Northern Territory of Australia v Doepel

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Northern Territory of Australia v Doepel [2003] FCA 1384

NATIVE TITLE – application to review decision of Native Title Registrar to accept application for registration under s 190A of Native Title Act 1993 – consideration of requirements of ss 190B and 190C – whether description of composite native title claim group comprising several language groups requires Registrar to look beyond application in addressing the requirement of s 190C(2) – whether information otherwise available to suggest claim group is larger than specified claim groups requires Registrar to look beyond the application in addressing requirement of s 190C(2) – whether Registrar was required to be satisfied in fact of due authorisation of native title claimants or only of matters referred to in s 62(1) in addressing requirement of s 190C(2) – whether Registrar, upon being satisfied of certification under s 190C(4)(a), also required to address separately whether authorisation of application had in fact been given under s 251B – whether affidavits filed in support of native title application satisfied requirements of s 190C(2) and s 62 – whether description of claimed native title rights and interests in application, and material available to the Registrar, could satisfy requirement of s 190B(2) – whether Registrar properly considered the requirements of s 190B(4) – whether, in addressing the requirements of s 190B(5), Registrar may have regard to material in application – consideration of nature of material required to satisfy requirement of s 190B(5) – whether s 190B(5) and s 62(2)(e) require Registrar to address each of the claimed native title rights and interests separately and additionally to the particular matters specified by s 62(2)(e)(i) (ii) and (iii) – whether Registrar erred in not determining finally the applicability of s 47B when addressing the requirement of s 190B(6) – whether Registrar erred in addressing requirements of s 190B(8) and (9).

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 23F, 29, 47B, 61, 61A, 62, 63, 66B, 186, 190, 190A, 190B, 190C, 190D, 203BE, 223, 251B
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1975 (Cth) s 13
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 4, 172
Crown Lands Act 1992 (NT) s 96

Western Australia v Ward (2002) 76 ALJR 1098 followed
Moran v Minister for Land & Water Conservation for the State of New South Wales [1999] FCA 1637 noted
Quall v Risk [2001] FCA 378 noted
Edward Landers v State of South Australia [2003] FCA 264 noted
Mabo v the State of Queensland (No.2) (1992) 175 CLR 1 followed
Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria [2002] HCA 58 followed
Borkovic v Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs (1981) 39 ALR 186 noted
Hamblin v Duffy (1981) 34 ALR 333 cited
Western Australia v Strickland [2000] FCA 652; (2000) 99 FCR 33 followed
Minister for Immigration Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 cited
Quall v Native Title Registrar [2003] FCA 145 considered
Milirrpum v Nabalco Ltd (1971)17 FLR 141 cited
Ward v State of Western Australia (1998) 159 ALR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Northern Territory of Australia v Doepel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 1384
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Northern Territory of Australia has brought a case against Doepel regarding a native title claim. The claimants are the Wardaman, Liyi, Yingawurnarri, and Narrwan groups, who assert a communal native title in the area of the application. Each group is defined by descent from specified apical ancestors. The Registrar of the Federal Court had approved the registration of the application based on the information provided, which included a description of the native title claim group. The Northern Territory has contested this decision, arguing that the Registrar failed to consider whether the identified language groups together constitute an identifiable community and whether the claim group includes all persons who hold native title rights in the area.

The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation and application of sections 190B and 190C of the relevant legislation. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the Registrar properly assessed whether the Registrar was satisfied that the application provided an objective means of verifying the identity of the members of the native title claim group. The Territory argued that the Registrar should have considered whether the language groups constituted an identifiable community under Yorta Yorta and whether the Registrar was aware of individuals or groups not included in the claim group.

The court found that the Registrar had correctly considered the information provided and was satisfied that the description of the native title claim group provided an objective means of verifying the identity of its members. The court held that the Registrar did not err in concluding that the claim group as described could comprise a native title claim group. Furthermore, the court determined that the Registrar was not required to identify individuals or groups outside the defined claim group as long as there was no information indicating that the specified group did not include all persons holding native title rights in the area.

In light of the court's findings, the application was dismissed. The court held that the Registrar's decision to register the application was correct, and the Northern Territory's contentions were without merit. The Registrar had satisfied the statutory requirements for registering the native title claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J
Schedule A to the application describes the native title claim group. It is said to be comprised of the following:‘1.The native title claim group (“the claimants”) is comprised by the Wardaman, Liyi, Yingawurnarri and Narrwan Groups who, according to traditional laws acknowledged, and customs observed: a. are traditionally connected with the area described in schedule B (“the area claimed”) through:i. spiritual, religious, physical and historical associations;ii.biological, classificatory or adoptive descent through one of the four grandparental lines of father’s father, mother’s father, father’s mother, and mother’s mother; and iii.processes of succession.b.have a communal native title in the application area, from which rights and interests derive.’Each of the Wardaman, Liyi, Yingawurnarri and Narrwan groups are then said to be comprised by all persons descended from 31 specified apical ancestors. There are 23 specified apical ancestors for the ‘Wardaman (Wardaman Language)’ group, three for the ‘Liyi (Karrangpurru Language)’ group, four for the ‘Yingawurnarri (Mutpurra Language)’ group, and two for the ‘Narrwan (Mutpurra Language)’ group. Further detail is provided as to each of those apical ancestors. (c) The Decision of the Registrar The Registrar’s reasons for considering that the requirements of s 61(1) were met were brief. The issue is addressed by reference to the conditions imposed under s 190C(2). He noted that Schedule A to the application provided a description of the native title claim group comprised of the Wardaman, Liyi, Yingawurnarri and Narrwan groups. He added that he did not have any other information that indicated that the group does not include, or may not include, all the persons who hold native title in the area of the application. The Registrar was satisfied that the description of the native title claim group in the application provided an objective means of verifying the identity of members of the native title claim group. He was therefore satisfied that the condition imposed by s 190C(3)(b) was met.(d) The Territory Contentions The Territory contentions fell under two general topics. The first is that the Registrar failed to consider whether the several identified language groups together constitute an identifiable community, the members of whom are identified by one another as members of that community living under its laws and customs: Mabo, Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria [2002] HCA 58 (Yorta Yorta). Alternatively, it is argued that the Registrar erred in concluding that the native title claim group as described can in fact comprise a native title claim group for the purposes of s 61(1) of the NT Act. The second of the Territory’s contentions is that the Registrar, on the information provided in support of the registration of the application, knew that there were individuals and clan groups who may hold native title rights and interests in the claim area who were not included in the definition of the native title claim group in Schedule A to the application, and that therefore the Registrar erred in law in concluding that there was no information that indicated that the specified claim group did not include, or might not include, all the persons who hold native title in the area of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

