FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Rita Augustine v State of Western Australia [2013] FCA 338
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rita Augustine v State of Western Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FCA 338
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the application for leave to discontinue was not a result of a proper assessment of the GJJ claim group's validity. Instead, it revealed internal divisions within the GJJ claim group. The Court emphasised the significant public interest in upholding commercial contracts and the associated benefits for the Kimberley Indigenous Peoples and the State's economic well-being. The Court concluded that discontinuance before 18 April 2013 would cause immediate and significant prejudice to the State, Woodside, and others, including the GJJ claim group itself. The Court also highlighted the potential breach of the PPA by the applicant, who had obtained contractual benefits from the registration of the GJJ Determination Application.
Based on the Court's discretion, the GJJ claim group's consent to the future act under the PPA, and the objects of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), the Court decided not to grant unconditional leave to discontinue the GJJ Determination Application before 18 April 2013. The Court ordered that the applicant, the State of Western Australia, Woodside Energy Limited, Waardi Limited, and Guumbarr Limited participate in a mediation to resolve issues arising from the discontinuance of the Application in relation to the Browse Agreements. The Court also reserved costs and adjourned the interlocutory application until after the conclusion of the mediation.
The Court's decision highlights the importance of considering the public interest, contractual obligations, and potential prejudice to other parties when exercising discretion in granting leave to discontinue native title proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The applicant, the State of Western Australia, Woodside Energy Limited, Waardi Limited and Guumbarr Limited participate in a mediation with a view to resolving issues which will otherwise arise upon the discontinuance of the Application in relation to the Browse Agreements as defined in paragraph [4] of the Reasons for Judgment.
2. The parties and the interveners referred to in Order 1 confer and within 14 days of this order file a Minute of Orders as to the identity of the mediator and the terms of reference for the mediation.
3. There be liberty to apply to those parties and those interveners referred to in Order 1 as to the matters the subject of Order 2.
4. The interlocutory application dated 13 February 2013 be adjourned to a date to be fixed after the conclusion of the mediation referred to in Order 1.
5. Costs reserved.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The third condition is advanced on the basis that members of the GJJ claim group approved the PPA in the first place, but apparently did not consider the effect of the discontinuance upon the PPA when they voted in favour of discontinuance. Consideration Prejudice to the interests of the State and other parties The negotiation and entry into the Browse Agreements, as I have said, involved an exercise by the applicant, acting with the authorisation of the entire GJJ claim group, of certain procedural rights to which the GJJ Determination Application gave rise. This occurred despite the existence, for a number of years, of division within the GJJ claim group as between its Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr members. This was their group choice in the face of those divisions. The present applicant could have, confronted by these divisions, applied to discontinue the proceedings before entering the Heads of Agreement in 2009, and certainly before entering the Browse Agreements. Had they done so, the extraordinary difficulties which will ensue if unconditional leave to discontinue is granted, would not have eventuated. However, they did neither of those things. Rather, they committed to the Heads of Agreement and then the Browse Agreements expressly warranting that they had the authority to do so on behalf of the entire GJJ claim group and in full knowledge, as expressed in the PPA, that the State and other parties were conducting themselves in reliance on those warranties. The persons who are the applicant, in particular, warranted at cl 3.1(c), in effect, that the GJJ claim group had authorised them to enter into the PPA in the manner required by the NTA on behalf of the GJJ claim group, and that as the NTP, it had the full power and authority to enter into and perform the obligations of the NTP. Further, by PPA cl 4.1, the applicant as the NTP, in effect, consented to and covenanted it would not object to the doing of the future act comprised in the, relevantly, Replacement Section 29 Notice pursuant to section 31(1)(b) of the NTA. Relevantly, the State and Woodside, pursuant to PPA cl 3.6(a) and (b), were entitled to rely upon the warranties given by the applicant, as the NTP, as well as consents given by it. Importantly, the NTP covenanted that it would not do anything to adversely affect the “Takings”. “Taking” under the PPA means “the taking of rights … in the land comprised in the Precinct Notices …”. “Precinct Notices” under the PPA includes, relevantly, the Second Replacement Section 29 Notice. I have concluded that by seeking leave to discontinue unconditionally and to take effect before 18 April 2013 the applicant, as NTP under the PPA, given its knowledge of the purpose of the Goolarabooloo is by means of this grant of leave is to put it in a position to oppose the Takings upon the Goolarabooloo Determination Application being registered before 18 April 2013. Thus, arguably, the applicant is facilitating the aim of the Goolarabooloo pursuant to its purpose. This again arguably, is a breach of the NTP of PPA cl 5.2(c).