Rita Augustine v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rita Augustine v State of Western Australia [2013] FCA 338

Citation: Rita Augustine v State of Western Australia [2013] FCA 338 
Parties: RITA AUGUSTINE & OTHERS v STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & OTHERS
File number: WAD 6002 of 1998
Judge: GILMOUR J
Date of judgment: 12 April 2013
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – ongoing dispute between the Jabirr Jabirr members and the Goolarabooloo members of the Goolarabooloo Jabirr Jabirr claim group - application for leave to discontinue – whether leave to discontinue should be granted – the Court’s discretion – whether it is in the public interest for the Court to make orders discontinuing the proceedings prior to the parties resolving certain outstanding issues under the Browse LNG Precinct Project Agreement - whether the grant of leave will cause such prejudice to the other parties that leave should not be granted or should be granted upon conditions  
Legislation: Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 3(b), 28, 29, 30(1), 31, 35(1), 36(1), (3), 61, 62A, 84D, 190C(3), 251B
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.33, 9.12, 26.12(4)
Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) s 171, Pt 9
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (Cth) s 10
Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA)
Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Akiba (on behalf of the Torres Strait Islanders of the Regional Seas Claim Group) v Queensland (No 2) (2010) 270 ALR 564
Anderson v Western Australia (2003) 134 FCR 1
Bodney v Bropho (2004) 140 FCR 77
Brown v State of South Australia [2009] FCA 206
Brownley v Western Australia (1999) 95 FCR 152
Close v Queensland (2010) 190 FCR 182

Combined Dulabed & Malanbarra-Yidinji Peoples v State of Queensland [2004] FCA 1097
Covell Matthews & Partners v French Wools Ltd [1977] 1 WLR 876
Edward Landers v State of South Australia [2003] FCA 264
Foster v Copper Strike Ltd (2006) 200 FLR 182 at [39]; Moore v Mungeranie (2005) 193 FLR 62
Gale on behalf of the Darug Tribal Aboriginal Corporation v New South Wales Minister for Land and Water Conservation [2011] FCA 77
Harrington-Smith on behalf of the Wongatha People v Western Australia (No 9) (2007) 238 ALR 1
Hazelbane v Northern Territory of Australia [2008] FCA 291
Hazelbane on behalf of the Warai and Kungarakany Groups v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 1186
Hughes Aircraft Systems International v Airservices Australia (1997) 76 FCR 151
Lawson on behalf of the ‘Pooncarie’ Barkandji (Paakantyi) People v Minister for Land and Water Conservation for the State of New South Wales [2002] FCA 1517

Levinge on behalf of the Gold Coast Native Title Group v State of Queensland [2012] FCA 1321
McKenzie v Minister for Lands (2011) 256 FLR 1
McKenzie v South Australia (2005) 214 ALR 214

McKenzie v State of South Australia [2006] FCA 891
Moore v Mungeranie (2005) 193 FLR 62
Re Carlton and United Breweries (NSW) Pty Ltd v Bond Brewing New South Wales Ltd; Tooth & Co Limited and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rita Augustine v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 338
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Rita Augustine, on behalf of the Goolarabooloo Jabirr Jabirr (GJJ) claim group, sought leave to discontinue the GJJ Determination Application, which claimed native title over an area in Western Australia. The application was opposed by the State of Western Australia, Woodside Energy Limited, Waardi Limited, and Guumbarr Limited. The legal issues before the Court were whether leave to discontinue should be granted and whether it was in the public interest to do so, considering the potential prejudice to other parties involved in the Browse LNG Precinct Project Agreement (PPA).

The Court found that the application for leave to discontinue was not a result of a proper assessment of the GJJ claim group's validity. Instead, it revealed internal divisions within the GJJ claim group. The Court emphasised the significant public interest in upholding commercial contracts and the associated benefits for the Kimberley Indigenous Peoples and the State's economic well-being. The Court concluded that discontinuance before 18 April 2013 would cause immediate and significant prejudice to the State, Woodside, and others, including the GJJ claim group itself. The Court also highlighted the potential breach of the PPA by the applicant, who had obtained contractual benefits from the registration of the GJJ Determination Application.

Based on the Court's discretion, the GJJ claim group's consent to the future act under the PPA, and the objects of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), the Court decided not to grant unconditional leave to discontinue the GJJ Determination Application before 18 April 2013. The Court ordered that the applicant, the State of Western Australia, Woodside Energy Limited, Waardi Limited, and Guumbarr Limited participate in a mediation to resolve issues arising from the discontinuance of the Application in relation to the Browse Agreements. The Court also reserved costs and adjourned the interlocutory application until after the conclusion of the mediation.

The Court's decision highlights the importance of considering the public interest, contractual obligations, and potential prejudice to other parties when exercising discretion in granting leave to discontinue native title proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant, the State of Western Australia, Woodside Energy Limited, Waardi Limited and Guumbarr Limited participate in a mediation with a view to resolving issues which will otherwise arise upon the discontinuance of the Application in relation to the Browse Agreements as defined in paragraph [4] of the Reasons for Judgment.

2. The parties and the interveners referred to in Order 1 confer and within 14 days of this order file a Minute of Orders as to the identity of the mediator and the terms of reference for the mediation.

3. There be liberty to apply to those parties and those interveners referred to in Order 1 as to the matters the subject of Order 2.

4. The interlocutory application dated 13 February 2013 be adjourned to a date to be fixed after the conclusion of the mediation referred to in Order 1.

5. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant did not have to obtain the approval of the GJJ claim group to seek leave to discontinue the proceeding although the fact that it did so is relevant in the exercise of the Court’s discretion whether to grant leave: Close v Queensland at [32]; Anderson v Western Australia (2003) 134 FCR 1. Background facts The facts are not in issue, although whether certain inferences arise from certain of the facts is. The following background facts are not, I think, controversial, and are taken principally from the State’s written outline of submissions. The GJJ Determination Application is the result of a combination of two separate determination applications commenced by Mr Joseph Roe and others as applicants in 1994 and 1995. Since 1996, the GJJ Determination Application has claimed native title on behalf of the GJJ claim group: Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2011] FCA 102 at [122]-[126]. The GJJ Determination Application, as amended by order of the Court on 21 October 1999, defines the GJJ claim group, described as the "Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr Peoples", in the following terms:This claim is brought on behalf of those Aboriginal people who are ancestrally connected to the original occupiers of the area the subject of the claim and who hold in common the body of traditional law and custom governing the area the subject of the claim; namely, the descendents of Bornal, Appolonia, Wallai William, Nelagumia Mary "Maudie", Keleregado, Milare, Frank Dixon, Nyobing Babere, Chimbere Sitocay and Paddy Roe, and excepting those people who, for their own reasons, have chosen not to be part of the claim group and who have given instructions to this effect; namely: Louisa Grey, Barry Grey, Donald Grey Junior, Doreen Grey, Pauline Grey, Lorraine Grey, Thomas Grey, Regina Grey and James Grey. The GJJ Determination Application was accepted for registration on 29 October 1999. Joseph Roe and Mr Cyril Shaw were, from that time, registered native title claimants, who both controlled the conduct of the litigation and the exercise of procedural rights that are conferred by the NTA on registered native title claimants. "Goolarabooloo" is a family name rather than a tribal name, referring to the descendants of Joseph Roe's grandparents. The claim by the Goolarabooloo to hold native title as members of a native title claim group depends on the incorporation of that family, through Paddy Roe, into Jabirr Jabirr (JJ) society. Disputes about the LNG Precinct The disputes which arose in relation to the GJJ Determination Application began at around the time that James Price Point, located within the claim area, was identified by the State as the preferred site for an LNG Precinct at which the construction of gas processing facilities related to the development of the gas resources in the Browse Basin will occur. The identification of James Price Point as the preferred location for the LNG Precinct was announced by the Premier and Minister for State Development on 23 December 2008.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The evidence does not disclose that the Current Discontinuance Application is brought as a result of a proper assessment as to whether or not the GJJ claim group is in truth the properly defined claim group. Rather, the evidence discloses the existence of internal divisions within the GJJ claim group.Conclusion I do not consider, against this background, that the GJJ claim group ought be allowed to discontinue until sometime after 18 April 2013. Discontinuance before then would visit very significant prejudice upon the State, Woodside and others including, ironically, as I have observed, the members of the GJJ claim group itself as well as the Kimberley Indigenous Peoples. I am almost certain that the likely prejudice I have identified has not been explained to the GJJ claim group at any meeting or at least not explained in meaningful detail. It would undermine the very significant public interest in upholding commercial contracts and, in this case, the associated significant benefits to the Kimberley Indigenous Peoples and the economic wellbeing of the State as a whole. It is less clear since Woodside’s announcement today that it will not proceed with its involvement in the LNG Precinct at least in its present form as to the exact extent of that prejudice. Nonetheless, I am satisfied that there is present and immediate prejudice which emerges from the uncertainties and unresolved issues concerning the Browse Agreements to which I have referred. It is still contemplated by Woodside that it will consider developing a smaller onshore option at the proposed LNG Precinct. The applicant is arguably in breach of the PPA at least in respect to cl 5.2(c) and possibly other warranties and covenants. It should not be permitted to ignore its contractual obligations. It obtained contractual Benefits for the very reason that it gained procedural rights under the NTA stemming from the registration with the National Native Title Tribunal of the GJJ Determination Application. The submissions by the Goolarabooloo that the subject matter of the PPA is unrelated to the conduct of the proceedings is, viewed in this context, wrong. It would be unjust to permit it to walk away from its responsibilities and leaving behind serious contractual problems which are, in my opinion, capable of relatively simply resolution by action on its part and if necessary, by negotiation and agreement. It is of considerable force, in the exercise of my discretion, that the GJJ, under the PPA, consented to the future act the subject of the Second Replacement Section 29 Notice. Moreover, the objects of the NTA include to facilitate the resolution of native title issues by agreement and to allow future acts to proceed: s 3(b) of the NTA; and, for example, Brownley v Western Australia (1999) 95 FCR 152 at [16]-[17]; Weribone on behalf of the Mandandanji People v State of Queensland [2013] FCA 255 at [64]. The interests of the GJJ claim group even after 18 April will also be protected. Their internal divisions should not be permitted and, probably unknown to them, to derail the enormous amount of effort to which of course they contributed co-operatively during that long period, because they may have decided to part company and proceed with independent and competing claims. There is also to be considered the likely massive financial losses which will be suffered by the State and others both actual and prospective.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The third condition is advanced on the basis that members of the GJJ claim group approved the PPA in the first place, but apparently did not consider the effect of the discontinuance upon the PPA when they voted in favour of discontinuance. Consideration Prejudice to the interests of the State and other parties The negotiation and entry into the Browse Agreements, as I have said, involved an exercise by the applicant, acting with the authorisation of the entire GJJ claim group, of certain procedural rights to which the GJJ Determination Application gave rise. This occurred despite the existence, for a number of years, of division within the GJJ claim group as between its Goolarabooloo and Jabirr Jabirr members. This was their group choice in the face of those divisions. The present applicant could have, confronted by these divisions, applied to discontinue the proceedings before entering the Heads of Agreement in 2009, and certainly before entering the Browse Agreements. Had they done so, the extraordinary difficulties which will ensue if unconditional leave to discontinue is granted, would not have eventuated. However, they did neither of those things. Rather, they committed to the Heads of Agreement and then the Browse Agreements expressly warranting that they had the authority to do so on behalf of the entire GJJ claim group and in full knowledge, as expressed in the PPA, that the State and other parties were conducting themselves in reliance on those warranties. The persons who are the applicant, in particular, warranted at cl 3.1(c), in effect, that the GJJ claim group had authorised them to enter into the PPA in the manner required by the NTA on behalf of the GJJ claim group, and that as the NTP, it had the full power and authority to enter into and perform the obligations of the NTP. Further, by PPA cl 4.1, the applicant as the NTP, in effect, consented to and covenanted it would not object to the doing of the future act comprised in the, relevantly, Replacement Section 29 Notice pursuant to section 31(1)(b) of the NTA. Relevantly, the State and Woodside, pursuant to PPA cl 3.6(a) and (b), were entitled to rely upon the warranties given by the applicant, as the NTP, as well as consents given by it. Importantly, the NTP covenanted that it would not do anything to adversely affect the “Takings”. “Taking” under the PPA means “the taking of rights … in the land comprised in the Precinct Notices …”. “Precinct Notices” under the PPA includes, relevantly, the Second Replacement Section 29 Notice. I have concluded that by seeking leave to discontinue unconditionally and to take effect before 18 April 2013 the applicant, as NTP under the PPA, given its knowledge of the purpose of the Goolarabooloo is by means of this grant of leave is to put it in a position to oppose the Takings upon the Goolarabooloo Determination Application being registered before 18 April 2013. Thus, arguably, the applicant is facilitating the aim of the Goolarabooloo pursuant to its purpose. This again arguably, is a breach of the NTP of PPA cl 5.2(c).