Rrumburriya Borroloola Claim Group v Northern Territory

Link copied
Case Copied 91 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rrumburriya Borroloola Claim Group v Northern Territory of Australia
[2016] FCA 776

File numbers: NTD 6014 of 2000
NTD 6003 of 2003
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 30 June 2016
Catchwords:

NATIVE TITLE – native title rights and interests claimed – where the native title rights and interests claimed, subject to one qualification, are not in dispute – right to take resources – whether right is an unconfined right to take resources of the claim area – whether right to take resources is confined to personal or communal purposes of a domestic or subsistence nature, but not for commercial or business purposes – question of fact on the evidence – exchange of goods for economic utilitarian purposes – exchange of goods for religious, ceremonial or political purposes

NATIVE TITLE – extinguishment – non-tidal waters and subterranean waters – legislation asserting Crown rights in and/or powers over waters in lakes, springs and watercourses – whether native title right of exclusive possession is relevantly inconsistent with a limitation on the use of particular kinds of water – whether non-exclusive rights may properly be read as limited by legislation in a manner that does not abrogate any right vested in the Crown – land areas, bed or subsoil where there is, or may be, water from time to time – appropriate formulation and/or qualification of the right

Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)

Lands Acquisition Act (NT)

Aboriginal Land Rights (NT) Act 1975(NT)

Control of Roads Act (NT)

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)

Road Districts Act 1919 (WA)

Control of Roads Act 1979 (Cth)

Native Title Bill 1993 (Cth)

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)

Native Title (Queensland) Act 1993 (Qld)

Validation (Native Title) Act 1994 (NT)

Control of Roads Act 1986 (NT)

Planning Act (NT)

Control of Waters Ordinance 1938 (NT)

Water Act (NT)

Rights in Water and Irrigation Act 1914 (WA)

Native Title Amendment Bill (No 2) 1997 (Cth)

Crown Lands Act (NT)

Aboriginal Councils and Associations Act 1976 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Western Australia v Ward (2002) 213 CLR 1

Durrayjaba v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1242

Charlie v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1237

Peter v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1238

McDinny v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1239

Rory v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1240

Rory v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1241

Jurluba v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1248

Ngajapa v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1249

Jack v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1250

Miller v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1251

Green v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1252

Brown v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1268

Largut v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1269

Mabo v Queensland (No 2) (1992) 175 CLR 1

Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422

Sampi v Western Australia [2005] FCA 777

Alyawarr, Kaytete, Warumungu, Wakay Native Title Claim Group v Northern Territory (2004) 207 ALR 539

De Rose v South Australia [2002] FCA 1342

Lardil, Kaiadilt, Yangkaal, Gangalidda Peoples v Queensland [2000] FCA 1548

TJ (on behalf…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rrumburriya Borroloola Claim Group v Northern Territory and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 776
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rrumburriya Borroloola Claim Group v Northern Territory, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the extent of native title rights and interests claimed by the Rrumburriya Borroloola Claim Group over a specific area, including the Town of Borroloola. The dispute involved the nature of the right to take resources from the claim area and the potential extinguishment of native title by legislation concerning water rights. The Court had to decide whether the claimed right to take resources was limited to personal or communal purposes, excluding commercial activities, and whether this right was inconsistent with the Crown's rights over non-tidal and subterranean waters as asserted by legislation.

The legal issues at hand required the Court to examine the anthropological evidence and historical interactions, particularly with the Macassans and other Aboriginal groups, to ascertain the character of the claimed rights. Additionally, the Court needed to determine the effect of legislation that purportedly asserted Crown rights over waters in lakes, springs, and watercourses on the native title right of exclusive possession. The central question was whether the non-exclusive rights could be limited by the legislation in a manner that did not abrogate any right vested in the Crown.

The Court concluded that the claimed rights, subject to one qualification, were not in dispute and found that the right to take resources was indeed confined to personal or communal purposes for domestic or subsistence activities. The Court also determined that the native title right of exclusive possession was not inconsistent with the Crown's asserted rights over non-tidal and subterranean waters as outlined in the legislation. The Court formulated the right in a manner that recognised the traditional practices of the claimants while accommodating the statutory framework.

The Court ordered the parties to bring in within a specified period minutes of the determination and orders to be made to give effect to the reasons for judgment. The Federal Court Rules 2011, Rule 39.32, would govern the entry of these orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties do bring in within a period to be specified minutes of the determination and orders to be made to give effect to these reasons for judgment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

No respondent parties, other than the Territory and the Commonwealth, elected to participate in the hearing or to make any submissions.BACKGROUNDThe claim area and surrounding areas As in many claims under the NTA in the Northern Territory, the area the subject of the claim, the Town of Borroloola is surrounded by land granted to the traditional owners (as defined in the Aboriginal Land Rights (NT) Act 1975 (ALRA), and now held by the Narwinbi Aboriginal Land Trust. Under the ALRA, only unalienated Crown land was available to be the subject of a claim that the land is held by or on behalf of the traditional owners of that land. The claim area, as a declared township, was ineligible for that purpose. Surrounding the claim area, there are also areas which were ineligible for grant under the ALRA because of the grant of other interests in that land, principally pastoral interests. It is remarked that the other nearby areas, insofar as they are not addressed in any report by the Aboriginal Land Commissioner under the ALRA, have largely now been recognised by Determinations of the Court as held by the Claim Group, in some cases slightly redefined because of local considerations, under the NTA. The present issue as to the nature and extent of the right to control access to the claim area, and to take and use the resources of the claim area, was not contentious in those determinations: see Durrayjaba v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1242; Charlie v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1237; Peter v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1238; McDinny v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1239; Rory v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1240; Rory v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1241; Jurluba v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1248; Ngajapa v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1249; Jack v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1250; Miller v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1251; Green v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1252; Brown v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1268; Largut v Northern Territory [2015] FCA 1269. Borroloola lies inland of the south-western corner of the Gulf of Carpentaria. In that section of the Gulf of Carpentaria there is the Sir Edward Pellew group of islands (the larger ones of which are West Island, South-west Island, Centre Island, North Island and Vanderlin Island). There are numerous smaller islands. I will call them collectively the Islands. They are variously proximate to the coastline, which features significant saline coastal flats with mangroves and extensive water channels. Relevantly, for present purposes, the McArthur River flows into the Gulf of Carpentaria by a broad delta of channels proximate to South-west Island and runs inland roughly from the south-west, affected by the tides, for some 40 kms to and past Borroloola. Significantly further upstream, is the McArthur River Mine. The McArthur River flows further upstream from that mine as well. It is not necessary, for present purposes, to describe in any detail the full extent of the water courses in that area flowing into the Gulf of Carpentaria.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The content or focus for the reference to the evidence generally which now follows is twofold. As appears in the uncontested or agreed facts and agreed issues, the existence or otherwise of the claimed rights, extending to “commercial activities” or being confined in the manner urged by the Territory and the Commonwealth, may depend first upon the evidence as to the extent and character of the dealings with the Macassans at settlement, and secondly upon the evidence as to the extent and character of the dealings with other Aboriginal groups (which includes for ceremonial or cultural purposes) at settlement. (2) Anthropological evidence The two expert witnesses Mr Stead and Professor Sansom are both very experienced and well-respected anthropologists. Mr Stead has very long, hands-on experience of studying and working with Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory. He has over thirty years’ experience working as an applied anthropologist. This experience dates back to 1972 and includes working as a Patrol Officer / Community Advisor for the Welfare Branch, Department of Aboriginal Affairs at various locations in the Northern Territory from 1972 to 1977. He was then a part-time historical/anthropological researcher in 1979 and an anthropologist (mining issues) from 1980 to 1983 for the Central Land Council in 1979, and an anthropologist for the Aboriginal Sacred Sites Protection Authority from 1983 to 1984 before returning to the Central Land Council from 1984 to 1986. He was then appointed as Manager, Anthropology and Land Tenure Branch, for the Northern Land Council from 1991 to 2003, and then as Chief Executive Officer of AAPA from 2003 to 2008. He has worked also as a consultant anthropologist from 1986 to 1991, and currently is performing such work. Mr Stead has been the author or co-author of over thirty reports in relation to claims under the ALRA or native title anthropological reports and associated documents for various Aboriginal organisations, the Aboriginal Land Commissioner and the Federal Court. He has provided written reports to the Northern Territory and Commonwealth Governments on native title and ALRA matters. He has given expert anthropological evidence in ALRA land claim hearings and in native title hearings, as well as in prosecutions by the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Protection Authority. He has, importantly, had substantial hands-on experience with the Borroloola region and the general surrounding region. He lived in Borroloola for approximately six or seven months during 1975/76, and then until the end of 1976 commuting there on a regular basis from another Aboriginal community, Ali Curung. During that period he undertook approximately 70 weeks’ field work for a range of projects, including the St Vidgeon Station native title claim, the Urapunga Township native title claim, McArthur River and Bing Bong native title issues and various ALRA claims. He has explained that in detail in an appendix to his Report: “Applied Anthropology Field Work: Gulf of Carpentaria/Roper River/McArthur River Region”. The St Vidgeon Station claim was heard by Olney J under the name Wandarang, Alawa, Mara and Ngalakan Peoples v Northern Territory [2000] FCA 923; (2000) 177 ALR 512. The Urapunga Township claim was heard by O’Loughlin J under the name Ngalakan People v Northern Territory (2001) 112 FCR 148.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In reaching those views, I have sought to give effect to the Full Court decision in Moses. I do not consider that it required a focus, at the time of the grant, exclusively upon the legislative framework applicable to either or both of the grantor or the grantee, although that will be a significant perspective. It clearly invites the focus on the time of the grant, where no facts are shown post the grant which might inform the current status of the grant. It accommodates the consideration of the status and structure of the grantee.CONCLUSION I noted at the commencement of these reasons concerning extinguishment that the parties invited the Court to express its reasons, so that they could then prepare a Determination with the detail necessary to give effect to them. I have also indicated that I accept that offer. I propose, therefore, to publish these reasons for decision and to fix a time within which the parties may agree upon the terms of a Determination to give effect to them. I will then make a Determination in those terms.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established