| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA333/2016 [2017] NZCA 273 |
| BETWEEN | MYOAK HOLDINGS LIMITED |
| AND | MILLSTONE GRAZING LIMITED |
| Court: | Harrison, Venning and Simon France JJ |
Counsel: | PWG Ahern for Appellant |
Judgment: (On the papers) | 28 June 2017 at 3.30 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
Both applications for costs are dismissed.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Harrison J)
Myoak Holdings Ltd abandoned its appeal to this Court on 29 May 2017, the day before the fixture for its hearing.
Each party has now applied for an order for costs pursuant r 44(3) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005. This Court has an overriding discretion under r 53 to make any costs order which we think is just.
The brief history of the appeal is as follows. In 2016 Myoak filed an appeal against a judgment of Mander J in the High Court dismissing its application to remove a caveat lodged against its property by the respondent Millstone Grazing Ltd.[1] Myoak sought to fast track its appeal. A Judge of this Court suggested to counsel that the parties would have been better served by applying at the outset for a priority fixture in the High Court on Millstone’s substantive claim based on an option to purchase. The parties then pursued that course which culminated in a judgment delivered by Mallon J on 24 April 2017 dismissing Millstone’s claim following trial.[2] Millstone did not appeal and as a result had no arguable grounds for sustaining its caveat.
Nevertheless, Myoak’s appeal remained on foot. The parties prepared for the hearing in this Court on 30 May even though the issue was by then moot. We did not learn that Millstone had removed its caveat on 15 May 2017 until receipt of its counsel’s synopsis with a brief passing reference to that fact. It was only following a further conference with a Judge of the Court on 29 May that Myoak withdrew its appeal.
Each side seeks costs. Millstone applies on the premise that in accordance with ordinary principles the discontinuing party should pay costs incurred to that point. It seeks a further 50-per-cent uplift to take account of the factors that, first, Myoak contributed unnecessarily to the time or expense of this appeal by proceeding with it following delivery of Mallon J’s judgment; and, second, Myoak failed without reasonable justification to accept an offer to settle and dispose of the appeal. That offer was made in a letter to Myoak’s solicitors on 28 April 2017: its effect was that Millstone was prepared to bear its own costs subject to Myoak’s discontinuance of its appeal within three working days. The letter finished with this statement:
Finally, following Mallon J’s judgment we have been expecting a request from you [the solicitors] for Millstone to remove its caveat over Myoak’s…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Myoak Holdings Limited v Millstone Grazing Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZCA 273
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether costs should be awarded to the prevailing party, Millstone, or if an alternative approach was warranted given the unique circumstances of the case. Millstone argued for costs on the basis that the discontinuing party should bear the costs incurred up to the point of abandonment, with an additional 50 per cent uplift considering Myoak's continued pursuit of the appeal post Mallon J's judgment and its failure to accept a settlement offer. Myoak, on the other hand, contended that the standard approach to costs should not apply because it had effectively obtained the relief it sought by having the caveat removed, albeit after a delay.
The Court of Appeal, in dismissing both applications for costs, held that neither party was entitled to costs. The reasoning of the Court was that both parties had contributed equally to the costs incurred through the appeal process. The Court emphasised that the entire proceeding could have been avoided if the parties had jointly applied for a priority fixture of the substantive claim in the High Court. The Court found that Millstone should have promptly informed Myoak of its decision not to appeal and the subsequent withdrawal of the caveat, while Myoak should have discontinued the appeal upon learning of the caveat's removal. As a result, both applications for costs were dismissed, with no costs awarded on the applications themselves.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi