Kempton Holdings Limited v StraitNZ Freight Forwarding Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2021-485-000539

[2023] NZHC 688

BETWEEN

KEMPTON HOLDINGS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

STRAITNZ FREIGHT FORWARDING LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

STRAITNZ HOLDINGS LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 17 – 21 October 2022

Appearances:

G P Blanchard KC, E D Nilsson and S G T Ma Ching for Plaintiff J F Anderson KC, M Eastwick-Field and C F Butters for Defendants

Judgment:

3 April 2023


JUDGMENT OF GRICE J


KEMPTON HOLDINGS LIMITED v STRAITNZ FREIGHT FORWARDING LIMITED [2023] NZHC 688

[3 April 2023]

Contents

Introduction[1]

Background[5]

Issues[17]
First issue: Did StraitNZ unlawfully repudiate the contract?[17]

Second issue: What damages or compensation is Kempton entitled to?[22] First issue: Did StraitNZ unlawfully repudiate the contract?[27] Events leading up to the cancellation of the contract by StraitNZ[27] The positions of the parties[40]

Principles of contractual interpretation[56]

The condition — clause 2[59]

Was there an estoppel or waiver which operates to prevent StraitNZ from enforcing the condition?  [84]

Estoppel[87]

Waiver[97]

Variation[103]

Affirmation[104]

Second issue: What damages or compensation is Kempton entitled to?        [111]

Loss and damages principles[111]

Mitigation — the sale of the property[128]
Who takes the benefit of the gain on the sale of the land?[132]

Valuation evidence[150]

Value of property as bare land[159]

Value of land with resource consent[161]

Value of resource consent and agreement in place (the “bundle of rights”) [169] Kempton’s market valuation based on “as if complete” development[187] Alternative damages claim — loss of profits[194]

StraitNZ approach to damages[197]
Conclusion on “as if complete” valuation approach[203]
Alternative claim for damages — loss of income[214]

Conclusion on damages[228]

Wasted costs/reliance damages claim[233]

Conclusion[243]

Summary of damages[249]

Costs[253]

Introduction

[1]    In June 2018 the plaintiff (Kempton) and the defendants (collectively referred to as StraitNZ) entered into an agreement (the Agreement) in which Kempton agreed to design, build for and lease to StraitNZ a bespoke commercial/industrial development on land owned by Kempton in Wiri, Auckland. In September 2018, before the construction contract had been awarded, but after the resource consent had been issued, StraitNZ cancelled the deal. Kempton says StraitNZ wrongfully repudiated the Agreement, and it claims from StraitNZ damages in excess of

$7 million.

[2]    Kempton says it was taken by surprise when StraitNZ cancelled the Agreement. The ground given for cancellation was that Kempton had breached a condition of the Agreement by failing to obtain resource consent by 1 July 2018. Kempton says it had until 1 September 2018 to gain the consent and it did so by then.

[3]    Kempton says the real reason that StraitNZ cancelled the Agreement was because it had plans to sell off part of its operations and did not want to be left with the lease of the premises.

[4]    This case deals with two main issues. The first issue is whether or not the cancellation by StraitNZ was unlawful. The second issue is, if the cancellation was unlawful or otherwise unenforceable, what amount of damages should be awarded to Kempton…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kempton Holdings Limited v StraitNZ Freight Forwarding Limit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 688
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard a case between Kempton Holdings Limited (Kempton) and StraitNZ Freight Forwarding Limited (StraitNZ), with StraitNZ Holdings Limited also involved. The case revolved around a development agreement where Kempton agreed to design, build, and lease a commercial/industrial property to StraitNZ. The dispute arose when StraitNZ cancelled the agreement, alleging that Kempton had failed to obtain resource consent by the specified date. Kempton argued that it had obtained the consent by the extended deadline and that StraitNZ's cancellation was unlawful. The court had to determine whether StraitNZ's cancellation was justified and, if not, the appropriate amount of damages to award Kempton. The court found that Kempton was entitled to complete the condition of obtaining resource consent by 1 September 2018, which it did. StraitNZ's cancellation of the agreement on 20 September 2018 was deemed unlawful. Consequently, Kempton was entitled to damages. The court awarded Kempton expectation damages of $3,100,000, calculated based on loss of income and an allowance for profit on the development, along with interest on the total amount from the estimated completion date of the contract. Additionally, Kempton was entitled to retain the full proceeds from the sale of the undeveloped site, as the sale was unrelated to the breach. The court also allowed for a separate claim of $100,000 for wasted or reliance damages, acknowledging some of the costs incurred by Kempton in reliance on the contract. The case highlighted the importance of contractual interpretation and the principles of damages in commercial law, particularly in the context of development agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established