Millstone Grazing Limited v Myoak Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV 2016-441-102 [2017] NZHC 773

BETWEEN

MILLSTONE GRAZING LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

MYOAK HOLDINGS LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 22 March 2017

Appearances:

J D Haig and H Gordon for the plaintiff
P W Ahern for the defendant

Judgment:

24 April 2017

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

Table of contents

Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... [1] The facts ............................................................................................................................................. [3] The settlement agreement ............................................................................................................... [35] The Buy Back Agreement ............................................................................................................... [41] The Subdivision Land ..................................................................................................................... [47] The parties’ respective positions .................................................................................................... [52] My assessment ................................................................................................................................. [54] Result ................................................................................................................................................ [73]

Introduction

[1]      This claim concerns an option to purchase land.  The plaintiff (Millstone), a company associated with Heughan Gordon, considers it is entitled to exercise that option.   The defendant (Myoak), a company associated with John O’Connor, considers it is not.  Which position is correct depends on the proper construction of

the terms of the option.

MILLSTONE GRAZING LIMITED v MYOAK HOLDINGS LIMITED [2017] NZHC 773 [24 April 2017]

[2]      Millstone has pleaded three causes of action.   Its primary cause of action pleads that Myoak failed to perform its obligation in the option and seeks specific performance.   The other two causes of action plead equitable estoppel and rectification and seek the same relief.

The facts

[3]      The parties provided an agreed statement of facts.  The following paragraphs are largely from that agreed statement. Additional evidence adduced at the hearing is also  incorporated.    Before discussing the  agreed  facts  and  evidence  I note two matters:

(a)      Both parties adduced evidence as to what they understood or intended when they agreed to the option.   They did so on the basis that rectification  had  been  pleaded.     It  is  accepted  this  evidence  is otherwise irrelevant.

(b)Counsel  for each  party submitted that,  where the evidence of Mr Gordon  and  Mr  O’Connor  was  in  conflict,  I  should  prefer  the evidence of their client.  However the only material respect in which their evidence differed concerned what they understood or intended by the option they agreed to. As that evidence is irrelevant to the first two causes of action, and fails to establish the existence of a mutual mistake for the third cause of action, it is not necessary to prefer the evidence of one over the other.  Moreover I regarded both Mr Gordon and  Mr  O’Connor  to  be  honest  witnesses,  doing  their  best  to accurately recall events as they saw them.

[4]      This  proceeding  has  its  genesis  in  an  arrangement  entered  into  between entities with two family groups:

(a)      The Gordon interests comprise the trustees of the Heughan Gordon Family Trust, Timoti Limited and Millstone Grazing Limited (referred to generally as the “Gordon interests” or, where applicable, “Millstone”).

(b)The O’Connor interests comprise Silverfern Vineyards Limited (Silverfern), Seamar Investments Limited and Myoak Holdings Limited (referred to generally as the “O’Connor interests” or, where applicable, “Myoak”).

[5]      Mr Gordon is a farmer.  Prior to 2009 he ran a farm near Pahiatua.  He was looking for a change when, in March 2009, he saw an advertisement for the sale of a

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Millstone Grazing Limited v Myoak Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 773
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Millstone Grazing Limited v Myoak Holdings Limited, the plaintiff sought to exercise an option to purchase certain land from the defendant. The option was contained in a settlement agreement which was entered into by the parties to resolve their dispute over a prior sale and purchase agreement. The central issue in the case was the proper interpretation of the option to purchase. The option related to certain lots after completion of Stage 1 of a subdivision and after subdivision out of those lots, the lots contemplated in Stages 2, 3 and 4 of a Resource Consent Variation. The plaintiff argued that the option applied regardless of whether Stages 2 to 4 were completed. The defendant argued that the option only applied if Stages 2 to 4 were completed. The court found that the option was intended to apply only if Stages 2 to 4 were completed or some variation of them. The option was a condition precedent to the option arising. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claims and awarded costs to the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established