SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Emanuel Management Pty Ltd (in liquidation) & Ors v. Foster’s Brewing Group Ltd & Ors and Coopers & Lybrand & Ors [2003] QSC 299
PARTIES:
EMANUEL MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) AND ORS
(plaintiffs)
v.
FOSTER’S BREWING GROUP LTD AND ORS
(first group of defendants)
AND
COOPERS & LYBRAND AND ORS
(second group of defendants)FILE NO:
3723 of 1999
DIVISION:
Trial
PROCEEDING:
Application for costs
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court, Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
11 September 2003
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
25 August 2003
JUDGE:
Chesterman J
ORDER:
1. The plaintiffs pay the first group of defendants’ costs of and incidental to the proceedings (including the costs of and incidental to the third party claims brought by and against the second defendants in these proceedings, the costs of this application and all reserved costs) to be assessed on the indemnity basis, subject to paragraph 3 of this order.
2. Gordian Runoff Limited (ACN 052 179 647) pay the first defendants’ costs of and incidental to the proceedings (including the costs of and incidental to the third party claims brought by and against the second defendants, the costs of this application and all reserved costs) to be assessed on the indemnity basis, subject to paragraph 3 of this order.
3. The said costs are to be assessed on the basis that:
(a) all costs are to be allowed, except so far as they are of an unreasonable amount or were unreasonably incurred so that, subject to such exceptions, each of the first defendants will be completely indemnified for their costs.
(b) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first defendants’ rights for the first defendants to have retained the counsel whose appearance was announced (being Mr Keane QC, Mr Sheahan SC, Mr Bond SC, Mr McKenna, Mr Pomerenke and Mr Fox) for the conduct of these proceedings.
(c) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first Group of Defendants’ right for the First Group of Defendants to have engaged the expert witnesses called by them to given evidenced at the trial (being Professor Boymal, Mr Kendall, Mr Southwell and Mr Dover).
(d) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first defendants’ rights for the first defendants to have caused the documents relevant to these proceedings to be converted to an electronic format.
(e) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first defendants’ rights for the first defendants to have paid their share of the costs to e.Law as required by the court order dated 16 August 2002.
4. The plaintiffs and Gordian Runoff Limited pay interest, pursuant to the Supreme Court Act 1995 (Qld), on the costs that they have been ordered to pay, with interest at 10 per cent per annum to run from 17 July 2003.
5. The plaintiffs pay the second defendants’ costs:
(a) of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Emanuel Management Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Foster's Brewi... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] QSC 299
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the costs of the proceedings could be awarded on an indemnity basis, which goes beyond the usual "costs follow the event" principle, and whether a non-party's application for costs should be assessed under the indemnity basis. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the institution and prosecution of the action by the plaintiffs was unreasonable.
The court found that the institution and prosecution of the action was unreasonable, and therefore, the defendants were entitled to costs on an indemnity basis. The court ruled that it was necessary and proper for the defendants to have retained certain counsel and experts to enforce their rights. The court also determined that the non-party's application for costs should be heard by the trial judge, adhering to the principles set out in the case of Bahai v Rashidian. The court ordered that the plaintiffs and the non-party pay the defendants' costs, including interest at a rate of 10 per cent per annum from a specified date.
The court's orders included detailed provisions for the assessment of costs on an indemnity basis, specifying that all costs would be allowed except those that were unreasonable or unreasonably incurred. The orders also included specific directions regarding the payment of costs by the plaintiffs and the non-party, with interest accruing from a particular date. This decision provided clarity on the assessment of costs in cases where the institution and prosecution of the action are deemed unreasonable.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The plaintiffs pay the first group of defendants’ costs of and incidental to the proceedings (including the costs of and incidental to the third party claims brought by and against the second defendants in these proceedings, the costs of this application and all reserved costs) to be assessed on the indemnity basis, subject to paragraph 3 of this order.
2. Gordian Runoff Limited (ACN 052 179 647) pay the first defendants’ costs of and incidental to the proceedings (including the costs of and incidental to the third party claims brought by and against the second defendants, the costs of this application and all reserved costs) to be assessed on the indemnity basis, subject to paragraph 3 of this order.
3. The said costs are to be assessed on the basis that:
(a) all costs are to be allowed, except so far as they are of an unreasonable amount or were unreasonably incurred so that, subject to such exceptions, each of the first defendants will be completely indemnified for their costs.
(b) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first defendants’ rights for the first defendants to have retained the counsel whose appearance was announced (being Mr Keane QC, Mr Sheahan SC, Mr Bond SC, Mr McKenna, Mr Pomerenke and Mr Fox) for the conduct of these proceedings.
(c) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first Group of Defendants’ right for the First Group of Defendants to have engaged the expert witnesses called by them to given evidenced at the trial (being Professor Boymal, Mr Kendall, Mr Southwell and Mr Dover).
(d) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first defendants’ rights for the first defendants to have caused the documents relevant to these proceedings to be converted to an electronic format.
(e) it was necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the first defendants’ rights for the first defendants to have paid their share of the costs to e.Law as required by the court order dated 16 August 2002.
4. The plaintiffs and Gordian Runoff Limited pay interest, pursuant to the Supreme Court Act 1995 (Qld), on the costs that they have been ordered to pay, with interest at 10 per cent per annum to run from 17 July 2003.
5. The plaintiffs pay the second defendants’ costs:
(a) of defending the claim against the thirteenth defendant on an indemnity basis, and
(b) other than those referred to in paragraph 5(a), on a standard basis until 18 January 2003 and, thereafter, on an indemnity basis.
6. The plaintiffs pay the second defendants’ costs of the claim made by them for contribution against the first defendants and their costs of defending the cross-claim brought against them by the first defendants.
7. Gordian Runoff Limited (ABN 11 052 179 647) pay to the second defendants the costs ordered to be paid to them by the plaintiffs, being the second group of defendants’ costs:
(a) of defending the claim against the thirteenth defendant on an indemnity basis, and
(b) other than those referred to in paragraph 7(a), on a standard basis until 18 January 2003 and, thereafter, on an indemnity basis.
8. The assessment of the second defendants’ costs be made on the basis that except so far as they are of an unreasonable amount or were unreasonably incurred the following items are to be regarded as costs necessary and proper for the attainment of justice and for enforcing the second defendants’ rights:
(a) The fees of Mr B C Oslington QC
(b) The fees of Mr G A Thompson SC
(c) The fees of Mr L F Kelly
(d) The costs of the expert reports of Mr G Leppinus
(e) The costs of the expert report of Mr D Van Homrigh
(f) The costs of the expert report of Mr D Lombe
(g) The second defendants’ share of the costs paid to e.Law as required by the Court order dated 16 August 2002.
9. The plaintiffs and Gordian RunOff Limited pay interest, pursuant to the Supreme Court Act 1995, on the costs that they have been ordered to pay, with interest to run from 17 July 2003 at the rate of 10 per cent per annum.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi