City of Mitcham v MOL Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

CITY OF MITCHAM v MOL PTY LTD & ORS

[2003] SASC 166

Full Court: Doyle CJ, Duggan and Debelle JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ             I would allow the appeal and make the orders proposed by Debelle J.  I agree with the reasons given by Debelle J for so ordering.  There is nothing that I wish to add to those reasons.

  2. DUGGAN J           I agree with the conclusions reached by Debelle J and the orders which he has proposed.  I also agree with his reasons for decision.

  3. DEBELLE J           This is an appeal from a decision of a Judge and two Commissioners of the Environment Resources and Development Court.

  4. One issue which falls for consideration in the appeal is whether the establishment of a vineyard is consistent with the provisions of the Development Plan which regulates development in that part of the Hills Face Zone which provides a backdrop to metropolitan Adelaide.  That issue is to be determined, not by any beliefs as to whether vineyards are a desirable form of development in the Hills Face Zone, but by reference to the terms of the Development Plan.

    An Application to Develop a Vineyard is Refused

  5. The respondents, MOL Pty Ltd and Averil Garrett, own a substantial parcel of land known as “Springwood Park”.  The land has a total area of some 205 hectares and is within the area of the City of Mitcham (“the Council”).  It has a substantial frontage to Mount Barker Road and extends back generally in a south-westerly direction toward Brownhill Creek.  The land and adjacent land is within the Hills Face Zone prescribed by the Council’s Development Plan.

  6. On 8 November 2000 the Council had granted the respondents consent to develop seven acres of land within the Hills Face Zone as a vineyard.  It seems that consent was granted because the development application had been made when the provisions of the Development Plan were in terms different from those which now exist.  (Section 53 of the Development Act 1993 provides that a planning application is to be determined in accordance with the law and Development Plan in force at the time when the application was lodged.)

  7. On 20 June 2000 the respondents lodged an application for consent to develop a further 24.5 hectares as a vineyard.  The proposed development was described in the application form as “Agriculture (vines)”.  As ultimately proposed, it included planting, trellising and irrigation of vines.  The respondents intended to add to the vineyard, the subject of the approval granted in November 2000.  Only five hectares have been developed pursuant to that approval.  The resulting vineyard of 29.5 hectares was to be managed as one development.  By notice dated 1 May 2001 the Council refused the application on the ground that it was contrary to provisions of the Development Plan, including Objectives 1 and 2 and Principle of Development Control 1 for the Hills Face Zone.

  8. On 19 November 2001 the respondents lodged a separate application to erect trellising on the vineyard of five hectares.  By…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City of Mitcham v MOL Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of City of Mitcham v MOL Pty Ltd was before the Environment Court of South Australia, concerning the proposed development on land within the Hills Face Zone. The primary issue was whether the proposed development could be approved under the relevant provisions of the Development Plan, specifically focusing on the Objectives and Principles of Development Control for the Hills Face Zone. The applicant, MOL Pty Ltd, sought approval for development on the land, which is part of the locality described by the court as extending from the ridge line of Mount Osmond in the north, including residential uses and a golf course, to the South-Eastern Freeway, with various land uses such as grazing, viticulture, and residential development.

The legal issues centred on how the proposed development would impact the preservation and enhancement of the natural character of the locality, as mandated by Objectives 1 and 2 of the Hills Face Zone. The court considered whether the development aligned with these objectives, which emphasise the preservation and enhancement of the natural character, limiting visual intrusion, and preventing potential demand for services at a community cost. Additionally, Principle 1 of the Principles of Development Control was relevant, stipulating that development should not be undertaken unless it is associated with low-intensity agricultural activities or other specified uses and preserves or enhances the natural character of the zone.

The Environment Court concluded that the proposed development did not align with the Objectives for the Hills Face Zone, particularly in terms of preserving and enhancing the natural character. The court found that the development would detract from the open rural and natural character of the locality, contrary to the stated objectives. Moreover, the court considered that the development would create a potential demand for services, which is inconsistent with the principles governing development in the Hills Face Zone. Consequently, the court ruled that the development proposal could not be approved under the Development Plan. The court's decision was grounded in the need to protect the natural assets of the western slopes of the Mount Lofty Ranges, ensuring that any development in the zone contributes to the preservation and enhancement of the natural character, rather than detracting from it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ DUGGAN J DEBELLE J
There was no dispute as to the bounds of the locality as determined by the Environment Court. It extended generally in the north to the approximate ridge line of Mount Osmond, including the residential uses and golf course; in the north-east and east to include the Leawood Gardens residential development and visitor look-out; in the south as far as Sheoak Road, including the Belair ridge line and residential development in that area; and in the west as far as Brownhill Creek Road and passing through the Brownhill Creek Recreation Park. The land within that locality is presently used for a range of purposes. A significant portion of it is used for grazing and that is mainly cleared land. There is at least one small area of viticulture. Within the locality, residential development exists on a range of allotment sizes. A substantial amount of the land within the locality is bushland. The locality includes the South-Eastern Freeway. Limited parts of the locality and a small part of the subject land are visible from parts of the Adelaide Plains. The amenity of the locality is reasonably high. One feature of the amenity is its open rural and natural character. There are, however, areas which detract from the general amenity of the area and they include quarrying activity to the south-east of the subject land, the prominent siting of some dwellings and other buildings, some visually obtrusive high voltage overhead power lines and the presence of a range of noxious pest plants. The character of the locality is generally rural with extensive indigenous bushland areas. The fact that development has occurred in the locality is not a factor to which any real weight should be attached. That is the consequence of the requirement in the Objectives for the Hills Face Zone which state that “each development should be assessed on the extent to which it preserves and enhances the natural character … rather than on the basis of a comparison with existing development in its locality”. The full text of the Objectives immediately follows.The Environment Court’s Decision The central issue before the Environment Court was whether the proposed development could be approved having regard to the provisions in the Development Plan relating to the Hills Face Zone. Although regard was had to other provisions in the Development Plan, the court principally had regard for the provisions of Objectives 1 and 2 for the Hills Face Zone, the two paragraphs explaining those Objectives and to Principle 1 of the Principles of Development Control for the Zone. It is common ground that these are relevant provisions. It is convenient to set them out.“OBJECTIVESObjective 1: A zone in which the natural character is preserved and enhanced or in which a natural character is re-established in order to:(a)provide a natural backdrop to the Adelaide plains and a contrast to the urban area;(b)preserve and develop native vegetation and fauna habitats close to metropolitan Adelaide;(c)provide for passive recreation in an area of natural character close to the metropolitan area;(d)provide a part of the buffer area between metropolitan districts and prevent the urban areas extending into the western slopes of the Mount Lofty Ranges; and(e)ensure that the community is not required to bear the cost of provided (sic) services to land within the zone.Objective 2: A zone accommodating low-intensity agricultural activities and public/private open space and one where structures are located and designed in such a way as to:(a)preserve and enhance the natural character or assist in the re-establishment of a natural character in the zone;(b)limit the visual intrusion of development in the zone, particularly when viewed from roads within the zone or from the Adelaide plains;(c)not create, either in themselves, or in association with other developments, a potential demand for the provision of services at a cost to the community; and(d)prevent the loss of life and property resulting from bushfires.The western slopes of the Mount Lofty Ranges in metropolitan Adelaide are an important natural asset to both the population of the urban area and the tourism industry. Development which is undertaken in this zone should not only preserve but should also enhance the natural character of the zone or assist in the re-establishment of a natural character.The term ‘natural character’ refers to the natural topography, native vegetation and colours, such as greens and browns of non-reflective earthen tones, normally associated with a natural landscape. Additionally, natural character refers to the open character of the land in those areas of the zone where open grazing currently predominates. Thus, existing buildings should not be seen as setting a precedent when assessing the impact of a proposed development. Each development should be assessed on the extent to which it preserves and enhances the natural character or, more importantly, assists in the re-establishment of a natural character, rather than on the basis of a comparison with existing development in its locality.…The Hills Face Zone is not a residential zone and so the services provided in an urban area will not be provided in this zone. Accordingly, development should not be undertaken if it is likely, in itself or in association with other development, to create a potential demand for such services.…PRINCIPLES OF DEVELOPMENT CONTROL1 Development should not be undertaken unless:(a)it is associated with a low-intensity agricultural activity, a public open space area or a private use of an open character, or is a detached single-storey dwelling, including outbuildings and structures normally associated with such dwellings, on a single allotment; and(b)together with associated native landscaping, it preserves and enhances the natural character of the zone or assists in the re-establishment of a natural character.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ, DUGGAN J, DEBELLE J