Dann v Yamera

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dann v Yamera [2017] FCA 513

File number: WAD 10 of 2017
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 15 May 2017
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – application for judicial review of Native Title Registrar’s decision to accept claim for registration – operation of s 190C(3) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – overlap of two claimant applications – where member of one claim group also member of second claim group – whether Registrar improperly exercised power under s 190A of the Act – whether exercise of power so unreasonable no reasonable person could have so exercised power – decision set aside
Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 190A(3), 190A(6), 190C, 190C(3)

Administrative  Decisions  (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 5(1)(e) and s 5(1)(f)

Cases cited:

Brooking on behalf of the Bunuba People (Bunuba #2) v State of Western Australia [2015] FCA 1481

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18

Northern Territory of Australia v Doepel (2003) 133 FCR 112; [2003] FCA 1384

Date of hearing: 21 April 2017
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Native Title
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 94
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr DR Chandler
Solicitor for the Applicant: Kimberley Land Council
Counsel for the First, Second and Third Respondents: Mr GM McIntyre SC
Solicitor for the First, Second and Third Respondents: Corser & Corser Lawyers

ORDERS

WAD 10 of 2017
BETWEEN:

KEVIN DANN AND KEVIN OSCAR

Applicant

AND:

DAISY YAMERA

First Respondent

ROSIE MULLIGAN

Second Respondent

SAMMY COSTAIN (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BARKER J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 MAY 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The decision of the fourth respondent to accept the Warlangurru #2 application for registration on 2 December 2016 be set aside.

2.The fourth respondent amend the Register of Native Title Claims so as to remove the entry of the Warlangurru #2 application.

3.There be no order as to costs, unless the applicant moves for costs within 21 days.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BARKER J:

  1. This judgment concerns the proper application of s 190C(3) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA), in circumstances where two claimant applications, made in respect of land and waters in the vicinity of Fitzroy Crossing in the Kimberley Region of Western Australia, overlap.

  2. The first claimant application in time is that of the Bunuba People, known as the Bunuba #2 application.  The second in time is that of the Warlangurru People, known as the Warlangurru #2 application.  Until the Warlangurru #2 application was lodged there was no overlap between the two claims.

  3. Indeed, until the Warlangurru #2 application was made, the earlier Warlangurru #1 claim abutted the Bunuba #2 application. But for the overlapping of the two claims, there would be no current issue arising under the NTA.

  4. The current issue arises because of the terms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dann v Yamera and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 513
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dann v Yamera involved an application for judicial review of a decision by the Native Title Registrar to accept a claim for registration under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The applicant, Dann, sought to have the decision set aside on the basis that it was unreasonable and that there was an absence of evidence to support the Registrar's conclusion that there were no overlapping members between the Warlangurru #2 and Bunuba #2 claim groups. The applicant argued that the Registrar should have made further inquiries to ascertain whether a particular individual, Gracie Mulligan or Grace Mulligan, was a member of the Bunuba #2 claim group. The applicant also contended that the Registrar misconstrued the description of the Bunuba #2 claim group and that the decision was legally unreasonable under section 5(1)(e) and (f) of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth).

The court was required to determine whether the Registrar's decision was legally unreasonable and whether there was an absence of evidence to justify the decision. The court considered whether the Registrar properly exercised her power under section 190A of the NTA, and whether the exercise of that power was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have made the same decision. The court also examined whether the Registrar's interpretation of the Bunuba #2 claim group description was correct and whether there was sufficient evidence to support the decision.

The court held that the Registrar's decision was not legally unreasonable and that there was sufficient evidence to support the decision. The court found that the Registrar had made a reasonable decision based on the information available to her at the time. The court further held that the Registrar's interpretation of the Bunuba #2 claim group description was correct and that there was no requirement for the Registrar to make further inquiries regarding Grace Mulligan's membership of the Bunuba #2 claim group. The court rejected the applicant's contention that the decision was legally unreasonable or that there was an absence of evidence to justify the decision.

The court set aside the decision of the Registrar to accept the Warlangurru #2 application for registration and ordered that the Register of Native Title Claims be amended to remove the entry of the Warlangurru #2 application. The court made no order as to costs unless the applicant moved for costs within 21 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the fourth respondent to accept the Warlangurru #2 application for registration on 2 December 2016 be set aside.

2. The fourth respondent amend the Register of Native Title Claims so as to remove the entry of the Warlangurru #2 application.

3. There be no order as to costs, unless the applicant moves for costs within 21 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Registrar was, therefore, these applicants submit, correct to conclude that the application satisfies the condition.WAS THERE AN ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE OR OTHER MATERIAL TO JUSTIFY THE DELEGATE’S DECISION TO ACCEPT THE WARLANGURRU #2 APPLICATION FOR REGISTRATION? The applicant alleges:(1)There was no evidence or other material to justify the decision of the delegate to accept the Warlangurru #2 claim for registration: s 5(1)(f) of the ADJR Act.ParticularsThere was no information before the delegate capable of reasonably satisfying him for the purposes of s 190C(3) that Gracie Mulligan or Grace Mulligan was not a member of the Warlangurru #2 claim and Bunuba #2 claim groups. The applicant says that, in determining whether the Registrar was satisfied that there was no common claim group member, it appears from the reasons that the Registrar went about this task by, instead, being satisfied that it had not been established that Grace Mulligan was a Bunuba #2 claim group member. The applicant says that making an inquiry of whether Grace Mulligan was not a Bunuba #2 claim group member was an obvious task to be undertaken by the Registrar, and the Registrar could easily have obtained evidence going to that question. In that regard, the applicant says the Registrar was put on notice by the submissions of the Warlangurru #2 applicants that Grace Mulligan and the applicants’ anthropologist had not reviewed the Bunuba Connection Report Genealogies. The Registrar, the applicant says, ought reasonably have concluded from those submissions that the applicants had been and could be in communication with Grace Mulligan and their anthropologist and/or reasonably have known that the Bunuba Connection Report Genealogies were in the possession of the Kimberley Land Council, as the relevant native title representative body. In those circumstances, the applicant submits, the Registrar ought reasonably have made inquiries of the representative body and the applicant in order to obtain evidence that Grace Mulligan was not a Bunuba #2 claim group member. Instead, it appears from her reasons that the delegate was persuaded by the responsive submissions of the Warlangurru #2 claim applicants and reached a level of satisfaction under s 190C(3) from the absence, rather than the presence, of material. It is submitted it was legally unreasonable for the Registrar to do this.DID THE DELEGATE MISCONSTRUE THE BUNUBA #2 CLAIM GROUP DESCRIPTION? The applicant raises what it describes in its written submissions as a “Third Ground” of judicial review – even though only two grounds are actually stated in the originating application, as set out above. No issue is taken by the Warlangurru #2 claim group in this regard. This third ground is said to be the misconstruction of the Bunuba #2 claim group description set out at [15] above. The applicant says the Registrar appears to have placed most weight on the assertion by the Warlangurru #2 claim group that Ms Mulligan does not identify as a Bunuba person and that this is an essential criteria for members of the Bunuba #2 claim group in order to be satisfied for the purposes of s 190C(3).

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant seeks an order that the Registrar’s decision be set aside and the Register be amended so as to remove the entry of the Warlangurru #2 application.WAS THE NATIVE TITLE REGISTRAR’S DECISION SO UNREASONABLE THAT NO REASONABLE PERSON COULD HAVE SO EXERCISED THE POWER UNDER S 190A OF THE NTA? The applicant alleges that:(1)The delegate improperly exercised her power under s 190A of the NTA by deciding to accept the Warlangurru #2 application for registration because it was an exercise of power so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have so exercised the power: s 5(1)(e) of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) (ADJR Act).Particulars(a)No reasonable person would have been satisfied under s 190C(3) of the NTA that there was no person included in the Warlangurru #2 claim group whom was also a member of the Bunuba #2 claim group in circumstances where there was information that:(i)Gracie Mulligan or Grace Mulligan may be the same person;(ii)this person was identified in a Bunuba Connection Report Genealogies as a member of the Bunuba #2 claim group;(iii)this person had not verified that she was or was not a member of the Bunuba #2 claim group; and(iv)the Warlangurru #2 claim group’s anthropologist had not reviewed the Bunuba Connection Report Genealogies.(b)No reasonable person would have been satisfied under s 190C(3) of the NTA that Gracie Mulligan or Grace Mulligan is not a member of the Bunuba #2 claim group on the basis she does not appear to identify as a Bunuba person when having regard to the description of the Bunuba #2 claim group, which properly construed consists of three independent not cumulative elements: [39] and [45] of the delegate’s reasons. The key issue of fact and law raised by the applicant concerning this ground is that the Registrar could not be satisfied that no person included in the native title claim group for the application was a member of the native title claim group for any previous application, if “any information obtained by the Registrar as a result of any searches conducted by the Registrar of registers of interests in relation to land or waters maintained by the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory”. The applicant contends this question admits a yes or no answer which is determinative of whether an application should be accepted. The applicant refers to Doepel at [19]. At [37] of the delegate’s reasons, the applicant notes, the Registrar recorded the relevant information relied upon, including the PowerPoint presentation attached to the draft minutes of the meeting between Warlangurru and Bunuba representatives dated 26 November 2015. The applicant says that, as identified in [41] of the reasons, the presentation stated that Gracie Mulligan was identified on the Bunuba Connection Report Genealogies as a member of the Muway Danggu, that these are the same genealogies used to describe the Bunuba #2 claim group, and that this means Gracie Mulligan and her descendants are members of the Bunuba #2 claim group.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant says the three criteria of the Bunuba #2 claim group are independent and not cumulative. It makes no sense that to be a Bunuba #2 claim group member you have to be a descendant of an apical ancestor and be adopted by members of the application group and be an Aboriginal person that self-identifies and is recognised by members of the claim group as Bunuba.CONSIDERATION OF ALL THREE QUESTIONS As explained by counsel for the applicant, the three grounds identified are all intended to support the first stated ground of the judicial review application, namely, that the exercise of the registration power on behalf of the Registrar was legally unreasonable. I am not at all satisfied that it was legally unreasonable for the delegate to proceed in the way that she did. I do not consider it was an unreasonable exercise of power, in a relevant sense, for her to make a decision on the basis of the information before her. Even more complete information may arguably have been available, including by requesting an anthropological report held by the Kimberley Land Council concerning the Bunuba People. Even if such information had been requested, it is by no means apparent on the material before me that it would necessarily have resolved the question of Grace Mulligan’s membership of the Bunuba #2 claim group. If anything it might simply have made the resolution of that question more perplexing, a task that obviously does not fall to the Registrar finally to decide, as Doepel establishes. In my view, there was sufficient information available to the Registrar, through the delegate, to make the registration test decision. It follows that I also do not think it can be said that there was no evidence to support the making of the decision. The significant question which arises, in the context of the first ground of review, is whether, having regard to the description of the Bunuba #2 claim group relied on by the delegate, the assertion before the delegate that Grace Mulligan did not identify as a Bunuba person was material to the application of s 190C(3) in this case. This is the issue raised by the “third ground” pressed at the hearing. Senior counsel who appeared for the Warlangurru #2 respondents did not dispute that it was open to conclude that Grace Mulligan fell within the Bunuba claim group description, but only if one applied the descent category set out in para (a) above. He submitted, however, that the claim group membership description must be construed in a case such as the present on the following basis. If a person falls within the descent category in para (a), they must also satisfy para (c). That is, they must also identify as an “Aboriginal person” who identifies as a Bunuba person and is recognised by the Bunuba group as a member of that community. Senior counsel thus argued that because the Registrar was reasonably informed on the information before her that Grace Mulligan did not identify as a Bunuba person, she did not fall within the membership of the Bunuba claim group because para (c) was not satisfied. That, he said, was the essence of the finding ultimately made by the delegate, which was open to her, and so the decision she made was not legally unreasonable.