| [2024] FWC 2207 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution
Li Yan Wang
v
Crown Melbourne Limited T/A Crown Melbourne
(C2024/3349)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT BELL | MELBOURNE, 9 SEPTEMBER 2024 |
Alleged dispute about any matters arising under the enterprise agreement – whether eligible for part-time to full-time conversion – not eligible – whether contra proferentem rule applies
Ms Wang has made an application under s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act) for the Commission to deal with a dispute concerning the Crown Melbourne Limited Enterprise Agreement 2023 (Agreement).
The factual circumstances of the dispute are quite unusual, although essentially undisputed. Ms Wang is a part-time employee, employed as a Dealer within the Premium Tables division of the respondent, Crown Melbourne. Ms Wang wishes to be a full-time Dealer and she is on a waitlist to that effect, along with a number of other part-time employees who are also seeking to become full-time. Ms Wang has been on the waitlist for a number of years and, while she is moving closer to the top of it, is evidently frustrated with the slow pace (from her perspective) of progress through the waitlist. To accelerate her wait time, Ms Wang conceived of a plan to take advantage of cl 20.6 of the Agreement (which is titled “Conversion to Full-Time Employment”), that would, in effect, let her automatically be converted to a full-time position.
Clause 20.6 relevantly permits a part-time employee to request to convert to full-time employment where the employee is rostered for 152 “Minimum Rostered Hours” per cycle for any 9 cycles in the 13 full roster cycles immediately before the request. Clause 20.7 of the Agreement sets which hours can be included for the Minimum Rostered Hours. Crown Melbourne contends that Ms Wang does not meet the eligibility criteria in cl 20.7.
Clause 20.7.2 is expressed to include any period of paid leave towards the calculation of the minimum hours for conversion. However, the same clause excludes from those calculations hours that relate to “pick up shifts”. It is the apparent tension between these subclauses that is the critical issue for the resolution of the dispute.
After unsuccessful attempts by the parties to resolve the dispute between themselves and, subsequently, with the assistance of the Commission, the matter was listed for arbitration. The agreed question for arbitration was:
“In the case of C2024/3349 Li Yan Wang v Crown Melbourne Limited T/A Crown Melbourne, were the conditions for full-time conversion met by the applicant per subclauses 20.6 and 20.7 of the Crown Melbourne Limited Enterprise Agreement 2023?”
For the reasons that follow, Crown Melbourne’s position is correct and the answer to the question is “no”.
Factual background
The Agreement is a comprehensive enterprise agreement. It was approved on 6 March 2024 and, by operation of s 54 of the Act, commenced operation on 13 March 2024. While the critical events in question all occurred under the previous enterprise agreement, there is no disagreement (correctly in my view)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Li Yan Wang v Crown Melbourne Limited T/A Crown Melbourne and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWC 2207
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined clauses 20.6 and 20.7 of the Agreement, focusing on the exclusion of hours relating to pick up shifts in clause 20.7.2(i) and the inclusion of paid leave in clause 20.7.2(ii). Ms Wang argued that the exclusion of hours relating to pick up shifts did not apply to her situation because she did not work the shifts but instead took paid leave. Crown Melbourne argued that the exclusion applied regardless of whether the shifts were worked, as the clause referred to hours relating to pick up shifts. The court considered the intent of the clause and determined that the exclusion applied to unworked hours taken as leave, resolving the inconsistency between the clauses.
The court concluded that Ms Wang's accepted shift pick-ups, converted to paid leave, did not count towards her Minimum Rostered Hours for conversion eligibility, as they related to pick up shifts. The court also rejected the application of the contra proferentem rule, finding that the clause was not ambiguous and could be interpreted without it. The court ruled that Ms Wang did not meet the eligibility criteria for conversion to full-time employment under the Agreement.
In summary, the court determined that Ms Wang was not eligible for conversion to full-time employment based on the terms of the Crown Melbourne Limited Enterprise Agreement 2023, specifically clauses 20.6 and 20.7, as her accepted shift pick-ups, converted to paid leave, did not count towards her Minimum Rostered Hours.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi