Prime Infrastructure (DBCT) Management P/L v Vero Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Prime Infrastructure (DBCT) Management P/L v Vero Insurance Ltd & Ors [2005] QCA 369

PARTIES:

PRIME INFRASTRUCTURE (DBCT) MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED ACN 097 698 916
(applicant/respondent)
v
VERO INSURANCE LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ROYAL AND SUN ALLIANCE INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED)
ACN 005 297 807
(first respondent/first appellant)
AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE COMPANY
ARBN 007 483 267
(second respondent/second appellant)
ZURICH INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED
(third respondent/third appellant)
QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED
ACN 003 191 035
(fourth respondent/fourth appellant)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 9690 of 2004
SC No 8009 of 2004

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

30 September 2005

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 May 2005

JUDGES:

McMurdo P, Jerrard JA and Mullins J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, McMurdo P and Mullins J concurring as to the order made, Jerrard JA dissenting

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed with costs to be assessed

CATCHWORDS:

INSURANCE - GENERAL - POLICIES OF INSURANCE - CONSTRUCTION - respondent insured under an Industrial Special Risks Insurance Policy issued by the appellants - one of respondent's machines collapsed causing damage to machine and other machinery - parties in a statement of facts agreed the collapse of the machine was initiated by the final severing of an internal fatigue crack in a defective weld in one of the machine's undercarriage legs which was the result of faulty workmanship at the time of its original construction - policy of insurance contained 'Perils' exclusions - 'Perils' exclusions clause 4 included 'faulty workmanship' and 'gradual deterioration and developing flaws' - 'Perils' exclusions clause 4 contained proviso that 'this Exclusion ... shall not apply to subsequent loss, destruction of or damage ... occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded) resulting from any event or peril referred to in this exclusion' - respondent applied for a declaration the appellants were liable to indemnify it under the policy for approximately $8M for the cost of repairing the machinery - primary judge found the application of the proviso did not require two separate causes and would apply where there was subsequent damage that was not excluded by a term of the policy other than 'Perils' exclusions clause 4 - application granted on two alternative bases - first that the damage was subsequent in time and effect to the failure of the defective weld and not otherwise excluded by the policy - second that if 'peril' were interpreted as 'danger' the damage occasioned by the faulty workmanship resulted in the peril that loss of structural integrity would lead to a failure of the entire structure and once that eventuated it caused subsequent damage not otherwise excluded by the policy - whether the primary judge erred in determining that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' did not encompass the exclusions in the 'Perils' exclusions clause 4 - whether the primary judge erred in determining the meaning of 'peril' - whether there was subsequent damage to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prime Infrastructure (DBCT) Management P/L v Vero Insurance... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QCA 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Prime Infrastructure (DBCT) Management P/L brought a claim against Vero Insurance Ltd, seeking a declaration that Vero Insurance Ltd was liable to indemnify it under an Industrial Special Risks Insurance Policy for approximately $8 million for the cost of repairing machinery damaged when one of its machines collapsed. The collapse was due to a faulty weld in one of the machine's undercarriage legs, which was the result of faulty workmanship at the time of the original construction. The policy contained 'Perils' exclusions, including exclusions for 'faulty workmanship' and 'gradual deterioration and developing flaws'. However, the exclusions also contained a proviso stating that they did not apply to subsequent loss or damage caused by a peril not otherwise excluded, which resulted from any event or peril referred to in the exclusions. The primary judge found that the application of the proviso did not require two separate causes and would apply where there was subsequent damage not otherwise excluded by the policy. The primary judge granted the application on two alternative bases: first, that the damage was subsequent in time and effect to the failure of the defective weld and not otherwise excluded by the policy, and second, that if 'peril' were interpreted as 'danger', the damage occasioned by the faulty workmanship resulted in the peril that loss of structural integrity would lead to a failure of the entire structure, and once that eventuated it caused subsequent damage not otherwise excluded by the policy.

Vero Insurance Ltd appealed against the primary judge's decision, arguing that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' did not encompass the exclusions in the 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The appeal hinged on the interpretation of the phrase 'occasioned by a peril' and the meaning of 'peril'. Vero Insurance Ltd contended that the damage was not subsequent damage not otherwise excluded by the policy, and that the primary judge had erred in determining the meaning of 'peril'. The appeal also raised the question of whether there was subsequent damage to bring into effect the proviso to 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The court considered various authorities, including Acme Galvanizing Co Inc v Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, Chadwick v Fire Insurance Exchange, Chalmers Leask Underwriting Agencies v Mayne Nickless Limited, Hamilton, Fraser & Co v Pandorf & Co, L'Union Des Assurances de Paris Iard v Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd, McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd, Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Aust) Ltd v Rowprint Services, Ranicar v Frigmobile Pty Ltd, R v Zischke, Skandia Insurance Co Ltd v Skoljarev, and Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd v Lebah Products Pty Ltd. The court also considered Wilkie v Gordian Runoff Ltd.

The court found that the primary judge had not erred in determining that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' did not encompass the exclusions in the 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The court held that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril' meant that the damage must have been caused by a peril that was not otherwise excluded by the policy, and that the damage must have been a result of that peril. The court also found that the primary judge had not erred in determining the meaning of 'peril'. The court held that 'peril' should be interpreted as 'danger', and that the damage occasioned by the faulty workmanship resulted in the danger that loss of structural integrity would lead to a failure of the entire structure, and once that eventuated it caused subsequent damage not otherwise excluded by the policy. The court found that there was subsequent damage to bring into effect the proviso to 'Perils' exclusions clause 4, and that the primary judge had not erred in granting the application on either of the alternative bases.

The appeal was dismissed with costs to be assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs to be assessed

Background

Background to the litigation

Vero Insurance Ltd insured its machinery under an Industrial Special Risks Insurance Policy issued by Prime Infrastructure (DBCT) Management P/L. One of Vero Insurance's machines collapsed, causing damage to the machine and other machinery. The collapse was initiated by the final severing of an internal fatigue crack in a defective weld in one of the machine's undercarriage legs, which was a result of faulty workmanship at the time of its original construction. The policy contained 'Perils' exclusions, which included 'faulty workmanship' and 'gradual deterioration and developing flaws'. However, there was a proviso in the exclusions that stated the exclusion did not apply to subsequent loss, destruction, or damage occasioned by a peril resulting from any event or peril referred to in the exclusion. Vero Insurance applied for a declaration that Prime Infrastructure was liable to indemnify it under the policy for approximately $8 million for the cost of repairing the machinery. The primary judge found that the application of the proviso did not require two separate causes and would apply where there was subsequent damage that was not excluded by a term of the policy other than 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The application was granted on two alternative bases: first, that the damage was subsequent in time and effect to the failure of the defective weld and not otherwise excluded by the policy; and second, that if 'peril' were interpreted as 'danger', the damage occasioned by the faulty workmanship resulted in the peril that loss of structural integrity would lead to a failure of the entire structure, and once that eventuated, it caused subsequent damage not otherwise excluded by the policy.

The matter came before the court on an appeal from a decision of the primary judge, who granted Vero Insurance's application for a declaration. The primary judge found in favour of Vero Insurance on two alternative bases, as outlined above. Prime Infrastructure appealed the decision, arguing that the primary judge erred in determining that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' did not encompass the exclusions in the 'Perils' exclusions clause 4 and that the primary judge erred in determining the meaning of 'peril'. The court considered various authorities in its judgment, including cases from Australia and other jurisdictions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary judge erred in determining that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' did not encompass the exclusions in the 'Perils' exclusions clause 4.
2. Whether the primary judge erred in determining the meaning of 'peril'.
3. Whether there was subsequent damage to bring into effect the proviso to 'Perils' exclusions clause 4.

Held
1. The court held that the primary judge did not err in determining that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' did not encompass the exclusions in the 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The court found that the phrase referred to a subsequent event that was not otherwise excluded by the policy, rather than an event that triggered the exclusions.
2. The court held that the primary judge did not err in determining the meaning of 'peril'. The court agreed that 'peril' should be interpreted as 'danger', and that the damage caused by faulty workmanship resulted in the danger of loss of structural integrity, which led to a failure of the entire structure and subsequent damage.
3. The court held that there was subsequent damage to bring into effect the proviso to 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The court found that the damage was subsequent in time and effect to the failure of the defective weld and not otherwise excluded by the policy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the arguments of both parties and the relevant authorities in determining the meaning of the exclusions in the policy. The court found that the primary judge correctly interpreted the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' as referring to a subsequent event that was not otherwise excluded by the policy, rather than an event that triggered the exclusions. The court also found that the primary judge correctly interpreted the meaning of 'peril' as 'danger', and that the damage caused by faulty workmanship resulted in the danger of loss of structural integrity, which led to a failure of the entire structure and subsequent damage. The court noted that the proviso to 'Perils' exclusions clause 4 would apply where there was subsequent damage that was not excluded by a term of the policy other than 'Perils' exclusions clause 4. The court held that the damage was subsequent in time and effect to the failure of the defective weld and not otherwise excluded by the policy. The court found that the primary judge correctly granted the application on two alternative bases and dismissed the appeal with costs to be assessed.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the phrase 'occasioned by a peril (not otherwise excluded)' in an insurance policy refers to a subsequent event that is not otherwise excluded by the policy, rather than an event that triggers the exclusions. Additionally, the court held that the meaning of 'peril' in an insurance policy should be interpreted as 'danger', and that a subsequent event caused by a danger not otherwise excluded by the policy can bring into effect a proviso in an exclusions clause.