Nicholls v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Nicholls & Anor v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd [2022] QCATA 103

PARTIES:

SERENA NICHOLLS
LYN NICHOLLS

(applicants/appellants)

v

KLINE INDUSTRIES INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD T/AS KLINE HOMES

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL196-20

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO:

BDL056-16

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

4 July 2022

HEARING DATE:

19 May 2021

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown

ORDERS:

1.   The time to file the application for leave to appeal or appeal is extended.

2.   The application for leave to appeal is refused.

3.   The appeal is dismissed.

4.   The parties must file in the Tribunal two (2) copies and exchange (1) copy of submissions on the costs of the appeal by 4:00pm on 18 July 2022.

5.   The parties must file in the Tribunal two (2) copies and exchange (1) copy of submissions in response by 4:00pm on 18 July 2022.

6.   The submissions on costs filed by the parties in accordance with these orders must not exceed three (3) pages in length.

7.   The Appeal Tribunal will decide the cost of the appeal on the papers after 18 July 2022.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE-QUEENSLAND – TIME FOR APPEAL – EXTENSION OF TIME – WHEN REFUSED – CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING, AND RELATED CONTRACTS – THE CONTRACT – CONSTRUCTION OF PARTICULAR CONTRACTS AND IMPLIED CONDITIONS – VARIATIONS – where applicants entered into a building contract with the respondent - where survey report erroneous – whether survey report formed part of contract documents – whether applicants liable for errors in the survey report - where second survey report resulted in variations to the contract - where the building works had reached practical completion save for works under an extended works agreement – where finding of finding practical completion not appealed - where applicants found liable for the increased building costs resulting from the variations to the contract - whether tribunal erred in finding material errors in first survey report - whether tribunal erred in accepting expert evidence - whether tribunal erred in finding retaining wall was landscape feature only and not structural - whether tribunal erred in finding exceptional circumstances pursuant to s 84(4) of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) in respect of variations claimed by the respondent – whether tribunal erred in the exercise of the discretion to allow recovery of amounts for non-compliant variations

Building Regulation 2006 (Qld) schedule 1, s 3 Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) s 84, s 84(4), s 84(4)(a)(i), s 84(4)(b) Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) s 61(1)(a), s 61(3), s 92, s 93(1)(a), s 142(1), s 142(3)(a)(ii), s 142(3)(a)(iii), s 142(3)(b), s 143(4)(b), s 143(5)(c), s 146, s 147, s 147(2), s 147(3), Sch 3
 

Allaro Homes Cairns Pty Ltd v O’Reilly & Anor [2012] QCA 286
Amundsen v Queensland College of Teachers [2011] QCATA 2
Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Rights Association (1973) 129 CLR 99
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
Azzopardiv Tasman…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicholls v Kline Industries International Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCATA 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Court was brought by the Nicholls against Kline Industries International Pty Ltd, the builder responsible for constructing a second house on a Gold Coast property. The dispute centred on the costs associated with variations to the original building contract due to an erroneous survey report provided by the Nicholls. The Appeal Tribunal had previously found the Nicholls liable for the increased building costs resulting from these variations. The key issues before the Court were whether the tribunal had erred in finding material errors in the first survey report, accepting expert evidence, determining the nature of the retaining wall, and finding exceptional circumstances for the variations claimed by Kline.

The Court found that the tribunal's decision was well-reasoned and supported by the evidence. The tribunal had correctly accepted the evidence of Kline's expert, Mr Sim, that there were material errors in the first survey report. The tribunal had also correctly accepted the evidence that a site inspection may not necessarily have revealed the inaccuracy of the first survey report. Furthermore, the tribunal had appropriately determined that the retaining wall was a landscape feature only and not structural. The tribunal had also correctly found that exceptional circumstances existed pursuant to s 84(4) of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) in respect of the variations claimed by Kline. The tribunal had exercised its discretion appropriately in allowing recovery of amounts for the non-compliant variations.

Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeal, refused the application for leave to appeal, and extended the time for filing the application for leave to appeal or appeal. The Court also ordered the parties to file and exchange submissions on the costs of the appeal by a specified date, with a limit on the length of the submissions. The cost of the appeal was to be decided by the Appeal Tribunal on the papers after the specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time to file the application for leave to appeal or appeal is extended.

2. The application for leave to appeal is refused.

3. The appeal is dismissed.

4. The parties must file in the Tribunal two (2) copies and exchange (1) copy of submissions on the costs of the appeal by 4:00pm on 18 July 2022.

5. The parties must file in the Tribunal two (2) copies and exchange (1) copy of submissions in response by 4:00pm on 18 July 2022.

6. The submissions on costs filed by the parties in accordance with these orders must not exceed three (3) pages in length.

7. The Appeal Tribunal will decide the cost of the appeal on the papers after 18 July 2022.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Nicholls decided to build a second house on their Gold Coast property and approached Kline Industries International Pty Ltd to undertake the construction. Prior to signing the building contract on 23 October 2014, the Nicholls provided Kline with a contour survey report dated 24 May 2013 prepared by Alan Sullivan & Associates, which was used to develop initial plans for the house. Following substantial amendments to the preliminary plans, the building contract was signed, with a contract price of $400,342.00 inclusive of GST. After the contract was signed, it became apparent that the initial survey report was incorrect, leading to an updated survey report on 18 November 2014. This updated survey report resulted in variations to the contract, increasing the building costs by $42,448.22 and decreasing them by $7,711.29. The contract included a Client Confirmation of Building Products and an Excluded Works Agreement (EWA) which outlined additional works to be completed once the Nicholls refinanced their loan and paid Kline $43,270.00.

This case involves an appeal from a decision made by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The appeal was heard by the Appeal Tribunal of QCAT. The initial decision was made by a QCAT panel in favour of Kline Industries International Pty Ltd, finding the Nicholls liable for the increased building costs resulting from the variations to the contract. The Nicholls appealed this decision, challenging several findings of fact made by the QCAT panel. The appeal was ultimately dismissed by the Appeal Tribunal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In deciding an appeal on a question of fact or mixed law and fact, subject to leave to appeal being granted, the appeal must be decided by way of rehearing.[10] In deciding the appeal the Appeal Tribunal may confirm or amend the decision, set aside the decision and substitute its own decision, or set aside the decision and return the matter to the Tribunal below for reconsideration.[11][10]QCAT Act, s 147(2).[11]Ibid, s 147(3).The decision at first instance It is appropriate to outline the background to the dispute before turning to the grounds of appeal advanced by the Nicholls. The Nicholls lived in a house on the Gold Coast. They decided to build another house on the same lot and then to strata title the houses. In mid-2014, the Nicholls approached Kline to build the second house.[12] In the period between when the Nicholls first contacted Kline and the signing of the contract the parties engaged in extensive negotiations. [12]First decision, [5]. Of significance in the current appeal, the Nicholls provided Kline with a contour survey report dated 24 May 2013 prepared by Alan Sullivan & Associates, consulting surveyors (the first survey report). The first survey report was used by Kline’s draftsman, Stuart Osman, to develop initial plans for the proposed second house. It was also used by Mr Jason Anderson of All Round Scaffolding, one of Kline’s sub-contractors, to quote scaffolding costs for the build. Following substantial amendments to the preliminary plans requested by the Nicholls, a building contract was signed on 23 October 2014. The contract price was $400,342.00 inclusive of GST. The price was agreed after the parties varied the preliminary plans to enable the Nicholls to obtain finance. A set of plans, ‘Rev C’, was provided to the Nichols by Mr Osman on 27 October 2014, that is, after the parties had signed the building contract. Kline says that it became apparent after Rev C was developed that the first survey plan was incorrect. An updated survey was sought and provided by Alan Sullivan & Associates on 18 November 2014, which showed differences to the slope gradient on the lot (the second survey report). After the preparation of the Rev C plans, the parties worked through various further editions of the plans, ultimately leading to the Rev J plans.[13] The Rev J plans, which reflected a decrease in the size of the house, resulted in some building costs claimed by Kline increasing and some costs decreasing. These additional costs related to framing, redrafting, external cladding, fix-out materials, and scaffolding. The total increased costs were $42,448.22. The decrease in costs, totalling $7,711.29, related to gyprock, roof, tiles, waterproofing and windows. [13]Ibid, [94]. The second survey report resulted in variations to the contract and, ultimately, variations to the cost of the build. As referred to above, the contents of the report also resulted in changes to scaffolding quotes and costs by All Round Scaffolding. The contract incorporated a Client Confirmation of Building Products and an Excluded Works Agreement (EWA).[14] The EWA provided for a number of items of excluded works: $17,865 for timber flooring; $3,000 in reduction to window changes; $10,000 deck extension to existing house; $6,243 back landings; $1,862 water tank and pump; $4,300 air conditioning. These items were to be completed once the Nicholls refinanced their loan and paid to Kline $43,270.00. The EWA provided that the Nicholls would indemnify Kline in respect of any loss associated with the incomplete works until the payment to Kline was made.[15][14]Ibid, [24].[15]Ibid, [27].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In all the circumstances, balancing the considerations to which I have referred, I am satisfied that it is appropriate to extend the time for the filing of the application for leave to appeal or appeal in respect of the first decision. Consideration of the grounds of appealGround of appeal 1 - the learned member erred by finding there were material errors in the first survey report. The Nicholls say that the learned member erred by accepting evidence which was glaringly improbable or self-contradictory or contrary to indisputable fact. The Nicholls challenge three findings by the learned member:(a)his acceptance of the evidence of Kline’s expert, Mr Sim, that there was a material error in the first survey report which resulted in the need for an updated survey plan;(b)his acceptance of Mr Sim’s evidence that a site inspection would not necessarily have revealed that the first survey report was inaccurate; and(c)his acceptance of Mr Sim’s evidence that the ‘first survey report indicated that the front boundary and the land was larger than it was’. The Nicholls seek to cast this ground of appeal as involving a question of law ostensibly on the basis that there was no evidence to support the findings complained of. It is an error of law to make a finding of fact without any evidence to support the finding.[48] However the submissions by the Nicholls are not consistent with a ‘no evidence’ ground. [48]Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321, [109]. The learned member said the following about the errors in the first survey report and his assessment of the evidence of Mr Sim and the Nicholls’ expert, Mr Dyer:[62] Mr Kline engaged Stuart Osman to draw plans. Mr Kline frequently used Mr Osman as a draftsman. However, he was engaged as an independent contractor. He did not deal with the Homeowners.[63] The Contract was signed on 23 October 2014. Mr Kline says that the day after the Contract was signed he commenced preparations and reviewed the plans being Revision C prepared by Stuart Osman.[64] On 27 October 2014 Kline Homes wrote to the Homeowners advising that there might be an error in the First Survey Report. The Second Survey Report is dated 18 November 2014 and confirmed that the gradient of the slope was steeper than originally depicted in the First Survey Report. That necessitated the plans to be redrawn by Stuart Osman.[65] The error in the contour plans also caused problems with the placement of the house. That was because the First Survey Report indicated that the front boundary and the land was larger than it was. It was necessary in redesigning the house to make it narrower to fit on the smaller area. The Homeowners were advised of this problem in around mid-November 2014. Kline homes recommended the homeowners make an application for a relaxation from the local authorities for moving position of the works. This they did and the relaxation was approved.[66] Ms Nicholls submitted that Mr Kline conceded that he had considered the extra costs associated with the new survey plans. Mr Kline does not recall any such concession. In any event it would not affect the additional costs incurred in amending the plans.[67] Under the Contract the Homeowners were responsible for the errors of the First Survey Report and warranted the accuracy of the documents. The Homeowners by paying for the revised plans by implication accepted the error as theirs.[68] It is alleged that Mr Kline should have inspected land prior to the signing of the Contract and had he done so he would have been aware of the discrepancy in the First Survey Report. Mr Dyer thought Mr Kline should have checked the site, whereas, Mr Sim considered the builder had no reason to doubt the accuracy of the plan. He also testified that a site inspection may not necessarily have revealed the inaccuracy of the First Survey Report.[69] I should interpolate here that I did not find Mr Dyer to be an impressive witness. During cross-examination his answers, frequently, were not responsive to the questions being asked and he often volunteered answers that were not responsive but advanced the Homeowners’ case. Essentially, he was an advocate for the Homeowners. For these reasons, his evidence has to be approached with caution. I am hesitant to accept his opinion unless corroborated by other evidence. Where his opinion disagrees with Mr Sim, I prefer Mr Sim’s evidence.[49] (emphasis added) [49]First decision.