Brennan v Permanent Trustee Co of NSW Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read
73 CLR 404

PERMANENT TRUSTEE COMPANY OF NEW

RESPONDENTS.

SOUTH WALES LIMITED AND OTHERS

PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Will-Construction " Who shall survive me."

After directing that the income of certain legacies was to be paid to the respective legatees for their sole and separate use and without power of anticipation, a will provided that after or in the case of the decease of each of July 31;

the said legatees then the sum given for her benefit was to be held upon trust Aug. 17.

" 'for all her children who shall survive me and attain the age of twenty-one years or die in my lifetime leaving issue." At the date of the will, which was made one year before the testator's death, six of the twelve legatees, nieces of the testator, were married and had children. Since the testator's death other legatees had married and more children had been born.

Held, by Rich, Dixon and Williams JJ. (Starke J. dissenting), that the pro- vision in question included all children of the nieces of the testator who lived after his death and attained or should attain the age of twenty-one years whether such children were born in his lifetime or after his death.

Decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Roper J.), by majority,

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

William Edward Sparke, who died on 27th July 1905 at the age of seventy-five years, left a will made by him on 5th July 1904, wherein he appointed his nephew Wallace John Carson to be the executor and trustee thereof and to whom probate thereof was granted on 29th August 1905.

73 CLR 405

By his will the testator, inter alia, directed his trustee to set apart and invest for his five named nieces, the daughters of his sister Fanny, and their respective issue, if any, five several legacies being the sum of £7,000 to one of those nieces, the sum of £5,000 to another of those nieces, and the sum of £3,000 to each of the other three of those nieces, such legacies to be settled upon each of them respectively and their respective children in the manner thereinafter declared. The testator also directed his trustee to set apart and invest and settle in like manner for his seven named nieces the daughters of his deceased brother Edward Joseph Sparke and their respective issue, if any, certain legacies being the sum of £15,000 to one of those nieces and the sum of £13,000 to each of the other six of those nieces. After making provision for other gifts, devises and bequests not material to this report the testator devised certain real estate upon the trust thereinafter declared for the benefit of Charlotte Maud Gilbert and for her issue, and he gave, devised and bequeathed the rest, residue and remainder of his real and personal estate to his nephew the said Wallace John Carson his heirs, executors, adminis-…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brennan v Permanent Trustee Co of NSW Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1945] HCA 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brennan v Permanent Trustee Co of NSW Ltd concerned the interpretation of a will made by William Edward Sparke. The dispute arose over the distribution of certain legacies settled upon the testator's nieces and their children. The primary issue was whether children born to the nieces after the testator's death were included in the class of beneficiaries entitled to the corpus of these legacies, specifically in relation to the phrase "all her children who shall survive me and attain the age of twenty-one years or die in my lifetime leaving issue." The High Court of Australia was tasked with determining the true construction of this provision.

The legal question before the court was whether the phrase "who shall survive me" in the will should be interpreted in its strict grammatical sense, thereby excluding children born after the testator's death, or if the testator's intention, as evidenced by the will as a whole and surrounding circumstances, indicated a broader meaning that included such after-born children. The court was required to reconcile the literal meaning of "survive" with the testator's apparent overall intention to provide for his nieces and their issue.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Rich, Dixon, and Williams JJ., held that the testator's intention was to include all children of his nieces who lived after his death and attained the age of twenty-one years, regardless of whether they were born before or after his death. The majority reasoned that while the literal meaning of "survive" would exclude after-born children, the context of the will, including the general intention to benefit nieces and their issue, and particularly the provisions made for Charlotte Maud Gilbert and her issue, strongly indicated that the testator had misused the word "survive" and intended to include all children who outlived him. Starke J., dissenting, maintained that the literal and natural meaning of "survive" should be applied, excluding children born after the testator's death, and found insufficient evidence in the will or surrounding circumstances to justify departing from this meaning. The appeal was allowed, and the order was varied to declare that the provision included all children of the nieces who lived after the testator's death and attained or should attain the age of twenty-one years, whether born in his lifetime or thereafter.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established