Far West Coast Native Title Claim v South Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Far West Coast Native Title Claim v State of South Australia [2012] FCA 733

Citation: Far West Coast Native Title Claim v State of South Australia [2012] FCA 733
Parties: FAR WEST COAST NATIVE TITLE CLAIM v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA & ORS
File number: SAD 6008 of 1998
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 10 July 2012
Date of corrigendum 13 July 2012
Catchwords:

NATIVE TITLE – consolidated claims – application for de-consolidation of claim – summary judgment – whether interlocutory applicant has no prospect of success – standing - where interlocutory applicant is a member of the claim group – interlocutory applicant not authorised to make application – deconsolidation refused – proceedings affected by possible defect in authorisation – authorisations subject to conditions

NATIVE TITLE – application under s 84D Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) by member of claim group for order that authorised applicant produce evidence of authorisation to deal with claim in particular way – consideration – whether particular decisions of claim group are terms of authorisation – whether terms of authorisation can limit nature of dealing with claim

Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) s 84D
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules 2011
Native Title Amendment Act 2007 (Cth)
Native Title Amendment (Technical Amendments) Bill 2007 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Far West Coast Native Title Claim v State of South Australia (2011) 191 FCR 381 cited
Byron Environment Centre Inc v Arakwal People (1997) 78 FCR 1 cited
Fiorentino v Irons (1997) 79 FCR 327 cited
Pasdale Pty Ltd v Concrete Constructions (1995) 59 FCR 446 cited
Spencer v Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118 cited
Boston Commercial Services Pty Ltd v GE Capital Finances Australasia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1352 cited
Barunga v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2011] FCA 755 cited
Starkey v State of South Australia [2011] FCA 456 discussed
Roe v Kimberly Land Council Aboriginal Corporation [2010] FCA 809 cited
Anderson on behalf of the Wulli Wulli People v State of Queensland (2011) 197 FCR 404 cited
Butchulla People v State of Queensland (2006) 154 FCR 233 cited
Doolan v Native Title Registrar (2007) 158 FCR 56 cited
Lennon v State of South Australia [2010] FCA 743 cited
Anderson v State of Western Australia (2003) 134 FCR 1 discussed
Tigan v State of Western Australia (2010) 188 FCR 533 cited
Ward v Northern Territory (2002) 196 ALR 32 cited
Daniel v Western Australia (2002) 194 ALR 278, [2002] FCA 1147 cited
Gorringe on behalf of the Mithaka People v State of Queensland [2010] FCA 716 discussed
Que Noy v Northern Territory [2007] FCA 1888 discussed

Date of hearing: 23 April 2012
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 64
Counsel for the Applicant: V Hughston SC and O Linde
Solicitor for the Applicant: South Australia Native Title Service
Counsel for the State of South Australia: S McCaul
Solicitor for the State of South Australia: Crown Solicitor
Counsel for the Commonwealth
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Far West Coast Native Title Claim v South Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 733
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court in Far West Coast Native Title Claim v South Australia (No 2) involved an application by Robert Victor Miller, a Mirning man, to deconsolidate the Mirning Native Title Claim from the Far West Coast Native Title Claim, which had been consolidated in 2006. Miller sought to represent the interests of some Mirning people, arguing that their interests were not being adequately protected or represented in the consolidated claim. The applicant, who was authorised to deal with the consolidated claim on behalf of the composite claim group, opposed the application and sought summary dismissal on the basis that Miller lacked standing and that the application had no reasonable prospect of success.

The legal issues before the court included whether Miller had standing to make the application and whether the terms of the authorisation given to the applicant could limit the nature of the dealing with the claim. The court held that Miller did not have standing to seek the deconsolidation order because he did not represent the claim group that authorised the consolidated claim and only represented some of the Mirning people. The court also found that the authorisation given to the applicant was subject to conditions and could limit the nature of the dealing with the claim. However, the court refused to grant the deconsolidation order because it considered that the proceedings were affected by a possible defect in the authorisation and that there was no reasonable prospect of Miller successfully prosecuting the application.

The court's reasoning was based on the principle that the onus was on the applicant to show that there was no reasonable prospect of Miller successfully obtaining the orders he sought. The court emphasised that the test did not require it to determine whether Miller would succeed on his claim, but whether there was no reasonable prospect of Miller successfully prosecuting the proceedings. The court also considered that the authorisation given to the applicant was subject to conditions and could limit the nature of the dealing with the claim. However, the court refused to grant the deconsolidation order because it considered that the proceedings were affected by a possible defect in the authorisation and that there was no reasonable prospect of Miller successfully prosecuting the application.

The final orders of the court were that Miller's application for the reinstatement of the Mirning Native Title Claim by its deconsolidation from the Far West Coast Native Title Claim was refused. The applications of Miller for his joinder as a party to the Far West Coast Native Title Claim, and for an order or orders under s 84D(1) or (4) were stood over to a date to be fixed. The parties, including Miller, were given liberty to apply.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application of Robert Victor Miller for the reinstatement of the Mirning Native Title Claim (WAD 6016 of 1998) (by its deconsolidation from the Far West Coast Native Title Claim) is refused.

2. The applications of Robert Victor Miller for his joinder as a party to the Far West Coast Native Title Claim, and for an order or orders under s 84D(1) or (4) – if still pressed – and for the summary dismissal of those claims, are stood over to a date to be fixed.

3. The parties, including Robert Victor Miller, are given liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant denies that Mr Miller has standing to make the application and seeks a summary dismissal of the application. BACKGROUND It is necessary to refer to how the Far West Coast Native Title Claim came about, and more recent events, to understand why the present application is made. The background is described in Far West Coast Native Title Claim v State of South Australia (2011) 191 FCR 381 at [6]-[12]. By way of summary, in 1998 the Mirning people and Far West Coast people each separately made claims for native title under s 61 of the NT Act, namely WAD 6016/1998 (Mirning) and SAD 6008/1998 (Far West Coast). The areas claimed in the two applications overlapped. This presented problems, as under s 68 of the NT Act only one approved determination of native title can be made with respect to an area. In May 2004 at Spear Creek an extensive mediation was held, facilitated by the Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement Inc (ALRM), which at the time was the native title representative body for South Australia, and the National Native Title Tribunal. Amongst other outcomes, that mediation resulted in an agreement for the Mirning claim to be combined with the Far West Coast claim. Following this, ALRM continued to facilitate a number of meetings to further consider the combination of the two claims. On 19-20 December 2005 a meeting at the Standpipe Hotel in Port Augusta was held for the purposes of authorising the amendment of the existing claims pursuant to s 251B of the NT Act to facilitate their combination. That meeting authorised the persons comprising the Applicant to apply to consolidate the two claims and to deal with matters in relation to the consolidated claim. Clem Lawrie is a Mirning man and was authorised by the Mirning people to join as part of the Applicant in the proposed consolidated claim on behalf of the Mirning people at an earlier meeting of the Mirning native title claim group on 21-22 July 2005 (following the Spear Creek agreement in principle). On 18 January 2006, leave was granted to amend the Far West Coast application, to combine it with the Miring native title claim (WAD 6016/1998) thereby expanding the claim area to cover the two claim areas of the previously separate claims, and consolidating the two claims so that the two applications were to be conducted as a single application. That resolved any issues of overlapping claims. The separate claim groups were redescribed as one claim group to incorporate the apical ancestors of both the previously separate claim groups and their successors. The amended application bears the title of the application numbered SAD 6008/1998, and the previously separate Mirning Native Title Claim application was consolidated with that application. It ceased to be a separate claim. That is the claim which is sought to be “reinstated” as a separate claim. The consolidated claim is called the Far West Coast Native Title Claim. The Far West Coast Native Title Claim has since progressed to the point where there is a real prospect that in the proximate future there may be a determination by consent of the claim in favour of the composite claim group.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The onus is on the Applicant, responding to Mr Miller’s application, to show that there is no reasonable prospect of Mr Miller successfully obtaining the orders he seeks. In Spencer v Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118, the High Court warned against the “judicial creation of a lexicon of words or phrases intended to capture the operation of a particular statutory phrase like ‘no reasonable prospect’, but instead, ‘full weight must be given to the expression as a whole’”: at [58]-[60] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ. The test does not require the Court to determine whether Mr Miller will succeed on his claim, but whether there is no reasonable prospect of Mr Miller successfully prosecuting the proceedings or part of the proceedings in question: Boston Commercial Services Pty Ltd v GE Capital Finances Australasia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1352 [42] per Rares J. CONSIDERATIONDe-consolidation Mr Miller first seeks an order to deconsolidate the Mirning Native Title Claim from the Far West Coast Native Title Claim. The consequence would be that there would again be overlapping native title claims over part of the Far West Coast Native Title Claim area, even more extensive than existed at the time of the Spear Creek decision as the Far West Coast Native Title Claim now covers the whole of the two separate previous claim areas. The Applicant (including Mr Lawrie) submits that the orders sought by Mr Miller should be summarily refused because he lacks standing to make any of his claims; and there is no legal basis on which the interlocutory orders sought could or should be made. As to the first order, on the issue of standing, Mr Miller correctly said that his evidence showed at least an arguable case that:(a)he considers it his role to give a voice to some Mirning concerns; and(b)he and some other Mirning people have concerns that Mirning interests are not being protected or represented by the Applicant in dealing with the Far West Coast Native Title Claim, in particular not giving effect to the agreement which constituted part of the authorisation given, apparently under s 251B of the NT Act at the meeting on 19-20 December 2005 at the Standpipe Hotel. However, in my view, Mr Miller has no standing to seek the first order relating to deconsolidation, even accepting that there is an arguable case that the Mirning interests are not being fully protected or represented or are not being properly included in the conduct of the Far West Coast Native Title Claim by the Applicant. Mr Miller does not purport to represent the claim group which authorised the Far West Coast Native Title Claim as it emerged following the 19-20 December 2005 meeting. Nor does he purport to represent the Mirning people as previously defined in the pre-consolidation Mirning Native Title Claim, but only some of them. Prior to the decisions referred to in [7] above and the consolidation order he was not the person who alone was authorised under s 251B to bring and conduct the then Mirning Native Title Claim on behalf of the Mirning People as a claim group.