Wagners Cement Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wagners Cement Pty Ltd & Anor v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited & Anor [2021] QCA 79

PARTIES:

WAGNERS CEMENT PTY LTD
ACN 126 029 481
(first appellant)
WAGNERS QUEENSLAND PTY LTD
ACN 122 170 745
(second appellant)
v

BORAL RESOURCES (QLD) PTY LIMITED
ACN 009 671 809
(first respondent)
BORAL LIMITED
ACN 008 421 761
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 7375 of 2020
SC No 4294 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal – Further Orders

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2020] QSC 124; [2020] QSC 163 (Bond J)

DELIVERED ON:

23 April 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Heard on the papers

JUDGES:

Fraser and Philippides JJA and Crow J

ORDERS:

1.   The appeal and cross appeal are allowed to the extent provided in orders 2 and 3.

2.   Orders numbered 2 to 7 and 10 made in the Trial Division on 10 June 2020 be set aside.

3.   In addition to the orders numbered 1, 8 and 9 made in the Trial Division on 10 June 2020:

(a)   It is declared that the notice of 18 March 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was not valid or effective as a notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement electing to suspend supply as at 18 March 2019.

(b)  It is declared that the notice of 1 April 2019 from the First Respondent to the First Appellant was a valid and effective Pricing Notice under clause 7.2 of the Agreement.

(c)   It is declared that the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was a valid and effective notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.

(d)  It is declared that, pursuant to clauses 7.4 and 7.5 of the Agreement, the effect of the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was that the supply of Products under the Agreement was suspended for six months, from 1 May 2019.

(e)   It is declared that, for the purposes of clauses 3.4 and 3.5 of the Agreement, the period which should be treated as an Affected Period is the period commencing on 1 May 2019 and ending on 22 October 2019.

4.   The First Respondent pay the First Appellant the sum of $4,671,683.83 in respect of the Agreement Year ending 30 June 2019, plus interest in the amount of $169,499.56 pursuant to the Agreement.

5.   The appeal and cross appeal are otherwise dismissed.

6.   The Respondents pay 60 per cent of the Appellant’s costs of the proceeding in the Trial Division.

7.   The Respondents pay 60 per cent of the Appellant’s costs of the appeal.

8.   The parties’ written submissions and any further affidavit material filed after the delivery of judgment of the Court of Appeal on 15 December 2020 be placed on the Court file in a sealed envelope marked “Confidential – Not to be opened without further Court order.”

9.   Copies of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wagners Cement Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCA 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wagners Cement Pty Ltd appealed against a decision of the Trial Division of the Supreme Court of Queensland and Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited cross-appealed. The primary issue for determination was whether the first respondent was required to pay the first appellant the sum of $4,671,683.83 for the Agreement Year ending 30 June 2019, plus interest, in accordance with the terms of an agreement between the parties. A further issue was whether the first respondent’s notice of 18 March 2019 was a valid notice electing to suspend supply under the agreement, and whether the first appellant’s notice of 1 April 2019 was a valid pricing notice under the agreement. An additional issue was the amount of costs to be awarded in the proceeding.

The Court allowed the appeal and cross-appeal to the extent provided in orders 2 and 3. It set aside orders 2 to 7 and 10 made by the Trial Division on 10 June 2020 and declared that the notice of 18 March 2019 from the first appellant to the first respondent was not valid or effective as a notice under clause 7.4 of the agreement electing to suspend supply. It also declared that the notice of 1 April 2019 from the first respondent to the first appellant was a valid and effective pricing notice under clause 7.2 of the agreement. The Court further declared that the notice of 1 May 2019 from the first appellant to the first respondent was a valid and effective notice under clause 7.4 of the agreement and that, pursuant to clauses 7.4 and 7.5 of the agreement, the effect of that notice was that the supply of products under the agreement was suspended for six months, from 1 May 2019. It also declared that, for the purposes of clauses 3.4 and 3.5 of the agreement, the period which should be treated as an affected period was the period commencing on 1 May 2019 and ending on 22 October 2019. The Court ordered that the first respondent pay the first appellant the sum of $4,671,683.83 in respect of the agreement year ending 30 June 2019, plus interest, in accordance with the agreement. The appeal and cross-appeal were otherwise dismissed. The Court also ordered that the respondents pay 60 per cent of the appellants’ costs of the proceeding in the Trial Division and 60 per cent of the appellants’ costs of the appeal.

The Court ordered that the parties’ written submissions and any further affidavit material filed after the delivery of judgment of the Court of Appeal on 15 December 2020 be placed on the Court file in a sealed envelope marked “Confidential – Not to be opened without further Court order.” Copies of the written submissions and affidavit material, from which confidential information had been redacted, were to be placed on the Court file and made publicly available.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal and cross appeal are allowed to the extent provided in orders 2 and 3.

2. Orders numbered 2 to 7 and 10 made in the Trial Division on 10 June 2020 be set aside.

3. In addition to the orders numbered 1, 8 and 9 made in the Trial Division on 10 June 2020:

(a) It is declared that the notice of 18 March 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was not valid or effective as a notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement electing to suspend supply as at 18 March 2019.

(b) It is declared that the notice of 1 April 2019 from the First Respondent to the First Appellant was a valid and effective Pricing Notice under clause 7.2 of the Agreement.

(c) It is declared that the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was a valid and effective notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.

(d) It is declared that, pursuant to clauses 7.4 and 7.5 of the Agreement, the effect of the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was that the supply of Products under the Agreement was suspended for six months, from 1 May 2019.

(e) It is declared that, for the purposes of clauses 3.4 and 3.5 of the Agreement, the period which should be treated as an Affected Period is the period commencing on 1 May 2019 and ending on 22 October 2019.

4. The First Respondent pay the First Appellant the sum of $4,671,683.83 in respect of the Agreement Year ending 30 June 2019, plus interest in the amount of $169,499.56 pursuant to the Agreement.

5. The appeal and cross appeal are otherwise dismissed.

6. The Respondents pay 60 per cent of the Appellant’s costs of the proceeding in the Trial Division.

7. The Respondents pay 60 per cent of the Appellant’s costs of the appeal.

8. The parties’ written submissions and any further affidavit material filed after the delivery of judgment of the Court of Appeal on 15 December 2020 be placed on the Court file in a sealed envelope marked “Confidential – Not to be opened without further Court order.”

9. Copies of the written submissions and affidavit material referred to in paragraph 8 above, from which confidential information has been redacted be placed on the Court file and made publicly available.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Wagners Cement Pty Ltd (the appellant) and Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited (the respondents) regarding a contract for the supply of cement products. The dispute arose from a series of notices and communications between the parties in 2019. On 18 March 2019, Wagners Cement attempted to suspend the supply of products under the agreement, but this was not effective. On 1 April 2019, Boral Resources issued a valid Pricing Notice under the agreement. On 1 May 2019, Wagners Cement issued a notice to suspend supply, which was effective, leading to a suspension of supply from 1 May 2019 for six months. The dispute included questions about the validity of the notices and the interpretation of the contract clauses, as well as financial claims related to the supply agreement.

The matter initially came before the Trial Division of the court on 10 June 2020, where several orders were made. Wagners Cement appealed certain aspects of these orders, and Boral Resources filed a cross-appeal. The Court of Appeal heard both the appeal and cross-appeal, and subsequently gave leave to the parties to make submissions about the appropriate orders to give effect to the Court’s reasons. The parties presented differing views on the financial judgment and the allocation of costs. The Court of Appeal then considered the submissions and issued its decision on 15 December 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the notice of 18 March 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was valid or effective as a notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.
2. Whether the notice of 1 April 2019 from the First Respondent to the First Appellant was a valid and effective Pricing Notice under clause 7.2 of the Agreement.
3. Whether the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was a valid and effective notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.
4. Whether the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent effectively suspended supply under clauses 7.4 and 7.5 of the Agreement.
5. Whether the period which should be treated as an Affected Period is the period commencing on 1 May 2019 and ending on 22 October 2019.
6. What monetary sum, if any, the First Respondent should pay the First Appellant in respect of the Agreement Year ending 30 June 2019.
7. What order should be made in respect of the costs of the proceeding in the Trial Division and the appeal.

Held
1. The appeal and cross appeal are allowed to the extent provided in orders 2 and 3.
2. Orders numbered 2 to 7 and 10 made in the Trial Division on 10 June 2020 be set aside.
3. It is declared that the notice of 18 March 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was not valid or effective as a notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.
4. It is declared that the notice of 1 April 2019 from the First Respondent to the First Appellant was a valid and effective Pricing Notice under clause 7.2 of the Agreement.
5. It is declared that the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was a valid and effective notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.
6. It is declared that, pursuant to clauses 7.4 and 7.5 of the Agreement, the effect of the notice of 1 May 2019 from the First Appellant to the First Respondent was that the supply of Products under the Agreement was suspended for six months, from 1 May 2019.
7. It is declared that, for the purposes of clauses 3.4 and 3.5 of the Agreement, the period which should be treated as an Affected Period is the period commencing on 1 May 2019 and ending on 22 October 2019.
8. The First Respondent pay the First Appellant the sum of $4,671,683.83 in respect of the Agreement Year ending 30 June 2019, plus interest in the amount of $169,499.56 pursuant to the Agreement.
9. The appeal and cross appeal are otherwise dismissed.
10. The Respondents pay 60 per cent of the Appellant’s costs of the proceeding in the Trial Division.
11. The Respondents pay 60 per cent of the Appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed several issues regarding the validity and effect of notices exchanged between the parties and the financial obligations arising from the Agreement. The court set aside certain orders made in the Trial Division and made new declarations regarding the notices and their effects. The court also addressed the financial obligations of the First Respondent to the First Appellant, ordering payment of a specified sum plus interest. Regarding costs, the court exercised its discretion under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) and ordered the Respondents to pay 60 per cent of the Appellants’ costs of the proceeding in the Trial Division and the appeal. The court considered the submissions from both parties on the appropriate orders for costs and monetary judgments, applying the principles of fairness and the relevant statutory provisions to reach its decision. The court's approach to determining the costs order was a balanced exercise of discretion, taking into account the parties' respective degrees of success and the overall conduct of the proceedings.