Kite v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kite v State of South Australia [2007] FCA 1662 

NATIVE TITLE – notice of motion to strike out native title determination application under s 84C Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) or s 31A Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether the claim group includes all people who hold the native title claimed – whether all members of the claim group satisfy criteria said to give status as native title holders

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13(1)(a), 61, 61A, 62, 84C, 223(1), 251B
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A
Federal Court Rules O 13

Reid v State of South Australia [2007] FCA 1479 cited
Harrington-Smith v State of Western Australia (No 9) [2007] FCA 31 cited
Landers v State of South Australia (2003) 128 FCR 495 cited
Colbung v State of Western Australia [2003] FCA 774 cited
Risk v National Native Title Tribunal [2000] FCA 1589 cited
McKenzie v State of South Australia (2005) 214 ALR 214 cited
Hillig as Administrator of Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales (No 2) [2006] FCA 1115 cited
Bodney v Bropho (2004) 140 FCR 77 cited
Bolton on behalf of the Southern Noongar Families v State of Western Australia [2004] FCA 760 cited

JOHN GILBERT KITE v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

No SAD 130 of 2007

FINN J
2 NOVEMBER 2007
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 130 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

JOHN GILBERT KITE
Applicant

AND:

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

FINN J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 NOVEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The native title determination application (SAD 130 of 2007) be struck out under s 84C of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 130 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

JOHN GILBERT KITE
Applicant

AND:

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

FINN J

DATE:

2 NOVEMBER 2007

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The respondent, the State of South Australia, has moved under s 84C of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) and, in the alternative, s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) that the native title determination application filed by the applicant, John Gilbert Kite, be struck out or else be summarily dismissed. For present purposes s 84C empowers the Court to strike out an application which does not comply with s 61 of the Native Title Act, and s 31A permits the Court to give summary judgment for a respondent in relation to the whole of a proceeding if it is satisfied that the applicant has no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting the application.

  2. There are two principal bases on which the State challenges Mr Kite’s application.  The first is that the claim group does not include all of the persons who hold…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kite v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1662
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kite v State of South Australia, the Federal Court was tasked with determining whether Mr Kite had the proper authority to make a native title claim on behalf of a specific group. The application was contested by the State of South Australia, which argued that Mr Kite's claim was flawed on several grounds. The primary legal issue was whether Mr Kite's claim complied with the requirements of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), specifically in terms of the authority and composition of the claim group. The court also needed to decide whether the claim complied with the procedural requirements imposed by sections 61, 61A, and 62 of the Act.

The Federal Court found that Mr Kite's claim was fatally flawed in multiple respects, including apparent contradictions, ambiguities, and infelicities in the claim's documentation and evidence. The court observed that the claim contained statements that did not align with the statutory provisions of the Act and failed to adequately address the differing bases of the claim group members' connections to the claim area. Additionally, the claim did not sufficiently demonstrate that all members of the group were properly authorised to make the claim, as required by section 61 of the Act. Given these findings, the court concluded that the claim was untenable upon the version of the evidence favourable to the respondent. Therefore, the court ordered that the native title determination application be struck out under section 84C of the Native Title Act.

