NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 204

PARTIES:

NIGHTOWL PROPERTIES PTY LTD

(plaintiff)

v
REPLAY AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 8260 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

30 September 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

16 June and 4 July 2022

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

The Court declares that:

1.   The plaintiff validly exercised the option in cl 7.2 of registered lease No 715779923, as amended by registered amendment No 716557560, (the “Lease”) for the grant of a further lease of the premises the subject of the Lease (the “Option”), by written notice to the defendant on 22 January 2020; and

2.   The covenant by the defendant to grant to the plaintiff a further lease of those premises, in cl 7.2(B) of the Lease, ought to be specifically performed.

The order of the Court is that:

3.   The plaintiff is relieved from the forfeiture of the Option by reason of its failure to punctually pay to the defendant the rent reserved by the Lease, without any deduction whatsoever and without prior demand, in April, May, June, July and August 2020.

4.   The defendant specifically perform the covenant in cl 7.2(B) of the Lease by granting to the plaintiff a further lease of the premises for the period from 14 October 2020 to 13 October 2025 upon the same terms as are contained in the Lease, with the necessary changes, except that:

(a)     cl 7.2 of the Lease is to be omitted;

(b) the Base Rent is to be determined under the provisions contained in cl 18.2(A), and the Appendix, of the Lease; and

(c)     any other alterations and additions which the defendant may reasonably require.

Each party has liberty to apply on not less than three business days’ notice in writing to the other party.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RENEWALS AND OPTIONS – EXERCISE OF OPTION – WHERE LESSEE IN BREACH OF COVENANT – where the lease was for a term of ten years, commencing 14 October 2010 and expiring on 13 October 2020 – where the tenant gave notice of exercise of the option in January 2020 - where the tenant failed to pay part of the rent due in April, May, June and July 2020 – where the tenant paid rent reduced in accordance with turnover during the COVID-19 pandemic – where the landlord later served an notice to remedy the breach – where the tenant remedied the breach by payment of outstanding rent - where the tenant asserts that the landlord had waived the breach - where, in the alternative, the tenant seeks relief against forfeiture of the option under s 124(2) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) or as an equitable remedy – where the landlord asserts it was not obliged to grant a new lease as the tenant was in breach at the expiry of the lease - where the landlord denies waiver…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd commenced proceedings against Replay Australia Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Queensland, seeking a declaration that it had validly exercised an option to renew a lease, and specific performance of the covenant to grant a new lease. The dispute arose from a lease that was originally for a term of ten years, commencing on 14 October 2010 and expiring on 13 October 2020. The lease contained an option to renew the lease for a further five years, exercisable within six months of the expiration of the initial term. The tenant, NightOwl, gave notice of exercise of the option in January 2020. However, it failed to pay part of the rent due in April, May, June and July 2020. During the COVID-19 pandemic, NightOwl paid reduced rent in accordance with its turnover. The landlord, Replay, later served a notice to remedy the breach, which NightOwl remedied by payment of outstanding rent. The landlord denied waiver of the breach and relief under s 124(2) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), and asserted that it was not obliged to grant a new lease as the tenant was in breach at the expiry of the lease. The court was required to decide whether the tenant validly exercised the option to renew the lease, whether the tenant should have equitable relief against forfeiture of the option, and whether the covenant to grant a new lease ought to be specifically performed.

The court found that Replay had not waived the breaches by NightOwl. It rejected Replay’s argument that relief under s 124(2) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) was not available because the option was not a lease within the meaning of the statute. The court rejected Replay’s argument that the court is unable to grant equitable relief against the forfeiture of an option in a registered lease where the circumstances would otherwise make relief appropriate. The court found that NightOwl had a right to a rent reduction due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and that Replay did not seem to have formed a definitive view that NightOwl had no entitlement to pay reduced rent until about 9 December 2020. In the circumstances, the court found that NightOwl’s breach was not wilful or grave, and that it was proper in a legal sense.

The court declared that NightOwl validly exercised the option in cl 7.2 of the lease for the grant of a further lease of the premises, and that the covenant to grant to NightOwl a further lease of the premises ought to be specifically performed. The court ordered that NightOwl be relieved from the forfeiture of the option by reason of its failure to punctually pay to Replay the rent reserved by the lease, and that Replay specifically perform the covenant by granting to NightOwl a further lease of the premises for the period from 14 October 2020 to 13 October 2025 upon the same terms as are contained in the lease, with the necessary changes. Each party has liberty to apply on not less than three business days’ notice in writing to the other party.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Court declares that:

1. The plaintiff validly exercised the option in cl 7.2 of registered lease No 715779923, as amended by registered amendment No 716557560, (the “Lease”) for the grant of a further lease of the premises the subject of the Lease (the “Option”), by written notice to the defendant on 22 January 2020; and

2. The covenant by the defendant to grant to the plaintiff a further lease of those premises, in cl 7.2(B) of the Lease, ought to be specifically performed.

The order of the Court is that:

3. The plaintiff is relieved from the forfeiture of the Option by reason of its failure to punctually pay to the defendant the rent reserved by the Lease, without any deduction whatsoever and without prior demand, in April, May, June, July and August 2020.

4. The defendant specifically perform the covenant in cl 7.2(B) of the Lease by granting to the plaintiff a further lease of the premises for the period from 14 October 2020 to 13 October 2025 upon the same terms as are contained in the Lease, with the necessary changes, except that:

(a) cl 7.2 of the Lease is to be omitted;

(b) the Base Rent is to be determined under the provisions contained in cl 18.2(A), and the Appendix, of the Lease; and

(c) any other alterations and additions which the defendant may reasonably require.

Each party has liberty to apply on not less than three business days’ notice in writing to the other party.

Background

Background to the litigation

NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd, the tenant, had a lease for premises with Replay Australia Pty Ltd, the landlord, that began on 14 October 2010 and expired on 13 October 2020. The lease contained an option for NightOwl to renew the lease for another five years, exercisable by giving written notice to Replay by 10 December 2020. NightOwl gave notice of exercising the option on 22 January 2020. However, NightOwl failed to pay the full rent due for April, May, June, and July 2020. During the COVID-19 pandemic, NightOwl paid a reduced rent in line with the reduction in turnover. Replay did not object to these reduced payments until 9 December 2020, when it served a notice to remedy the breach of the rent covenant. NightOwl subsequently paid the outstanding rent and argued that Replay had waived the breaches. Replay denied this and argued that NightOwl was not entitled to a new lease due to the breaches and the failure to comply with the lease provisions. NightOwl sought relief against forfeiture of the option under s 124(2) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) or as an equitable remedy.

