BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v BGC Contracting Pty Ltd & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

O’Brien & Anor v Smith & Anor [2012] QSC 166

PARTIES:

ELIZABETH ANNE O’BRIEN AND BRONWYN JANE JONES as executors of the Will of Jack Jones (deceased)

(applicants)

v

FREDERICK SMITH as litigation guardian for Finn Patrick Timothy O’Brien, Bridget Mary Elizabeth O’Brien, Timothy John Patrick O’Brien, Beau Jones, Harley Jones and Alicia Jones (infants)

(respondents)

and

JANICE REINECKER

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS303/12

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Originating application

DELIVERED ON:

19 June 2012

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 March 2012

JUDGE:

Margaret Wilson J

ORDER:

1. That there be a declaration that upon the proper construction of clause 4 of the will of Jack Jones deceased dated 31 October 2006 there is an intestacy as to the deceased’s residuary estate created by the words:

“OTHER than the gifts and bequests set out in Clause 3 of this my Will I GIVE, DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the balance, rest, remainder and residue of my estate to a trust or other entity to be set up by my Executors and Administrators and administered by them as they shall see fit.

Monies may be applied to Education of all my Grandchildren and allocated as my Executors shall see fit. Monies may be invested as my Executors shall see fit. On my death, my Executors may sell or dispose of properties as they see fit. All gifts and bequests as set out in Clause 3 to be distributed at times as seen fit by the Executors. Loans may be made to those whose ability to repay such loans is proved.”

2.  That the costs of the applicants, the first respondent and the second respondent of and incidental to this application, including reserved costs if any, be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid out of the deceased’s estate.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – GIFT TO TRUSTEES – BENEFICIARIES OF TRUST – where testator left a homemade will and an estate with a net value in excess of $3,260,000 – where application made for declaratory relief as to the proper construction of clause 4 of the will – where testamentary disposition to establish a trust administered as the executors ‘shall see fit’ – whether a valid trust was created under the will – whether beneficiaries of the trust were defined with sufficient certainty to satisfy “criterion certainty” – whether the trust the deceased purported to create failed for want of beneficiaries – whether a partial intestacy created 

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND THE EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – ADMISSIBILITY OF EXTRINSIC EVIDENCE – admissibility of evidence of factual matrix – “armchair rule” – admissibility of evidence to determine deceased’s intention – section 33C Succession Act 1981 (Qld)

Succession Act 1981 (Qld), s 33C, s 33R.

Perrin v Morgan [1943] AC 399, 420; [1943] 1 All ER 187, cited.
The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith [2009] 1 Qd R 26, cited.
The Trust…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v BGC Contracting Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QSC 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Queensland Court of Appeal was tasked with interpreting a handwritten will left by Jack Jones, who passed away in 2007. The estate's net value exceeded $3.26 million, and the central issue was the construction of clause 4, which aimed to establish a trust administered by the executors as they saw fit. The primary question was whether the clause created a valid trust and if the beneficiaries were defined with sufficient certainty. Additionally, the court had to consider the admissibility of extrinsic evidence to determine the deceased's intentions under the Succession Act 1981 (Qld).

The Court of Appeal found that clause 4 did not create a valid trust due to the absence of defined beneficiaries, which failed the "criterion certainty" test. The clause was deemed to create a partial intestacy regarding the residuary estate. The court also addressed the admissibility of extrinsic evidence, adhering to the "armchair rule" and considering section 33C of the Succession Act, which allows for evidence to ascertain the deceased's intention. The court ruled that such evidence could be admitted to clarify the terms of the will.

The final orders declared that clause 4 of Jack Jones's will resulted in an intestacy concerning his residuary estate, as the clause did not sufficiently define beneficiaries to create a valid trust. The court also ruled that the costs of the application, including any reserved costs, would be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the deceased's estate. This decision highlights the importance of clear and certain language in testamentary dispositions to avoid intestacies and the potential use of extrinsic evidence to interpret ambiguous terms.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That there be a declaration that upon the proper construction of clause 4 of the will of Jack Jones deceased dated 31 October 2006 there is an intestacy as to the deceased’s residuary estate created by the words:

“OTHER than the gifts and bequests set out in Clause 3 of this my Will I GIVE, DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the balance, rest, remainder and residue of my estate to a trust or other entity to be set up by my Executors and Administrators and administered by them as they shall see fit.

Monies may be applied to Education of all my Grandchildren and allocated as my Executors shall see fit. Monies may be invested as my Executors shall see fit. On my death, my Executors may sell or dispose of properties as they see fit. All gifts and bequests as set out in Clause 3 to be distributed at times as seen fit by the Executors. Loans may be made to those whose ability to repay such loans is proved.”

2. That the costs of the applicants, the first respondent and the second respondent of and incidental to this application, including reserved costs if any, be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid out of the deceased’s estate.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.