The court's decision was based on the understanding that the power to strike out a claim should only be exercised when the claim is untenable on the version of the evidence favourable to the respondent. The court held that Mr Kite's claim did not meet the necessary standards and, as such, it was appropriate to strike it out. The court found that the claim group was not properly authorised to make the claim, and the procedural requirements were not adequately met. Consequently, the court struck out the native title determination application, affirming the State of South Australia's challenge to the claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The native title determination application (SAD 130 of 2007) be struck out under s 84C of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Kite’s affidavit, sworn in compliance with s 62(1) of the Native Title Act, described the basis of his authorisation both to make the claim and to deal with matters arising in relation to it, in the following terms:“7.The members of the claim group discussed the making of this application on 26 June 2007.8.I knew the other members of the claim group in that discussion. I knew that they were each people who can claim the country covered by this native title determination application.9.In the discussion the other claim group members and I unanimously decided that I should make this application on behalf of the claim group and deal with matters arising in relation to it.10.The procedure used by the group in the discussion on 26 June 2007 was the traditional process of discussion and the reaching of an agreed position that is used by the members of the claim group pursuant to their traditional laws and customs in making decisions about their traditional country.11.It has become the established and agreed practice of our claimant group that this is the way in which we run our group meetings and discussions about native title claim business. That was what was understood and agreed between all of the claimants in the discussion on 26 June 2007.”Additional Evidence Some number of affidavits were filed in support of the motion. Mr Kite filed a further affidavit. The following is drawn from this material. (i) Mr Kite’s claimant application appears to be another instalment in the disintegration of agreements struck at Spear Creek in South Australia in May 2004 which sought, it would seem, to resolve overlapping native title claims in parts of the State. In one such agreement – that between the Antakirinja People, the Antakirinja Land Management (Aboriginal Corporation) and the Kokatha Munta Native Title Claim Group – Mr Kite is described as a member of the Kokatha Munta claim group and his name and signature are given as signifying support for the agreement. His membership of that claim (which was later withdrawn) was founded, apparently, on the Kokatha ancestry of his mother, Mrs Gladys Kite. (ii) The claimant application overlaps (inter alia) the Kokatha Native Title Claim. Mr Kite and his family have been involved in that claim; he is said by his sister to have represented his family on a management committee for the claim and continued to do so until an unspecified incident in February 2006. It is the case, though, that the Kite family does not fall within the current claim group description. (iii) The Form 1 Application for the Antakirinja Matu-Yankunytjatjara Native Title Claim Group includes Gladys Kite and all her descendants. In his second affidavit he indicated he was not aware of that membership and at the hearing it was indicated steps would be taken to have him removed from it. His present claim overlaps that claim. (iv) In his second affidavit Mr Kite acknowledges that all the members of his claim group were members of the extended family of his mother. He also indicated that the former Kokatha Munta claim was made on the basis of Kokatha ancestry and his mother, as earlier noted, was of Kokatha ancestry. He went on to say:“12.The present Southern Arunda Yunkunjatjara Nguraritja claim is not based upon Kokatha ancestry, but upon my father’s and his father’s ancestry and upon the paternal ancestry of the other members of the Southern Arunda Yunkunjatjara Nguraritja claim. …18.Under my traditional law and culture, my father’s father and his ancestors are the basis of my capacity to be one of the claimants in the Southern Arunda Yunkunjatjara Nguraritja claim. My capacity to make this claim, and the capacity of the other claimants, (apart from Adam Tunkin, to whom I refer in paragraphs 19 to 22) is through our paternal grandfather Bill Kite and his ancestors, more so than through my father or the other claimants’ fathers. My father, Gilbert Kite, always used to say to me and to my brothers and sisters that he and his father and the ancestors before them were Southern Arunda people and that they had family connections as far north as to Hermannsburg in the Northern Territory.”Mr Tunkin apart (see below), there is a handwritten genealogy in evidence which is accepted by Mr Kite. It indicates that while Bill Kite is Mr Kite’s grandfather, he is the great-grandfather of the other members of the claim group. Mr Kite’s father is the grandfather of two of the members (Luke Ayre and Marcus Moore). Mr Kite’s brother is the grandfather of the third (Trevor Warrior).

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINN J
The State also raised subsidiary issues of non-compliance with procedural requirements imposed by s 61A and s 62. Given my conclusion as to the fate of the application itself, it is unnecessary that I deal with these. CONCLUSION I will order that the native title determination application (SAD 130 of 2007) be struck out under s 84C of the Native Title Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINN J

Finally I should note that s 84C(1) provides that, if an application does not comply with s 61, s 61A or s 62, a party to the proceedings may at any time apply to this Court to strike it out. All I need observe here is that the court’s power should be exercised only where the claim as expressed is untenable upon the “version of the evidence” favourable to the respondent to the strike out: McKenzie, at [26]; Bodney v Bropho (2004) 140 FCR 77.THE PRESENT MOTION – CONSIDERATION The State has challenged Mr Kite’s application on a broad front. As the claimant application is fatally flawed in a number of respects, I need only refer to four matters. Before doing so, I should indicate that, on its face, the application contains apparent contradictions, ambiguities and infelicities that would have required systematic address were I not to strike it out. I would merely instance (a) the assertion in Pt A2 of the Form 1 that the rights and interests claimed are “individual rights and interests”: cf s 223 of the Act; (b) the general rights described do not accommodate the differing bases of the connection to the claim area of the four Kite descendant claimants and of Adam Tunkin: see Schedule F; and (c) the recognition that the rights and interests claimed are “non-exclusive”: Schedule E; and that other Aboriginal people acknowledge apparently the same traditional laws and observe the same traditional customs in relation to the claim area: Schedule F. The contradictions and ambiguities become the greater when one has regard to Mr Kite’s evidence and the submissions made at the hearing. To illustrate this I would note the following. (i) While Schedule F to Form 1 suggests that the claim group members’ status as native title holders is derived by means of ancestry in some manner, it was said by Mr Kite’s counsel in oral submissions – and this is consistent with his second affidavit – that “Mr Kite’s instructions to me have been adamantly and repeatedly: you claim through your grandfather”. The grandfather relied upon for the purposes of the application is Bill Kite. Of the five claim group members, John Kite alone is the grandchild of Bill Kite. (ii) As I indicated above, the Schedule F description of native title rights and interests suggests on its face that Aboriginal peoples other than the claim group acknowledge the same traditional laws and observe the same customs in relation to the claim area. In response to the State’s submission on Schedule F, Mr Kite has asserted in written submissions that:“[b]y acknowledging that there may be others with native title rights and interests in parts of the SAYN claim area the SAYN claimants are not inevitably asserting that they have failed to include all possible members of their claimant group in their claim.Rather, they are acknowledging that there may be others who hold native title rights and interests in the parts of the same country, but on the basis of different groups’ laws, customs and traditions.”I merely note that this is not what is said in Schedule F. Neither is there any evidence suggesting that there may be other native title holders observing different laws and customs in relation to the claim area or parts of it.