Gumana v Northern Territory (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gawirrin Gumana v Northern Territory of Australia (No 2)
[2005] FCA 1425

SUMMARY

MANSFIELD J
11 OCTOBER 2005 (SUMMARY 11 OCTOBER 2005)
YILPARA


  1. The principal claim under the Native Title Act 1993 in these matters is for a determination of native title in respect of an area in and around Blue Mud Bay in coastal remote East Arnhem Land, northwest of Groote Island.  The second claim involved a challenge to the power of the Northern Territory to issue commercial fishing licences in relation to the inter-tidal zone of Aboriginal land.  The matters were heard together by Justice Selway, and his Honour delivered reasons for judgment on 7 February 2005.

  2. Justice Selway decided that there should be a grant of native title to the claimants over the claim area.  The grant of native title was:

    (a)to be for a right of exclusive possession over that part of the claim area other than the sea and the inter-tidal zone, that is the area of the foreshore between the high water mark and the low water mark and the area of rivers, streams and estuaries affected by the ebb and flow of the tides, and

    (b)to be for rights associated with non-exclusive possession over the inter-tidal zone and the adjacent sea.

    He did not consider it appropriate to make any order to the effect that the Northern Territory had no power to issue commercial fishing licences in relation to the inter-tidal zone of Aboriginal land.

  3. The claim area is part of the area of two land grants to the Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust made under the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976.  Justice Selway was asked to decide whether the traditional owners of Blue Mud Bay could exclude fishermen and others from the inter-tidal zone in the areas of those land grants, which were made to the low water mark.  By reason of an earlier decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Commonwealth v Yarmirr (1999) 101 FCR 171, he decided he was bound to conclude that the land grants did not have that effect. Consequently, the grant of native title he proposed in respect of the inter-tidal zone was for non-exclusive native title rights.

  4. Before final orders were made, sadly Justice Selway died.  Justice Mansfield, with the consent of the parties, has completed the hearing for the purposes of making a determination of native title to reflect the reasons for judgment of Justice Selway.

  5. For that purpose, the parties consulted regarding the appropriate form for the determination of native title.  They reached substantial agreement.  The native title rights in respect of the land and inland waters are those which, under the traditional laws and customs, involve their possession, occupation, use and enjoyment to the exclusion of all others.  The non-exclusive native title rights in the inter-tidal zone include the rights to hunt, fish, gather and use resources for the purposes allowed by traditional laws and customs and to access the area…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gumana v Northern Territory (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 1425
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gumana v Northern Territory (No 2) involved the determination of native title claims by the applicants, the Gumana clan, over specific areas of land and waters in the Northern Territory. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with deciding on the legal issues surrounding the validity and extent of the native title claims, as well as the implications of other existing interests and rights over the claimed areas.

The court had to determine whether native title existed over the specified areas, and if so, what rights and interests the native title holders possessed. The court also had to consider the relationship between the native title rights and other statutory interests, such as those held by the Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust, Telstra Corporation Limited, and public rights like fishing and navigation. Furthermore, the court needed to address the exclusion of certain natural resources from the scope of native title.

In its reasoning, the court found that native title did indeed exist over the areas claimed by the applicants. The court outlined the native title rights and interests, noting that they were subject to the traditional laws and customs of the native title holders. The court also clarified the relationship between native title rights and other interests, stating that while other interests could prevail over native title rights, the native title itself was not extinguished. The court further determined that native title did not extend to certain natural resources such as minerals, petroleum, and prescribed substances.

The court granted the applicants leave to amend their application to include specific provisions regarding the Fisheries Act 1988 (NT), but ultimately dismissed the amended application. Each party and intervenor were ordered to bear their own costs of the proceedings.

The final determination established native title over the specified areas, outlined the rights and interests of the native title holders, and clarified the coexistence and interaction of these rights with other statutory interests and public rights.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. There be a determination of native title in the terms of the determination set out below.

2. The native title is not to be held on trust.

3. An Aboriginal corporation whose name is to be provided within 12 months, or such other time as the Court may allow, is to:

(a) be the prescribed body corporate for the purposes of subs 57(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (‘the Act);

(b) perform the functions outlined in subs 57(3) of the Act after becoming a registered native title body corporate.

4. Each party and the intervenor bear their or its own costs of the proceeding.

THE COURT DETERMINES THAT:

The Determination Area

1.1. Native title exists in the areas of land and waters depicted on the map comprising Schedule B and described in Schedule A hereto (‘the determination area’), the determination area being made up of:

(a) the areas described in item 1(a) of Schedule A (‘the land and inland waters’);

(b) the areas described in item 1(b) and (c) of Schedule A (‘the inter-tidal zone’); and

(c) the areas described in item 1(d) of Schedule A (‘the outer waters’).

1.2. In the event of inconsistency between Schedules A and B, Schedule A prevails.

1.3 In this determination, unless the contrary intention appears:

(1) ‘land’ and ‘waters’ bear the meanings given by s.253 of the Act;

(2) ‘low water mark’ and ‘high water mark’ refer to the mean low water mark and the mean high water mark;

(3) ‘resources’ does not include minerals, petroleum, natural gas and any other natural resource to the extent to which native title has been extinguished or affected pursuant to valid laws of the Northern Territory and Commonwealth of Australia.

The native title holders

2. The whole of the determination area comprises parts of the estates of the eight Yirritja Moiety clans and the seven Dhuwa Moiety clans known as:

(a) Yirritja moiety clans: (1) Yarrwidi Gumatj, (2) Manggalili, (3) Gumana Dhalwangu, (4) Wunungmurra (Gurrumuru) Dhalwangu, (5) Dhupuditj Dhalwangu, (6) Munyuku, (7) Yithuwa Madarrpa, (8) Manatja.

(b) Dhuwa moiety clans: (1) Gupa Djapu, (2) Dhudi Djapu, (3) Marrakulu 1, (4) Marrakulu 2, (5) Djarrwark 1, (6) Djarrwark 2, (7) Galpu.

3. The persons who hold the communal, group and individual rights comprising the native title are the Aboriginal persons who:

(a) are members of one of the fifteen clans referred to at 2 by virtue of descent through his or her father’s father or by virtue of adoption into the clan;

(b) are the guardians of or successors to the rights of a clan and its members in relation to a clan’s estate;

(c) have kinship connections to one or more of those clans by virtue of the fact that his or her mother (ngandi) or mother's mother (mari) is or was a member of such clan;

(d) are spouses of persons referred to in sub-par (a); or

(e) have non-descent based connections to part or parts of the determination area by virtue of:

(1) his or her place of spirit conception being in the determination area;

(2) being a member of a clan (other than one of the fifteen clans referred to at 2), which clan has one or more estate areas adjacent to one or more of the estate areas that comprise the determination area and that person has relations with one or more of the fifteen clans and their estates through kinship or marriage; or

(3) related spiritual (wangarr) affiliations or ritual authority in or related to the determination area;

(4) being a member of one of the clans known as Ngaymil, Datiwuy, Guyula Djambarrpuyngu and Marrangu who are at times entitled to access places in the determination area associated with ceremony and known as ringgitj places.

Native Title Rights in Land and Inland Waters

4. In relation to the land and inland waters, the native title rights and interests that are possessed under the traditional laws and customs are, subject to the traditional laws and customs that govern the exercise of the native title rights and interests by the native title holders, possession, occupation, use and enjoyment to the exclusion of all others.

Other Interests in Land and Inland Waters

5. The other interests in relation to the land and inland waters are:

(a) the interests of the Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust under the two deeds of grant dated 30 May 1980 made under the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth);

(b) the rights of a holder of a permit granted under Part II of Aboriginal Land Act 1978 (NT) and the rights of a person to otherwise enter or remain on or use the area permitted by ss.69-71 of the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth), Part II of the Aboriginal Land Act 1978 (NT) and Parts IV and V of the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989 (NT);

(c) the rights and interests of Telstra Corporation Limited:

(1) as the owner and operator of telecommunications facilities installed within the determination area, being, the Warralwuy Radio Site situated on Northern Territory Portion 5748(A), the Durabudboi Radio Site situated on Northern Territory Portion 5752(A), and certain customer radio terminals and as the holder of a carrier licence under the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth), including the right for its employees, agents or contractors to have access to the telecommunications facilities for the purposes of maintaining and operating the telecommunications facilities; and

(2) pursuant to the lease to Telstra Corporation Limited from the Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust in relation to NT Portion 5748(A), registered 31 May 2000, in respect of the Warralwuy Radio Site.

(d) rights of access by an employee, servant, agent or instrumentality of the Northern Territory, Commonwealth or other statutory authority as required in the performance of his or her statutory duties;

(e) the interests of persons to whom valid and validated rights and interests have been:

(1) granted by the Crown pursuant to statute or otherwise in the exercise of its executive power; or

(2) otherwise conferred by statute.

6. The relationship between the native title rights and interests and the other interests in relation to the land and inland waters is as follows:

(a) the other interests and the doing of any activity required or permitted to be done by or under the other interests, prevail over the native title rights and interests, but do not extinguish them, and the existence and exercise of the native title rights and interests do not prevent the doing of the activity;

(b) to the extent that the other interests are inconsistent with the continued existence, enjoyment or exercise of the native title rights and interests, the native title continues to exist in its entirety, but the native title rights and interests have no effect in relation to the other interests during the currency of those interests;

(c) if those other interests are later removed or otherwise cease to operate, either wholly or partly, the native title rights and interests will again have effect.

Native Title Rights in the Inter-Tidal Zone and Outer Waters

7. In relation to the inter-tidal zone and outer waters the native title rights and interests that are possessed under the traditional laws and customs are, subject to the traditional laws and customs that govern the exercise of the rights and interests by the native title holders, rights of access to, and use of resources in or on, clan estate areas, being:

(a) the right to hunt, fish, gather and use resources within the area (including the right to hunt and take turtle and dugong) for personal, domestic or non-commercial exchange or communal consumption for the purposes allowed by and under their traditional laws and customs;

(b) the right to access, use and travel over and visit any part of the area in accordance with and for the purposes allowed by and under their traditional laws and customs, including:

(i) to access the area for religious, spiritual or cultural purposes or to engage in religious, spiritual or cultural practices;

(ii) to visit, have access to, and maintain sites, places and areas of religious, spiritual or cultural importance or significance within the area;

(c) the right to make decisions about access to and use and enjoyment of the area by Aboriginal people who recognise themselves as governed by the traditional laws and customs acknowledged and observed by the native title holders.

8. The native title rights and interests do not confer on the native title holders possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of the inter-tidal zone and outer waters to the exclusion of others.

Other Interests in the Inter-tidal Zone

9. The other interests in the inter-tidal zone are:

(a) the interests of the Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust under the two deeds of grant dated 30 May 1980 made under the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth);

(b) the rights of a holder of a permit granted under Part II of the Aboriginal Land Act 1978 (NT) and the rights of a person to otherwise enter or remain on or use the area permitted by ss.69-71 of the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth), Part II of the Aboriginal Land Act 1978 (NT) and Parts IV and V of the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989 (NT);

(c) the rights of the persons holding licences to fish granted under the Fisheries Act 1988 (NT) and the regulations made thereunder or any other legislative scheme for the control, management and exploitation of the living resources within the area;

(d) the right of members of the public to fish otherwise than under the rights specified at (c) above;

(e) the rights of members of the public to navigate;

(f) rights of access by an employee, servant, agent or instrumentality of the Northern Territory, Commonwealth or other statutory authority as required in the performance of his or her statutory duties;

(g) the interests of persons to whom valid and validated rights and interests have been:

(1) granted by the Crown pursuant to statute or otherwise in the exercise of its executive power; or

(2) otherwise conferred by statute.

10. The relationship between the native title rights and interests and the other interests referred to at 9(a) (b), (c) (f) and (g) in relation to the inter-tidal zone is as follows:

(a) the other interests and the doing of any activity required or permitted to be done by or under the other interests, prevail over the native title rights and interests, but do not extinguish them, and the existence and exercise of the native title rights and interests do not prevent the doing of the activity;

(b) to the extent that the other interests are inconsistent with the continued existence, enjoyment or exercise of the native title rights and interests, the native title continues to exist in its entirety, but the native title rights and interests have no effect in relation to the other interests during the currency of those other interests;

(c) if those other interests are later removed or otherwise cease to operate, either wholly or partly, the native title rights and interests will again have effect to that extent.

11. The relationship between the native title rights and interests and the other interests referred to at 9(d) and (e) in relation to the inter-tidal zone is as follows:

(a) the other interests co-exist with the native title rights and interests;

(b) the determination does not affect the validity of those other interests;

(c) to the extent of any inconsistency, the native title rights and interests yield to the other interests.

Other Interests in the Outer Waters

12. The other interests in the outer waters are:

(a) the rights of the persons holding licences to fish granted under the Fisheries Act 1988 (NT) and the regulations made thereunder or any other legislative scheme for the control, management and exploitation of the living resources within the area;

(b) the right of members of the public to fish otherwise than under the rights specified at (a) above;

(c) the right of members of the public to navigate;

(d) rights of access by an employee, servant, agent or instrumentality of the Northern Territory, Commonwealth or other statutory authority as required in the performance of his or her statutory duties;

(e) the interests of persons to whom valid and validated rights and interests have been:

(1) granted by the Crown pursuant to statute or otherwise in the exercise of its executive power; or

(2) otherwise conferred by statute

13. The relationship between the native title rights and interests and the other interests referred to at 12 in relation to the outer waters is as follows:

(a) the other interests co-exist with the native title rights and interests;

(b) the determination does not affect the validity of those other interests;

(c) to the extent of any inconsistency, the native title rights and interests yield to the other interests;

Other Matters

14. The native title rights and interests are subject to and exercisable in accordance with the valid laws of the Northern Territory of Australia and the Commonwealth of Australia.

15. There are no native title rights and interests in:

(a) minerals as defined in s.2 of the Minerals Acquisition Act 1953 (NT);

(b) petroleum as defined in s.5 of the Petroleum Act (NT);

(c) prescribed substances as defined in s.5 of the Atomic Energy Act 1953 (Cth) and s.3 of the Atomic Energy (Control of Materials) Act 1946 (Cth).

1. The applicants have leave to amend the amended application dated 26 August 2004 by the insertion of par 1E in the following form:

‘The Fisheries Act 1988 (NT):

(1) is not a law regulating or prohibiting the entry of persons into, or controlling fishing or other activities in, waters of the sea adjoining, and within 2 kilometres of, Aboriginal land within the meaning of and for the purposes of s 73(1)(d) of the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth);

(2) has no application in relation to waters of the sea that are seaward of and adjoining, and within 2 kilometres of, the boundary lines described in the said grants; and

(3) is invalid and of no effect in so far as it relates to waters of the sea that are seaward of and adjoining, and within 2 kilometres of the boundary lines described in the said grants.’

2. The applicants file and serve the further amended application within seven days.

3. The application, as further amended, is dismissed.

4. Each party and intervenor bear their or its own costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J
As there is no apparent arguable factual foundation in the reasons for judgment for the respondent’s proposal, I do not propose to accede to the contention of the respondents to include in the determination the suggested reservation relating to public roads and public works. I do not think it would, in the particular circumstances, reflect the reasons for judgment to do so.conclusion As I have indicated, in other respects the parties were agreed as to the form of the determination the Court should make. There were minor drafting differences in a few respects, to which I have had regard. I am satisfied that the proposed determination of the applicants, where there is no real concern raised by any of the respondents, does give effect to the reasons for judgment. I do not consider it necessary to address each of those terms of the proposed determination seriatim. For those reasons, there will be a determination of native title in terms of the determination and order accompanying these reasons for orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

Full text does not contain this section.