Replay Australia Pty Ltd v NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Replay Australia Pty Ltd v NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd [2023] QCA 76

PARTIES:

REPLAY AUSTRALIA PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE UNDER INSTRUMENT 707248123
ACN 088 310 785
(appellant)
v
NIGHTOWL PROPERTIES PTY LTD
ACN 126 734 549
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 13117 of 2022
Appeal No 16181 of 2022
SC No 8260 of 2021

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2022] QSC 204 (Bradley J)

DELIVERED ON:

24 April 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 April 2023

JUDGES:

Dalton and Flanagan JJA and Gotterson AJA

ORDERS:

1.   The appeal be allowed.

2.   The respondent’s claim be dismissed.

3.   The order for costs made in the proceeding below against the appellant be set aside.

4.   The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the proceeding below and of the appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RENEWALS AND OPTIONS – EXERCISE OF OPTION – RIGHT TO EXERCISE OPTION – WHERE LESSEE IN BREACH OF COVENANT – where the lessee gave notice of exercise of an option for renewal but did not subsequently satisfy other conditions for the exercise of the option because it was in arrears of rent – where the lease then expired – where the lessee did not validly exercise the option for renewal – where no obligation arose for the lessor to grant a further lease – where the lessee’s interest arising from the option was commensurate with the availability of specific performance – whether the lessee had, after the expiry of the lease, an interest in the leased premises arising from the option for renewal – whether equitable relief against forfeiture was available to the lessee in respect of the option

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RENEWALS AND OPTIONS – NATURE OF AN OPTION – where the lessee argued that the giving of notice of exercise of the option for renewal created an interest in the leased premises which entitled it to seek equitable relief against forfeiture of the option – where the lessee argued that the option for renewal was a conditional contract – where the lessor argued that, regardless of the option’s legal characterisation, the lessee’s failure to satisfy the conditions for its exercise precluded the right to a further lease from arising – whether equitable relief against forfeiture was available to the lessee in respect of the option

Australian Aggregates (NSW) Pty Ltd v Maxmin Pty Ltd, unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Hodgson J 17 September 1996, approved
Carter Holt Harvey Woodproducts Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (2019) 268 CLR 524; [2019] HCA 20, cited
Grepo & Anor v Jam-Cal Bundaberg Pty Ltd[2015] QCA 131, followed
Hill v Terry [1993] 2 Qd R 640; [1990] QSCFC 96, cited
Mercantile Credits Ltd v Shell Co of Australia (1976) 136 CLR 326; [1976] HCA 9, applied
Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104; [2015] HCA 37, cited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Replay Australia Pty Ltd v NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCA 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Replay Australia Pty Ltd v NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd, the Queensland Court of Appeal considered the nature of an option for lease renewal and the circumstances in which a lessee may seek equitable relief against forfeiture of an option for lease renewal. NightOwl, the lessee, had given notice of exercising an option for renewal under a lease that had expired. Replay, the lessor, refused to grant a further lease, asserting that NightOwl had not satisfied the conditions for exercising the option due to arrears in rent and breaches of the lease. The primary issue was whether NightOwl had an interest in the premises arising from the option for renewal and whether it was entitled to equitable relief against forfeiture. The Court of Appeal found that NightOwl did not have a valid interest in the premises arising from the option for renewal as it had not satisfied the conditions precedent for exercising the option. The court held that the giving of notice of exercise of the option did not create an interest in the premises or a contract for a further lease. Instead, the option for renewal was a conditional contract that required strict compliance with the conditions set out in the lease. The failure to satisfy these conditions precluded any right to a further lease from arising. The court also found that equitable relief against forfeiture was not available to NightOwl because there was no unconscientious conduct by Replay and the loss of the equitable interest did not involve a lesser proprietary interest than the leasehold to which it was attached. The appeal was allowed, and the respondent's claim was dismissed. The costs orders made in the proceeding below were set aside, and the respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the proceeding below and of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The respondent’s claim be dismissed.

3. The order for costs made in the proceeding below against the appellant be set aside.

4. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the proceeding below and of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue arises in the context of the following relevant background.Relevant background At the time the proceeding was commenced, Replay was the named lessor in a lease dated 14 February 2014, which had expired. NightOwl was the named lessee. The lease was for 10 years, commencing on 14 October 2010 and expiring on 13 October 2020. By the lease, Replay granted NightOwl a leasehold estate over ground floor premises at 132 Albert Street, Brisbane. NightOwl covenanted that it would punctually and regularly pay to Replay “the rent … reserved by the lease, without any deduction whatsoever and without prior demand, calendar monthly in advance” during the term and afterwards so long as it occupied the premises.[1][1]Clause 1.2 of the Lease. On 12 June 2015 the lease was amended. By the amendment, the parties relevantly inserted a new cl 7.2 which provided for a “first option for renewal”.[2][2]There were some other amendments, including the insertion of a new cl 7.3 which provided for a “second option for renewal” in terms materially the same as cl 7.2. Both the lease and the amendment were registered over the title to the land. It is convenient to refer to the registered lease as amended by the registered amendment as the Lease. Clause 7.2 of the Lease relevantly provides:“7.2 FIRST OPTION FOR RENEWAL7.2(A)Conditions of Exercise of First OptionIf the Lessee desires a further lease of the Demised Premises for the First Option Term, clause 7.2(B) and 7.2(C) shall apply if:(a) the Lessee gives written notice of exercise of option to the Lessor during the Option Exercise Period;(b) this Lease has not been terminated or surrendered;(c) there is not at the time of giving the notice under clause 7.2(A)(a) or thereafter prior to the Expiry Date any unremedied beach of the provisions of the Lease on the Lessee’s part which has not been waived by the Lessor; and(d) the Lessee has at all times during the term strictly observed and performed the provisions of the Lease on the Lessee’s part.7.2(B)Grant of First Option TermSubject to clauses 7.2(A) and 7.2(E) the Lessor shall grant to the Lessee and the Lessee shall accept from the Lessor a further lease of the Demised Premises for the First Option Term upon the same terms, with the necessary changes, as are contained in this Lease except for:(a) this clause 7.2 which shall be omitted;(b) the Base Rent payable during the First Option Term which shall be determined under the provisions contained in clause 18.2(A) and the Appendix; and(c) any other alterations and additions which the Lessor may reasonably require.7.2(C)Execution of Lease for First OptionIf the Lease for the First Option Term is granted the Lessee shall execute and deliver to the Lessor or the Lessor’s solicitors a new lease … within 20 Business Days of the delivery of such lease … by the Lessor or the Lessor’s solicitors to the Lessee or the Lessee’s solicitors. Such lease … shall be prepared, stamped and (…) registered by the Lessor’s solicitors at the cost of the Lessee. If the Base Rent for the First Option Term has not been determined by the commencement date of the First Option Term the Lessee shall pending such determination and the execution of the lease … be bound by the terms of the lease for the First Option Term on the Lessee’s part. Subject to the provisions contained in clause 18.2(A) and the Appendix, if the Base Rent for the First Option Term has not been determined by the commencement date of the First Option Term then pending such determination the Lessee shall pay Base Rent at the rate payable as at the Expiry Date. Upon such determination the Lessor and the Lessee shall promptly make any necessary adjustment.…7.2(E)Guarantee and Indemnity for First Option If a person has guaranteed the Lessee’s performance of the provisions of the Lease … If the Lessee does not procure the execution of such guarantee and indemnity the notice given under clause 7.2(A)(a) shall, at the election of the Lessor, be of no effect. In the event of such election the Lessee shall not be entitled to any lease for the First Option Term.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

At trial, NightOwl sought both a declaration that it had validly exercised the first option for renewal and an order for specific performance of the Lease. Further or in the alternative, it sought relief against forfeiture under s 124(2) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) (PLA) or as an equitable remedy. Replay’s position was that the Lease had expired in circumstances where it was not obliged to grant a further lease because NightOwl was in breach of the conditions in cl 7.2(A)(c) and (d). NightOwl asserted that Replay had waived the breaches with respect to those conditions.The decision below NightOwl was successful at trial on the issue of the court’s jurisdiction to grant equitable relief against forfeiture. The trial judge made the following findings which are not challenged on appeal:(a)The Lease expired on 13 October 2020.[8](b)At the expiry of the Lease, NightOwl was in breach of cl 1.2 of the Lease by having failed to pay rent in the sum of $57,821.52.[9](c)As a result, NightOwl did not satisfy the condition in cl 7.2(A)(c) for the exercise of the option, namely the requirement that there be no unremedied breach of the Lease which had not been waived by Replay.[10](d)By the same conduct, NightOwl also did not satisfy the condition in cl 7.2(A)(d) for the exercise of the option, namely the requirement that the Lease provisions had been strictly observed and performed at all times during the term.[11](e)Replay had not waived NightOwl’s failure to satisfy the conditions in cl 7.2(A)(c) and (d) for the granting of a further lease.[12](f)Replay was not re-entering; it was relying on NightOwl’s failure to satisfy cl 7.2(A) as a basis to refuse to grant a further lease, and there was no inconsistent conduct in taking the rent and relying on the non-satisfaction for that purpose.[13](g)There was no unconditional agreement to lease.[14](h)There was no unconscientious conduct on Replay’s part.[15][8]Reasons, [33].[9]Reasons, [51].[10]Reasons, [63]-[64].[11]Reasons, [68].[12]Reasons, [87].[13]Reasons, [84]-[86].[14]Reasons, [92].[15]Reasons, [122]. On the issue of waiver by Replay of NightOwl’s breaches, the trial judge considered Replay’s conduct, including:(a)receiving, without substantive comment or demur, the correspondence sent by NightOwl on 22 October 2020, 17 November 2020 and 30 November 2020;(b)serving the notice to remedy breach on 9 December 2020;(c)receiving and accepting the $57,821.52 paid in response to that notice; and(d)receiving and accepting rent paid by NightOwl since 10 December 2020. None of that conduct was held to be inconsistent with Replay having a right to rely on NightOwl’s failure to satisfy cl 7.2(A) as a basis for avoiding the obligation in cl 7.2(B) to grant a further lease. The trial judge also held that relief against forfeiture pursuant to s 124(2) of the PLA was not available to NightOwl because the option in cl 7.2 was not a “lease” within the meaning of s 123.[16][16]Reasons, [91]-[92]. This left NightOwl with its claim for equitable relief against forfeiture of the option. In finding that the discretion to grant such relief did arise, the trial judge reasoned as follows:(a)NightOwl was a leaseholder with an equitable interest in the land arising from its option for renewal and attached to its leasehold estate.[17](b)NightOwl’s right of renewal ran with the land and the reversion and was so intimately connected with the leasehold that it should be regarded as part of the estate or interest acquired under the Lease, so as to obtain similar protection upon registration as the term itself.[18](c)The loss of contractual rights under a lease was no bar to the availability of equitable relief against forfeiture of an estate or interest in property.[19](d)The loss of the equitable interest conveyed by the option for renewal would involve a lesser proprietary interest than the leasehold to which it was attached, but nevertheless an interest capable of yielding an equivalent leasehold estate.[20](e)The Court was able to grant equitable relief against the loss of a proprietary interest arising from an option for renewal contained in a registered lease.[21][17]Reasons, [112].[18]Reasons, [102], relying on the reasoning of Gibbs J in Mercantile Credits Ltd v Shell Co of Australia (1976) 136 CLR 326, 344-345.[19]Reasons, [104].[20]Reasons, [126].[21]Reasons, [112]-[113].This appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the nature and terms of the option for renewal as stipulated in the lease agreement. It found that the lessee had given notice of exercising the option for renewal but had not satisfied other conditions necessary for the exercise of the option, such as not being in arrears of rent. The court concluded that since the lessee did not validly exercise the option for renewal, no obligation arose for the lessor to grant a further lease. The court determined that the lessee's interest arising from the option was commensurate with the availability of specific performance, but since the lessee did not meet the conditions for exercising the option, no such interest existed post-expiry of the lease.

On the issue of equitable relief against forfeiture, the court examined whether the option for renewal constituted a conditional contract or a proprietary interest that entitled the lessee to seek equitable relief. The court noted that regardless of the option's legal characterisation, the lessee's failure to satisfy the conditions for its exercise precluded the right to a further lease from arising. The court further found that equitable relief was not available because the option for renewal was not a "lease" within the meaning of the Property Law Act, and thus did not fall under the provisions allowing relief against forfeiture. The court relied on the principle that the loss of contractual rights under a lease does not bar the availability of equitable relief against forfeiture of an estate or interest in property. However, in this case, the specific conditions of the option and the failure to meet them precluded the lessee from claiming equitable relief.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a lessee must satisfy all conditions for exercising an option for renewal in order to have an interest in the leased premises after the expiry of the lease, and that equitable relief against forfeiture is not available if the option is not a "lease" within the meaning of the Property Law Act and the lessee fails to meet the conditions for exercising the option. The court's decision also underscores that the failure to satisfy the conditions for exercising an option for renewal precludes the lessee from claiming equitable relief against forfeiture, regardless of the option's characterisation as a conditional contract or a proprietary interest.