The matter came before the court for a final hearing. This was not the first instance of the matter being heard; it followed a series of events where NightOwl exercised the option to renew the lease, failed to pay full rent, and later paid the outstanding rent. Replay had issued a notice to remedy the breach, and NightOwl sought to argue waiver and equitable relief against forfeiture. Prior to this hearing, there were no significant procedural steps or rulings that are directly relevant to the final hearing beyond the basic procedural path of a final determination on the merits of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The receipt by Replay of the post-10 December 2020 rent was a waiver by Replay of the right to re-enter in reliance on NightOwl’s earlier failure to pay the rent in full. It was not conduct inconsistent with Replay having a right to rely on the earlier breach by NightOwl as a basis to refuse to grant a new lease. Conclusion on waiver By the conduct identified in NightOwl’s pleading and submissions, Replay did not waive the breaches by NightOwl. Nor did it waive the benefit of the conditions in cl 7.2(A)(c) and (d) of the Lease. Relief under s 124(2) of the Property Law Act NightOwl seeks relief against the forfeiture under s 124(2) of the PLA. It provides: “Where a lessor is proceeding by action or otherwise to enforce such a right of re-entry or forfeiture, or has re-entered without action the lessee may, in the lessor’s action (if any) or in proceedings instituted by the lessee, apply to the court for relief, and the court, having regard to the proceedings and conduct of the parties under subsection (1), and to all the other circumstances, may grant or refuse relief, as it thinks fit, and in case of relief may grant the same on such terms (if any) as to costs, expenses, damages, compensation, penalty or otherwise, including the granting of an injunction to restrain any like breach in the future, as the court in the circumstances of each case thinks fit.” A lessor’s right of re-entry or forfeiture, which can be the subject of relief under s 124(2), is a right “under any proviso or stipulation in a lease, for a breach of any covenant, obligation, condition or agreement (express or implied) in the lease”.[16] [16]s 124(1). By s 123, “lease” is defined as including: “an original or derivative under-lease, also a grant at a fee farm rent, or securing a rent by condition, and an agreement for a lease where the lessee has become entitled to have the lease granted”. Replay submits relief is not available to NightOwl under s 124(2). Replay is not proceeding by action or otherwise to enforce any right of re-entry or forfeiture under the Lease. Replay has not re-entered. The option for a new lease in cl 7.2 is not a lease. It is merely a provision in the Lease. The option provision is not an agreement for a lease where NightOwl “has become entitled to have the lease granted”. On this basis, the option is not a “lease” within the meaning in s 124(2). NightOwl sought to meet these submissions by proving that it had exercised the option, and that the option “progressed to the point of being an unconditional agreement to lease.” This part of NightOwl’s case depended on the court accepting that Replay had waived what Replay had called the “post-option breaches” that comprised unremedied breaches and a failure to strictly comply with the provisions of the Lease between 7 April 2020 and 13 October 2020. As NightOwl’s waiver submissions have been rejected, this part of its case must also fail. Characterisation of the option provision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I reject Replay’s submission that the court is unable to grant equitable relief against the forfeiture of an option in a registered lease where the circumstances would otherwise make relief appropriate. As Lord Wilberforce put it:‘‘The word ‘appropriate’ involves consideration of the conduct of the applicant for relief, in particular whether his default was wilful, of the gravity of the breaches, and of the disparity between the value of the property of which forfeiture is claimed as compared with the damage caused by the breach.’’[39][39]Shiloh Spinners Ltd v Harding [1973] AC 691, 722-724.Consideration of whether to grant equitable relief NightOwl was a long-standing tenant of Replay. It had held a leasehold estate in the land since 14 October 2010. The loss of a right to be granted a new lease for the first option period would occasion also the loss of a right to be granted a new lease for the second option period. Replay had not executed the original lease instrument until about three years and four months after the tenancy began. By cl 7.2(C), Replay was responsible for preparing the new lease and delivering it to NightOwl for execution. In the circumstances, Replay’s failure to proffer a new lease by 9 December 2020 did not signal any refusal to grant a new lease for the first option period. At all times after 22 January 2020, Replay knew that NightOwl was proceeding on the basis that it had exercised the option and was entitled to a lease for a further five years and to the second option for another five year term. On giving notice of exercise of the option, NightOwl preserved (or created) certain equitable rights in respect of the option. Replay was completely silent until 22 October 2020. Replay’s response that its solicitor would “be in contact with you soon” proved to be quite untrue. There was no response until 9 December 2020. So, Replay’s discourtesy was succeeded by, at best, careless deception. NightOwl had asserted a right to a rent reduction due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Replay accepted that during the peak of the pandemic restrictions NightOwl had paid a reduced rent “in line with the reduction of turnover.” The period has been described as a once in a century public health crisis.[40] The prevailing circumstances of the pandemic, the economic impact resulting from statutory regulations restricting travel, work and social contact, and the speed with which such regulations were introduced and changed, would have created uncertainty for the parties as to their respective obligations. Replay does not seem to have formed a definitive view that NightOwl had no entitlement to pay reduced rent until about 9 December 2020. In the circumstances, I would not characterise NightOwl’s breach as a wilful forfeiture,[41] a wilful or grave breach,[42] or find it was improper in a legal sense.[43] [40]Sneakerboy Retail Pty Ltd v Georges Properties Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 996, [66] (Robb J).[41]Thomas v Porter (1668) 1 Chan Cas 95 (Bridgeman LK). [42]Shiloh Spinners v Harding [1973] AC 691, 723-724 (Lord Wilberforce).[43]Dering v Earl of Winchelsea (1787) 1 Cox 318 (Eyre CB).