Coyne v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Coyne v State of Western Australia [2009] FCA 533

NATIVE TITLE – application under s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to replace current applicant to a native title determination – whether claim group meeting was representative – whether authorisation of replacement applicant was effective – whether application was affected by the death of two persons authorised by claim group to comprise the replacement applicant before application was heard

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 66B, 251B
Native Title Amendment Bill 1997 (Cth), Explanatory Memorandum, para 25.16

Federal Court Rules O 80

Combined Mandingalbay Yidinji‑Gunggandji Claim v State of Queensland [2004] FCA 1703
Noble v Mundraby [2005] FCAFC 212
Risk v National Native Title Tribunal [2000] FCA 1589
De Rose v State of South Australia [2002] FCA 1342
Dingaal Tribe v State of Queensland [2003] FCA 999
Bolton on behalf of the Southern Noongar Families v State of Western Australia [2004] FCA 760
Anderson v State of Western Ausralia [2007] FCA 1733
Sambo v State of Western Australia (2008) 172 FCR 271

DALLAS COYNE & OTHERS and AB (DECEASED) & OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & OTHERS

WAD 6134 OF 1998 AND WAD 6286 OF 1998

SIOPIS J
22 MAY 2009
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 6134 OF 1998 AND WAD 6286 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

DALLAS COYNE & OTHERS
First Applicant

AB (DECEASED) & OTHERS
Second Applicant

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & OTHERS
Respondent

JUDGE:

SIOPIS J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 MAY 2009

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Hazel Brown, Glen Colbung, Ken Colbung, Rita Dempster and Mingli Wunjurri Nungala do jointly replace the current second applicant.

2.Any requirement to file and serve an amended application be dispensed with.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 6134 OF 1998 AND WAD 6286 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

DALLAS COYNE & OTHERS
First Applicant

AB (DECEASED) & OTHERS
Second Applicant

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & OTHERS
Respondent

JUDGE:

SIOPIS J

DATE:

22 MAY 2009

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 4 July 2008, a notice of motion was filed on behalf of Hazel Brown, Glen Colbung, Ken Colbung, Rita Dempster and Mingli Wunjurri Nungala (the applicant movers), relating to the Wagyl Kaip native title claim. The applicant movers seek orders that they replace the current applicant in the native title determination claim WAD 6286 of 1998 (the Wagyl Kaip applicant) pursuant to s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (the Act). This application is part of a consolidated proceeding with WAD 6134 of 1998, which is known as the Southern Noongar claim.

  2. Each of the applicant movers is a member of the current Wagyl Kaip applicant.  There are five other people who are members of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coyne v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 533
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants in the case of Coyne v State of Western Australia sought to replace the current applicants for the Wagyl Kaip native title claim, leading to a dispute with three respondents who opposed the motion. The case arose from a meeting held on 1 December 2007, where decisions were made regarding the authorisation of new applicants for the Wagyl Kaip claim. The respondents argued that the meeting process did not comply with the traditional laws and customs of the Wagyl Kaip native title claim group and that their status as elders precluded their removal as members of the applicant. The central legal issues before the court were whether there was a mandated decision-making process for the authorisation of applicants under the traditional laws and customs of the Wagyl Kaip group, whether the respondents' status as elders precluded their removal, whether the meeting was an effective process for revoking the authority of the current applicants, and whether the authorisation was affected by the subsequent death of two proposed replacement applicants.

The court found that there was no specific decision-making process mandated under the traditional laws and customs of the Wagyl Kaip group that needed to be complied with for the authorisation of applicants. It held that the authorisation could be granted through a process agreed upon by the claim group or according to their traditional laws and customs if they existed. The respondents' status as elders did not preclude their removal as members of the applicant if the claim group authorised such a decision. The court determined that the meeting held on 1 December 2007 was an effective process for revoking the authority of the current applicants and authorising a new set of applicants. The court also concluded that the authorisation was not affected by the subsequent deaths of two persons from the proposed replacement applicant group.

The court ordered that Hazel Brown, Glen Colbung, Ken Colbung, Rita Dempster, and Mingli Wunjurri Nungala jointly replace the current second applicant, and any requirement to file and serve an amended application was dispensed with.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Hazel Brown, Glen Colbung, Ken Colbung, Rita Dempster and Mingli Wunjurri Nungala do jointly replace the current second applicant.

2. Any requirement to file and serve an amended application be dispensed with.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Each of the applicant movers is a member of the current Wagyl Kaip applicant. There are five other people who are members of the current Wagyl Kaip applicant, but who are not included in the proposed new Wagyl Kaip applicant. Two of those people are deceased. The other three are Kevin Miller, Samuel Miller and Mark Smith (the respondents) and they oppose the motion filed by the applicant movers. The motion is not opposed by any other party to the proceeding. I made a referral under O 80 of the Federal Court Rules in respect of the representation of the respondents.BACKGROUND A meeting of members of the Wagyl Kaip and Southern Noongar native title claim groups was held in Albany, Western Australia, on 1 December 2007. In the weeks prior to the meeting, the South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Council (SWALSC) sent 582 notices of the meeting to people for whom SWALSC had addresses and who had either been identified by SWALSC as having descended from the named ancestors on the application or who had self‑identified as Wagyl Kaip/Southern Noongar people. SWALSC also arranged for notices of the meeting to be placed in the Albany Advertiser, The Albany Extra and The West Australian newspapers. The notices stated:South West Aboriginal Land & Sea CouncilWAGYL KAIP/SOUTHERN NOONGAR AUTHORISATION MEETINGA meeting is being held at Dymesbury Lodge Function Centre, Albany on Saturday 1 December 2007 registration at 9.00 am with a 10.00 am start for the members of the native title group for the Wagyl Kaip native title claim WAD 6286 of 1998 and the Southern Noongar native title claim WAD 6134 of 1998 in the Federal Court of Australia.All members of the native title claim group for these claims are invited to attend. The members of that claim group are the biological and adopted descendants of the following people:• Billy Colbung + Clara Brockman + Nina Bayla Brockman;• Helen Williams + Bill Woods;• Sarah Yettung James + Jack Woods;• Sammy “Jimmy” Miller + Polly, from Gnowangerup;• Alice Davidson + Alice Williams + Henry Woods;• Charles or Peter Eades + Lucy Coyne;• William Hayward + Minnie Knapp;• Emily Coyne + William “Peg” Farmer;• Fred Coyne + Margaret Davidson;• Johnny Penny + Margaret “Maggie” Piggott (Starlight);• Charles Williams + Ellen Nelly Foot;• Elijah Quartermaine + Mary “Wartum”;• Ah Lee + Mary Bateman;• Peerup Roberts + Monkey + Emily (Mudah) D’Abb;• Edward Smith + Sarah Punch;• Ernie or George Moir or Muir + Aboriginal woman named Karlbyirt;• Eddie “Womber” Williams + Lily “Tjorlian” Burchell;• George “Bordriditch” Riley + Elizabeth Smith;• Jack MindumDecisions may be made to authorise a new set of persons to be the “applicant” for the Wagyl Kaip claim, and to authorise a new set of persons to be the “applicant” for the Southern Noongar claim. This could involve removing some or all of the existing applicants and/or adding new applicants. If current applicants were to be removed, it would need to be determined by the meeting that those persons were no longer authorised by the claim group, or that they had exceeded the authority previously given to them by the claim group.The current surviving named applicants on the Wagyl Kaip claim are [AB (deceased)], Hazel Brown, Glen Colbung, Ken Colbung, Rita Dempster, Kevin Miller, Sam Miller, [RP (deceased)], Mark Smith and Mingli Wunjurri Nungala.The current surviving named applicants on the Southern Noongar claim are [AB (deceased)], Glen Colbung, Dallas Coyne, Rita Dempster and Aden Eades. (Original emphasis.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

SIOPIS J
The matters raised in the affidavits and the respective parties’ contentions give rise to the following issues:(a)Whether there is a decision‑making process under the traditional laws and customs of the Wagyl Kaip native title claim group for the making of the decisions of the kind made by the second resolution.(b)Whether the fact that the respondents were elders of their respective families precluded their removal as members of the applicant.(c)Whether the resolution passed at the 1 December 2007 meeting was an effective process for the revocation of the authority of the current applicant and authorisation of a proposed replacement applicant, by the Wagyl Kaip native title claim group.(d)Whether, if the 1 December 2007 meeting was effective to revoke the authority of the current applicant and to authorise the substitution of the current applicant with the proposed replacement applicant, that authorisation is affected by the subsequent death of two persons comprising the proposed replacement applicant.THE DECISION‑MAKING PROCESS The first question is whether there is a decision‑making process under the traditional laws and customs of the persons comprising the Wagyl Kaip claim group which had to be complied with in relation to the authorisation of an applicant to bring and deal with a native title determination claim on behalf of the claim group. This question arises by reason of the following statutory provisions. Section 66B(1) of the Act provides:One or more members of the native title claim group (the claim group) in relation to a claimant application, or of the compensation claim group (also the claim group) in relation to a compensation application, may apply to the Federal Court for an order that the member, or the members jointly, replace the current applicant for the application on the grounds that:(a)one or more of the following applies to a person who is, either alone or jointly with one or more other persons, the current applicant:(i)the person consents to his or her replacement or removal;(ii)the person has died or become incapacitated;(iii)the person is no longer authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it;(iv)the person has exceeded the authority given to him or her by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it; and(b)the member or members are authorised by the claim group to make the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it. (Original emphasis.) Section 251B of the Act deals with what it means to be authorised by the native title claim group:For the purposes of this Act, all the persons in a native title claim group or compensation claim group authorise a person or persons to make a native title determination application or a compensation application, and to deal with matters arising in relation to it, if:(a)where there is a process of decision‑making that, under the traditional laws and customs of the persons in the native title claim group or compensation claim group, must be complied with in relation to authorising things of that kind – the persons in the native title claim group or compensation claim group authorise the person or persons to make the application and to deal with the matters in accordance with that process; or(b)where there is no such process – the persons in the native title claim group or compensation claim group authorise the other person or persons to make the application and to deal with the matters in accordance with a process of decision‑making agreed to and adopted, by the persons in the native title claim group or compensation claim group, in relation to authorising the making of the application and dealing with the matters, or in relation to doing things of that kind. (Original emphasis.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SIOPIS J