Fulton v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fulton v Northern Territory of Australia [2016] FCA 1236

File number: NTD 20 of 2013
Judge: WHITE J
Date of judgment: 18 October 2016
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – respondent added as a party to the proceedings – separate question as to whether one respondent is a member of the native title claim group.
Legislation:

Aboriginal Land Rights Act (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 131

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 30.01

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 84(3), 86

Cases cited:

Ellaga v Northern Territory of Australia [2012] FCA 665

Ellaga v Northern Territory of Australia [2012] FCA 670

Fulton v Northern Territory of Australia [2013] FCA 1088

Risk v Northern Territory of Australia [2006] FCA 404

Wandarang, Alawa, Marra, and Ngalakan Peoples v Northern Territory of Australia [2000] FCA 923; (2000) 104 FCR 380

Date of hearing: 25 July and 28 September 2016
Registry: Northern Territory
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Native Title
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 83
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J Edwards with Ms A Gibson
Solicitor for the Applicant: Northern Land Council
Counsel for the First, Second and Third Respondents: The First, Second and Third Respondents did not appear
Counsel for the Fourth Respondent: The Fourth Respondent appeared in person

ORDERS

NTD 20 of 2013
BETWEEN:

VINCENT FULTON, ROY CRESSWELL, PETER ELLIS, BARNEY ELLAGA AND NELSON LIMMEN ON BEHALF OF THE MAMBALI AMALING-GAN, MURUNGUN IGALUMBA, MURUNGUN MILGAWIRRI, BUDAL YUWARAN AND GUYAL BARDI BARDI DUMNYUN‑NGATANYANA ESTATE GROUPS (NUTWOOD DOWNS PASTORAL LEASE)

Applicant

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

First Respondent

MINERALS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
Second Respondent

LEXCRAY PTY LTD
Third Respondent (and another named in the Schedule)

JUDGE:

WHITE J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 OCTOBER 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 84(8) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) the Fourth Respondent, Kevin John Kingston, cease to be a Respondent in the proceeding.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

WHITE J:

  1. This judgment is the determination of a separate question arising in an application for the determination of native title filed on 12 November 2013. 

  2. The application concerns the land covered by the Nutwood Downs Pastoral Lease in the Northern Territory.  Schedule A to the application identifies the persons on whose behalf the application is made. 

  3. First, there are those persons who are members by descent of one or more of five estate groups or who have been accepted by senior members of one of those estate groups as members of that estate group.  The estate groups are: Mambali Amaling‑Gan, Murungun Igalumba, Murungun Milgawirri, Budal Yuwaran and Guyal Bardi Bardi Dumnyun‑Ngatanyana.  Each of the estate groups comprises all the persons descended from identified apical ancestors (the application lists some of the descendants).  The application describes these persons as “the Primary Native Title holders”.

  4. Secondly, the application is brought on behalf of “other Native Title Holders” identified in para 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fulton v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1236
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fulton v Northern Territory of Australia is a case concerning the determination of native title over Nutwood Downs in the Northern Territory. The case involves the question of whether Cygnet (Signet) Ada McLennan and her descendants are members of the native title claim group. The dispute arose from an application for native title over Nutwood Downs and required the court to decide on the membership of the claim group. The primary legal issues that the court had to decide included whether Cygnet and her descendants are members of the estate groups listed in the application for native title, whether they have been accepted as members by virtue of a non-descent connection to an estate group, and whether they are "other Native Title Holders" as referred to in the application.

The court examined the anthropological evidence provided by Ms Gay English, a qualified anthropologist who had conducted extensive research in the Roper River region. The court found that Ms English's evidence was reliable and supported the conclusions of Gray J and Mansfield J. The court also considered the ethnographic surveys conducted by Ms English, which confirmed the genealogy of Cygnet and her descendants. The court held that Cygnet and her descendants were not members of the native title claim group. The court found that the evidence did not establish that they were members of the estate groups listed in the application for native title or that they had been accepted as members by virtue of a non-descent connection to an estate group. The court also held that they were not "other Native Title Holders" as referred to in the application.

The court ordered that Kevin John Kingston cease to be a Respondent in the proceeding, pursuant to s 84(8) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 84(8) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) the Fourth Respondent, Kevin John Kingston, cease to be a Respondent in the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The determination of the separate question requires the Court to consider three principal issues:(a)whether Cygnet (Signet) Ada McLennan (Cygnet) and her descendants are members of one of the estate groups listed in the application for native title by virtue of descent from one of the named apical ancestors;(b)whether Cygnet and her descendants have been accepted as members of one or more of the listed estate groups by virtue of a non‑descent connection to an estate group;(c)whether Cygnet and her descendants are “… other Native Title Holders” to whom para 14 of the application of the native title claim group refers.I will also consider Mr Kingston’s claims summarised in (c) and (d) above and some other matters upon which he relied for his claim of membership of the Native Title Claim Group.Anthropological background As mentioned, the NLC, representing the applicant, relied on a report of Ms Gay English. Ms English is an appropriately qualified anthropologist, having obtained a Bachelor of Arts with First Class Honours in Anthropology from Charles Darwin University in 2004 and a Bachelor of Arts with a double major in Anthropology from the Northern Territory University in 1995. Before that, Ms English had obtained a Bachelor of Applied Social Science from the Western Australian College of Advanced Education (in 1989). Ms English has worked as an anthropologist in the Northern Territory since 2002 and had a number of Aboriginal community related employments before then. Her work as an anthropologist has included research in the Roper River region with, amongst others, people of the Alawa Language group. This included research in relation to native title claims concerning a number of pastoral leases in the Roper River area including pastoral leases which adjoin or surround Nutwood Downs. Ms English said, and I accept, that she has worked extensively with senior Alawa informants over a long period of time and that she had formed her opinions relying on their information regarding Alawa country, law, ceremony and ownership of land. Ms English provided the report to the NLC concerning the underlying claim for native title over Nutwood Downs. Mr Kingston raised an issue concerning Ms English which it is appropriate to address before making my assessment of the reliability of her evidence. The issue arises from statements which Mr Kingston attributes to Ms English on the first occasion they met, which was at Hodgson Downs (Minyeri) on 14 August 2011. There were significant differences between the accounts of Mr Kingston and Ms English as to what occurred during this meeting. Mr Kingston’s account was that, at the time, he was visiting Hodgson Downs with his son Haydon and another. He was speaking to Mr Ellaga at his home. Mr Ellaga was an elder in the Guyal estate group. Mr Kingston said that Ms English arrived while he was talking to Mr Ellaga. She had some maps and was seeking the assistance of Mr Ellaga in relation to site surveys she was carrying out on the St Vidgeon Pastoral Lease. Mr Kingston said that he raised his own position with Ms English and provided her with some information, including that his grandmother, Violet, was one of three mixed blood Farrars born at Nutwood Downs. He said that Ms English then told him that “I was only chasing royalties and the evidence I was providing does [not] assist with any claim as the genealogy goes back to[o] far”. Mr Kingston said that Mr Ellaga reacted to this statement in a way which indicated that he did not regard Ms English’s statement as being appropriately respectful.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Court may adopt the findings of Gray J and Mansfield J. That is the effect of s 86 of the NT Act, which provides:86 Evidence and findings in other proceedings(1) Subject to subsection 82(1), the Federal Court may:(a)receive into evidence the transcript of evidence in any other proceedings before:(i) the Court; or(ii) another court; or(iii) the NNTT; or(iv) a recognised State/Territory body; or(v) any other person or body;and draw any conclusions of fact from that transcript that it thinks proper; and(b)receive into evidence the transcript of evidence in any proceedings before the assessor and draw any conclusions of fact from that transcript that it thinks proper; and(c)adopt any recommendation, finding, decision or judgment of any court, person or body of a kind mentioned in any of subparagraphs (a)(i) to (v).(2) Subject to subsection 82(1), the Federal Court:(a)must consider whether to receive into evidence the transcript of evidence from a native title application inquiry; and(b)may draw any conclusions of fact from that transcript that it thinks proper; and(c)may adopt any recommendation, finding, decision or determination of the NNTT in relation to the inquiry. As can be seen, subs (1)(c) authorises the Court to “adopt any … finding, decision or judgment of any court, person or body of a kind mentioned in any of the subs (a)(i) to (v)”. Section 86 permits but does not bind the Court to adopt the findings of an identified body. One circumstance which may make it inappropriate to adopt a previous finding would be the presence of evidence casting doubt on its reliability. The Court did not receive any evidence or submission in the present case to the effect that it would be inappropriate for the Court to adopt the findings of Gray J and Mansfield J (other than that their conclusions are inconvenient for the case Mr Kingston puts forward). Further, the conclusions of Gray J and Mansfield J are supported by the ethnographic surveys conducted by Ms English. In April 2015, Ms English interviewed three of Cygnet’s then surviving children, Franklyn Johns (born in 1924), Harold Johns and Lorna Motlop (Johns). They confirmed to her that Cygnet’s mother was Minnie Lily and that they understood Cygnet to have been born around 1898. Further still, they recognised Minnie Lily and her descendants (including themselves) as being matrilineal members of the Larrakia McLennan group. It is appropriate to record some further genealogy. These matters were common ground or, at least, not disputed. Cygnet had three children to John Samuel Farrar (Jnr) (a non‑Aboriginal man). The three children were David Nutwood Farrar (born 1911), Nancy Mary Elizabeth Farrar (born 1915) and Violet Elizabeth Mary Farrar (born 1917). All were born on Nutwood Downs. In 1916, David Nutwood Farrar was taken by his white grandparents to Maryborough in Queensland and did not return to Nutwood Downs until about 1947. In 1918 or 1919, Cygnet and her two daughters Violet and Nancy were removed to Darwin and then to Bathurst Island. Cygnet died in Brisbane in 1943, having been evacuated there in 1941 following the bombing of Darwin.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established