It is convenient to set out ss 190B and 190C in full. The consideration of them throws some light upon what the Registrar is required to be satisfied about in relation to their separate requirements. They relevantly provide:‘190B Registration: conditions about merits of the claim(1)This section contains the conditions mentioned in paragraph 190A(6)(a).Identification of area subject to native title(2)The Registrar must be satisfied that the information and map contained in the application as required by paragraphs 62(2)(a) and (b) are sufficient for it to be said with reasonable certainty whether native title rights and interests are claimed in relation to particular land or waters.Identification of native title claim groups(3)The Registrar must be satisfied that:(a)the persons in the native title claim group are named in the application; or(b)the persons in that group are described sufficiently clearly so that it can be ascertained whether any particular person is in that group.Identification of claimed native title(4)The Registrar must be satisfied that the description contained in the application as required by paragraph 62(2)(d) is sufficient to allow the native title rights and interests claimed to be readily identified.Factual basis for claimed native title(5)The Registrar must be satisfied that the factual basis on which it is asserted that the native title rights and interests claimed exist is sufficient to support the assertion. In particular, the factual basis must support the following assertions:(a)that the native title claim group have, and the predecessors of those persons had, an association with the area; and(b)that there exist traditional laws acknowledged by, and traditional customs observed by, the native title claim group that give rise to the claim to native title rights and interests; and(c)that the native title claim group have continued to hold the native title in accordance with those traditional laws and customs.Prima facie case(6)The Registrar must consider that, prima facie, at least some of the native title rights and interests claimed in the application can be established.Physical connection(7)The Registrar must be satisfied that at least one member of the native title claim group:(a)currently has or previously had a traditional physical connection with any part of the land or waters covered by the application; or(b)previously had and would reasonably have been expected currently to have a traditional physical connection with any part of the land or waters but for things done (other than the creation of an interest in relation to land or waters) by:(i)the Crown in any capacity; or(ii)a statutory authority of the Crown in any capacity; or(iii)any holder of a lease over any of the land or waters, or any person acting on behalf of such a holder of a lease.No failure to comply with section 61A(8)The application and accompanying documents must not disclose, and the Registrar must not otherwise be aware, that, because of section 61A (which forbids the making of applications where there have been previous native title determinations or exclusive or non-exclusive possession acts), the application should not have been made.No extinguishment etc. of claimed native title(9)The application and accompanying documents must not disclose, and the Registrar must not otherwise be aware, that:(a)to the extent that the native title rights and interests claimed consist of or include ownership of minerals, petroleum or gas – the Crown in right of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory wholly owns the minerals, petroleum or gas; or(b)to the extent that the native title rights and interests claimed relate to waters in an offshore place – those rights and interests purport to exclude all other rights and interests in relation to the whole or part of the offshore place; or (c)in any case – the native title rights and interests claimed have otherwise been extinguished (except to the extent that the extinguishment is required to be disregarded under subsection 47(2), 47A(2) or 47B(2)).190C Registration: conditions about procedural and other matters(1)This section contains the conditions mentioned in paragraph 190A(6)(b).Information etc. required by sections 61 and 62(2)The Registrar must be satisfied that the application contains all details and other information, and is accompanied by any affidavit or other document, required by sections 61 and 62.No previous overlapping claim groups(3)The Registrar must be satisfied that no person included in the native title claim group for the application (the current application) was a member of the native title claim group for any previous application, if:(a)the previous application covered the whole or part of the area covered by the current application; and(b)an entry relating to the claim in the previous application was on the Register of Native Title Claims when the current application was made; and(c)the entry was made, or not removed, as a result of consideration of the previous application under section 190A.Identity of claimed native title holders(4)The Registrar must be satisfied that either of the following is the case:(a)the application has been certified under Part 11 by each representative Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander body that could certify the application in performing its functions under that Part; or(b)the applicant is a member of the native title claim group and is authorised to make the application, and deal with matters arising in relation to it, by all the other persons in the native title claim group.Requirements for uncertified applications(5)If the application has not been certified as mentioned in paragraph (4)(a), the Registrar cannot be satisfied that the condition in subsection (4) has been satisfied unless the application:(a)includes a statement to the effect that the requirement set out in paragraph (4)(b) has been met; and(b)briefly sets out the grounds on which the Registrar should consider that it has been met.’