SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Eaves v Dr Allan J. Bond & Associates Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] QSC 299
PARTIES:
KIRSTY LEE EAVES
(first plaintiff)
JAMES RICHARD HANNON
(second plaintiff)
v
DR ALLAN J. BOND & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD
ACN 092 748 319(defendant)
FILE NO/S:
BS 10444 of 2023
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Originating Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
2 December 2024
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
Heard on the papers. Plaintiffs’ submissions on costs filed on 15 November 2024. Defendant’s submissions on costs filed on 15 November 2024. Plaintiffs’ submissions in reply on costs filed on 20 November 2024.
JUDGE:
Cooper J
ORDER:
1. The defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to the proceeding (including any reserved costs) to be assessed on the standard basis.
2. The costs to be paid to the plaintiffs under order 1 are not to be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court.
3. Once the costs to be paid by the plaintiffs to the defendant pursuant to r 692(2) of the UCPR and claimed in the costs statement served by the defendant on 8 July 2024 have been assessed or agreed, those costs are to be set off against the costs payable by the defendant under order 1
CATCHWORDS:
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – OFFERS OF COMPROMISE, PAYMENTS INTO COURT AND SETTLEMENTS – OFFER OF COMPROMISE OR OFFER TO SETTLE OR CONSENT TO JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULES – WHAT CONSTITUTES VALID OFFER – where the plaintiffs’ claim succeeded at trial and the defendant’s counterclaim was dismissed – where the plaintiffs made an offer pursuant to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 and pursuant to the principles in Calderbank v Calderbank to settle the proceedings on 17 June 2024 that was rejected by the defendant – where the plaintiffs submit that pursuant to r 360 the defendant should pay their costs on the standard basis from 17 June 2024 and on the indemnity basis from 18 June 2024 – where the defendant submits that the plaintiffs’ offer did not engage r 360 because, inter alia, it was subject to a “suitably worded” deed of settlement, the terms of which were not disclosed in the offer – where the defendant made an offer pursuant to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 and the principles in Calderbank on 26 July 2024 which the plaintiffs rejected – where the defendant submits that pursuant to r 361 the defendant should pay the plaintiffs’ costs on the standard basis up to and including 26 July 2024 and that the plaintiffs should pay the defendant’s costs on the indemnity basis from 27 July 2024 – where the plaintiffs submit that the defendant’s offer did not engage r 361 because, inter alia, the defendant had not established that the judgment was less favourable to the plaintiffs than the offer – whether the offer made by either party was an…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Eaves v Dr Allan J. Bond & Associates Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QSC 299
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the nature of the offers made by both parties. The plaintiff made an offer on 17 June 2024, which the defendant rejected. Subsequently, the defendant made an offer on 26 July 2024, which the plaintiff also rejected. The plaintiff argued that the defendant should pay their costs on the standard basis from 17 June 2024 and on the indemnity basis from 18 June 2024. The defendant countered that the plaintiff's offer was not valid under rule 36.0 of the UCPR because it was contingent on the terms of a deed of settlement that were not disclosed. The defendant also argued that they should pay the plaintiff's costs on the standard basis up to 26 July 2024 and that the plaintiff should pay the defendant's costs on the indemnity basis from 27 July 2024. The plaintiff contended that the defendant's offer was not valid because the defendant had not shown that the judgment was less favourable than the offer. The court had to determine whether either offer qualified as a valid offer to settle and whether the refusal of these offers was unreasonable.
In its decision, the court found that neither party's offer qualified as a valid offer under rule 36.0 of the UCPR. The court ruled that the plaintiff's offer was not valid because it was conditional on undisclosed terms, and the defendant's offer did not demonstrate that the judgment was less favourable than the offer. Consequently, neither party was entitled to indemnity costs. The court held that the plaintiff's offer did not meet the criteria for a valid offer to settle because it was subject to undisclosed conditions. Similarly, the defendant's offer did not establish that the judgment was less favourable to the plaintiff than the offer. The court concluded that both parties had acted reasonably in rejecting the other party's offer, and thus the general rule that costs on the standard basis should follow the event applied. The court further ordered that the costs should not be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court.
The court's final orders were that the defendant should pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the proceeding on the standard basis. The court specified that these costs should not be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court. Additionally, once the costs claimed by the defendant and served on 8 July 2024 were assessed or agreed, they were to be set off against the costs payable by the defendant to the plaintiff.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to the proceeding (including any reserved costs) to be assessed on the standard basis.
2. The costs to be paid to the plaintiffs under order 1 are not to be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court.
3. Once the costs to be paid by the plaintiffs to the defendant pursuant to r 692(2) of the UCPR and claimed in the costs statement served by the defendant on 8 July 2024 have been assessed or agreed, those costs are to be set off against the costs payable by the defendant under order 1
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court for the assessment of costs following the trial of the proceedings. The plaintiffs and the defendants each made offers to settle the proceedings under the UCPR and the principles in Calderbank. These offers were rejected by the opposing party. The plaintiffs sought costs on the standard and indemnity basis from the date of their offer, while the defendants sought costs on the standard basis up to the date of their offer and indemnity basis thereafter. The court needed to determine whether either offer was a valid compromise offer under the UCPR and, if so, whether either party acted unreasonably in rejecting the other's offer. The court also needed to consider whether the costs should be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the offer made by the plaintiffs on 17 June 2024 was a valid offer to settle for the purposes of the UCPR.
2. Whether the offer made by the defendants on 26 July 2024 was a valid offer to settle for the purposes of the UCPR.
3. Whether either party acted unreasonably in rejecting the other party’s offer.
4. Whether either party established a basis for departing from the general rule that costs on the standard basis should follow the event.
5. Whether, otherwise, the costs should be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court.
Held
1. The court held that the offer made by the plaintiffs on 17 June 2024 was not a valid offer to settle for the purposes of the UCPR.
2. The court held that the offer made by the defendants on 26 July 2024 was not a valid offer to settle for the purposes of the UCPR.
3. The court found that neither party acted unreasonably in rejecting the other party's offer.
4. The court held that neither party established a basis for departing from the general rule that costs on the standard basis should follow the event.
5. The court held that the costs should not be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the validity of the offers made by both parties under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) and the principles in Calderbank v Calderbank. The plaintiffs' offer on 17 June 2024 was rejected by the defendants who argued that the offer did not engage rule 360 because it was subject to a "suitably worded" deed of settlement, the terms of which were not disclosed in the offer. The court agreed with the defendants that the offer did not constitute a valid offer to settle for the purposes of the UCPR, as it was conditional and lacked specificity regarding the settlement terms. Similarly, the defendants' offer on 26 July 2024 was rejected by the plaintiffs who argued that it did not engage rule 361 because the defendants had not established that the judgment was less favourable to the plaintiffs than the offer. The court found that the defendants' offer also failed to meet the criteria for a valid offer to settle under the UCPR, as it did not provide a clear and unequivocal proposal for settlement.
Regarding the reasonableness of the refusals, the court concluded that neither party acted unreasonably in rejecting the other's offer. The plaintiffs' offer was conditional and lacked specificity, and the defendants' offer also failed to meet the necessary criteria for a valid offer. The court further held that neither party established a basis for departing from the general rule that costs on the standard basis should follow the event, as neither offer was valid. Consequently, the court assessed the costs of the proceeding on the standard basis, with the defendant paying the plaintiffs' costs. The court also ruled that the costs should not be assessed as if the proceeding had been started in the District Court, as the relief obtained by the plaintiffs was within the jurisdiction of the Local Court. The court's decision focused on the proper application of the UCPR and the principles of Calderbank, ensuring that the procedural requirements for valid offers to settle were strictly adhered to.