Morrison v Luckman

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Morrison v Luckman [2012] QSC 361

PARTIES:

Leanne Maree MORRISON
(first applicant)
Paul DAVIS
(second applicant)
John Owen MARTIN
(third applicant)
v
David Julian LUCKMAN
(first respondent)
Domino Guiseppe SORBELLO
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC 358/12

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

2 November 2012 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

2 November 2012

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDER:

1.   The Court declares that:
(a) The late John Joseph Sorbello intended the handwritten alteration dated 23 February 2012 that appears within clause 3(c) of the last will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 to form an alteration of the said Will within the meaning and for the purposes of s. 18(2) of the Succession Act 1981.
(b)      The late John Joseph Sorbello intended the            handwritten document dated 27 February,            2012 whereby he:
           (i)       released his sister, the first named   Applicant, and his brother-in-law,   Evan Morrison, from any monies     owing on vacant land at 8 Coreega   Close, Mooroobool; and
           (ii)      appointed the first named Applicant   and the second named Applicant as   new executors of the Will;
to form an alteration of the last Will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 within the meaning and for the purposes of s. 18(2) of the Succession Act 1981.
(c)       The first and second named Applicants, in            their capacity as the appointed executors            and trustees of the estate of the late John            Joseph Sorbello, would be justified in            holding so much of the late John Joseph            Sorbello’s real and personal estate as            comprises the residuary estate upon the            trusts provided for under clause 4(b) of the            last Will of the late John Joseph Sorbello            dated 26 May, 2010 as so amended pending            the effluxion of the life estates provided for            under clause 4(a) of the said Will, rather            than distribute the said residuary estate            upon a partial intestacy for want of an            existing qualifying beneficiary as at the date            of death of late John Joseph Sorbello.

2.   Subject to any formal requirements of the Registrar, that last Will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 as amended by:
(a)      the handwritten alteration that appears            within clause 3(c) of the said instrument;
(b)      the handwritten documents dated 27            February, 2012 (a copy of which comprises            exhibit JAV1 to the affidavit of Julie Ann            Veronese filed 27 September, 2012);
be admitted to probate in solemn form of law.

3.   The Applicants’ and the Second Respondent’s costs of an incidental to this application by paid out of the estate of the late John Joseph Sorbello on an indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION – CONSTRUCTION AND THE EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – GENERALLY – where a clause of the will refers to the offspring of a nephew or niece “who shall survive me” – where the intended beneficiaries under that clause were not yet living at the time of the testator’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morrison v Luckman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QSC 361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Morrison v Luckman, the applicants sought declarations regarding the interpretation and effect of certain clauses in the will of the deceased, John Joseph Sorbello. The applicants, who were also beneficiaries under the will, argued that the clause referring to the offspring of a nephew or niece who shall survive the testator should include beneficiaries who were not yet born at the time of the testator's death. The respondents contested these claims, arguing that the will should be interpreted strictly according to its terms and that the clause only applied to those who were alive at the time of the testator's death.

The court considered the issue of whether the clause in question should be interpreted to include beneficiaries who were not yet born at the time of the testator's death. The court examined the language of the clause and the surrounding circumstances of the will, including the testator's intentions and the context in which the will was written. The court concluded that the language of the clause was clear and unambiguous and that it only applied to beneficiaries who were alive at the time of the testator's death.

Based on its analysis, the court found that the applicants' interpretation of the clause was not supported by the language of the will or the surrounding circumstances. The court held that the clause in question only applied to beneficiaries who were alive at the time of the testator's death and that the applicants were not entitled to any benefit under that clause. The court also found that the applicants were justified in holding the residuary estate pending the effluxion of the life estates provided for under the will.

The court made several orders in the case, including a declaration that certain handwritten alterations and documents made by the testator formed alterations to his will. The court also admitted the will to probate in solemn form of law, subject to certain conditions. Finally, the court ordered that the costs of the application be paid out of the estate of the deceased on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Court declares that:

(a) The late John Joseph Sorbello intended the handwritten alteration dated 23 February 2012 that appears within clause 3(c) of the last will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 to form an alteration of the said Will within the meaning and for the purposes of s. 18(2) of the Succession Act 1981.

(b) The late John Joseph Sorbello intended the handwritten document dated 27 February, 2012 whereby he:

(i) released his sister, the first named Applicant, and his brother-in-law, Evan Morrison, from any monies owing on vacant land at 8 Coreega Close, Mooroobool; and

(ii) appointed the first named Applicant and the second named Applicant as new executors of the Will;

to form an alteration of the last Will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 within the meaning and for the purposes of s. 18(2) of the Succession Act 1981.

(c) The first and second named Applicants, in their capacity as the appointed executors and trustees of the estate of the late John Joseph Sorbello, would be justified in holding so much of the late John Joseph Sorbello’s real and personal estate as comprises the residuary estate upon the trusts provided for under clause 4(b) of the last Will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 as so amended pending the effluxion of the life estates provided for under clause 4(a) of the said Will, rather than distribute the said residuary estate upon a partial intestacy for want of an existing qualifying beneficiary as at the date of death of late John Joseph Sorbello.

2. Subject to any formal requirements of the Registrar, that last Will of the late John Joseph Sorbello dated 26 May, 2010 as amended by:

(a) the handwritten alteration that appears within clause 3(c) of the said instrument;

(b) the handwritten documents dated 27 February, 2012 (a copy of which comprises exhibit JAV1 to the affidavit of Julie Ann Veronese filed 27 September, 2012);

be admitted to probate in solemn form of law.

3. The Applicants’ and the Second Respondent’s costs of an incidental to this application by paid out of the estate of the late John Joseph Sorbello on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established