Wagners Cement Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wagners Cement Pty Ltd & Anor v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited & Anor [2020] QCA 289

PARTIES:

WAGNERS CEMENT PTY LTD
ACN 126 029 481
(first appellant)
WAGNERS QUEENSLAND PTY LTD
ACN 122 170 745
(second appellant)
v

BORAL RESOURCES (QLD) PTY LIMITED
ACN 009 671 809
(first respondent)
BORAL LIMITED
ACN 008 421 761
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 7375 of 2020
SC No 4294 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2020] QSC 124; [2020] QSC 163 (Bond J)

DELIVERED ON:

15 December 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

22 October 2020

JUDGES:

Fraser and Philippides JJA and Crow J

ORDER:

In default of agreement between the appellants and the respondents upon the orders (including declarations, monetary orders, and orders about costs) that are appropriate to give effect to the Court’s reasons, the appellants and the respondents have leave to lodge and serve a submission in writing upon that topic, any such submission not to exceed 10 pages (in addition to any draft order annexed to the submission) and to be made within 10 business days of this order unless the Registrar otherwise directs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS – where the parties entered into a long term contract under which the first appellant (“the Supplier”) agreed to supply cement products to the first respondent (“the Purchaser”) – where the contract contained a price adjustment mechanism which allowed the Purchaser to serve a notice on the Supplier containing market pricing evidence – where such a notice would have the effect of reducing the price of products under the contract unless the Supplier elected to suspend supply for six months – where the Purchaser served a notice containing market pricing evidence that consisted of a quotation for supply commencing at a future date, rather than at the date of the notice – whether this was a valid and effective pricing notice under the clause

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS – where, in response to the purported pricing notice served by the Purchaser, the Supplier gave the Purchaser a notice stating that the notice was invalid and referring the matter to the dispute resolution process under the contract – where this notice also stated that if, as the Purchaser contended, the notice was valid, the Supplier elected to suspend supply under the contract – whether the Supplier waived any invalidity in the Purchaser’s notice by its notice electing to suspend supply – whether the Supplier’s notice was effective to suspend supply under the contract

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS – where the price adjustment clause provided that if, during a suspension period, the Purchaser ceased to be able to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wagners Cement Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCA 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Wagners Cement Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Limited, the dispute centred around the interpretation and application of a long-term supply contract, specifically the price adjustment mechanism outlined in Clause 7. The Supplier, Wagners Cement, contested the validity and effectiveness of various notices served by the Purchaser, Boral Resources, under Clause 7.2, which permitted the Purchaser to adjust prices based on market pricing evidence.

The primary legal issues involved the interpretation of Clause 7.2, whether the Supplier's response to an allegedly invalid notice constituted a waiver, the interpretation of Clause 7.6 regarding the resumption of supply during a suspension period, and whether the Purchaser could serve a pricing notice during a suspension period. The court had to determine if the Purchaser's notices were valid under Clause 7.2, if the Supplier's response effectively suspended supply, and whether the Purchaser could resume procurement at a different price during a suspension period.

The court concluded that the Purchaser's notice dated 1 April 2019 was a valid Pricing Notice under Clause 7.2. The court found that the Supplier's notice dated 1 May 2019 was a valid notice electing to suspend supply under Clause 7.4. The court further ruled that the Supplier's notice did not result in an Affected Period as described in Clause 3.4. Additionally, the Purchaser's notice dated 2 October 2019 was held to be a valid Pricing Notice under Clause 7.2.

The court allowed the appeal and cross-appeal, setting aside certain orders made in the Trial Division. The court ordered declarations regarding the invalidity of the 18 March 2019 notice, the validity of the 1 April 2019 and 1 May 2019 notices, and the suspension period commencing 1 May 2019. It also directed that the parties submit written submissions regarding the appropriate orders, including declarations and costs, within 10 business days unless otherwise directed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

In default of agreement between the appellants and the respondents upon the orders (including declarations, monetary orders, and orders about costs) that are appropriate to give effect to the Court’s reasons, the appellants and the respondents have leave to lodge and serve a submission in writing upon that topic, any such submission not to exceed 10 pages (in addition to any draft order annexed to the submission) and to be made within 10 business days of this order unless the Registrar otherwise directs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Clause 7 provided:“7.1For the purposes of this clause 7 Market Pricing Evidence means:(1)a bona fide offer or quotation by another supplier (excluding any supplier in which any Related Body Corporate of the Purchaser holds a material shareholding), which provides for:(a) the supply of the relevant type of Product ex-plant in South East Queensland or the Darling Downs region; and(b) supply for a period of at least 6 months; and(c) supply of an aggregate volume of at least 10,000 tonnes per month (on average); and(d) confirmation that the supplier has been supplying cement in South East Queensland or the Darling Downs for at least 3 months; or(2)any other evidence reasonably acceptable to the Supplier of the price at which the relevant type of Product can be purchased from another supplier (excluding any supplier in which any Related Body Corporate of the Purchaser holds a material shareholding) on the basis set out in (a), (b) and (c) above and confirmation that the supplier has been operating for at least 3 months,(and for the purposes of this clause 7.1 it is acknowledged that at the date of this Agreement a Related Body Corporate of the Purchaser holds a material shareholding in Sunstate Cement Ltd).7.2If at any time and from time to time the Purchaser gives notice to the Supplier (a Pricing Notice) setting out Market Pricing Evidence in respect of any type of Product which provides for a price for that type of Product (per tonne and excluding GST) which is lower than the then prevailing price under this Agreement, then subject to clause 7.4 the price for that type of Product under this Agreement will from the date of the Pricing Notice be reduced to the price specified in the relevant Market Pricing Evidence.7.3If the price of any type of Product is reduced under clause 7.2, the Purchaser may not give a further Pricing Notice under clause 7.2 seeking a further adjustment to the price of that type of Product for at least 6 months after the date of the relevant Pricing Notice.7.4If the Supplier is unwilling to supply any type of Product at the price specified in a Pricing Notice, it may by notice to the Purchaser within 20 Business Days after the date of the Pricing Notice elect to suspend supply of Products (but if the Supplier does not elect to suspend within that 20 Business Days’ period the price reduction will take effect in accordance with clause 7.2).7.5If the Supplier elects to suspend supply of Products under clause 7.4, then:(1)the suspension will last from the date of the election until the earliest of:(a) the date 6 months after the date of the election;(b) if the parties agree a mutually acceptable price, the date the parties agree to resume supply; and(c) if clause 7.6 applies, the Purchaser becomes obliged to resume purchasing Products from the Supplier,the duration of the suspension being the Suspension Period;(2)during the Suspension Period, the Supplier will have no obligation to supply Products, and the Purchaser will have no obligation to purchase Products; and(3)any period during an Agreement Year falling within the Suspension Period will be treated as an ‘Affected Period’ for the purposes of clause 3.4 (and clause 3.5 will also apply accordingly), and the Minimum Quantity in respect of the relevant Agreement Year will be adjusted down accordingly; and(4)at the end of the Suspension Period, the Supplier will recommence supply of the Products to the Purchaser at the prevailing List Prices applying under clause 6 of this Agreement, subject to the Purchaser’s right to provide further Pricing Notices in accordance with clause 7.2.7.6Where the supply of Products has been suspended in accordance with clause 7.4, the Purchaser must resume purchasing Products from the Supplier if it ceases to be able to (or for any reason chooses not to) procure supply from a third party supplier (excluding any supplier in which any Related Body Corporate of the Purchaser holds a material shareholding) at the price specified in the Pricing Notice giving rise to the suspension.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

I would hold that the Purchaser’s October notice was effective as a Pricing Notice under cl 7.2.Summary of conclusions and disposition In summary, my conclusions upon the issues agitated in the appeal and cross appeal are as follows:(a)The Purchaser’s notice dated 1 March 2019 was not a Pricing Notice under cl 7.2, the Supplier’s related notice dated 18 March 2019 was not a notice electing to suspend supply under cl 7.4, and the Supplier’s notice did not result in any period being an Affected Period described in cl 3.4.(b)The Purchaser’s notice dated 1 April 2019 was a Pricing Notice under cl 7.2, the Supplier’s related notice dated 1 May 2019 was a notice electing to suspend supply under cl 7.4, that notice created a Suspension Period from 1 May 2019 under cl 7.5, and that Suspension Period was not brought to an end under cl 7.6.(c)The Purchaser’s Notice dated 2 October 2019 was a Pricing Notice under cl 7.2. The following orders appear to be appropriate (subject to considering further submissions lodged by the parties in accordance with the order I propose below):1.Allow the appeal and the cross appeal.2.Set aside the orders numbered 2 to 7 made in the Trial Division on 4 June 2020.3.In addition to the orders numbered 1, 8 and 9 made in the Trial Division on 4 June 2020, order that:a.It is declared that the notice of 18 March 2019 from the first plaintiff to the first defendant was not valid or effective as a notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement electing to suspend supply as at 18 March 2019.b.It is declared that the notice of 1 April 2019 from the first defendant to the first plaintiff was a valid and effective Pricing Notice under clause 7.2 of the Agreement.c.It is declared that the notice of 1 May 2019 from the first plaintiff to the first defendant was a valid and effective notice under clause 7.4 of the Agreement.d.It is declared that, pursuant to clauses 7.4 and 7.5 of the Agreement, the effect of the notice of 1 May 2019 from the first plaintiff to the first defendant was that the supply of Products under the Agreement was suspended for six months from 1 May 2019.e.It is declared that, for the purposes of clauses 3.4 and 3.5 of the Agreement, the period which should be treated as an Affected Period is the period commencing on 1 May 2019 and ending on 22 October 2019.[40][40]It appears from the parties’ submissions that supply under the Agreement resumed from 22 October 2019. At the hearing of the appeal counsel indicated that they expected to be able to reach agreement about the orders required to give effect to the Court’s reasons. It is appropriate also to allow the parties an opportunity to make submissions about the appropriate costs orders.Proposed order I propose the order that, in default of agreement between the appellants and the respondents upon the orders (including declarations, monetary orders, and orders about costs) that are appropriate to give effect to the Court’s reasons, the appellants and the respondents have leave to lodge and serve a submission in writing upon that topic, any such submission not to exceed 10 pages (in addition to any draft order annexed to the submission) and to be made within 10 business days of this order unless the Registrar otherwise directs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established