People v State of Queensland (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Malone on behalf of the Western Kangoulu

People v State of Queensland (No 3) [2022] FCA 827  

File number: QUD 17 of 2019
Judgment of: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 19 July 2022
Catchwords:

EVIDENCE – evidentiary rulings – objections to evidence in anthropological report – principles governing admissibility of expert opinion evidence and hearsay basis materials – where expert anthropological witness relied upon opinions of other anthropologists not being called as witnesses in the proceeding – opinions of other anthropologists admissible to prove the foundation of the expert witness’ opinion pursuant to ss 60 and/or 77 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – hearsay opinions not admissible to show that they are in harmony with expert witness’ opinion – where applicant proposed to tender materials prepared by other anthropologists not being called as witnesses in the proceeding – materials of other anthropologists admissible in so far as they are a foundation for the opinions of the anthropologist giving expert evidence in the proceeding, but not otherwise – not appropriate to dispense with rules of evidence

NATIVE TITLE – principles governing admissibility of anthropological evidence and basis material

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 59, 60, 63, 72, 76, 77, 79, 135, 136, 192A

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 61, 82

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 30.01

Cases cited:

Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (No 5) (1996) 64 FCR 73

Alphapharm Pty Ltd v H Lundbeck A/S [2008] FCA 559; 76 IPR 618

Alyawarr, Kaytetye, Warumungu, Wakay Native Title Claim Group v Northern Territory [2004] FCA 472; 207 ALR 539

Blucher on behalf of the Gaangalu Nation People v State of Queensland [2018] FCA 1621

Bodney v Bennell (2008) 167 FCR 84

Borowski v Quayle [1966] VR 382

Daniels v Western Australia [2000] FCA 858; 178 ALR 542

Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588

English Exporters (London) Ltd v Eldonwall Ltd [1973] Ch 415

Gumana v Northern Territory (2005) 141 FCR 457

Harrington-Smith & Ors on behalf of the Wongatha People v Western Australia (No 2) (2003) 130 FCR 424

Jango v Northern Territory (No 2) [2004] FCA 1004

Lardil, Kaiadilt, Yangkaal, Gangalidda Peoples v Queensland [2000] FCA 1548

Lee v The Queen (1998) 195 CLR 594

Lithgow City Council v Jackson (2011) 244 CLR 352

Malone on behalf of the Western Kangoulu People v State of Queensland [2020] FCA 1188

Miller v State of South Australia (Far West Coast Sea Claim) (No 3) [2022] FCA 466

Neowarra v Western Australia (2003) 134 FCR 208

Quick v Stoland Pty Ltd (1998) 87 FCR 371

R v Deputy Industrial Injuries Commissioner, ex parte Moore [1965] 1 QB 456

Risk v Northern Territory [2006] FCA 404

TJ (on behalf of the Yindjibarndi People) v State of Western Australia (No 3) [2015] FCA 1359

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Native Title
Number of paragraphs: 109
Date of hearing: 5 July 2022
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read People v State of Queensland (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 827
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of People v State of Queensland (No 3), the applicant sought to introduce anthropological evidence in relation to a native title claim by the Western Kangoulu people. The State of Queensland contested the admissibility of certain evidence, specifically the opinions of other anthropologists not called as witnesses and additional materials prepared by these anthropologists. The matter was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which had to determine the legal issues concerning the admissibility of expert opinion evidence and the application of the rules of evidence in this context.

The primary legal issues the court had to decide involved the principles governing the admissibility of expert opinion evidence under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), particularly in relation to whether an expert could rely on the opinions of other experts who were not called as witnesses. The court also had to consider whether the additional materials prepared by these other anthropologists were admissible to establish the foundation of the expert's opinion or to demonstrate that the expert's opinion was in harmony with the opinions of other experts. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether it was appropriate to dispense with the rules of evidence in this instance.

The court held that while the Joint Statements were admissible in so far as they served as a foundation for the opinions expressed by Dr Martin in his reports, the additional materials prepared by other anthropologists were not admissible. The court found that these materials were hearsay and could not be used to show that Dr Martin's opinion was in harmony with the opinions of other experts. Furthermore, the court held that it was not appropriate to dispense with the rules of evidence, which require expert witnesses to rely on their own specialised knowledge rather than adopting the opinions of others. Consequently, the court ruled that Dr Kenny's Report and the Conferral Reports were inadmissible.

In conclusion, the court rejected the objections to Dr Martin’s Revised Report, accepted the Joint Statements as admissible in so far as they were relied upon by Dr Martin as a foundation for his opinions, and ruled that Dr Kenny’s Report and the Conferral Reports were inadmissible. This decision underscores the importance of adhering to the rules of evidence and the necessity for experts to base their opinions on their own specialised knowledge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The State also contests the applicant’s submission that the Additional Materials are admissible to show that Dr Martin’s opinion is in harmony with the opinions of Dr Kenny, Dr de Rijke, Dr Gorring and Mr McCaul.BackgroundThe Western Kangoulu claim The Western Kangoulu native title claim was originally filed on 9 May 2013. The most recent form of the application was filed on 10 January 2019. The native title claim group is defined in Schedule A to the application as follows:The group of persons claiming to hold the common or group rights comprising the native title is the Western Kangoulu People.A person is a Western Kangoulu person if and only if the other Western Kangoulu People recognise that he or she is biologically descended from a person who they recognise as a Western Kangoulu ancestor, including the following deceased persons:ŸPolly aka Polly Brown aka Polly McAvoy;ŸJohn ‘Jack’ Bradley;ŸHanny of Emerald;ŸNaimie, mother of Nelly Roberts; andŸAnnie/Naimy Duggan and Ned Duggan. The application describes the Aboriginal people who were associated with the land and waters of the claim area at the time of the acquisition of British sovereignty as being part of a broader regional society. The application states:5.At the time the crown acquired legal sovereignty over the Application Area, there was a body of Aboriginal people who were associated with the land and waters of the Application Area.6.The Aboriginal people who were associated with the land and waters of the Application Area were part of a broader regional society, but were a localised constituent part of this society confining their primary territorial interests to the lands and waters of the Application Area. The contemporary members of the claim group have adopted the name “Western Kangoulu” to explicitly distinguish their localised interests from those of their regional neighbours to whom they have close social and cultural ties dating from the pre-sovereignty period.7.The areas surrounding Western Kangoulu country belonged to groups who have or were identified as: the Jagalingu, Wangan, Karingbal, Kanolu, Wadja and Gangalu amongst others. Together these groups and the Western Kangoulu formed an interconnected cluster of distinct groups who interacted for cultural and social purposes, and shared common spiritual beliefs, religious institutions, social organisation and classificatory kinship systems, and common laws and customs. Together, these groups form what may be termed a regional society situated within the cultural bloc often referred to as the Maric cultural bloc by linguists and anthropologists so named for the common word for human (“Mari”) shared throughout much of this bloc.The Ganggalu cluster The Western Kangoulu claim area identified in the application is not overlapped by any other native title claim and there are no Indigenous respondent parties to the application. However, the claim area adjoins the boundary of one other native title claim area which in turn adjoins and was previously overlapped by other claims areas, which comprise the Ganggalu cluster. Specifically:(a)part of the eastern boundary of the Western Kangoulu claim area adjoins the western boundary of the GNP claim; and(b)part of the southern boundary of the claim area of the GNP claim adjoins the northern boundary of the Wadja claim and the northern boundary of the Wulli Wulli 3A claim.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

By interlocutory application dated 18 March 2022, the applicant applied to have the remaining objections concerning the anthropological evidence determined before trial in accordance with s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act). The application was supported by two affidavits of David Knobel, a solicitor at the firm P&E Law representing the applicant, dated 18 March 2022 and 25 May 2022 respectively. On 30 March 2022, I made orders listing the interlocutory application for hearing on 5 July 2022 and orders for the exchange of written submissions in respect of the remaining objections. Submissions in chief were filed by the State and the applicant on 10 and 13 June 2022 respectively, and responsive submissions were filed by the State and the applicant on 29 June 2022. The State objects to certain paragraphs of Dr Martin’s Revised Report on the basis that Dr Martin’s opinion is not demonstrated to be based upon an application of his specialised knowledge to the relevant facts or assumptions, as required by s 79 of the Evidence Act. The majority of the objections concern Dr Martin’s reliance upon the First and Second Joint Statements. In summary, the State submitted that it is not permissible for Dr Martin to adopt the opinions expressed by others because that does not involve an application of his specialised knowledge to relevant facts or assumptions. The State also objects to the tender of the Additional Materials. In summary, the State submitted that:(a)the Additional Materials are hearsay and inadmissible under s 59 of the Evidence Act; and(b)the Additional Materials are not acceptable basis material for Dr Martin’s Supplementary Report or Revised Report and, accordingly, are not admissible under s 60 of the Evidence Act. The State also contests the applicant’s submission that the Additional Materials are admissible to show that Dr Martin’s opinion is in harmony with the opinions of Dr Kenny, Dr de Rijke, Dr Gorring and Mr McCaul.BackgroundThe Western Kangoulu claim The Western Kangoulu native title claim was originally filed on 9 May 2013. The most recent form of the application was filed on 10 January 2019. The native title claim group is defined in Schedule A to the application as follows:The group of persons claiming to hold the common or group rights comprising the native title is the Western Kangoulu People.A person is a Western Kangoulu person if and only if the other Western Kangoulu People recognise that he or she is biologically descended from a person who they recognise as a Western Kangoulu ancestor, including the following deceased persons:ŸPolly aka Polly Brown aka Polly McAvoy;ŸJohn ‘Jack’ Bradley;ŸHanny of Emerald;ŸNaimie, mother of Nelly Roberts; andŸAnnie/Naimy Duggan and Ned Duggan. The application describes the Aboriginal people who were associated with the land and waters of the claim area at the time of the acquisition of British sovereignty as being part of a broader regional society. The application states:5.At the time the crown acquired legal sovereignty over the Application Area, there was a body of Aboriginal people who were associated with the land and waters of the Application Area.6.The Aboriginal people who were associated with the land and waters of the Application Area were part of a broader regional society, but were a localised constituent part of this society confining their primary territorial interests to the lands and waters of the Application Area. The contemporary members of the claim group have adopted the name “Western Kangoulu” to explicitly distinguish their localised interests from those of their regional neighbours to whom they have close social and cultural ties dating from the pre-sovereignty period.7.The areas surrounding Western Kangoulu country belonged to groups who have or were identified as: the Jagalingu, Wangan, Karingbal, Kanolu, Wadja and Gangalu amongst others. Together these groups and the Western Kangoulu formed an interconnected cluster of distinct groups who interacted for cultural and social purposes, and shared common spiritual beliefs, religious institutions, social organisation and classificatory kinship systems, and common laws and customs. Together, these groups form what may be termed a regional society situated within the cultural bloc often referred to as the Maric cultural bloc by linguists and anthropologists so named for the common word for human (“Mari”) shared throughout much of this bloc.The Ganggalu cluster

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant did not advance any submissions as to why it would be appropriate for the Court to dispense with the rules of evidence in respect of Dr Kenny’s Report or the Conferral Reports. In the circumstances, I am not satisfied that it would be appropriate to do so.Conclusion In conclusion, my rulings are:(a)I reject the objections made to Dr Martin’s Revised Report;(b)the Joint Statements are admissible in so far as they are relied upon by Dr Martin as a foundation for opinions expressed in his Supplementary Report or his Revised Report; and(c)Dr Kenny’s Report and the Conferral Reports are inadmissible.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established