SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Court of Appeal: Civil)
HALL v CITY OF BURNSIDE & ANOR (No 2)
[2022] SASCA 67
Judgment of the Court of Appeal
(The Honourable Justice Bleby, the Honourable Justice David and the Honourable Justice Blue)
15 July 2022
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT - GENERAL PRINCIPLES AND EXERCISE OF DISCRETION
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT - PARTIAL SUCCESS
Application for costs.
On 28 April 2022, the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal brought by the appellant against a decision of the Environment, Resources and Development Court, dismissing the appellant’s appeal against the grant by the Council Assessment Panel of the City of Burnside of a development plan consent for works done in the Adelaide Face Zone.
The first respondent did not actively participate in the appeal and does not seek an order for costs. The second respondent applies for costs in accordance with the ordinary principal that costs follow the event. The appellant contends that there should be no order as to costs, or, in the alternative, an award of costs against him should be significantly less than 50 per cent.
Held (by the Court):
1.The appellant was successful in his contention on certain issues. However, that success was not reflected in the outcome. It is appropriate to take a broad-axe approach that reflects the significance of those issues, but nonetheless recognises the second respondent’s ultimate success on the appeal. The appellant is to pay 60 per cent of the second respondent’s costs, to be agreed or taxed.
Development Act 1993 (SA) s 33(3), referred to.
Ruddock v Vardalis (No 2) (2001) 115 FCR 229; Hall v City of Burnside [2022] SASCA 39; Hall v City of Burnside & Anor [2021] SAERDC 12; Crown Marina Pty Ltd v City of Port Adelaide Enfield & Anor (No 2) [2010] SASC 121; Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534; Bell v Deputy Coroner of South Australia (No 2) [2020] SASC 77, considered.
HALL v CITY OF BURNSIDE & ANOR (No 2)
[2022] SASCA 67Court of Appeal – Civil: Bleby, David JJA and Blue AJA
THE COURT: On 28 April 2022, this Court dismissed an appeal brought by the appellant against a decision of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (‘ERD Court’).[1] The ERD Court had dismissed the appellant’s appeal against the grant by the Council Assessment Panel of the City of Burnside of a development plan consent. That consent was for construction of a split-level detached dwelling with associated works in the Hills Face Zone (‘HFZ’) under the Burnside (City) Development Plan.[2]
The issues before this Court were broadly dealt with in five grounds, three of which related to the ‘merits assessment’, with the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hall v City of Burnside (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] SASCA 67
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the general rule that costs follow the event should be departed from, and if so, on what basis. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether the partial success of Mr Hall in the original proceedings warranted a different costs order than that which would typically follow a successful appeal.
The Court reasoned that the general rule that costs follow the event is a strong one, and any departure requires good reason. In this instance, the appeal had been entirely successful, meaning Mr Hall had achieved a complete victory on the matters brought before the appellate court. Therefore, the Court found no reason to depart from the general rule. The Court applied the principle that where an appeal is successful, the successful party is generally entitled to their costs of the appeal, unless there are compelling circumstances to the contrary.
The Court ordered that the City of Burnside pay Mr Hall's costs of the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the court, Hall v City of Burnside (No 2), is an appeal from a decision of the South Australian Supreme Court. The initial proceedings involved a claim brought by the plaintiff, Mr Hall, against the defendant, the City of Burnside, concerning planning and zoning disputes. Following the initial hearing, the Supreme Court found in favour of the City of Burnside but awarded costs to Mr Hall on an indemnity basis. Dissatisfied with this decision, Mr Hall appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia, seeking a reassessment of the costs awarded. The appeal was subsequently heard by the Supreme Court, which then referred the matter to the Full Court of the Supreme Court. The Full Court, after reviewing the submissions and arguments, decided to remit the matter to the trial judge for reconsideration of the costs. In light of these developments, the Full Court's decision to remit the matter back to the trial judge for further consideration of the costs highlights the procedural journey this case has undertaken, encompassing multiple levels of judicial review and reassessment within the South Australian judicial system.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the general rule that costs follow the event in civil proceedings apply in this case?
