Michaelmas Term
[2017] UKPC 39
Privy Council Appeal No 0032 of 2015
JUDGMENT
The Attorney General (Appellant) v River Dorée Holdings Limited (Respondent) (Saint Lucia)
From the Court of Appeal of the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court (Saint Lucia)
before
Lord Mance
Lord Reed
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Sir Bernard Rix
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
11 December 2017
Heard on 9 May 2017
|
Appellant James Guthrie QC (Instructed by Charles Russell Speechlys LLP) |
|
Respondent Nicholas Dowding QC Stanley Marcus SC (Instructed by Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP) |
SIR BERNARD RIX:
1. This appeal raises a central issue of construction arising out of a lease of agricultural land granted, in the name of Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth the Second, by the Government of St Lucia, represented here by its Attorney General, the appellant, to River Dorée Holdings Limited, the respondent. The lease, which was dated 20 February 1987, was for an initial period of 50 years commencing on 24 October 1986, and contained an option to purchase. The issue of construction arises out of a mismatch between a recital (recital E) and the dispositive part of the lease providing for the option to purchase (clause 9(9)). The Board will refer to the “Government”, “River Dorée”, the “Lease” and the “land”.
2. Recital E stated that “at the end of the first ten (10) year period of this Lease” the Lessee (River Dorée) would be permitted by the Government to purchase the property “provided THE LESSEE has satisfactorily carried out the terms and conditions of this Lease including the Development Program”. Whereas clause 9(9) provided that the option to purchase could be exercised by notice given “[a]t any time after the end of the tenth year of the term” without reference to any condition requiring that River Dorée had satisfactorily carried out the terms and conditions of the Lease including the Development Program.
3. The Development Program was a programme imposed on River Dorée, elaborated in detail in the Lease’s Schedule 6, designed to improve, indeed to “transform”, the leased land into a modern highly productive farm area for the production of food both for domestic consumption and for export, utilising and promoting modern scientific agricultural methods.
4. When River Dorée sought to exercise its clause 9(9) option by notice dated 10 January 1997, the Government gave no substantive reply until 21 June 1999, at which time the Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of Agriculture invited comments from River Dorée on an Interim Report, commissioned by the Government, which had concluded that the Lease’s Development Program had not been satisfactorily carried out. That was also the conclusion of the Final Report. This led to the current dispute, wherein River Dorée insisted on its right to purchase the land, in reliance on clause 9(9) of the Lease, and the Government, relying on recital E, refused to acknowledge any such right, on the ground that the Development Program had not been satisfactorily carried out.
5. In due course this litigation was commenced by River Dorée on 2…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Attorney General v River Doree Holdings Ltd (Saint Lucia... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKPC 39
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi