The Trust Company Limited v Zdilar

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

The Trust Company Limited & Anor v Zdilar & Ors [2011] QSC 5

PARTIES:

THE TRUST COMPANY LIMITED AND JOHN EDWARD SIMONS (as Executors of the Estate of ANN MARY ASHTON, DECEASED)
(applicants)
v
SUSAN ANNE ZDILAR, ROBERT JAMES SIMONS and MICHELLE TRACEY MILES
(first respondents)
ADAM ROBERT SIMONS, JORDAN HELENE SIMONS and MARK ANTHONY MILES
(second respondents)
JESSICA MAITLAND SIMONS, HOLLY ASHTON ZDILAR, LUKE DAVID MILES, MATTHEW THOMAS ZDILAR AND AXELLE KATRINA SIMONS by their Litigation Guardian TIMOTHY CLIFTON WHITNEY
(third respondents)

FILE NO/S:

BS7945 of 2010

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

31 January 2011

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 September 2010

JUDGE:

Margaret Wilson J

ORDER:

That upon the proper construction of the will of Ann Mary Ashton deceased dated 29 September 1998, and in the events which have occurred, the exit entitlement paid to the deceased’s estate by Tall Trees Rochedale Pty Ltd, pursuant to clause 21.2 of the sub-lease commencing on 5 September 2007 is payable to the second and third respondents pursuant to clause 3(e) of the will; and1)   

That all parties’ costs of this application be paid out of the deceased’s residuary estate on the indemnity basis.2)   

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND THE EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – GENERALLY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF CONSTRUCTION – ORDINARY AND GRAMMATICAL MEANING OF WORDS – where testatrix bequeathed the "house property" and "substitute house property" that she owned at the date of her death – where testatrix owned house at time of making will – where testatrix sold house – where testatrix lived in retirement village pursuant to 99 year sub-lease at time of death – whether recourse to extrinsic evidence necessary to determine testatrix’s intention – whether retirement village was "substitute house property" – whether testatrix "owned" unit at retirement village

Succession Act 1981 (Qld) ss 33C, 33I

Perrin v Morgan [1943] AC 399, cited
Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith [2009] 1 Qd R 26; [2008] QSC 339, applied
Re Blake Dec’d [2009] VSC 184, distinguished
Re Purcell Dec’d (1991) 103 FLR 271, cited

COUNSEL:

R T Whiteford the applicants
No appearance for the first and second respondents
R M Treston for the third respondents

SOLICITORS:

Geoffrey R Funnell for the applicants
McCullough Robertson for the third respondents

  1. Margaret Wilson J: Ann Mary Ashton ("the testatrix") died on 8 October 2009.

  1. The applicants, who are her executors, have applied for a declaration as to the proper construction of her will.

Background

  1. The testatrix was aged 91 years when she died. Her husband and her only child had predeceased her. She was survived by four grandchildren and eight great grandchildren.

  1. The second applicant and the first respondents are the testatrix’s grandchildren. The second respondents are her adult great grandchildren, and the third respondents are her infant great grandchildren.

  1. The testatrix made her last will on 29 September 1998 (about 15…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Trust Company Limited v Zdilar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QSC 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Trust Company Limited, as trustee for the estate of Ann Mary Ashton, brought an application to the Supreme Court of Queensland for directions in respect of the construction of Ms Ashton’s will, dated 29 September 1998. The will contained a bequest of the testatrix’s “house property” and “substitute house property” to her nephew and niece, the second and third respondents. The testatrix had owned a house at the time of making the will but sold it prior to her death. At the time of her death, the testatrix was living in a retirement village under a 99-year sub-lease. The question arose whether the testatrix had owned the unit in the retirement village at the time of her death, and whether the exit entitlement paid by the retirement village to the estate was payable to the second and third respondents.

The court needed to determine whether the testatrix owned the unit in the retirement village at the time of her death and whether recourse to extrinsic evidence was necessary to determine the testatrix’s intention. The court also needed to determine whether the retirement village was the “substitute house property” bequeathed by the will and whether the exit entitlement was payable to the second and third respondents. The court found that the testatrix had not owned the unit in the retirement village at the time of her death and that recourse to extrinsic evidence was not necessary to determine the testatrix’s intention. The court also found that the retirement village was not the “substitute house property” bequeathed by the will and that the exit entitlement was not payable to the second and third respondents.

The court held that the testatrix had not owned the unit in the retirement village at the time of her death, and that recourse to extrinsic evidence was not necessary to determine the testatrix’s intention. The court found that the ordinary and grammatical meaning of “house property” and “substitute house property” did not include the unit in the retirement village. The court also found that the retirement village was not the “substitute house property” bequeathed by the will and that the exit entitlement was not payable to the second and third respondents. The court ordered that the exit entitlement paid to the deceased’s estate by Tall Trees Rochedale Pty Ltd was not payable to the second and third respondents, and that all parties’ costs of this application be paid out of the deceased’s residuary estate on the indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

That upon the proper construction of the will of Ann Mary Ashton deceased dated 29 September 1998, and in the events which have occurred, the exit entitlement paid to the deceased’s estate by Tall Trees Rochedale Pty Ltd, pursuant to clause 21.2 of the sub-lease commencing on 5 September 2007 is payable to the second and third respondents pursuant to clause 3(e) of the will; and1)

That all parties’ costs of this application be paid out of the deceased’s residuary estate on the indemnity basis.2)

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established