Hyatt v BHP Biliton IRON-ORE Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   HYATT -v- BHP BILITON IRON-ORE PTY LTD & ANOR [2010] WADC 131

CORAM:   DAVIS DCJ

HEARD:   2 SEPTEMBER 2010

DELIVERED          :   3 SEPTEMBER 2010

FILE NO/S:   CIV 34 of 2009

BETWEEN:   MICHAEL JOHN HYATT

Plaintiff

AND

BHP BILITON IRON-ORE PTY LTD
Defendant

ALLIANCE AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LTD
Third Party

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Late application to amend reply - Whether proposed amendment to reply introduces a new cause of action - Whether amendment should be allowed - Late application for leave to adduce expert evidence

Legislation:

Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 37
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 52, s 53, s 87

Result:

Application for leave to amend reply dismissed
Application for leave to adduce expert evidence allowed

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr D V Brand

Defendant:     Ms B A Mangan

Third Party                   :     Dr J T Schoombee

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Bradley Bayly Legal

Defendant:     WHL Legal Pty Ltd

Third Party                   :     SRB Legal

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

ABB Service Pty Ltd v Hetherington [2001] WASCA 235

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 258 ALR 14

Bank of America Australia Ltd v Ceda Jon International Pty Ltd (1988) 17 NSWLR 290

Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd (1987) 14 FCR 215

Girando v Padbury (1919) 22 WALR 7

Gumana v Northern Territory of Australia (2005) 218 ALR 292

Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Ltd (2001) ATPR 41-794

Ritz Hotel Ltd v Charles of the Ritz Ltd (No 7) (1987) 14 NSWLR 204

SH Lock (Australia) Ltd v Kennedy (1988) 12 NSWLR 482

Tony Sadler Pty Ltd v McLeod Nominees Pty Ltd (1994) 13 WAR 323

University of Western Australia v Gray (No 17) [2007] FCA 924

Weal v Bottom (1966) 40 ALJR 436

Wiltrading (WA) Pty Ltd v Lumley General Insurance Ltd (2005) 30 WAR 290

  1. DAVIS DCJ:  Yesterday, 2 September 2010, I heard two applications, one to amend pleadings and the other for leave to adduce expert evidence, brought by the defendant in this action, BHP Billiton Iron‑ore Pty Ltd.  These applications are urgent, as this action is listed for trial to commence on 13 September 2010, less than two weeks away.

Background to these applications

  1. The action involves a claim for damages made by the plaintiff, Mr Hyatt, following injuries he suffered on 16 January 2006 in the course of his employment when working on a mine‑site known as Area C Mine‑site at Newman, Western Australia.

  2. Mr Hyatt was employed as a serviceman for Capena Contracting Pty Ltd, formerly known as Henry Walter Eltin Constructing Pty Ltd, however Mr Hyatt did not sue his employer, Capena.  Mr Hyatt sued the defendant, BHP Billiton, the owner and occupier of the mine‑site, as Mr Hyatt's "deemed" or "principal" employer.

  3. BHP Billiton commenced third party proceedings against Capena, however, these were not pursued after Capena went into administration.  BHP Billiton also commenced third party proceedings against Allianz Australia…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hyatt v BHP Biliton IRON-ORE Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WADC 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Hyatt v BHP Billiton Iron-Ore Pty Ltd concerned a late application to amend a reply in proceedings brought by Allianz Global Corporate and Specialty Insurance Company Limited (Allianz) against BHP Billiton Iron-Ore Pty Ltd (BHP Billiton) and others. The primary issue was whether the proposed amendment to the reply introduced a new cause of action and, if not, whether leave to amend should be granted. A related matter was the application for leave to adduce expert evidence.

The court examined whether the proposed amendments to the reply introduced a new cause of action, focusing on the details of the misrepresentation or false representation, when it was made, and how reliance was placed on it. The court found that the proposed Trade Practices Act claims were impermissibly contained in a reply and were vague and embarrassing, disclosing no reasonable cause of action. The court also considered the delay in bringing the application to amend the reply and the lack of an adequate explanation for this delay. Despite BHP Billiton's argument that delays in discovery contributed to the late application, the court noted that BHP Billiton had been aware of the potential claim under the Trade Practices Act well before filing the reply.

The court concluded that the proposed Trade Practices Act claims in the amended reply were insufficiently detailed and did not provide a reasonable cause of action. The court also found that there was no adequate explanation for the significant delay in bringing the application to amend the reply. Therefore, the application to amend the reply was refused. The court did not reach the issue of the expert evidence as the primary issue of the proposed amendment was resolved against BHP Billiton.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, as I have already noted, damages must be pleaded. It is not sufficient simply to allege loss and damage as a result of the alleged contravention of the Trade Practices Act. It is necessary to plead material facts to identify a causal connection between the impugned conduct and such loss as is said to have been suffered: see Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd (supra) at 222. In the proposed amendments to the reply, it is not pleaded how the misrepresentation in par 5.5 or the false representation in par 5.6 was made, whether it was something said or left unsaid – and if it was something said, whether that was done in writing or some other way and the substance of what was said. It is not pleaded when the misrepresentation or false representation was made. BHP Billiton's receipt of or knowledge of the misrepresentation or false representation has not been pleaded in either of the par 5.5 or par 5.6. So far as reliance is concerned, it is pleaded only that "Capena or the defendant" relied on the misrepresentation or false representation. There are no details as to how BHP Billiton so relied, or to put it as expressed in Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia (supra) how BHP Billiton was led into error. In fact it is pleaded that "the defendant will provide further particulars of how the [misrepresentation or false representation] was made to Capena or the defendant and how reliance was placed on the false representation upon discovery of the third party's relevant underwriting files". Finally, there is no pleading of the damage suffered. In my view, the proposed Trade Practices Act claims are impermissibly contained in a reply, and in any event they are in a form which ought to be struck out because, as presently pleaded they disclose no reasonable cause of action, are vague and embarrassing. Allianz, on the basis of these proposed pleadings, would be unable to know what case under the Trade Practices Act it had to meet at trial. I turn now to the discretionary factors relevant to the consideration of whether leave to amend ought to be granted. On the affidavit material there is in my view no adequate explanation as to the delay in bringing the application for leave to amend the reply, particularly as BHP Billiton was aware well before filing of the reply in April 2010 of the stance which Allianz was taking with respect to the construction of the Principal's Indemnity Extension. There is evidence, in the form of a letter dated 3 November 2009 from its solicitors to Allianz's solicitors, that BHP Billiton was aware of Allianz's reliance on the terms of the Principal's Indemnity Extension in order to deny indemnity to BHP Billiton. There is no explanation as to why the possibility of a claim under the Trade Practices Act was not addressed at that stage, or later addressed at the stage of the filing of the reply in April 2010. It was submitted by counsel for BHP Billiton that delays in discovery of documents from Allianz can go some way in explaining the delay, however, BHP Billiton gave notice to Allianz of its proposed claim by a letter dated 24 June 2010 from BHP Billiton's solicitors to Allianz's solicitors. There is evidence that on 2 July 2010 BHP Billiton filed an amended third party notice to include a claim pursuant to the Trade Practices Act. That was filed without leave, and therefore does not stand as the third party notice (and the information in that third party notice is insufficient in any event: see ABB Service Pty Ltd v Hetherington (supra) at [12]). However, it does indicate that BHP Billiton had instructed its solicitors in relation to a claim under the Trade Practices Act, at that time. There is in my view no adequate explanation of the delay after 24 June 2010 in bringing this application.