The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith [2008] QSC 339

PARTIES:

THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND

(applicant)

AND

HELEN MARIE SMITH

(first respondent)

AND

KIM HELEN LUNDGAARD

(second respondent)

AND

MEGAN JODY RANDALL

(third respondent)

AND

ANDREW MACGREGOR SMITH

(fourth respondent)

AND

KRISTEN ELIZABETH McKENZIE

(fifth respondent)

AND

CHARLOTTE MARY ALLEN

(sixth respondent)

AND

ANTONIO SEAN D’ALESSANDRO McINTYRE

(seventh respondent)

AND

EMMA KATE RANDALL

(eighth respondent)

AND

AMY JULIETTE RANDALL

(ninth respondent)

AND

KATIE ALEXANDRA RANDALL

(tenth respondent)

AND

CALLUM HUGH McKENZIE

(eleventh respondent)

AND

KAITLIN PAIGE McKENZIE

(twelfth respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS2228/08

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

19th December 2008

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

21 July 2008

JUDGE:

Atkinson J

ORDERS:

1.  The court declares that upon a proper construction of the will of Hugh Joseph Mackay, deceased, dated 23 June 2003:

(a)the class of beneficiaries referred to in cl 6.02(vi) of that will:    

(i)is comprised of such of the grandchildren of the siblings of the deceased who survive the deceased and attain 23 years of age; 

(ii)includes only persons living at the date of the deceased’s death;

(iii)closes when the first beneficiary therein attains the age of 23 years;

(b)the deceased’s residuary estate is to be divided into six equal parts, with one such part passing to each of the beneficiaries named in sub-clauses 6.02(i) – (v) with the remaining part to be shared equally between the members of the class referred to in sub-clause 6.02(vi) 

2.The time for the making of an application for rectification of the will of Hugh Joseph Mackay (also known as Peter Joseph Mackay) be extended to 18 April 2008.  

3.The application by the first to fifth respondents is otherwise dismissed.  

4.The costs are to be paid on an indemnity basis from the estate of Hugh Joseph Mackay (deceased).    

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND THE EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – GENERALLY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF CONSTRUCTION – ORDINARY AND GRAMMATICAL MEANING OF WORDS – whether the usual meaning rule was sufficient to resolve the construction of a provision of a will – whether the meaning of the words “as to one part” and “in each case” was clear in the context of the clause as a whole – whether there was need to go to extrinsic evidence – where the meaning  of the words “to survive” was  determined

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND THE EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – GENERALLY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF CONSTRUCTION – ADMISSIBILITY OF EXTRINSIC EVIDENCE – where section 33C Succession Act 1991 sets out what extrinsic evidence is admissible in interpreting a will – where rules of construction continue to allow admission of extrinsic evidence  whether extrinsic evidence could be admitted to aid in construction of this will

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND THE EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – GENERALLY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF CONSTRUCTION – GIFTS TO A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 339
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Public Trustee of Queensland brought an application against Smith, seeking clarification on the interpretation of Hugh Joseph Mackay's will. The will left a residuary estate to be divided among various beneficiaries, including the deceased's great nieces and nephews who survived him and reached the age of 23. The dispute centred on the interpretation of several clauses, including the meaning of the words "as to one part" and "in each case", and the admissibility of extrinsic evidence to aid in the construction of the will. The case was heard in the Queensland Supreme Court.

The court was required to decide several legal issues. The first was whether the ordinary and grammatical meaning of the words in the will was sufficient to resolve the construction of the testamentary dispositions, and whether extrinsic evidence was necessary. The second was whether the class of beneficiaries referred to as "each of my great nieces and nephews who survive me and live to be 23 years" was restricted to persons living at the date of the deceased's death or if it included persons born after the testator's death but before the class closed. The third was whether the deceased's residuary estate was to be divided into six equal parts, with one part passing to each of the beneficiaries named in the will, and the remaining part to be shared equally between the members of the class referred to in the will.

The court held that the ordinary and grammatical meaning of the words in the will was sufficient to resolve the construction of the testamentary dispositions, and extrinsic evidence was not necessary. The court found that the class of beneficiaries referred to in the will was restricted to persons living at the date of the deceased's death, and did not include persons born after the testator's death. The court also held that the deceased's residuary estate was to be divided into six equal parts, with one part passing to each of the beneficiaries named in the will, and the remaining part to be shared equally between the members of the class referred to in the will. The court extended the time for making an application for rectification of the will.

The court declared that upon a proper construction of the will of Hugh Joseph Mackay, the class of beneficiaries referred to in cl 6.02(vi) of that will is comprised of such of the grandchildren of the siblings of the deceased who survive the deceased and attain 23 years of age; includes only persons living at the date of the deceased’s death; and closes when the first beneficiary therein attains the age of 23 years. The court also extended the time for the making of an application for rectification of the will to 18 April 2008. The application by the first to fifth respondents was dismissed, and the costs were to be paid on an indemnity basis from the estate of Hugh Joseph Mackay (deceased).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The court declares that upon a proper construction of the will of Hugh Joseph Mackay, deceased, dated 23 June 2003:

(a)the class of beneficiaries referred to in cl 6.02(vi) of that will:

(i)is comprised of such of the grandchildren of the siblings of the deceased who survive the deceased and attain 23 years of age;

(ii)includes only persons living at the date of the deceased’s death;

(iii)closes when the first beneficiary therein attains the age of 23 years;

(b)the deceased’s residuary estate is to be divided into six equal parts, with one such part passing to each of the beneficiaries named in sub-clauses 6.02(i) – (v) with the remaining part to be shared equally between the members of the class referred to in sub-clause 6.02(vi)

2.The time for the making of an application for rectification of the will of Hugh Joseph Mackay (also known as Peter Joseph Mackay) be extended to 18 April 2008.

3.The application by the first to fifth respondents is otherwise dismissed.

4.The costs are to be paid on an indemnity basis from the estate of Hugh Joseph Mackay (deceased).

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established