Stevens v Hamilton

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Stevens v Hamilton and Anor [2015] QSC 279

PARTIES:

ERROL DAVID STEVENS as Executor of the Estate of Lionel Alexander Stevens deceased as Trustee of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund and as Beneficiary of the Estate of Lionel Alexander Stevens deceased

(Applicant)

v
DIANA CRYSTAL HAMILTON and GLENN PETER COLLIER HARWOOD as Executors of the Will of Lois Isabel Stevens deceased

(Respondents)

FILE NO/S:

Brisbane No 3075 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

8 October 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

28 July 2015

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ORDER:

I shall hear the parties as to the form of orders, and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE – where the applicant, who was the executor of the deceased’s Will and trustee of the deceased’s Trust Fund, sought an order pursuant to the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld) as to how he ought to treat funds held in the deceased’s investment account – whether the funds in issue are an asset of the deceased’s estate or of the deceased’s Trust Fund

Succession Act 1981 (Qld)

Trusts Act 1973 (Qld)

Re Gulbenkian’s Settlement Trust (1978) AC 508, cited

The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith [2008] QSC 339, cited

COUNSEL:

S K McLeod for the applicant

R T Whiteford for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Madsen Lawyers for the applicant

YHC Lawyers for the respondents

  1. BODDICE J: By originating application, filed 26 March 2015, the applicant sought an order pursuant to Section 96 of the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld) as to how funds held in an investment account ought to be treated by him as Executor of the Will of Lionel Alexander Stevens, deceased, and as Trustee of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund.

  2. At issue is the proper interpretation of the Will of the deceased and whether the funds in question are an asset of the deceased’s estate or of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund.

    Background

  3. The deceased was born on 6 October 1916. He had two sons: Errol, who is the applicant, and Gregory, who died in December 1995.  On 25 May 1996, the deceased married his second wife, Lois Isabel Stevens. The deceased died on 9 March 2014. 

  4. Lois Isabel Stevens died on 20 March 2015.  Probate of her Will was granted to her executors, Diana Crystal Hamilton and Glenn Peter Collier Harwood on 24 June 2015.  Those executors are the respondent in this application.

  5. The deceased’s last Will was dated 4 April 2003.  It appointed the applicant as his Executor.  Relevantly, it gave to the applicant “all of my share or interest in the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund”.  The residuary estate was left to the deceased’s wife.

  6. The Lionel Stevens Trust Fund was established by Deed dated 1 March 1996.  It was still in existence as at the date of the deceased’s death.  The applicant was its Trustee.  The deceased was entitled to the income of the Trust during his lifetime.  On his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stevens v Hamilton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QSC 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stevens v Hamilton, the court was asked to determine the proper interpretation of the Will of Lionel Stevens, who passed away on 9 March 2014. The applicant, Errol Stevens, who was named as the executor of his father’s Will and trustee of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund, sought clarification on how to treat funds held in his father's investment account with Colonial First State. The central issue was whether these funds were an asset of Lionel Stevens' estate or the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund.

The court had to decide whether the funds in the Colonial First State Investment Account were intended to be part of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund or if they belonged to Lionel Stevens' personal estate. The applicant argued that the funds in the investment account were proceeds from the estate of Lionel's late son Gregory, held in trust by the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. Alternatively, he argued that even if the funds were not held in trust, they should not form part of the residuary estate. The respondent, executors of Lois Isabel Stevens' Will, contended that the funds belonged to Lionel Stevens' estate.

The court considered the terms of the Will, the evidence of how the funds were managed and declared, and the legal principles governing the interpretation of Wills and trusts. It concluded that there was no evidence that the funds in the Colonial First State Investment Account were ever the property of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. Therefore, these funds were the property of Lionel Stevens at the time of his death and part of his personal estate. The court found that the words in clause 4 of the Will were clear and not ambiguous, and the deceased's intention did not extend to gifting the investment account funds to the trust.

The court directed the parties to discuss the form of orders and the allocation of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

I shall hear the parties as to the form of orders, and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

At issue is the proper interpretation of the Will of the deceased and whether the funds in question are an asset of the deceased’s estate or of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund.Background The deceased was born on 6 October 1916. He had two sons: Errol, who is the applicant, and Gregory, who died in December 1995. On 25 May 1996, the deceased married his second wife, Lois Isabel Stevens. The deceased died on 9 March 2014. Lois Isabel Stevens died on 20 March 2015. Probate of her Will was granted to her executors, Diana Crystal Hamilton and Glenn Peter Collier Harwood on 24 June 2015. Those executors are the respondent in this application. The deceased’s last Will was dated 4 April 2003. It appointed the applicant as his Executor. Relevantly, it gave to the applicant “all of my share or interest in the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund”. The residuary estate was left to the deceased’s wife. The Lionel Stevens Trust Fund was established by Deed dated 1 March 1996. It was still in existence as at the date of the deceased’s death. The applicant was its Trustee. The deceased was entitled to the income of the Trust during his lifetime. On his death, the applicant as Trustee had power to distribute the Trust assets to himself. Evidence The deceased was the sole beneficiary of the estate of his late son Gregory. The applicant claims the deceased received approximately $400,000 on account of that estate which was deposited into a Commonwealth Bank account in or about 1996 to be held “on trust by the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund”. The Commonwealth Bank has no record of any account in the name of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. On 10 June 1998, the deceased opened Commonwealth Bank Portfolio Investment Account No 704. The account was opened in the name of “Lionel Alexander Stevens”. The income generated from that account was paid into Commonwealth Bank Pensioner Security Account No 004 in the names of the deceased and his wife. On 20 August 2004, Account No 004 was closed and Commonwealth Bank Pensioner Security Account No 368 in the name of “L Stevens” was opened. Distributions from Account No 704 were thereafter paid into Account No 368. On 23 August 2004, Account No 704 was closed and the proceeds ($378,128.55) paid into Account No 368. On 30 August 2004, the deceased withdrew $335,000 from Account No 368 to establish an investment account with the Colonial First State. That investment was established by application dated 26 August 2004. The investor was listed as Lionel Alexander Stevens with the “Superannuation Fund/Trust” listed as “Lionel Stevens Trust Account”. The deceased was the sole signatory of that application. The income of that investment account was paid into Account No 368. On 6 June 2013, the deceased withdrew $20,000 from the Colonial First State Investment account. The remaining amount was retained in that account. At the time of the deceased’s death the amount in the Colonial First State Investment account was $329,107.64.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Lionel Stevens Trust Fund was established by Deed dated 1 March 1996. It was still in existence as at the date of the deceased’s death. The applicant was its Trustee. The deceased was entitled to the income of the Trust during his lifetime. On his death, the applicant as Trustee had power to distribute the Trust assets to himself. Evidence The deceased was the sole beneficiary of the estate of his late son Gregory. The applicant claims the deceased received approximately $400,000 on account of that estate which was deposited into a Commonwealth Bank account in or about 1996 to be held “on trust by the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund”. The Commonwealth Bank has no record of any account in the name of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. On 10 June 1998, the deceased opened Commonwealth Bank Portfolio Investment Account No 704. The account was opened in the name of “Lionel Alexander Stevens”. The income generated from that account was paid into Commonwealth Bank Pensioner Security Account No 004 in the names of the deceased and his wife. On 20 August 2004, Account No 004 was closed and Commonwealth Bank Pensioner Security Account No 368 in the name of “L Stevens” was opened. Distributions from Account No 704 were thereafter paid into Account No 368. On 23 August 2004, Account No 704 was closed and the proceeds ($378,128.55) paid into Account No 368. On 30 August 2004, the deceased withdrew $335,000 from Account No 368 to establish an investment account with the Colonial First State. That investment was established by application dated 26 August 2004. The investor was listed as Lionel Alexander Stevens with the “Superannuation Fund/Trust” listed as “Lionel Stevens Trust Account”. The deceased was the sole signatory of that application. The income of that investment account was paid into Account No 368. On 6 June 2013, the deceased withdrew $20,000 from the Colonial First State Investment account. The remaining amount was retained in that account. At the time of the deceased’s death the amount in the Colonial First State Investment account was $329,107.64. Throughout the period since establishing the investment account with Colonial First State, the deceased declared the income from that investment in his tax returns. His accountant did not, at any time, prepare tax returns for the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund.The application The applicant submits the words “Lionel Stevens Trust Fund” in clause 4 of the Will refer to the funds held in the Lionel Stevens Trust Account at Colonial First State. He submits those monies were the proceeds of funds received by the deceased from the Estate of his late son Gregory, which were held on trust by the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. The deceased’s intention was that the applicant receive these funds. Alternatively, the applicant submits the proceeds of the Colonial First State Investment account are an asset of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. Those funds do not form part of the residuary estate of the deceased.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant also submits it is significant that the deceased declared to a solicitor that he was the sole trustee of a trust, and that he had a right to appoint a new trustee in place of the applicant. Whilst those statements may be consistent with the deceased believing he was trustee of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund, it does not follow the deceased had gifted funds held in the account of the Colonial First State Investment Account to the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund, or that the deceased ever intended to do so. Conclusion The words in clause 4 of the deceased’s Will are neither meaningless nor ambiguous. There is no evidence the funds in the Colonial First State Investment Account were ever the property of the Lionel Stevens Trust Fund. Those funds were the property of the deceased, at the time of his death. I shall hear the parties as to the form of orders, and costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established