Caloundra City Council v Minister for Natural Resources

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

No. 6395 of 1998
Brisbane

Before Justice Wilson

[Caloundra City Council v Minister for Natural Resources & Ors]

BETWEEN:

THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CALOUNDRA

Applicant

AND:

THE MINISTER FOR NATURAL RESOURCES

First Respondent

AND:

ROBERT LACK

Second Respondent

AND:

PIPI HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Third Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WILSON J

Judgment delivered 6 August 1999

Further order delivered 12 August 1999

  1. The applicant has succeeded in obtaining an order that the decision under review be quashed. 

  2. The hearing was completed in one day. The evidence was all on affidavit, and there was no cross-examination. Counsel made written submissions to which they spoke. 

  3. The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules provide:-

    “General rule about costs

    689 (1) Costs of a proceeding are in the discretion of the court but follow the event, unless the court considers another order is more appropriate. 

    (2) Subrule (1) applies unless these rules otherwise provide.”

    and

    “Costs of question or part of proceeding

    682 (1) The court may make an order for costs in relation to a particular question in, or a particular part of, a proceeding.

    (2)  For subrule (1), the court may declare what percentage of the costs

    of the proceeding is attributable to the question or part of the proceeding to which

    the order relates.”

    These rules reflect the general law on costs which was summarized by Toohey J. in Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association (Inc.) (1986) A.T.P.R. 40-748 at 48,136 as follows:-

    “1.       Ordinarily, costs follow the event and a successful litigant receives his costs in the absence of special circumstances justifying some other order. Ritter v. Godfrey (1920) 2 K.B. 47.

    2.        Where a litigant has succeeded only upon a portion of his claim, the circumstances may make it reasonable that he bear the expense of litigating that portion upon which he has failed. Forster v. Farquhar (1893) 1 Q.B. 564.

    3.        A successful party who has failed on certain issues may not only be deprived of the costs of those issues but may be ordered as well to pay the other party’s costs of them. In this sense, “issue” does not mean a precise issue in the technical pleading sense but any disputed question of fact or of law. Cretazzo v. Lombardi (1975) 13 S.A.S.R. 4 at p.12.”

  4. In argument the majority of the time was occupied with the issue which prompted the first and second respondents to make the decision which I have quashed (that is, the issue of whether there had been a properly constituted objection hearing). The parties did address the issue on which the decision ultimately turned (that is, whether the Minister ought to have transmitted the  application to the Governor in Council) in written and oral submissions -

    Applicant:                     written submissions - paras. 40-42; oral submissions pages 19-21

    First and Second       written submissions - paras. 15-20; oral submissions pages 54-56

    Respondents:

    Third Respondent:     oral submissions pages 40-44.

  5. It was submitted by the respondents that in view…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caloundra City Council v Minister for Natural Resources and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QSC 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of Queensland presided over a case between the Council of the City of Caloundra and several respondents, including the Minister for Natural Resources, Robert Lack, and Pipi Holdings Pty Ltd. The Council sought an order to quash a decision made by the respondents, focusing on whether there had been a properly constituted objection hearing and if the Minister should have transmitted the application to the Governor in Council. The case was heard over a single day, with all evidence presented through affidavits and no cross-examination. The primary legal issue revolved around the discretionary nature of costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and the general law, particularly whether the applicant should bear the costs of the proceedings due to their partial success. The court referenced the general principle that costs typically follow the event, but also acknowledged that exceptions could be made based on the circumstances.

The court's reasoning emphasized that while the applicant succeeded in having the decision quashed, the issue prompting this success was not the ultimate deciding factor. Instead, the key issue was whether the Minister should have forwarded the application to the Governor in Council. Given that each party contributed to the situation, the court determined it inappropriate to allocate costs on an issues basis. The court concluded that, in all circumstances, no order should be made regarding costs. The decision underscored the principle that while the applicant achieved a significant outcome, the court could not predict the future decisions of the Governor in Council, making the applicant's success somewhat uncertain.

The court's judgment delivered on 6 August 1999, with a further order on 12 August 1999, resulted in the decision under review being quashed. The court found that neither party should bear the costs of the proceedings due to their shared responsibility for the situation. This decision aligns with the general rule that costs follow the event, but also reflects the discretionary nature of such orders, particularly in cases where the success of a party is partial or uncertain. The court's decision not to allocate costs on an issues basis highlights the complexity and shared responsibility in the circumstances of this case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established