historical research extracts confirming the existence and activities of Aboriginal people, including Ramindjeri People, in the lower Fleurieu Peninsula.CONSIDERATION(1) Is there a Ramindjeri claim group as described? It is important to note, having regard to certain of Mr Walker’s submissions, that neither the Kaurna People nor the Ngarrindjeri dispute the existence of the Ramindjeri People or tribe. The relevant dispute for present purposes is whether the Ramindjeri are a subgroup of a wider native title group under the name Ngarrindjeri or whether they are a discrete and separate native title group holding the native title rights over the Ramindjeri claim area. Consequently, there is no surprise that there is material which records the existence of a Ramindjeri group of people in the Adelaide Plains and Fleurieu Peninsula areas. The State has referred to “The Folklore, Manners, Customs and Languages of the South Australian Aborigines”, Taplin ed 1879 and more recently “A World that Was”, Berndt and Berndt, 1993. The first of those texts supports the proposition that the Ramindjeri group represent a clan of the larger Ngarrindjeri group with its own totem or “ngaitye” – in the case of the “Ramidjeri” the totem is the wattle gum. The second gives a more detailed analysis of the composition of the Ngarrindjeri group. The authors conducted extensive research in the 1940s. They confirm there is, and was, a dialectical or language group (Narrinyeri or Kukabrak) covering roughly the area of the Ngarrindjeri claim area, with different socio-cultural and linguistic groups adjacent to but away from that area. In that area, the various subgroups or clans had a common language with dialectical variations, and through matrimonial relationships they could move freely over the area and share hunting and ceremonial activities and important meetings, and trade amongst themselves within settled routes. The Ramindjeri tribe or clan was identified as within that wider group. There is other material in the extracts provided by Mr Walker. I do not need to refer to it all in detail. In those circumstances, as a matter of general principle, I would determine this ground of the strike-out motion as not made out. In other words, but for what follows, I would refuse to strike out the Ramindjeri claim on this ground. That is consistent with the State’s position on this arm of the strike out motion. There are two observations I make on the material relied upon by Mr Walker. The first is that there is very little material to support the very large claim area of the Ramindjeri claim. In particular, there is little material to support the existence of native title rights and interests over the large sea areas of the claim. There is also relatively little material to support the claim to native title rights and interests over Kangaroo Island. That is not to prejudge those matters, but is simply an observation about the content of the presently provided material.