Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association (inc)

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Re: KIMBERLEY JOHN HUGHES
And: WESTERN AUSTRALIAN CRICKET ASSOCIATION (INC.) and MT. LAWLEY DISTRICT
CRICKET CLUB (INC.); MELVILLE CRICKET CLUB (INC.); NORTH PERTH CRICKET CLUB
(INC.); SUBIACO FLOREAT CRICKET CLUB (INC.); BAYSWATER-MORLEY CRICKET CLUB
(INC.); PERTH CRICKET CLUB (INC.); FREMANTLE DISTRICT CRICKET CLUB (INC.);
CLAREMONT-COTTESLOE CRICKET CLUB (INC.); SOUTH PERTH CRICKET CLUB (INC.);
MIDLAND-GUILDFORD CRICKET CLUB (INC.); WANNEROO DISTRICT CRICKET CLUB (INC.)
and LESLIE ANNISON (sued on behalf of himself and all other members of the
Southern District Cricket Club); GREGORY BUNNEY (sued on behalf of himself and
all other members of the Scarborough Cricket Club); MICHAEL SNELL (sued on
behalf of himself and all other members of the Nedlands Cricket Club); PHILLIP
CLIFFORD (sued on behalf of himself and all other members of the University
Cricket Club) and KEVIN MORRIS TAYLFORTH (sued on behalf of himself and all
other members of the Cricket Council of Western Australia Australian Cricket
Association (Inc.)
No. WA G14 of 1986
Trade Practices

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Toohey J.
CATCHWORDS

Trade Practices - application under s.82 of Trade Practices Act and accrued jurisdiction - alleged contravention by respondents of s.45 of the Act - first and second respondents incorporated under Associations Incorporation Act - whether trading corporations in terms of s.4(1) of Trade Practices Act - summary of relevant principles - whether jurisdiction of the Court conditional upon existence of a trading corporation - disqualification of applicant from district cricket consequent upon applicant's participation in South African cricket tour - applicant disqualified pursuant to amended Cricket Council rule - no provision in original rule for disqualification for breach of rule - rule amended by resolution at Cricket Council meeting - Council's understanding of operation of original rule in relation to South African cricketers the subject of a resolution at an earlier meeting - whether conduct of Council members at relevant meetings constituted a contract arrangement or understanding in terms of s.45 of the Act - resolution to amend found to amount to an understanding between first, second and third respondents - whether understanding contained an exclusionary provision in terms of ss.45 and 4D of the Act - meaning of 'purpose' in s.4D - competition between second and third respondents for services of cricketers - whether second and third respondents 'competitive with each other' in terms of s.4D - disqualification provision directed inter alia at applicant and other 'rebel cricketers' - whether 'particular persons' in terms of s.4D - exclusion of South African cricketers from district cricket competition as a result of rule - whether likely effect thereof to substantially lessen competition in terms of s.45 - meaning of 'substantial lessening of competition' - consideration of relevant markets - decision by Cricket Council to reject motion for reinstatement of applicant - whether decision constitutes giving effect to an exclusionary provision or a provision likely to substantially lessen competition in terms of s.45 - contravention of s.45 by first respondent - whether second and third respondents involved…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association (inc) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1986] FCA 465
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association involved a dispute between cricketer Rodney Hughes and the Western Australian Cricket Association (WACA) over Hughes' disqualification from participating in district cricket due to his involvement in a cricket tour in South Africa. The dispute was brought before the Federal Court of Australia, which had jurisdiction under the Trade Practices Act 1974. Hughes sought to challenge the legality of his disqualification under sections 45 and 4D of the Trade Practices Act, which prohibit anti-competitive practices and exclusionary provisions, respectively.

The primary legal issues the court had to resolve were whether the respondents, including WACA and the Australian Cricket Board, were trading corporations under the Trade Practices Act, and if so, whether their conduct amounted to a contravention of sections 45 and 4D. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the Cricket Council's amendment to the rule disqualifying Hughes and other 'rebel cricketers' constituted an exclusionary provision or a practice likely to substantially lessen competition. Additionally, the court examined whether the disqualification was a restraint of trade, a breach of Hughes' right to work, or contrary to the Equal Opportunity Act.

The court found that the respondents were indeed trading corporations, and their conduct contravened sections 45 and 4D of the Trade Practices Act. The amendment to the Cricket Council rule was deemed to contain an exclusionary provision, as it effectively barred Hughes and other South African cricketers from participating in district cricket. The court held that this exclusion was likely to substantially lessen competition, as it disadvantaged certain cricketers and limited their employment opportunities within the cricket industry. Furthermore, the court determined that the disqualification was an unreasonable restraint of trade and that Hughes' right to work was breached due to the Council's failure to properly consider his application for consent to play in South Africa.

The court found that the disqualification of Hughes from district cricket was in breach of an implied term in a settlement deed between the parties, which aimed to protect Hughes' rights to participate in cricket. The court also rejected the notion that the disqualification was due to bad faith, bias, or political reasons. Ultimately, the court awarded Hughes damages for the loss of income and other consequential losses resulting from his disqualification.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the applicant, Hughes, who was disqualified from participating in district cricket by the second respondent, the Western Australian Cricket Association, following his participation in a cricket tour in South Africa. The disqualification was pursuant to an amended rule of the Cricket Council, which was not originally intended to include such a disqualification. The rule was amended by a resolution at a Cricket Council meeting, where it was understood that South African cricketers would be disqualified. The disqualification provision was intended to target the applicant and other 'rebel cricketers' and was found to amount to an understanding between the first, second, and third respondents. The Cricket Council subsequently rejected a motion to reinstate the applicant. The applicant alleged that the respondents conspired to injure or punish him by disqualifying him from the district competition, and that his disqualification was contrary to the Equal Opportunity Act. The applicant also claimed that the disqualification was in breach of an express or implied term of a deed in settlement of litigation concerning the effect of the South African tour on his participation in test and interstate cricket.

The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, which had jurisdiction to hear the matter under section 82 of the Trade Practices Act. The matter was brought before the court as an application for relief under the Act, and the court was required to determine whether the respondents had contravened section 45 of the Act. The court considered the relevant principles of law and the conduct of the respondents at the relevant meetings to determine whether there was an understanding or contract arrangement between the respondents that amounted to an exclusionary provision or a provision likely to substantially lessen competition. The court also considered the impact of the disqualification provision on the applicant and whether it constituted an unreasonable restraint of trade or a breach of the applicant's alleged right to work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the conduct of the Council members at the relevant meetings constituted a contract arrangement or understanding in terms of s.45 of the Trade Practices Act.
2. Whether the understanding contained an exclusionary provision in terms of ss.45 and 4D of the Act.
3. Whether the second and third respondents were 'competitive with each other' in terms of s.4D of the Act.
4. Whether the disqualification provision directed inter alia at the applicant and other'rebel cricketers' was a provision likely to substantially lessen competition in terms of s.45 of the Act.
5. Whether the contravention of s.45 by the first respondent involved the second and third respondents in terms of s.75B of the Act.
6. Whether the disqualification provision was an unreasonable restraint of trade or a breach of the applicant's alleged right to work.
7. Whether the failure by the Council to give any or proper consideration to the applicant's application for consent to participate in unrecognised matches amounted to a decision to disqualify ultra vires.
8. Whether the disqualification of the applicant from grade cricket was in breach of an express or implied term of a deed in settlement of litigation concerning the effect of the South African tour on his participation in test and interstate cricket.
9. What relief is appropriate for the applicant and what is the measure of damages.

Held
1. The court held that the conduct of the Council members at the relevant meetings constituted a contract arrangement or understanding within the terms of s.45 of the Trade Practices Act.
2. The understanding contained an exclusionary provision in terms of ss.45 and 4D of the Act.
3. The second and third respondents were found to be 'competitive with each other' in terms of s.4D of the Act.
4. The disqualification provision directed inter alia at the applicant and other 'rebel cricketers' was not a provision likely to substantially lessen competition in terms of s.45 of the Act.
5. The contravention of s.45 by the first respondent did not involve the second and third respondents in terms of s.75B of the Act.
6. The disqualification provision was not considered an unreasonable restraint of trade or a breach of the applicant's alleged right to work.
7. The failure by the Council to give any or proper consideration to the applicant's application for consent to participate in unrecognised matches did not amount to a decision to disqualify ultra vires.
8. The disqualification of the applicant from grade cricket was not in breach of an express or implied term of a deed in settlement of litigation concerning the effect of the South African tour on his participation in test and interstate cricket.
9. The appropriate relief for the applicant and the measure of damages were determined to be as follows.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the conduct of the Council members at the relevant meetings and determined that their conduct constituted a contract arrangement or understanding within the meaning of s.45 of the Trade Practices Act. The court found that the resolution to amend the Cricket Council rule, which resulted in the applicant's disqualification, amounted to an understanding between the first, second, and third respondents. The court also concluded that this understanding contained an exclusionary provision in terms of ss.45 and 4D of the Act. Regarding the meaning of 'purpose' in s.4D, the court considered the competition between the second and third respondents for the services of cricketers and found that they were indeed 'competitive with each other'. The court further held that the disqualification provision, which was directed at the applicant and other'rebel cricketers', was not likely to substantially lessen competition in terms of s.45 of the Act. The court found that the contravention of s.45 by the first respondent did not involve the second and third respondents in terms of s.75B of the Act. The disqualification provision was not considered an unreasonable restraint of trade or a breach of the applicant's alleged right to work. The court also held that the failure by the Council to give any or proper consideration to the applicant's application for consent to participate in unrecognised matches did not amount to a decision to disqualify ultra vires. Furthermore, the disqualification of the applicant from grade cricket was not in breach of an express or implied term of a deed in settlement of litigation concerning the effect of the South African tour on his participation in test and interstate cricket. The court determined the appropriate relief for the applicant and the measure of damages based on the findings and legal principles applied.