FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Koolan Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Infrassure Ltd (No 2) [2023] FCA 1654
File number: WAD 399 of 2018 Judgment of: JACKSON J Date of judgment: 21 December 2023 Catchwords: INSURANCE - business interruption insurance policy - failure of seawall between ocean and mine - claim under policy for business interruption - would applicant have continued operations under existing mine plan, or adopted a revised mine plan? - extent to which mine plan would have been achieved - consideration of mining operations - hypothetical board paper - additional expenditure to diminish reduction in output not proved - no adjustment for stock on hand - adjustment for redundancies - foreign exchange hedging arrangements not to be taken into account
INSURANCE - interest on claim - s 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) - time from which was unreasonable for insurer to withhold payment
CONTRACTS - construction of business interruption policies - adjustments clause - common sense approach to evidence - adjustments not to be made for entirely hypothetical trends, variations and other circumstances - taking account of revised mine plan not permitted under policy
CONTRACTS - meaning of words - 'adjustments' - 'trend of the business' - 'variations' and 'other circumstances'
EVIDENCE - establishing hypothetical past events - malleability of recollection of events - dangers of hindsight evidence - reliance on objective facts, contemporaneous materials and observable behaviour
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 135, 279B
Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) s 57
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B
Insurance Contracts Regulations 1984 (Cth) reg 38
Cases cited: AIG Australia Limited v Kaboko Mining Limited [2019] FCAFC 96
Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (No 5) (1996) 64 FCR 73
Australian Pipe & Tube Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited (No 2) [2018] FCA 1450
Brescia Furniture Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd [2007] NSWSC 598
Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67
Dalby Bio-Refinery Ltd v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2019] FCAFC 85
Diosdado Sayseng v Kellogg Superannuation Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 857
Fabcot Pty Ltd v Port Macquarie-Hastings Council [2011] NSWCA 167
HDI Global Specialty SE v Wonkana No. 3 Pty Ltd [2020] NSWCA 296; (2020) 104 NSWLR 634
Henry Booth & Sons v Commercial Union Assurance Co Ltd (1923) 14 Lloyds LR 114
Hosmer Holdings Pty Ltd v CAJ Investments Pty Ltd (1995) ATPR 41-442
Hughes Aircraft Systems International v Airservices Australia (No 3) (1997) 80 FCR 276
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Koolan Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Infrassure Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 1654
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues involved interpreting the terms of the insurance policy, particularly the adjustments clause, and determining whether Koolan was entitled to claim for increased costs of working, diminution in value of stock on hand, and losses from foreign exchange hedging arrangements. The court also had to decide if Koolan would have achieved the forecasts and targets in the EMP or the RMP and whether Infrassure was liable for interest on the claim. Additionally, the court needed to consider the implications of redundancy costs and the proper calculation of interest under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984.
The court held that Koolan would have continued operations under the EMP rather than adopting the RMP. The policy did not permit or require adjustments based on the RMP, and the evidence showed Koolan's commitment to the EMP. The court found that Koolan was not entitled to claim for increased costs of working under certain items of the policy, nor for the diminution in value of stock on hand. It also ruled that foreign exchange hedging losses were not to be factored into the indemnity calculation as they were unrelated to the insured peril. Regarding redundancies, Koolan could deduct necessary redundancy costs from savings in employment costs. Lastly, the court determined that Infrassure must pay interest on the claim from a specific date under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984.
The court ordered that the parties file a minute of consent orders reflecting these reasons and dealing with costs by a specified date. The matter was listed for mention on another date, with liberty to apply for further orders. The final orders were to be entered in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The parties must file a minute of consent orders reflecting these reasons and dealing with costs or, if necessary, competing minutes by 4.00 pm AWST on 22 February 2024.
2. The matter is listed for mention at 9.00 am AWST on 29 February 2024.
3. Liberty to apply in respect of paragraphs 1 and 2.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION
[1]
II. THE POLICY
[10]
III. THE ISSUES
[24]
EMP or RMP
[26]
Would Koolan have adopted the RMP?
[29]
To what extent would the EMP or the RMP have been achieved?
[34]
ICW-UWEs
[39]
Stock on Hand
[43]
Foreign exchange
[48]
Redundancies
[53]
Interest
[54]
List of issues
[58]
IV. THE WITNESSES
[61]
James Beyer
[65]
Lee Seng Hui
[72]
Peter Kerr
[79]
Andrew Thomson, Brett Morey and Scott de Kruijff
[82]
John McKenzie and Michael Potter
[84]
V. EMP OR RMP
[87]
Koolan's claim that it would have adopted and achieved the RMP
[87]
The proper construction of the Policy
[100]
General principles of construction
[113]
Business interruption policies
[119]
The terms of the Policy in this case
[130]
Some specific terms in the adjustments clause
[138]
Adjustments
[139]
'The trend of the Business'
[143]
'Variations' and 'other circumstances'
[152]
The proper construction of the adjustments clause as a whole
[159]
Koolan's RMP claim is not permitted under the Policy
[180]
Mining at Koolan Island
[181]
The approach to the evidence
[182]
Mount Gibson's mining operations
[202]
Mount Gibson's mine planning process
[206]
The chronology of events
[212]
First period of low iron ore prices - 2008-2009
[212]
Second period of low iron ore prices - 2012
[213]
2013 - the iron ore price rebounds
[229]
March 2013 - the Board approves the new mining plan
[235]
The rest of 2013
[245]
2014 - the iron ore price declines
[252]
The Board meeting of 29 April 2014
[256]
Mr Beyer asks about mining at the average strip ratio
[265]
Sterilisation of MW3
[273]
A broker visit to Koolan Island and broker reports
[288]
June to September 2014
[296]
September 2014 - Mr Lee is given information about cashflows and IRR
[310]
24 and 25 September 2014 - Board meeting and Board strategy meeting
[314]
October 2014 market release and investor teleconference
[323]
October and November 2014 - the first two slumps in the seawall
[333]
Mr Beyer's evidence about the IRR
[342]
The annual general meeting on 12 November 2014
[345]
The seawall fails
[348]
2015 - iron ore prices continue to decline
[356]
The changes at Extension Hill
[367]
Insurance claims are settled, the mine reopens
[380]
The evidence about what Koolan would have done had the seawall not failed
[389]
The hypothetical board paper (HBP)
[397]
Findings on whether Koolan would have adopted the RMP
[416]
Koolan was committed to the EMP
[423]
Senior management consistently defended the EMP
[427]
Koolan showed no signs of departing from the EMP, even though prices were falling
[436]
Mr Lee's concerns do not indicate that Mount Gibson would have abandoned the strategy
[449]
What was said and done after the seawall failed
[457]
Uncertainty about when revision to the EMP would have been initiated or completed
[462]
The evidence about when consideration of a revision to the EMP would have been initiated
[464]
The IRR 'threshold' of 15%
[473]
The prices that Mount Gibson would have assumed if it were revising the EMP
[478]
The mine planning process
[492]
Extension Hill was different
[493]
Mining at ACE
[500]
No mining of MW3 after the Incident
[504]
Other mining companies' responses to low prices
[505]
How long would it have taken to devise and approve a revision to the EMP?
[506]
It has not been established that a revision would have been materially similar to the RMP
[515]
Whether any Board paper would have been materially similar to the HBP
[515]
Whether any revised mine plan would have been materially similar to the RMP
[525]
A slowdown in mining cannot be ruled out
[531]
Conclusion on content of the HBP and the RMP
[536]
What decision the Board would have made on a proposed revision is unknown
[537]
Mr Lee's hindsight evidence is not reliable
[538]
Koolan's case as to how the other directors would have viewed the HBP/RMP
[541]
The absence of evidence from the other directors is significant
[546]
To what extent would Koolan have achieved the mine plan
[555]
To what extent would Koolan have achieved the EMP?
[558]
To what extent would Koolan have achieved the RMP?
[574]
VI. THE SUBSIDIARY ISSUES
[583]
ICW-UWE
[583]
Item 1(b)
[584]
The way in which Koolan claims ICWs under Item 1(b)
[586]
The grounds on which Infrassure objects to the ICW claim under Item 1(b)
[598]
The construction of the Policy concerning ICW
[605]
Koolan has not established its claim for ICW under Item 1(b)
[622]
The purpose of mining at ACE
[638]
Item 4
[650]
Stock on Hand
[655]
The construction of Item 1(a) and the definition of 'Output'
[661]
The adjustments clause
[670]
Salvage sale
[676]
When the Stock on Hand was sold
[695]
Foreign exchange
[706]
The parties' competing positions
[707]
Consideration
[724]
Redundancies
[733]
The issue
[733]
Consideration
[739]
Interest
[748]
The competing arguments
[749]
Consideration
[753]
VII. CONCLUSIONS
[760]
RMP and EMP
[761]
ICW-UWE
[761]
Stock on Hand
[761]
Foreign exchange
[761]
Redundancies
[761]
Interest
[761]
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Koolan also relied on Mr McKenzie's view, expressed in his Third Supplementary Report at paragraph 2.5. There, he says that his instructions are that 'Forex arrangements are made at a Mt Gibson Group level and were not affected as a result of the damage'. He calls it a 'mere accounting allocation of the overall group loss which was the same in both the standard (no loss) and actual worlds' (para 3.3, noting that this went into evidence on the basis that it was evidence only of the assumptions that Mr McKenzie made). Mr McKenzie goes on to explain that the foreign exchange losses are presented in, but ultimately eliminated from, the Standard Output and Rate of Gross Profit calculations in both Koolan's RMP and EMP claims. While he describes this as confusing, he appears to consider the ultimate result - that the foreign exchange losses are not factored into the claim - to be correct.Consideration Resolving this issue must, in the end, come back to the application of the Policy to the facts. Despite some suggestion to the contrary in Infrassure's written submissions, by the end of oral closing submissions, there did not appear to be any dispute about those facts. As salient to the present issue, they were:(1)Koolan is a subsidiary of Mount Gibson. Mount Gibson prepares accounts at a group level.(2)Koolan operates the business of mining at Koolan Island. Koolan sells iron ore to its two main customers under the Offtake Contracts. The customers pay for the iron ore in US dollars. Mount Gibson is a party to the Offtake Contracts but not in any capacity as seller.(3)Mount Gibson entered into foreign exchange hedging arrangements under which it could, in effect, sell a fixed number of US dollars at a fixed Australian dollar exchange rate. These arrangements did not form part of the Offtake Contracts and, save in one respect, were not otherwise linked to sales by Koolan under those agreements. The only discernible link is that predicted revenue by Koolan formed part of Mount Gibson's deliberations and calculations as to the amount of US dollars to be covered by the foreign exchange hedging arrangements. So too did the predicted revenue of the other operations within the group.(4)During the Indemnity Period, Mount Gibson experienced losses on the foreign exchange hedging arrangements. Those losses were unaffected by the Incident. They would have been experienced, in the same amount, had the Incident not occurred.(5)Mount Gibson allocated a portion of those losses to the accounts of Koolan. The portion was proportionate to Koolan's revenue, as a fraction of the overall revenue of Mount Gibson's operating subsidiaries. Infrassure did not make a submission as to how the Policy would apply to these facts, other than to contend that the foreign exchange losses would have reduced the 'sale and/or invoice value' of the ore that Koolan would have sold had the Incident not occurred. In the absence of any more direct link between the hedging arrangements and the Offtake Contracts, I do not see how that can be so. The relevant phrase forms part of the definition of Output in the Policy which, more fully, is that '"Output" shall mean the sale and/or invoice value of goods manufactured and/or processed by the Insured in course of the Business at the Premises'. This has been considered above in other contexts, but for present purposes it is simple enough. It means the amount of money that is received, or invoiced, as consideration for iron ore processed by 'the Insured' at the Premises.