Anderson v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Anderson v State of Western Australia [2003] FCA 1423

NATIVE TITLE – amendment of application – application to replace applicants – disagreement amongst named applicants concerning proposed amendments – whether authorisation of proposed replacement applicants – whether applicable decision-making process according to traditional law and custom exists – whether meetings of native title claim group members adequately advertised – whether attendance at meetings representative of native title claim group – evidence inadequate – whether members of native title claim group authorised to apply for replacement of applicants – whether amendment of application could proceed absent agreement of all named applicants – motion for amendment and replacement of applicants dismissed – springing order made for dismissal of native title determination application – conditions of springing order – motion to amend application to be agreed to by existing applicants – alternatively motion for programming orders to be agreed to by existing applicants – alternatively motion to replace applicants which complies with conditions under s 66B


Native Title Act 1993
(Cth) s 64, s 66B, s 251B

Federal Court Rules O 13 R 2, O 78 r 3, O 78 r 7

Strickland v State of Western Australia (1998) 89 FCR 117
State of Queensland v Hutchison (2001) 108 FCR 575
Wulgurukaba People # 1 v State of Queensland [2002] FCA 1555
Moran v Minister of Land & Water Conversation for the State of New South Wales [1999] FCA 1637
Duren v Kiama Council [2001] FCA 1363
Quandamooka People # 1 v State of Queensland  [2002] FCA 259
Johnson, in the matter of Lawson v Lawson [2001] FCA 894

CEDRIC ANDERSON, DONALD COLLARD, SYLVIA RACHEL COLLARD AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE BALLARDONG PEOPLE            v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
WG6181 OF 1998

FRENCH J
4 DECEMBER 2003
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W6181 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

CEDRIC ANDERSON, DONALD COLLARD, SYLVIA RACHAEL COLLARD AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE BALLARDONG PEOPLE
APPLICANTS

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 DECEMBER 2003

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The motion filed 2 September 2003 is dismissed.

2.The Ballardong native title determination application is to stand dismissed unless on or before 31 March 2004 one of the following events occurs:

(a) a motion is filed, which is agreed to by all named applicants, to amend the application or to seek further programming orders in relation to it;

(b)an application is filed by members of the native title claim group pursuant to s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) seeking replacement of the applicants.

3.Liberty to apply to vary or revoke order number 2 provided such application is made on or before 31 March 2004.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W6181 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

CEDRIC ANDERSON, DONALD COLLARD, SYLVIA RACHAEL COLLARD…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anderson v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 1423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Anderson v State of Western Australia involved a dispute over a native title application lodged on behalf of the Ballardong People, with Cedric Anderson and others as applicants. The case pertained to the authority of the named applicants and the process for amending or replacing them, as well as the broader question of whether the application could proceed given the internal disagreements among the applicants. The Federal Court was called upon to decide whether the motion to amend the native title application should be granted and whether the application itself could continue under the existing circumstances. The Court found that there were significant internal disagreements among the applicants and that the evidence concerning the authorisation of the applicants by the native title claim group was inadequate. Consequently, the Court dismissed the motion to amend and ordered that the native title determination application would be dismissed unless certain conditions were met by 31 March 2004, including either a unanimous motion by all named applicants to amend the application or an application by the native title claim group to replace the applicants. This decision was based on the need for consensus among the applicants and proper authorisation by the native title claim group, in accordance with the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The motion filed 2 September 2003 is dismissed.

2. The Ballardong native title determination application is to stand dismissed unless on or before 31 March 2004 one of the following events occurs:

(a) a motion is filed, which is agreed to by all named applicants, to amend the application or to seek further programming orders in relation to it;

(b) an application is filed by members of the native title claim group pursuant to s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) seeking replacement of the applicants.

3. Liberty to apply to vary or revoke order number 2 provided such application is made on or before 31 March 2004.

Background

Background to the litigation

As appears from the evidence before the Court there are two dissenters within the ranks of the applicants. There are also serious inadequacies in the evidence going to the important question whether the application for replacement of the applicants is authorised by the native title claim group. In the result there is a potential stalemate in the ongoing progress of this application. For the reasons that follow, the motion to amend is dismissed. It also appears to me that unless the applicants can reach consensus between themselves or are properly replaced pursuant to an application authorised in accordance with s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) the application as a whole cannot progress and should be dismissed. In the event, I have decided that I should make springing orders to that effect. Procedural Background and History An application for a native title determination was lodged with the National Native Title Tribunal on behalf of the Ballardong People on 10 July 1997. The application named Cedric Anderson and others as applicants. The area of land which it covers is in excess of 114,000 square kilometres in wheat belt areas of Western Australia. The claim area extends from Dalwallinu in the north-west to Wagin in the south, Lake King in the east and Southern Cross and Koolyanobbing in the north-east. On 30 September 1998 the application became a proceeding in the Federal Court pursuant to amendments to the Native Title Act. On 5 July 2000, the application was amended by combining it with five others. On 21 September 2000, the Bullenbuk-Noongar claim, WAG6097, was consolidated with the Ballardong claim, the Wom-Ber claim, WAG6130 of 1998, and the Ngadjunngarra claim , WAG6221 of 1998, to the extent of their geographic overlaps with the Bullenbuk-Noongar claim. On 15 April 2002, a motion was filed on behalf of the applicants to remove Robin Yarran as a named applicant for the Ballardong native title determination application. That motion was dismissed by order made on 13 December 2002. The interlocutory history up to that point is set out in the judgment in Anderson v State of Western Australia [2002] FCA 1558. At the time it was accepted by the applicants that on the state of the evidence then before the Court the motion could not succeed. On 2 September 2003, a motion was filed seeking orders in the following terms: ‘1.That native title determination application WAG 6181 of 1998 be amended pursuant to the provisions of section 64(1A) Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) in accordance with the Minute of Proposed Amendments as attached. 2.That service of the Motion and any amended Application upon parties other than the State of Western Australia be dispensed with. 3.That the Applicants together with overlapping applicants (being WAG 0002 of 1998, WAG 6216 of 1998 and WAG 0065 of 1998) be referred to the National Native Title Tribunal for the purpose of mediation to resolve the overlapping native title applications. 4.The overlapping Applicant parties in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program to resolve through negotiation and mediation the overlapping applications over a period of three months commencing 28 October 2003. 5.That the National Native Title Tribunal lodge a copy of the program referred to in (4) with the Court by 28 October 2003.6.That in the event that a program cannot be agreed by 28 October 2003 the matter is to be relisted for mention at a date to be fixed. 7.The National Native Title Tribunal be requested to provide a mediation report by 28 January 2004. 8.Any such further or other Order as this Honourable Court deems fit.’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J (dissent)
As well as the distribution of information and guidelines concerning the proposed Single Noongar Claim and its impact on the existing Ballardong claim prior to the meeting presentations were given on these topics by various SWALSC staff. A decision-making process was discussed, agreed to and adopted by those present at the commencement of the meeting. The resolution in relation to the decision-making method which was passed at the meeting was in the following terms: ‘Resolution One: Decision-Making ProcessThe native title claimants at this community meeting acknowledge that we are members of the Noongar native title claim group and we adopt the following decision making process: 1.Each native title claimant attending this community meeting will have the right to vote upon any resolutions that are considered at the meeting.2.The same resolutions will be considered at each of the community meetings. 3.The outcomes will be the result of a majority decision of all Noongar Native Title Claimants.’Dr Shaw did not specify the precise manner in which this resolution was passed. Nor did he address the question whether there was any applicable traditional decision-making method. A second resolution was passed, on a show of hands, in the following terms: ‘Resolution Two: Single Noongar Claim – instructions to SWALSCThe native title claimants agree and authorise the following: That our rights and interests are to be represented by a single Noongar claim. The external boundary of which is broadly reflective of the traditional boundary of Noongar country and which does not extend beyond the Native Title Representative Body boundaries for the south-west Region. Resolution Four: Authorisation of Named Applicants: 1.The native title claimants authorise the named applicants – whose names appear in the attached list - to do all things necessary to make application for a single Noongar claim on our behalf and to deal with all matters or things of that kind. 2.The native title claimants also authorise the named applicants who are nominated by the claimants in each of the other existing native title claim groups to do all things necessary to make application for a single Noongar claim on our behalf.’A list of the proposed applicants in the Single Noongar Claim was attached to that resolution. The names included: Alan Jones, Donald Collard, Doug Nelson, Reg Hayden, Reg Yarran, Robert Riley, Saul Yarran and Winnie McHenry, all of whom are current named applicants in the Ballardong application. According to Ms Lund, seventy-two people voted for resolution two, one against and one abstained. Dr Shaw confirmed that the proposed applicants to represent the Ballardong people in the Single Noongar Claim are Noongar people and are members of the proposed claim group for the single Noongar claim. Dr Shaw said that it was also resolved at the meeting that the Ballardong native title claim group agreed that those persons with an interest in the remaining North Eastern portion of the Ballardong claim area would continue to have their interests represented in a separate application for determination of native title over that area. This was to be discussed further at a later meeting.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: