Wilson v State of South Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wilson v State of South Australia (No 2) [2016] FCA 812

File number: SAD 6019 of 1998
Judge: WHITE J
Date of judgment: 15 July 2016
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – Application under s 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to replace original applicants – original applicants deceased or no longer authorised by claim group to make application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it – orders made to replace original applicants.
Legislation:

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 4.02, 4.04

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 61, 62A, 66B, 84B(1), 85, 203B, 203BB, 203BF, 203BK, 251B

Cases cited:

Anderson v State of Western Australia [2007] FCA 1733

Bolton of behalf the Southern Noongar Families v State of Western Australia [2004] FCA 760

Coyne v State of Western Australia [2009] FCA 533

Daniel v State of Western Australia [2002] FCA 1147; (2002) 194 ALR 278

De Rose v State of South Australia [2002] FCA 1342

Dingaal Tribe v State of Queensland [2003] FCA 999

Law Society of New South Wales v Ramalca Pty Ltd (1988) 12 NSWLR 34

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355

Roe v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2011] FCA 102

Watson v Ebsworth & Ebsworth [2008] VSC 510

Weribone on behalf of the Mandandanji People v State of Queensland [2011] FCA 1169

Wilson v State of South Australia [2015] FCA 1328

Date of hearing: 21 April and 27 June 2016
Registry: South Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Native Title
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 101
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr P Wilson appearing in person by leave on behalf of Mrs Neva Wilson
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr P Tonkin with Mr S Nelson
Solicitor for the Respondent: Crown Solicitor for the State of South Australia
Counsel for South Australian Native Title Services Ltd: Mr AC Collett with Ms B Lena (21 April 2016)
Solicitor for the South Australian Native Title Services Ltd: South Australian Native Title Services Ltd (21 April 2016)
Ms B Lena, South Australian Native Title Services Ltd (27 June 2016)

ORDERS

SAD 6019 of 1998
BETWEEN:

NEVA WILSON AND OTHERS (Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim)

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS

Respondent

SOUTH AUSTRALIAN NATIVE TITLE SERVICES
Other

JUDGE:

WHITE J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 JULY 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.On the interlocutory application filed on 18 March 2016, Caroline Wilson, Elizabeth Pool, Kenneth Wilson, Cindy Morrison, Neville Miller, Vernon Miller and Barry Dean Johncock Senior jointly replace Mr H Ernest Cox (deceased), Mr A Wilson (deceased), Mr L Royden Miller (deceased), Mr W Maurice Miller (deceased), Mr R John Ware (deceased) and Ms Neva Wilson (deceased) as the applicants in this proceeding.

2.The heading of the claimant application be amended so as hereafter to reflect the names of the Replacement Applicants.

3.The interlocutory applications filed by Ms Wilson on 8 March 2016, 10 May 2016…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson v State of South Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 812
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Wilson v State of South Australia (No 2) involved an application under section 66B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to replace the original applicants in a native title proceeding. The original applicants had either passed away or were no longer authorised by the Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim Group to continue with the application. The Replacement Applicants sought to replace the original applicants and to deal with all matters arising in relation to the application.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Replacement Applicants were entitled to replace the original applicants under section 66B(1) of the Native Title Act 1993. The court considered whether the original applicants were deceased or no longer authorised by the claim group to proceed with the application, and whether the Replacement Applicants had been properly authorised by the claim group to replace them. The court also needed to exercise its discretion under section 66B(2) to decide whether to grant the application.

The court found that all of the original applicants were deceased, and that Ms Wilson, the sole surviving original applicant, had indicated that she no longer wished to be the named applicant. The court was satisfied that the Replacement Applicants had been properly authorised by the claim group to replace the original applicants. The court considered that it was undesirable for there to be no live applicants and that the proceedings had effectively been at a standstill due to the delay in obtaining legal representation. The court also noted that the Replacement Applicants had been authorised by the claim group to be the applicants and that it was highly desirable that they be granted the application. The court therefore granted the application and ordered that the Replacement Applicants jointly replace the original applicants in the proceeding.

The final orders of the court were that the Replacement Applicants replace the original applicants in the proceeding, that the heading of the claimant application be amended to reflect the names of the Replacement Applicants, and that the interlocutory applications filed by Ms Wilson be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On the interlocutory application filed on 18 March 2016, Caroline Wilson, Elizabeth Pool, Kenneth Wilson, Cindy Morrison, Neville Miller, Vernon Miller and Barry Dean Johncock Senior jointly replace Mr H Ernest Cox (deceased), Mr A Wilson (deceased), Mr L Royden Miller (deceased), Mr W Maurice Miller (deceased), Mr R John Ware (deceased) and Ms Neva Wilson (deceased) as the applicants in this proceeding.

2. The heading of the claimant application be amended so as hereafter to reflect the names of the Replacement Applicants.

3. The interlocutory applications filed by Ms Wilson on 8 March 2016, 10 May 2016 and 23 June 2016 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

That importance is reflected in the identification in s 61 of the NT Act of those who may bring native title applications (subs (1)), in the provision that those members of the native title claim group who are not a named applicant are not themselves applicants (subs (2)), and in the authorisation granted by s 62A of the NT Act to applicants to deal with all matters arising under the NT Act in relation to the application for native title. It is for this reason that s 251B of the NT Act regulates the way in which a native title claim group is to authorise persons to bring claims for native title. Evidence supporting the replacement of Ms Wilson Although the death of Ms Wilson means that the Replacement Applicants can also rely on s 66B(1)(a)(ii) in her case, I consider it appropriate to address the parties’ contentions concerning whether she remained authorised to deal with matters arising in relation to the application for native title. In support of their application that that the original Applicants no longer had this authority, the Replacement Applicants relied on evidence (which I accept) of the following matters:(a)a meeting of the Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim Group was held on 12 February 2016 at Ceduna;(b)earlier meetings of the Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim Group had been held at Port Lincoln on 20 May 2015 and at Ceduna on 29 September 2015. A meeting scheduled for 14 July 2015 had been postponed following the death of one of the Original Applicants. Despite the meetings of 20 May and 29 September 2015 having been well advertised, they were not well attended. The agenda for the meeting on 29 September included proposed resolutions for the replacement of the Original Applicants but, because of the low attendance, consideration of those resolutions was deferred;(c)notice of the meeting scheduled for 12 February 2016 was sent by post by SANTS on 18 December 2015 to all members of the Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim Group for whom SANTS had contact details. Both the notice, which was in letter form, and the attached agenda made it plain that a principal item of business was the replacement of the sole surviving Original Applicant, Ms Wilson, together with consequential resolutions. SANTS’ letter of 18 December 2015 included the following:This meeting in February 2016 has been expressly requested by the current remaining named Applicant, Neva Wilson. Neva has expressed her desire to be replaced as an Applicant to the claim. The Judge has also said that this process needs to be completed before the next directions hearing on 22 March 2016.(d)the attendees at the meeting on 12 February 2016 were persons listed on the SANTS contact register. Many of the attendees had also attended the previous meetings on 20 May and 29 September 2015;(e)at the meeting at Ceduna on 12 February 2016, those attending resolved that the current applicants were no longer authorised by the Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim Group to proceed with the application and to deal with matters arising in relation to it; and that the seven Replacement Applicants should replace the current applicants on the following grounds:(i)Ms Wilson had indicated that she no longer wishes to be the named applicant;(ii)the other current named applicants had died;(iii)Ms Wilson was no longer authorised by the claim group.It was not suggested that there was any formal defect in the terms of these resolutions;(f)the Wirangu No 2 Native Title Claim Group has no particular process for making a decision under its traditional laws and customs in relation to the replacement of applicants. In that circumstance, the meeting proceeded on the basis that each person present had a right to vote, that voting should be by a show of hands and that resolutions would be passed if agreed by majority of those persons present and voting. All resolutions were passed unanimously and without any of the attendees abstaining from the vote; (g)each of the seven Replacement Applicants was authorised by this means to be a Replacement Applicant;(h)all but two of the Replacement Applicants (Vernon Miller and Barry Johncock Senior) were present at the meeting.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my opinion, it is not necessary for the Court to address Ms Wilson’s criticisms of the meeting of 29 September 2015. They do not bear directly on the matters arising for this Court’s determination on the s 66B application.Conclusion on s 66B(1) For these reasons, I am satisfied that the threshold matters for which s 66B(1) provides are established. All of the Original Applicants are now deceased so that s 66B(1)(a)(ii) is satisfied. Further, had it been necessary to do so, I would have found that, by reason of the resolutions passed at the meeting at Ceduna on 12 February 2016, Ms Wilson ceased as from that date to be authorised by the claim group to deal with matters arising in relation to the application and that Replacement Applicants were so authorised. I mention that Mr Wilson referred in the oral submissions to a number of authorities, albeit not providing the citations. These included Law Society of New South Wales v Ramalca Pty Ltd (1988) 12 NSWLR 34; Watson v Ebsworth & Ebsworth [2008] VSC 510; and Weribone on behalf of the Mandandanji People v State of Queensland [2011] FCA 1169. I have looked at those authorities but do no regard them as being of assistance in resolving the issues which arise on the present applications. Discretionary consideration It remains to considers the exercise of the discretion under s 66B(2). An important consideration in that respect is that there are currently no live applicants. Mr Wilson made an oral application that he be permitted to continue to represent his mother as one of the Original Applicants. An order as sought by Mr Wilson is undesirable for a number of reasons. Ms Wilson can no longer give him instructions in relation to the pursuit of the application and Mr Wilson himself has no authority from the native title claim group to be making decisions in relation the pursuit of the application. It is highly desirable that there be live applicants who can deal with the matters arising in relation to the application. The Replacement Applicants have been authorised by the claim group to be those applicants. This consideration points powerfully in favour of the grant of the s 66B application. Another pertinent matter is that Ms Wilson had not in the six month period between terminating the instructions of SANTS and her death, appointed any other legal representatives to act on behalf of the applicants in the proceedings. This has meant that the proceedings have effectively been at a standstill. That is an undesirable situation and should not continue. The delay to date by Ms Wilson an her son in obtaining legal representation does not inspire confidence that there will be any change in the near future. I mention that, in her affidavit of 7 March 2016, Ms Wilson deposed that she had spoken by telephone to her niece Elizabeth Pool and to three other of the Replacement Applicants who, she said, had assured her that, despite the resolutions passed at the meeting on 12 February 2016, they still acknowledged her as the Original Applicant. The suggestion seemed to be that this undermined the application of the Replacement Applicants for the order pursuant to s 66B.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I mention that Mr Wilson referred in the oral submissions to a number of authorities, albeit not providing the citations. These included Law Society of New South Wales v Ramalca Pty Ltd (1988) 12 NSWLR 34; Watson v Ebsworth & Ebsworth [2008] VSC 510; and Weribone on behalf of the Mandandanji People v State of Queensland [2011] FCA 1169. I have looked at those authorities but do no regard them as being of assistance in resolving the issues which arise on the present applications. Discretionary consideration It remains to considers the exercise of the discretion under s 66B(2). An important consideration in that respect is that there are currently no live applicants. Mr Wilson made an oral application that he be permitted to continue to represent his mother as one of the Original Applicants. An order as sought by Mr Wilson is undesirable for a number of reasons. Ms Wilson can no longer give him instructions in relation to the pursuit of the application and Mr Wilson himself has no authority from the native title claim group to be making decisions in relation the pursuit of the application. It is highly desirable that there be live applicants who can deal with the matters arising in relation to the application. The Replacement Applicants have been authorised by the claim group to be those applicants. This consideration points powerfully in favour of the grant of the s 66B application. Another pertinent matter is that Ms Wilson had not in the six month period between terminating the instructions of SANTS and her death, appointed any other legal representatives to act on behalf of the applicants in the proceedings. This has meant that the proceedings have effectively been at a standstill. That is an undesirable situation and should not continue. The delay to date by Ms Wilson an her son in obtaining legal representation does not inspire confidence that there will be any change in the near future. I mention that, in her affidavit of 7 March 2016, Ms Wilson deposed that she had spoken by telephone to her niece Elizabeth Pool and to three other of the Replacement Applicants who, she said, had assured her that, despite the resolutions passed at the meeting on 12 February 2016, they still acknowledged her as the Original Applicant. The suggestion seemed to be that this undermined the application of the Replacement Applicants for the order pursuant to s 66B. I do not consider that effect should be given to this submission. Rather, I consider it significant that each of the Replacement Applicants has made an affidavit in support their application and that all but two of them were present in Court on 21 April 2016 on the hearing of the application. Those present included Elizabeth Pool. None indicated at that time that he or she no longer joined in the application and none had sought to provide evidence or make submissions, despite having been given the opportunity to do so. In these circumstances, I do not consider that the generalised and unparticularised hearsay assertions of Ms Wilson on this topic should be given weight.