Inpex Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AIG Australia Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   INPEX OPERATIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD -v- AIG AUSTRALIA LTD [No 2] [2023] WASC 61

CORAM:   LUNDBERG J

HEARD:   2 FEBRUARY 2023

DELIVERED          :   3 MARCH 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1631 of 2020

(Consolidated with CIV 1620 of 2020)

BETWEEN:   INPEX OPERATIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 150 217 626)

Plaintiff

AND

AIG AUSTRALIA LTD ACN 004 727 753

First Defendant

ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LTD (ACN 000 122 850)

Second Defendant

TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INSURANCE CO., LTD (ARBN 000 438 291)

Third Defendant

SOMPO JAPAN INSURANCE INC (ARBN 000 837 801)

Fourth Defendant

AIOI NISSAY DOWA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD (ARBN 096 302 466)

Fifth Defendant

MITSUI SUMITOMO INSURANCE COMPANY, LTD (ARBN 000 525 637)

Sixth Defendant

ZURICH AUSTRALIAN INSURANCE LTD (ACN 000 296 640)

Seventh Defendant

HDI GLOBAL SE (ARBN 134 049 951)

Eighth Defendant

XL INSURANCE COMPANY SE (ARBN 083 570 441)

Ninth Defendant

AAI LTD (ACN 005 297 807)

Tenth Defendant

CHUBB INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LTD (ACN 001 642 020)

Eleventh Defendant

SWISS RE INTERNATIONAL SE (ARBN 138 873 211)

Twelfth Defendant

CERTAIN UNDERWRITING MEMBERS OF LLOYD'S SYNDICATE 4444

Thirteenth Defendant

UNDERWRITING MEMBERS OF LLOYD'S SYNDICATE 1221 AND SYNDICATE 4000 (Together, MILLENNIUM CONSORTIUM 9128)

Fourteenth Defendant

UNDERWRITING MEMBERS OF LLOYD'S SYNDICATE 1861 FOR THE 2012 YEAR OF ACCOUNT

Fifteenth Defendant

UNDERWRITING MEMBERS OF LLOYD'S SYNDICATE 1183 FOR THE 2012 YEAR OF ACCOUNT

Sixteenth Defendant

THE UNDERWRITING MEMBER OF LLOYD'S SYNDICATE 2623

Seventeenth Defendant

HDI GLOBAL SPECIALTY SE (ARBN 129 395 544)

Eighteenth Defendant

GREAT LAKES INSURANCE SE (ARBN 127 740 532)

Nineteenth Defendant

PAN INSURANCE DESIGNATED ACTIVITY COMPANY

Twentieth Defendant

SCOR UK COMPANY LTD

Twenty-first Defendant

XL CATLIN INSURANCE COMPANY UK LTD (Discontinued on 22 June 2022)

Twenty-second Defendant

HELVETIA SCHWEIZERISCHE VERSICHERUNGS-GESELLSCHAFT AG

Twenty-third Defendant

THE UNDERWRITING MEMBER OF LLOYD’S SYNDICATE 2003

Twenty-fourth Defendant

CERTAIN UNDERWRITING MEMBERS OF LLOYD'S SYNDICATE 0623

Twenty-fifth Defendant

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1729 of 2020

BETWEEN:   INPEX OPERATIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 150 217 626)

Plaintiff

AND

MITSUI SUMITOMO INSURANCE COMPANY, LIMITED

Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Applications for separate trials - Complex litigation - Onshore LNG Project - Indemnity claims made by project principal under Construction All Risks and Erection All Risks insurance policies - Consideration of utility, efficiency and economy of trial separation - Importance of proper construction of model exclusion clauses - Prospects of settlement - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 32 r 4 and 5

Result:

Applications dismissed in both proceedings

Representation in CIV 1631 of 2020 with CIV 1620 of 2020

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr J P Rowland KC and Mr R J Price
First to Fifth Defendants : Mr G G McArthur KC and Mr T W Marskell
Sixth Defendant : Mr S R Donaldson SC and Mr A P Hershowitz
Seventh to Twenty-fifth Defendants : Mr G G McArthur KC and Mr T W Marskell

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Allen & Overy
First to Fifth Defendants : Wotton + Kearney…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inpex Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AIG Australia Ltd [No 2... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Inpex Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AIG Australia Ltd [No 2], the plaintiffs, Inpex Operations Australia Pty Ltd and Inpex Australia Pty Ltd, sought a split trial of liability and quantum issues in a complex dispute with the defendant, AIG Australia Ltd. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendant had provided negligent services, resulting in significant defects in a project for which the plaintiffs were responsible. The case involved intricate technical issues, and the quantum of damages claimed by the plaintiffs was highly dependent on the outcome of the liability issues.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether it was just and convenient to order a separate trial of the liability issues from the quantum issues. The plaintiffs argued that the quantum of damages was inextricably linked to the liability issues and that a combined trial would be more efficient. The defendant, on the other hand, contended that the quantum issues were in a state of flux, and a separate trial of the liability issues would facilitate a clearer understanding of the damages, potentially leading to cost savings and an earlier resolution of the dispute.

The court found that the interests of justice and the need to avoid wasting resources on issues that were likely to change favoured a separate trial of the liability issues. The uncertainty surrounding the quantum of damages, exacerbated by potential early rectification works and the operational changes due to the COVID-19 pandemic, supported the defendant's position. The court concluded that a separate trial on liability would likely expedite the resolution of the entire proceeding, reduce costs, and facilitate a potential settlement.

The court ordered a separate trial on the liability issues, with the quantum of damages and other issues to be addressed in a subsequent trial if necessary. This decision highlights the importance of considering the practicalities and potential outcomes of complex litigation, and the role of the court in managing such disputes to achieve a just and efficient resolution.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A recent example in which an Australian court has ordered a split in large and complex proceedings can be found in Brisbane Airport Corporation Pty Limited v Arup Pty Limited [2020] QSC 202 (Applegarth J). Briefly stated, the defendant provided geotechnical, engineering and other consultancy services to the plaintiff airport. After cracks were identified in the newly constructed apron and taxiway at the airport terminal, the airport sued the defendant for negligence and, in the alternative, for misleading or deceptive conduct arising out of alleged representations in relation to the design, asserting five defects. The plaintiff alleged that extensive works were required to rectify these defects. Applegarth J noted that, if the defendant was found liable in any one or more of these five respects, then the basis of its liability and the nature of the defect would be relevant to the extent of rectification works required to address the particular defect and therefore the quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff.[58] [58] Brisbane Airport [6]. A major and contentious aspect of the airport’s quantum claim was the staging of rectification works. The cost of the rectification scheme was said to be based upon a proposed program of work, and the sequencing and cost of undertaking that work depended on operational restrictions the airport had instructed its experts to assume.[59] As the airport had remained operational, it appeared that the plaintiff (at least prior to the COVID-19 pandemic) was unable to close bays or taxiways to perform work otherwise than in off-peak periods and only by allowing the contractor to work on one front, or stage, at any one time. The time and other requirements substantially increased the cost of rectification.[60][59] Brisbane Airport [7].[60] Brisbane Airport [8]. The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic meant, according to the defendant, that the operational restrictions were no longer required. As the preparation of the quantum case was in something of a state of flux, the defendant sought orders for a separate trial on liability (with the quantum of the airport’s rectification works, mitigation issues, and betterment issues to be held over to a second trial, if required). The defendant urged this course upon the court for additional reasons as well, including that the scope and extent of a trial on the quantum issues depended upon the court’s findings as to liability. The defendant contended that a single trial on all issues would require the parties to address (at significant cost) a multitude of rectification possibilities, some of which would be made irrelevant by the court’s findings on liability.[61][61] Brisbane Airport [11]. Applegarth J granted the application. His Honour placed significant weight on the reality that the plaintiff’s case on quantum was in a state of flux, as well as the potential for a split trial to facilitate settlement. His Honour concluded as follows:[71] On balance, I consider that the interests of justice and doing justice to both parties favours ordering a separate trial on liability. That course carries the prospect of significant costs savings. Such a course will resolve liability (subject to any appeal on liability). By that time [the plaintiff airport’s] quantum case will be clearer than it presently is or is likely to be for some substantial time until at least a contract for early rectification works is let and the program of works and their cost is assessed, pleaded and considered by [the defendant]. One apparent reason as to why the proceedings have not settled to date is because of uncertainty on issues of both liability and quantum. A separate trial on liability, preferably conducted in the first half of 2021, will remove one significant element of uncertainty and thereby help facilitate resolution of the Remaining Issues by settlement or a shortening of any quantum trial.[72] Some factors weigh in favour of having a trial of all issues. However, with [the plaintiff airport’s] quantum case in a state of flux, such a trial is unlikely to be ready for some substantial time. In my view, it is just and convenient to conduct a liability trial before then. The prospect of savings of time and costs, and also facilitating settlement, favours a separate trial on liability. These considerations, in my view, and the other matters relied upon by [the defendant] outweigh the risk that a separate trial will delay the conclusion of the proceeding as a whole and the other disadvantages to which [the plaintiff airport] points.[73] The uncertainty injected in relation to quantum by the prospect of early rectification work and its significant implications for the preparation and conduct of a trial on quantum favour a separate trial on liability. It would be wasteful of costs and time to require [the defendant] to prepare evidence, including expert evidence, in the coming months to respond to [the plaintiff airport’s] case on quantum as presently pleaded and formulated. That case is bound to change because of altered operations at the airport and the real prospect of early rectification work. The need to avoid wasted costs on quantum issues which are almost certain to change is a factor which strongly favours ordering a separate trial on liability.[74] Overall, I conclude that it is just and convenient to order a separate trial on liability.