Hall v City of Burnside

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

HALL v CITY OF BURNSIDE

[2022] SASCA 39

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Justice Bleby, the Honourable Justice David and the Honourable Justice Blue)

28 April 2022

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - BUILDING CONTROL - COUNCIL CONSENT AND APPROVAL - APPLICATIONS

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - BUILDING CONTROL - COUNCIL CONSENT AND APPROVAL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION BY COUNCIL

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - BUILDING CONTROL - COUNCIL CONSENT AND APPROVAL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION BY COUNCIL - ALLOTMENTS AND BUILDING SITES - POSITION OF BUILDING

Appeal against dismissal by the Environment, Resources and Development Court of appeal against grant of development plan consent in respect of a proposed development involving the construction of a split-level detached dwelling with garage and swimming pool on land in the Hills Face Zone under the Burnside (City) Development Plan.

The appellant had made representations to the Council opposing the proposed development on grounds including that it would impair the view over the Adelaide Plains from a public walking trail that proceeds past the land and the view from the Adelaide Plains of the Hill Face Zone.

When the Council granted development plan consent, it reserved its decision on the adequacy of four matters for further assessment prior to the granting of any development approval pursuant to subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993 (SA). These included details of the off form concrete being of a darker toning to meet the requirements of the Hills Face Zone and a detailed landscaping plan showing the location of planting to soften the built form and provide a landscape commensurate with the setting of that section of the Hills Face Zone.

The appellant contended before the Environment Court, and contends on appeal, that the reservations relating to concrete colour and landscaping were invalid under subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993 and this rendered the development plan consent invalid.

The appellant also contends on appeal that the Environment Court erred in its assessment of the planning merits of the development proposal.

Held:

1(per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA dissenting) The Environment Court did not misconstrue the Development Plan by giving primacy to residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill rather than to the objectives of preserving, enhancing and assisting in the re-establishment of the natural character of the zone (per Bleby JA at [25] (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA at [161] dissenting).

2(per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA dissenting) The Environment Court did not err in its approach to the evidence relating to, and assessment of, the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail (per Bleby JA at [39]-[43] (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA at [171] dissenting).

3(per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA dissenting) The Environment Court did not err in its approach to the assessment of the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the Adelaide Plains (per Bleby JA at [57] (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hall v City of Burnside and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a decision by the Environment, Resources and Development Court (the Environment Court) to dismiss an appeal against the City of Burnside Council Assessment Panel's grant of development plan consent for a proposed dwelling. The appellant, Mr Hall, had opposed the development on grounds relating to the visual impact of the proposed dwelling on the Hills Face Zone, specifically concerning views from a public walking trail and from the Adelaide Plains. The Council had granted consent subject to reservations regarding the colour of off-form concrete and the details of a landscaping plan.

The legal issues before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia were whether the Environment Court had erred in its interpretation of the Development Plan, particularly in its assessment of the balance between residential development objectives and the preservation of the natural character of the zone. The Court was also required to determine if the Environment Court had made errors in its assessment of the evidence concerning the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail and the Adelaide Plains. Furthermore, the validity of the reservations made by the Council concerning concrete colour and landscaping under subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993 (SA) was a key issue.

The majority of the Court, comprising Bleby JA and David JA, held that the Environment Court had not misconstrued the Development Plan by prioritising residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill over the objectives of preserving the natural character of the zone. They also found no error in the Environment Court's approach to the evidence and assessment of the dwelling's visibility from the walking trail and the Adelaide Plains. While acknowledging that the reservations regarding concrete colour and landscaping were invalid under subsection 33(3) of the Act, the majority concluded that the Environment Court had conducted its own merits assessment of these matters, superseding the invalidity of the initial development plan consent. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held:

1 (per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA dissenting) The Environment Court did not misconstrue the Development Plan by giving primacy to residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill rather than to the objectives of preserving, enhancing and assisting in the re-establishment of the natural character of the zone (per Bleby JA at [25] (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA at [161] dissenting).

2 (per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA dissenting) The Environment Court did not err in its approach to the evidence relating to, and assessment of, the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail (per Bleby JA at [39]-[43] (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA at [171] dissenting).

3 (per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA dissenting) The Environment Court did not err in its approach to the assessment of the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the Adelaide Plains (per Bleby JA at [57] (David JA agreeing); Blue AJA at [181] dissenting).

4 (per the Court) The reservations relating to concrete colour and landscaping were invalid under subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993 (per Blue AJA at [206] (Bleby JA and David JA agreeing).

5 (per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing) The Environment Court exercised its own merits assessment of the development including the issues of colour and landscaping the subject of the reservations and this superseded the invalidity of the development plan consent granted by the Council (per Bleby JA at [73] (David JA agreeing)).

6 (per Bleby JA (David JA agreeing) Appeal dismissed (at [74]).

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Hall also contends on appeal that the Environment Court erred in its assessment of the planning merits of the development proposal. He contends that the Court misconstrued the Development Plan by giving primacy to residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill rather than to the objectives of preserving, enhancing and assisting in the re-establishment of the natural character of the zone. He also contends the Court erred in its approach to the evidence relating to, and assessment of, the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail and from the Adelaide Plains. Background Mr Finch is the owner of land situated at 15 Government Road Glen Osmond (the Land). The Land comprises approximately 6,097 square metres and is a pentagonal shape but is best envisaged as if it were a triangle with an eastern boundary, a south-western boundary and a north-western boundary. The eastern boundary is 98 metres[35] in length and fronts onto Government Road. The south-western boundary proceeds west for 55 metres and then turns approximately 60 degrees to proceed north-west for 66 metres. The north-western boundary proceeds north-east for 56 metres and then turns approximately 15 degrees to proceed east-north-east for 38 metres. [35] All dimensions in metres are rounded to the nearest whole metre unless otherwise shown. There is a three metre wide easement (the SA Water easement) recorded on the title in favour of the Minister of Public Infrastructure (for SA Water) which proceeds along the initial 55 metre length of the south-western boundary from the Apex to the point at which that boundary turns to the north-west. The south-eastern corner of the Land (which is approximately a right angle) is the highest point of the land, being about 303 metres AHD[36] (303 metres above mean sea level) and can be regarded as the apex of the Land (the Apex). The Land slopes downward from the Apex whether proceeding north along the eastern boundary, west/north-west along the southern boundary or north-west down the middle of the block. At the bottom of the block on its north-western boundary, the Land is about 273 metres AHD. There is therefore a fall of 30 metres from the Apex to the north-western boundary. The average gradient is approximately 1:3. The gradient is less steep (approximately 1:4) at the Apex and steeper (approximately 1:2.5) at the north‑western boundary. In general terms, land lying to the east of the Land continues to rise. [36] All heights in metres AHD are rounded to the nearest whole metre unless otherwise shown. The Land is essentially undeveloped and contains four eucalypts, several pines, Hawthorn and olive trees and shrubs and grasses. The Land is in the City of Burnside and lies wholly within the Hills Face Zone. The north-western boundary of the Hills Face Zone passes along the north‑western boundary of the Land so that land lying to the north of the Land is in a Residential Zone. Lying north of the Land are four houses on the southern side of Sunnyside Road situated in the Residential Zone.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It follows that I am not persuaded that the ERD Court erred by giving primacy to residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill rather than preserving, enhancing and assisting in re-establishing the natural character of the zone.Whether the Court erred in its approach to the evidence relating to the visibility of the dwelling from the walking trail Mr Outhred, the expert planner called by Mr Hall, included the following statement in his expert report in his consideration of Objective 1 of the Development Plan: The walking track over Government Road provides an important connection between Gully Reserve and extensive other walking tracks to the north-east (including connections to Waterfall Gully and Cleland Conservation Park) and the Toll Gate circuit and Danthonia Reserve to the south-west. The section over Government Road provides the public with a panoramic vista of the Adelaide plains to the sea. Therefore, any impact of the development on a significant passive recreation component, should be carefully considered. I am of the opinion, that the proposed dwelling is too close to Government Road and will partially obstruct the panoramic views from Government Road of the Adelaide plains. In cross-examination, he explained that he considered that this obstruction offended Objective 1(a). In his consideration of Objective 2, and specifically Objective 2(b), he said: Albeit that Government Road is limited in vehicle traffic, it is significant in respect to pedestrian traffic using the public walking track. Visual intrusion from the walking track along Government Road is important in view of the obstruction to the panorama of the Adelaide plains available from the track. The placement of the dwelling high on the land will partly obscure the panorama. He also commented adversely on the visibility of the dwelling from the walking track by reference to PDC 8, and then the Metropolitan Open Space System supported by Objectives 46, 48, 50 and 51:The section over Government Road, adjacent the subject land, plays an important role, in achieving the follows [sic] outcomes:·The provision of a visual and scenic contrast to the built environment between dwellings clustered lower along Sunnyside Road and dwellings clustered higher around Seaview Road – reference Objective 46(a)·Contributes to the separation of different parts of the metropolitan area – reference Objectives 46(b) & 51(b)·Accommodates a passive recreation and leisure activity, in the form of a scenic walking trail – reference Objective 46(f)·Emphasises the open natural and rural character – reference Objective 48·Ensures the face of the Mount Lofty Ranges is not impaired by visually intrusive development – reference Objective 50The Government Road link between Gully Reserve and Danthonia Reserve provides the public with a panoramic vista of the Adelaide plains to the sea. Therefore, any impact of the development on a significant passive recreation component, should be carefully considered.I am of the opinion, that the proposed dwelling is too close to Government Road and will partially obstruct the panoramic views from Government Road over the Adelaide plains and diminishes the outcomes contemplated in Objectives 46, 48, 50 & 51.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, as discussed above, the ERD Court engaged in its own merits assessment of the development that included the subject matter of the reservations to which the second respondent had, by then, provided answers. The Court made its own planning judgments with respect to the significant issues of colour and landscaping, with the benefit of those answers. No error has been shown in respect of the Court’s exercise of those judgments.Conclusion I would dismiss the appeal. DAVID JA: I agree with the reasons of Bleby JA, and the orders he has proposed. BLUE AJA: Grantley Hall appeals against the dismissal by the Environment, Resources and Development Court (the Environment Court) of his appeal[34] against the grant by the Council Assessment Panel of the City of Burnside, the first respondent, of development plan consent. The development plan consent is in respect of a proposed development by Justin Finch, the second respondent, involving the construction of a split-level detached dwelling with garage and swimming pool. [34] Under section 86 of the Development Act 1993 (SA). The land the subject of the proposed development is located in the Hills Face Zone under the Burnside (City) Development Plan. The relevant version of that plan is the version in force on the date of the application for development plan consent, namely the version consolidated on 8 December 2016 (the Development Plan). Mr Hall had made representations to the Council opposing the proposed development on grounds including that it would impair the view over the Adelaide Plains from a public walking trail that proceeds past the land and the view from the Adelaide Plains of the Hill Face Zone. When the Council granted development plan consent, it reserved its decision on the adequacy of four matters for further assessment prior to the granting of any development approval pursuant to subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993 (SA) (the Act). One matter was details of the off form concrete being of a darker toning to meet the requirements of the Hills Face Zone. Another matter was a detailed landscaping plan showing the location of planting to soften the built form and to provide a landscape commensurate with the setting of that section of the Hills Face Zone. Mr Hall contended before the Environment Court, and contends on this appeal, that the reservations relating to concrete colour and landscaping were invalid under subsection 33(3) of the Act and this rendered the development plan consent invalid. Mr Hall also contends on appeal that the Environment Court erred in its assessment of the planning merits of the development proposal. He contends that the Court misconstrued the Development Plan by giving primacy to residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill rather than to the objectives of preserving, enhancing and assisting in the re-establishment of the natural character of the zone. He also contends the Court erred in its approach to the evidence relating to, and assessment of, the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail and from the Adelaide Plains. Background

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Environment Court did not misconstrue the Development Plan by giving primacy to residential development and minimising driveway length and cut and fill rather than to the objectives of preserving, enhancing and assisting in the re-establishment of the natural character of the zone. The court found that the Development Plan's objectives included both residential development and the preservation of the natural character of the zone, and that the court had not erred by considering both aspects in its assessment of the development proposal. The court rejected Mr Hall's argument that the Environment Court had given primacy to residential development over the objectives of preserving the natural character of the zone.

The Environment Court did not err in its approach to the evidence relating to, and assessment of, the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail. The court found that the expert planner's evidence that the proposed dwelling would partially obstruct the panoramic views from Government Road of the Adelaide plains and diminish the outcomes contemplated in several objectives of the Development Plan was relevant and properly considered by the Environment Court. The court rejected Mr Hall's argument that the Environment Court had erred in its assessment of the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail.

The Environment Court did not err in its approach to the assessment of the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the Adelaide Plains. The court found that the expert planner's evidence that the proposed dwelling would impair the view from the Adelaide Plains of the Hill Face Zone was relevant and properly considered by the Environment Court. The court rejected Mr Hall's argument that the Environment Court had erred in its assessment of the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the Adelaide Plains.

The reservations relating to concrete colour and landscaping were invalid under subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993. The court found that the Environment Court had correctly identified that the Council's reservations relating to concrete colour and landscaping were invalid because they were not matters that could be reserved under subsection 33(3) of the Act. The court noted that the invalidity of the reservations did not affect the validity of the development plan consent granted by the Council.

The Environment Court exercised its own merits assessment of the development, including the issues of colour and landscaping the subject of the reservations, and this superseded the invalidity of the development plan consent granted by the Council. The court found that the Environment Court had properly exercised its own merits assessment of the development proposal, including the issues of colour and landscaping that were the subject of the invalid reservations. The court rejected Mr Hall's argument that the invalidity of the reservations rendered the development plan consent invalid and that the Environment Court should not have considered the merits of the development proposal.

The appeal should be dismissed. The court found that the Environment Court had not erred in its assessment of the planning merits of the development proposal, and that the Environment Court's exercise of its own merits assessment of the development proposal, including the issues of colour and landscaping that were the subject of the invalid reservations, was proper. The court rejected all of Mr Hall's grounds of appeal and dismissed the appeal.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Environment Court did not err in its assessment of the planning merits of the development proposal, and that the Environment Court's exercise of its own merits assessment of the development proposal, including the issues of colour and landscaping that were the subject of the invalid reservations, was proper. The court did not err in its approach to the evidence relating to, and assessment of, the visibility of the proposed dwelling from the walking trail or from the Adelaide Plains. The invalidity of the reservations relating to concrete colour and landscaping under subsection 33(3) of the Development Act 1993 did not affect the validity of the development plan consent granted by the Council, and the Environment Court's exercise of its own merits assessment of the development proposal superseded the invalidity of the reservations.