Arbuthnot v Queensland law Society

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Arbuthnot and Anor v Queensland law Society  [2024] QCAT 125

PARTIES:

HELEN MARY ARBUTHNOT
MAUREEN ANN DAVEY

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY 

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR004-20

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

24 April 2024

HEARING DATE:

15 March 2024

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Hon. Duncan McMeekin KC, Judicial Member

ORDERS:

1.     Subject to any submissions from the parties as to the proper orders I order:

(a)     The application is allowed.

(b)     That the applicants’ claim on the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund in the sum of $840,760 be admitted.

(c) That the sum of $840,760 be paid out to the applicants in their capacity as administrators of the estate of Peter James Saunderson (deceased) from the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund together with interest on that amount pursuant to s 384 LPA from 30 July 2015.

(d) That the respondent pay the applicants’ reasonable legal costs of making and proving the claim pursuant to s 383(1) LPA.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES — LAWYERS — FIDELITY AND GUARANTEE FUNDS — CLAIMS AGAINST FUND — review of decision under Legal Profession Act2007 (Qld) — where the respondent rejected the applicants claim on the Legal Practitioners’ Fidelity Guarantee fund —where a solicitor drew a will for a client and was made executor under that will — where the solicitor paid themselves as beneficiary under the will — whether the solicitor was dishonest — whether there was a ‘failure to pay’ the applicants who were not named in the will — whether the applicants suffered a pecuniary loss by reason of claimed default

Legal Profession Act2007 (Qld) s 359, s 374, s 392

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) s 20
Succession Act1981 (Qld)

Dore (as executor of the will of WHB Chenhall (dec’d) [2006] QCA 494
Legal Services Board v Gillespie-Jones (2013) 249 CLR 493
Legal Services Commissioner v Slipper [2019] QCAT 146
Nock v Austin (1918) 25 CLR 519
O'Brien & Anor v Smith & Anor [2012] QSC 166

Pilmer v Duke Group Ltd (in liq) (2001) 207 CLR 165

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

R A Kipps, instructed by Merthyr Law

Respondent:

L Sheptooha, instructed by Queensland Law Society

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This review concerns the right of the applicants to make a claim on the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund established under s 359 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) (“LPA”). The respondent, by its management committee, rejected the claim. The applicants seek a review of that decision under s 392 LPA.

  2. The amount claimed is $840,760.

    Principles governing review

  3. My task under the statute is to “produce the correct and preferable decision”: s 20(1) Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009 (“QCAA”). The applicants are entitled to a fresh hearing on the merits: s 20(2) QCAA.

    The legislation

  4. The right to claim against the fidelity fund is governed by Part 3.6 of the LPA. The crucial provision is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arbuthnot v Queensland law Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCAT 125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Arbuthnot v Queensland Law Society involved the applicants, who were the administrators of the estate of Peter James Saunderson, deceased, seeking compensation from the Legal Practitioners’ Fidelity Guarantee Fund. The dispute arose from the actions of Mr Slipper, a solicitor who had been appointed executor of the deceased’s will and had also been named as a beneficiary in the will. The applicants argued that Mr Slipper's actions constituted a breach of trust and dishonesty, warranting compensation under the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld). The Queensland Law Society, as the respondent, rejected the claim on the basis that there was insufficient evidence of dishonesty and that the applicants had not suffered a pecuniary loss due to the solicitor's actions.

The legal issues before the court included determining whether Mr Slipper's actions amounted to dishonesty and whether there was a 'failure to pay' as defined in the Legal Profession Act. The court had to assess if the solicitor's conduct constituted a breach of the trust and fiduciary duties owed to the estate and whether the applicants had indeed suffered a pecuniary loss as a result of these actions. The court's decision hinged on the interpretation of statutory provisions and the application of common law principles concerning fiduciary duties and breaches of trust.

The court found that there was evidence of Mr Slipper's dishonesty and that the applicants had indeed suffered a pecuniary loss. The court reasoned that the solicitor's actions in appointing himself as a beneficiary and executor, and subsequently appropriating estate funds for personal benefit, constituted a breach of his fiduciary duties. The court concluded that the applicants satisfied the statutory requirements for compensation under the Legal Profession Act, as they had suffered a pecuniary loss due to the solicitor's misconduct.

The final orders of the court included admitting the applicants' claim on the Legal Practitioners’ Fidelity Guarantee Fund, directing the payment of $840,760 plus interest to the applicants, and ordering the respondent to pay the applicants' reasonable legal costs. The parties were given 14 days to make further submissions regarding the appropriate orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Subject to any submissions from the parties as to the proper orders I order:

(a) The application is allowed.

(b) That the applicants’ claim on the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund in the sum of $840,760 be admitted.

(c) That the sum of $840,760 be paid out to the applicants in their capacity as administrators of the estate of Peter James Saunderson (deceased) from the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund together with interest on that amount pursuant to s 384 LPA from 30 July 2015.

(d) That the respondent pay the applicants’ reasonable legal costs of making and proving the claim pursuant to s 383(1) LPA.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent asserts that while Mr Slipper took the benefit of the estate there is no evidence that he dishonestly did so. The respondent also maintains that the applicants fail to show the essential requirement under s 374 LPA – that there was a “default" as defined.The Background It is necessary to go into some detail of the background facts. In February 2011 Peter James Saunderson (now deceased) engaged Mr Slipper to prepare a will. There is no sworn evidence of what transpired between the two men. The only evidence of the instructions Mr Slipper received are two file notes found on Mr Slipper’s file, no doubt prepared by Mr Slipper, perhaps dated 22 February 2011 (there is some doubt about that date as it is indecipherable on the copy I have and Mr Slipper contended for the day prior in correspondence) and 28 February 2011 purportedly setting out Mr Saunderson’s instructions, and two letters addressed to Mr Saunderson, both dated 28 February in almost identical terms save for two additions in one version (“version 2”). Whether the file notes or letters accurately set out the instructions received is unknown. There is no evidence that Mr Saunderson was made aware of their contents or otherwise adopted them, save to the extent they are reflected in the will. I will return to those documents. The will was prepared and executed by the testator on 28 February 2011. Mr Slipper and a secretary in his office witnessed the execution of the will. By the terms of the will Mr Slipper was appointed executor of the will and trustee of the estate and in that capacity to hold estate assets on trust. Clause 3 of the will is the dispositive clause. It provides:“I give devise and bequeath the whole of my estate … unto my executor and trustee UPON TRUST … [provisions dealing with payment of debts, duties and bequests (of which there were none)]… and to hold the balance then remaining (“my residuary estate”) UPON TRUST to my trustee to distribute same at his sole discretion to whomever, including the support of young footballers through schooling, equipment, tours and the like.” There is no express mention of Mr Slipper taking as a beneficiary in the will. Mr Saunderson died on 30 April 2013. Hereinafter he will be referred to as the deceased. His estate is estimated as comprising around $1,800,000. On 6 May 2013 Mr Slipper in his capacity as executor of the deceased’s estate entered into a retainer with his law practise. Mr Slipper obtained a grant of probate of the will in common form on 2 September 2013. Mr Slipper swore an affidavit supporting the application for probate in which he said, after confirming that he was the person named as executor in the will: “I know of no other matter which might bear on my standing as a fit and proper person to realise and administer the estate as required by the Succession Act 1981 and the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999.” There followed various dealings with the monies in the estate:(a)Mr Slipper created a corporate entity, Pathways Pty Ltd, and on 12 March 2014 in his capacity as solicitor transferred $5,000 from his trust account to that corporate entity.(b)On 15 May 2014 in his capacity as executor Mr Slipper opened a bank account entitled “Mr RJ Slipper as executor for the estate of Peter James Saunderson” (“the estate account”) and the following day caused the sum of $1.2 million to be paid from his trust account to the estate account as an “interim distribution".(c)On 2 June 2014 Mr Slipper withdrew $20,000 from the estate account.(d)On 11 July 2014 Mr Slipper in his capacity as solicitor acting for himself as executor received the proceeds of the sale of the deceased’s unit and passed those proceeds comprising $85,289.72 in the form of a bank cheque to himself as executor.(e)On the same date Mr Slipper withdrew from the estate account the sums of $1,040,000 and $25,000. The larger sum was paid into a bank account in the name of Mr Slipper’s wife as trustee for a family trust.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent did not maintain its submissions that the amount sought to be recovered was reasonably available from some other source – see s 385 LPA.Conclusion There is no doubt that the applicants have suffered pecuniary loss by reason of the claimed default. In my opinion the applicants have satisfied the elements of s 374 LPA. Subject to any submissions from the parties as to the proper orders I order:(a)The application is allowed.(b)That the applicants’ claim on the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund in the sum of $840,760 be admitted.(c)That the sum of $840,760 be paid out to the applicants in their capacity as administrators of the estate of Peter James Saunderson (deceased) from the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Guarantee Fund together with interest on that amount pursuant to s 384 LPA from 30 July 2015.(d)That the respondent pay the applicants’ reasonable legal costs of making and proving the claim pursuant to s 383(1) LPA. The parties have 14 days to make further submissions as to the orders that should be made in accordance with these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.