Phillips Fox (a firm) v Westgold Resources NL

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE FULL COURT (WA)

CITATION:   PHILLIPS FOX (A FIRM) -v- WESTGOLD RESOURCES NL & ORS [2000] WASCA 85

CORAM:   OWEN J

WHITE J
PARKER J

HEARD:   20-22 SEPTEMBER 1999

DELIVERED          :   4 APRIL 2000

FILE NO/S:   FUL 186 of 1998

BETWEEN:   PHILLIPS FOX (A FIRM)

Appellant (Third Party)

AND

WESTGOLD RESOURCES NL (ACN 009 260 306)
First Respondent (Plaintiff)

ST GEORGE BANK LTD (ACN 055 513 070)
Second Respondent (First Defendant)

EMLEN PTY LTD (ACN 008 959 769)
Third Respondent (Second Defendant)

MICHAEL GILL and ORS

Fourth Respondent (Putative Third Parties Appearing Under Protest)

FILE NO/S              :FUL 189 of 1998

BETWEEN              :ST GEORGE BANK LTD (ACN 055 513 070)

Appellant (First Defendant)

AND

WESTGOLD RESOURCES NL (ACN 009 260 306)
First Respondent (Plaintiff)

EMLEN PTY LTD (ACN 008 959 769)
Second Respondent (Second Defendant)

PHILLIPS FOX (A FIRM)
Third Respondent (Third Party)

MICHAEL GILL and ORS
Fourth Respondent (Putative Third Parties Appearing Under Protest)

Catchwords:

Contracts - General contractual principles - Construction and interpretation of put option deed - Form of notice of exercise stipulated in deed - Whether put option properly exercised - Whether strict or substantial performance required

Contracts - General contractual principles - Construction and interpretation of settlement deed - Proper construction of obligation to sell shares under settlement deed - Implication of terms - Whether settlement deed contains implied term as to price at which shares to be sold

Contracts - Assignment - Whether assignment supported by valuable consideration

Practice and procedure - Costs - Multiple issues or causes of action - Plaintiff successful overall but failing on many issues - Appropriate costs orders

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Appeal dismissed
Cross-appeal dismissed

Representation:

FUL 186 of 1998

Counsel:

Appellant (Third Party)  :        Mr M J Buss QC &

Mr D Wallace

First Respondent (Plaintiff)  :        Mr M L Bennett

Second Respondent (First Defendant)      :        Mr M C L Dicker

Third Respondent (Second Defendant)     :        No appearance

Fourth Respondent (Putative Third

Parties Appearing Under Protest)            :        No appearance

Solicitors:

Appellant (Third Party)  :        Minter Ellison

First Respondent (Plaintiff)  :        Bennett & Co

Second Respondent (First Defendant)      :        Arthur Robinson &

Hedderwicks

Third Respondent (Second Defendant)     :        No appearance

Fourth Respondent (Putative Third

Parties Appearing Under Protest)            :        No appearance

FUL 189 of 1998

Counsel:

Appellant (First Defendant)  :        Mr M C L Dicker

First Respondent (Plaintiff)  :        Mr M L Bennett

Second Respondent (Second Defendant)  :        No appearance

Third Respondent (Third Party)              :        Mr M J Buss QC &

Mr D Wallace

Fourth Respondent (Putative Third

Parties Appearing Under Protest)            :        No appearance

Solicitors:

Appellant (First Defendant)  :        Arthur Robinson &

Hedderwicks

First Respondent (Plaintiff)  :        Bennett & Co

Second Respondent (Second Defendant)  :        No appearance

Third Respondent (Third Party)              :        Minter Ellison

Fourth Respondent (Putative Third

Parties Appearing Under Protest)            :        No appearance

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Ballas v Theophilos (No 2) (1957) 98 CLR 193

Bava Holdings Pty Ltd v Pando Holdings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillips Fox (a firm) v Westgold Resources NL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] WASCA 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Phillips Fox (a firm) v Westgold Resources NL dealt with issues surrounding the construction and interpretation of contractual agreements, specifically a put option deed and a settlement deed, as well as questions about the requirement for strict or substantial performance and the implication of terms within these agreements. The dispute centred on whether Westgold Resources NL had properly exercised a put option, the form of notice required, and whether an implied term existed regarding the price at which shares should be sold. The court was also required to determine whether an assignment was supported by valuable consideration and to make appropriate costs orders given the complexities and multiple issues involved.

The primary legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the put option deed and settlement deed. The court had to determine whether the put option was properly exercised by Westgold, considering the form of notice stipulated in the deed, and whether strict or substantial performance was required. Additionally, the court needed to construe the obligation to sell shares under the settlement deed and ascertain whether there was an implied term regarding the price at which these shares should be sold. The court also considered the validity of an assignment and whether it was supported by valuable consideration.

In resolving these issues, the court examined the terms of the agreements meticulously. Regarding the put option, the court found that the notice of exercise was not in the stipulated form, but this did not relieve Westgold of its obligations as the defect did not impact the bank’s obligations. The court held that Westgold had not strictly complied with the form of notice required, but this non-compliance did not absolve them of their contractual duties. As for the settlement deed, the court concluded that there was no implied term regarding the price of the shares, and the assignment was not supported by valuable consideration. In terms of costs, the court found that while the plaintiff was successful overall, they had failed on several issues, leading to an order for costs to be borne by the plaintiff in relation to those unsuccessful issues.

The court's final orders reflected the complexity of the case and the various issues adjudicated. The court ordered that Westgold was still liable for the full amount under the put option, despite the non-compliance with the form of notice. It also ruled that there was no implied term regarding the sale price of the shares and that the assignment lacked valuable consideration. Costs were awarded to the plaintiff for the successful aspects of the case, while the unsuccessful issues resulted in costs being borne by the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WHITE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WHITE J

The learned trial Judge dealt with this aspect (AB 104 ‑ 105) as follows:"The 'false' statutory declarationOn behalf of Westgold, it was submitted that it would not have been obliged to settle on 1 July 1998 in any event, because Emlen/St George Bank was not in a position to settle. This is said to be mainly because there was not in existence a statutory declaration in the terms required by cl 4 of the cash security deed.I find that there was not such a document in existence. It is an extraordinary feature of the case that on 30 July 1997, Mr Dundo procured the signatures of two directors of Emlen Pty Ltd, Mr Crawley and Mr Brookes, to a blank form of statutory declaration in the form scheduled to the cash security deed. Of course, the statutory declaration required by cl 4 had to depose to a state of affairs as at 30 June 1998, as has already been observed. What Mr Dundo was thinking of when he had Mr Crawley and Mr Brookes sign the document in July 1997, I do not know. I think the answer must be that he was not thinking at all. He and the other witnesses involved, including Mr Wilkes, were rigorously cross-examined on the matter by Mr McClintock QC. They gave no satisfactory explanation. I should say, however, that I do not find that they had any intention to deceive. I do not believe it was in the mind of Mr Dundo, or Mr Wilkes or anyone else, to actually present a false declaration. The date written in to the jurat by Mr Dundo was 30 July 1997, that is, the day on which the document was signed. The declaration on its face was therefore incompetent inasmuch as it was, on its face, a declaration made on 30 July 1997 deposing to a state of affairs 'on 30 June 1998 ... '. In the result, however, there was not a compliance with cl 4. That there was not in existence a statutory declaration which satisfied the requirements of cl 4 of the cash security deed did not, however, provide Westgold with a warrant to decline to settle. The cash security deed required Emlen to produce the statutory declaration to the bank, not to Westgold. Non-production of the document or production of a disconform statutory declaration would have entitled the bank to be not satisfied of the fact of the exercise of the put option and to be not satisfied that Emlen had become entitled to withdraw money from the account. In these circumstances, the bank would have been entitled to refuse to permit the withdrawal sought to be made by Emlen. That is all. Failure to produce a statutory declaration in the prescribed form did not give rise to any relevant right in Westgold or relieve Westgold of any obligation." Westgold pointed out that Emlen and its associates sold approximately 14.8 million shares in St Barbara Mines in the period 30 July 1997 to 30 June 1998 and that the consequence was that the notice of exercise could only be valid so as to put 5.2 million shares to Westgold, or, alternatively, that Westgold's liability under the put option was reduced pro tanto to about $2.1 million.