Hilary Term
[2017] UKSC 24
On appeal from: [2015] EWCA Civ 839
| JUDGMENT |
Wood (Respondent) v Capita Insurance Services Limited (Appellant)
before
Lord Neuberger, President
Lord Mance
Lord Clarke
Lord Sumption
Lord Hodge
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
29 March 2017
Heard on 7 February 2017
Appellant Respondent
Edward Cumming Andrew Twigger QC (Instructed by Enyo Law (Instructed by Birketts
LLP) LLP)
LORD HODGE: (with whom Lord Neuberger, Lord Mance, Lord Clarke and
Lord Sumption agree)1. This appeal raises a question of contractual interpretation. It concerns an
indemnity clause in an agreement dated 13 April 2010 (“the SPA”) for the sale and
purchase of the entire issued share capital of a company, Sureterm Direct Limited
(“the Company”), which carries on business as a specialist insurance broker,
primarily offering motor insurance for classic cars.
2. The sellers of the Company were the respondent, Mr Andrew Wood (“Mr
Wood”), who owned 94% of its share capital, and Mr Christopher Kightley and Mr
Howard Collinge, who owned 1% and 5% of its share capital respectively. Each was a director of the Company and Mr Wood was its managing director. The purchaser
was Capita Insurance Services Ltd (“Capita”). Mr Wood remained as managing
director of the Company until the end of 2010. He brought proceedings against Capita arising out of the termination of his employment and Capita brought a counterclaim against him under the indemnity provision in the SPA, which is the subject matter of this appeal. Mr Kightley and Mr Collinge were, but are no longer, parties to the proceedings.
3. It is not necessary to set out in any detail the circumstances in which Capita
came to make its claim under the indemnity. It suffices to summarise Capita’s claim
as follows.
4. In about August 2008 the Company began to sell motor insurance through online aggregator sites such as Confused.com. The sales were not completed online: potential customers obtained a quotation from the Company on the aggregator site and the Company then contacted the potential customer directly with a view to confirming their risk details before selling them the appropriate insurance policy.
5. Shortly after Capita’s purchase of the Company’s share capital, employees
of the Company raised concerns about the Company’s sales processes, which had
resulted in some customers paying substantially more than they had been quoted online. The employees alleged that the Company had presented customers with higher quotations without informing them why the quotations had increased. The Company had thus increased its own arrangement fees when neither the underwriting premium nor the risk profile had changed significantly. The Company responded to the allegations by carrying out a review of its sales between January
2009 and January 2011. This review revealed that in many cases the Company’s
telephone operators had misled customers into believing that an underwriter had required a higher premium or that their risk profile was worse than it was or had pressurised the customer to make sure that a sale was made.
6. Capita and the Company were obliged…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wood v Capita Insurance Services Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKSC 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was the interpretation of clause 7.11 of the SPA, which provided that the sellers would indemnify the buyer against losses arising from claims or complaints related to mis-selling of insurance products prior to the completion date. The Court of Appeal had previously held that the indemnity could only be triggered by a claim or complaint, but Capita appealed this decision.
The Supreme Court considered the principles of contractual interpretation, emphasizing the need to ascertain the objective meaning of the language chosen by the parties, balancing textual analysis with contextual factors. The court noted that while both textual and contextual approaches are useful tools, their relative importance varies depending on the contract's nature and drafting quality. The court found that clause 7.11, though poorly drafted, clearly limited the indemnity to losses arising from claims or complaints, and not from regulatory actions prompted by internal reviews or whistleblowing. The Court of Appeal's interpretation was deemed correct, as it aligned with the plain meaning of the clause and the commercial context of the agreement.
The Supreme Court dismissed Capita's appeal, affirming the Court of Appeal's decision that the indemnity could only be triggered by a claim or complaint, not by regulatory actions based on internal reviews or whistleblowing. The court emphasized that it was not its role to improve the parties' commercial bargain.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.