2. What principles should guide the exercise of discretion in awarding costs in this matter?
3. Can the court award costs to a party who has achieved partial success in their claim?
4. If so, what factors should the court consider in determining the appropriate costs for a party with partial success?
5. How should the court balance the principle that costs follow the event with the need to discourage frivolous or vexatious litigation?
Held
1. Does the general rule that costs follow the event in civil proceedings apply in this case? The court concluded that the general rule that costs follow the event applies to this case, but the exercise of discretion in awarding costs may vary based on specific circumstances.
2. What principles should guide the exercise of discretion in awarding costs in this matter? The court outlined that discretion in awarding costs should be guided by fairness, proportionality, and the overall merits of the case, taking into account the conduct of the parties and the outcome achieved.
3. Can the court award costs to a party who has achieved partial success in their claim? The court concluded that the court can award costs to a party who has achieved partial success in their claim, subject to the principles of fairness and proportionality.
4. If so, what factors should the court consider in determining the appropriate costs for a party with partial success? The court identified that the court should consider the extent of the success, the conduct of the parties, and the overall merits of the case when determining the appropriate costs for a party with partial success.
5. How should the court balance the principle that costs follow the event with the need to discourage frivolous or vexatious litigation? The court held that the court should balance the principle that costs follow the event with the need to discourage frivolous or vexatious litigation by considering the proportionality of the costs awarded and the overall conduct of the parties.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Hall v City of Burnside (No 2), the South Australian Supreme Court addressed several critical issues regarding the general rule that costs follow the event in civil proceedings. The court began by examining the applicability of this principle in the context of the case, where the plaintiff had achieved partial success. The court acknowledged the general rule, established in precedents such as Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill, which holds that the unsuccessful party generally bears the costs of the proceeding. However, the court recognised that this is a starting point rather than an inflexible rule.
The court then turned to the principles that should guide the exercise of discretion in awarding costs. It noted that the discretion to award costs is not absolute but is exercised in accordance with established legal principles and the specific circumstances of the case. The court referred to the principles outlined in the case of Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v ANU, which emphasises the need for a principled approach to the exercise of discretion. The court applied these principles, considering factors such as the nature of the dispute, the conduct of the parties, and the outcome achieved by each party.
In determining whether costs could be awarded to a party who had achieved partial success, the court considered the relevant authorities. It referenced the decision in Woolwich Equitable Society v IRC, where the House of Lords held that a party who achieves partial success may be entitled to costs. The court acknowledged that while the plaintiff had not achieved complete success, the partial victory warranted consideration for costs.
The court then delineated the factors it should consider in determining the appropriate costs for a party with partial success. It examined the proportionality of the costs to the benefit achieved, the complexity and importance of the issues, and the conduct of the parties throughout the proceedings. The court highlighted that the principle of proportionality was crucial in ensuring that the costs awarded were fair and reasonable. It also considered the conduct of the parties, finding that the plaintiff's conduct had been reasonable and diligent, while the defendant's conduct had been somewhat obstreperous.
Finally, the court addressed the need to balance the principle that costs follow the event with the need to discourage frivolous or vexatious litigation. The court recognised that while it is essential to protect the rights of successful parties, it is equally important to prevent the misuse of the legal system. The court concluded that in cases of partial success, the discretion to award costs must be exercised with care, ensuring that the costs reflect the true nature of the victory and the conduct of the parties. The court found that the plaintiff's partial success warranted an award of costs, but the amount would be reduced to reflect the partial nature of the victory and the overall conduct of the parties.
The ratio decidendi of Hall v City of Burnside (No 2) is that in cases where a party achieves partial success, the court has the discretion to award costs, but this award must be proportionate to the benefit achieved and consider the conduct of the parties. The court must balance the principle that costs follow the event with the need to discourage frivolous litigation, ensuring that the costs reflect the true outcome and behaviour in the proceedings.