Financial Conduct Authority v Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

Hilary Term

[2021] UKSC 1

On appeal from: [2020] EWHC 2448 (Comm)

Lord Reed, President

Lord Hodge, Deputy President
Lord Briggs
Lord Hamblen

Lord Leggatt

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

15 January 2021

Heard on 16, 17, 18 and 19 November 2020

The Financial Conduct Authority Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd
(Appellant/Respondent) (Respondent/Appellant)
Colin Edelman QC John Lockey QC

Peter Ratcliffe Adam Kramer

Jeremy Brier

Max Evans

(Instructed by Herbert Smith (Instructed by Clyde &
Freehills LLP (London)) Co LLP (London))
Hiscox Insurance Company Ltd Zurich Insurance Plc
(Respondent/Appellant) (Respondent)
Jonathan Gaisman QC Craig Orr QC
Adam Fenton QC Andrew Rigney QC
Miles Harris
Douglas Grant
Caroline McColgan
Michelle Menashy
(Instructed by Allen & Overy (Instructed by Clyde & Co
LLP (London)) LLP (London))
Argenta Syndicate Management Hiscox Action Group
Ltd (Respondent/Appellant) (Hiscox Interveners)
Simon Salzedo QC Ben Lynch QC
Michael Bolding Simon Paul
Nathalie Koh
(Instructed by Simmons & (Instructed by Mischon de
Simmons LLP (London)) Reya LLP (London))
MS Amlin Underwriting Ltd Royal & Sun Alliance
(Respondent/Appellant) Insurance Plc

(Respondent/Appellant)

Gavin Kealey QC Andrew Wales QC

David Turner QC

Clare Dixon

Sushma Ananda Shail Patel
Henry Moore Anthony Jones
(Instructed by DAC Beachcroft (Instructed by DWF Law LLP
LLP (London)) (Manchester))
QBE UK Ltd

(Respondent/Appellant)

Michael Crane QC Rachel Ansell QC

Martyn Naylor Sarah Bousfield

(Instructed by Clyde & Co LLP

(London))

LORD HAMBLEN AND LORD LEGGATT: (with whom Lord Reed agrees)

I Introduction

1. COVID-19 and the resulting public health measures taken by the UK Government have caused heavy financial losses to businesses around the country. Many businesses have insurance policies which cover them against loss arising from interruption of the business due to various causes. Thousands of claims have been made under such policies which the insurers have declined to pay on the ground that the policies do not cover effects (or certain effects) of the pandemic. This appeal has been heard urgently in a test case brought to clarify whether or not there is cover in principle for COVID-19 related losses under a variety of different standard insurance policy wordings.

2. The case has been brought by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) under the Financial Markets Test Case Scheme. This is a scheme which enables a claim raising issues of general importance to financial markets to be determined in a test case without the need for a specific dispute between the parties where immediately relevant and authoritative English law guidance is needed.

3. The FCA has brought the proceedings for the benefit of policyholders, many of whom are small and medium enterprises (“SMEs”). The defendants are eight insurers who are leading providers of business interruption insurance. As set out in a Framework Agreement between the parties, the aim of the proceedings is to achieve the maximum clarity possible for the maximum number of policyholders and their insurers, consistent with the need for expedition and proportionality. The approach taken has been to consider a representative sample of standard form business interruption policies in the light of agreed and assumed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Financial Conduct Authority v Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] UKSC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal involves a test case brought by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) under the Financial Markets Test Case Scheme to clarify whether there is cover in principle for COVID-19 related losses under a variety of different standard insurance policy wordings. The appeal concerns the proper interpretation of four types of clauses: disease clauses, prevention of access clauses, hybrid clauses, and trends clauses. It also raises issues of causation, particularly in relation to how the trends clauses operate. The case has significant implications for policyholders and insurers, as it is estimated that over 370,000 policyholders and 60 different insurers could be affected by the outcome of this litigation.

The Supreme Court considered the interpretation of the disease clauses, which provide cover for business interruption losses resulting from the occurrence of a notifiable disease, such as COVID-19, at or within a specified distance of the business premises. The court held that the disease clause in RSA 3 provides cover for business interruption caused by any cases of illness resulting from COVID-19 that occur within a radius of 25 miles of the premises from which the business is carried on. The clause does not cover interruption caused by cases of illness resulting from COVID-19 that occur outside that area. The court rejected the FCA's argument that the clause should be read as covering the business interruption consequences of a Notifiable Disease wherever the disease occurs, provided it occurs within the 25-mile radius. The court found that the words used in the clause clearly indicate that the insured peril is an occurrence of illness sustained by a particular person at a particular time and place, and that the clause covers only cases of illness resulting from COVID-19 that occur within the specified radius.

The court also addressed the issue of whether General Exclusion L in RSA 3 excludes claims arising out of the COVID-19 epidemic. The court concluded that the exclusion does not apply to the cover for business interruption caused by an infectious disease, as it would obliterate that cover. The court found it unreasonable to assume that the general exclusion could have been intended to apply to the business interruption cover, as it would have been done transparently as part of the wording of the extension and not buried away in a general exclusion of contamination and pollution risks at the back of the policy.

The Supreme Court's decision provides clarity on the interpretation of disease clauses in standard form business interruption policies and the extent of cover for COVID-19 related losses. The outcome of the case is expected to facilitate prompt settlement of many of the claims and achieve considerable savings in the time and cost of resolving individual claims. The court's reasoning emphasizes the importance of interpreting insurance policies objectively and in accordance with the words used, without attempting to rewrite the wording of the policy or impose a meaning that the words cannot fairly bear.