King v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

King v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2015] QCA 101

PARTIES:

DANIEL RAYMOND KING
(appellant)
v
ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 000 122 850
(respondent)
BRETT RODNEY HOLZ
(not a party to the proceeding)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 9666 of 2014
SC No 406 of 2011

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Townsville – Unreported, 20 August 2014

DELIVERED ON:

12 June 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 May 2015

JUDGES:

Philippides JA, Mullins and Burns JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1.  Appeal allowed with costs.
2.  Set aside the orders at first instance.
3.  Instead, the application for review is dismissed.

4.  The respondent must refund to the appellant the amount paid by the appellant to the respondent consequential upon the orders at first instance.

5. The respondent must pay the appellant’s costs of the application for review assessed on the District Court scale.


CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – TAXATION – REVIEW – PRINCIPLES APPLICABLE – INTERFERENCE WITH EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – GENERAL – where appellant was injured in a motor vehicle accident – where personal injuries proceeding was settled and insurer agreed to pay the appellant’s costs and outlays to be assessed on the District Court scale – where appellant had engaged a clinical anatomist to provide a medico-legal report for the trial – where insurer objected to the costs of the report on the basis that it was not necessary or proper and overlapped with the reports obtained from the other medical specialists – where the costs assessor allowed the costs for the report – where insurer applied for a review of the costs assessor’s decision – where the primary judge found no error in the costs assessor’s exercise of discretion, but held the report was inadmissible and the appellant was not entitled to the costs of report – whether the review of the costs assessor’s decision should have succeeded

PROCEDURE – COSTS – TAXATION – REVIEW – PRINCIPLES APPLICABLE – INTERFERENCE WITH EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – GENERAL – where the appellant’s solicitors claimed care and consideration at 30 per cent – where insurer objected to the claim on the basis of heavy reliance on counsel and asserted care and consideration should be allowed at 25 per cent – where the costs assessor allowed 30 per cent for care and consideration – where insurer applied for a review of the costs assessor’s decision – where the primary judge considered the costs assessor’s reasons were inadequate and reduced amount of care and consideration to 25 per cent on the basis that 30 per cent was excessive – whether primary judge should have interfered with the exercise of discretion of costs assessor

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 423, r 702, r 722, r 742

Australian Coal and Shale Employees’ Federation v The Commonwealth (1953) 94 CLR 621; [1953] HCA 25

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read King v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCA 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of King v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the appellant was involved in a motor vehicle accident and subsequently settled a personal injuries proceeding with the insurer. The parties had agreed that the appellant’s costs and outlays would be assessed on the District Court scale. The appellant engaged a clinical anatomist to provide a medico-legal report for the trial, which the insurer objected to on the basis that it was not necessary or proper and overlapped with reports from other medical specialists. The costs assessor allowed the costs for the report, but the insurer applied for a review of this decision. The primary judge found no error in the costs assessor’s exercise of discretion but held that the report was inadmissible and the appellant was not entitled to the costs of the report. The insurer also objected to the amount of care and consideration claimed by the appellant’s solicitors, arguing that it should be reduced to 25 per cent due to the heavy reliance on counsel. The costs assessor allowed 30 per cent for care and consideration, and the insurer applied for a review of this decision. The primary judge considered the costs assessor’s reasons were inadequate and reduced the amount of care and consideration to 25 per cent on the basis that 30 per cent was excessive.

The primary legal issues the court was required to decide related to the appropriateness of the primary judge’s review of the costs assessor’s decision regarding the clinical anatomist’s report and the care and consideration allowance. The insurer argued that the primary judge should have interfered with the exercise of discretion of the costs assessor regarding the clinical anatomist’s report, as there was no error in the costs assessor’s exercise of discretion, and the relatively modest amount of costs associated with the objection did not warrant leave for reviewing this aspect of the costs assessor’s decision. The insurer further argued that the primary judge should have interfered with the exercise of discretion of the costs assessor regarding the care and consideration allowance, as the costs assessor’s reasons for allowing 30 per cent for care and consideration were inadequate, and the respondent submitted that there was not a corresponding reduction in the care and consideration item relative to the antecedent substantial allowance of the fees of counsel.

The court found that the ground on which the primary judge did base his decision was one for which he must have impliedly given leave under r 742(5). In view of the fact that it was not a ground raised by the respondent, the primary judge’s recognition that there was no error in the costs assessor’s exercise of discretion, and the relatively modest amount of costs associated with the objection, leave for reviewing this aspect of the costs assessor’s decision was not warranted. The application for reviewing this aspect of the decision should not have succeeded. Regarding the care and consideration allowance, the court found that the costs assessor had allowed or partially allowed the respondent’s objections to some items on the basis of excessive counsel’s fees or overuse of counsel, resulting in a small reduction in the overall fees allowed for counsel. The primary judge considered the costs assessor’s reasons were inadequate and reduced the amount of care and consideration to 25 per cent on the basis that 30 per cent was excessive. However, the court found that the primary judge should not have interfered with the exercise of discretion of the costs assessor regarding the care and consideration allowance, as the appellant submitted the competing arguments were before the costs assessor and resulted in a discretionary judgment in respect of which the respondent could show no error of principle.

ORDERS:
1. Appeal allowed with costs.
2. Set aside the orders at first instance.
3. Instead, the application for review is dismissed.
4. The respondent must refund to the appellant the amount paid by the appellant to the respondent consequential upon the orders at first instance.
5. The respondent must pay the appellant’s costs of the application for review assessed on the District Court scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders at first instance.

3. Instead, the application for review is dismissed.

4. The respondent must refund to the appellant the amount paid by the appellant to the respondent consequential upon the orders at first instance.

5. The respondent must pay the appellant’s costs of the application for review assessed on the District Court scale.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of King v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited arose from a motor vehicle accident where the appellant was injured. The personal injuries proceeding was settled, and the insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, agreed to pay the appellant's costs and outlays to be assessed on the District Court scale. The appellant had engaged a clinical anatomist to provide a medico-legal report for the trial. Allianz objected to the costs of the report on the grounds that it was not necessary or proper and overlapped with reports obtained from other medical specialists. The costs assessor allowed the costs for the report, which Allianz then challenged by applying for a review of the costs assessor's decision. The primary judge found no error in the costs assessor's exercise of discretion but held that the report was inadmissible, and the appellant was not entitled to the costs of the report.

Additionally, the appellant's solicitors claimed care and consideration at 30 per cent, which Allianz objected to on the basis that there was heavy reliance on counsel and that care and consideration should be allowed at 25 per cent. The costs assessor allowed 30 per cent for care and consideration, which Allianz also sought to review. The primary judge considered the costs assessor's reasons were inadequate and reduced the amount of care and consideration to 25 per cent, finding that 30 per cent was excessive.

This case involves a review of a costs assessor's decision in the context of a personal injury proceeding. Initially, the costs assessor allowed certain costs, including those for a clinical anatomist's report and for care and consideration by the appellant's solicitors. Allianz challenged these decisions by applying for a review under the relevant procedural rules. The primary judge heard the review application and made findings that the costs assessor's decision regarding the clinical anatomist's report should not have been disturbed but that the costs assessor's allowance for care and consideration was excessive. Consequently, the primary judge reduced the amount for care and consideration. Allianz appealed the primary judge's decision to the court, seeking to overturn the reduction in the care and consideration costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the review of the costs assessor's decision regarding the clinical anatomist's report should have succeeded.
2. Whether the primary judge should have interfered with the exercise of discretion of the costs assessor in reducing the amount for care and consideration.

Held
1. The court concluded that the review of the costs assessor's decision regarding the clinical anatomist's report should not have succeeded.
2. The court found that the primary judge should not have interfered with the exercise of discretion of the costs assessor in reducing the amount for care and consideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The ground on which the primary judge did base his decision was one for which he must have impliedly given leave under r 742(5). In view of the fact that it was not a ground raised by the respondent, the primary judge’s recognition that there was no error in the costs assessor’s exercise of discretion, and the relatively modest amount of costs associated with the Giles’ objection, leave for reviewing this aspect of the costs assessor’s decision was not warranted. The application for reviewing this aspect of the decision should not have succeeded.Care and consideration In the course of the assessment the costs assessor had allowed or partially allowed the respondent’s objections to some items on the basis of excessive counsel’s fees or overuse of counsel which resulted in a small reduction in the overall fees allowed for counsel. The respondent’s objection to the amount included in the costs statement in item 1694 for the solicitor’s care and conduct of the proceeding was relevantly in these terms:“It is submitted this item is excessive and should be reduced on the assessment of costs bearing in mind the heavy reliance upon Counsel and the items which have been reduced by the costs assessor on the assessment. This item should be reduced to 25% of allowable items.” The appellant’s response submitted that an allowance of 30 per cent for care and consideration was not excessive and was a proper cost, in reliance on Amos v Monsour Pty Ltd & Ors [2009] QCA 123 and ChongHerr Investments Ltd v Titan Sandstone Pty Ltd [2007] QCA 278. The costs assessor’s reasons for allowing care and consideration to be calculated at 30 per cent were:“After considering both the Defendant’s objection and the Plaintiff’s response I accept the Plaintiff’s response in preference to the objection.Taking into account all aspects of the matter, including the stage reached and overall work conducted by the Plaintiff’s solicitors, I consider the claim to be necessary, proper and reasonable in the circumstances. I also consider an allowance of 30% for care and conduct to be appropriate and a proper cost.The fee claimed was reduced in proportion to the deductions made to professional fees. 30% care and conduct allowed.” The respondent’s specific ground for objecting to the assessment in respect of care and consideration was set out in the application for review in terms that, notwithstanding the allowance of substantial additional items of costs occasioned by overuse of counsel, “there was not a corresponding reduction in the ‘care and consideration’ allowance which reduction would have offset the additional costs through ‘overuse’ of counsel”. The respondent submitted to the primary judge the discretion of the costs assessor miscarried in not making a significant reduction in the care and consideration item “relative to his antecedent substantial allowance of the fees of counsel”. It was also submitted the basis upon which an allowance of 30 per cent was considered appropriate and proper had not been stated. The appellant submitted the competing arguments were before the costs assessor and resulted in a discretionary judgment in respect of which the respondent could show no error of principle.