Purnell v Manson t/as Manson Homes

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Purnell & Anor v Manson t/as Manson Homes [2024] QCATA 48

PARTIES:

SARAH PURCELL AND STEWART BRETT 

(applicant/appellant)

v

LEE MANSON T/AS MANSON HOMES

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL346-19

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL117-14

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

17 April 2024

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown
Senior Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.     Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes must pay Sarah Purnell’s and Stewart Brett’s costs of the appeal on the standard basis to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the Magistrates Courts Scale, Schedule 2 Part 3 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1991 as if the proceeding had been brought in that court.

2.     The proceeding is remitted to enable the determination of costs in proceeding BDL117-14.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – POWERS OF COURT – COSTS  Where appellants successful on appeal – Where appellants made a settlement offer – Where respondent rejected the settlement offer – Whether rejection of offer reasonable – Where appellant claims costs on an indemnity basis – Whether the respondent was in a position to reasonably consider the offer at the time that it was made

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) s 77

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) s 147

Brett & Anor v Manson t/as Manson Homes [2020] QCATA 122
CJZ Pty Ltd v Giant Dwarf Pty Ltd; CJZ Pty Ltd v Morrow [2023] NSWCA 135
Fick v Groves (No 2) [2010] QSC 182
Harrison & Anor v Meehan [2017] QCA 315
Hazeldene's Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian Workcover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298
Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Purnell [2016] QCAT 282;
Lee Mason t/as Lee Manson Homes v Brett & Anor [2017] QCATA 124;
Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Anor [2018] QCATA 109;
Manson v Brett & Anor (No. 2) [2019] QCAT 411.
McGee v Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Anor [2018] QCATA 124
Partington & Anor v Urquhart (No 4) [2019] QCATA 96

Purnell & Anor v Manson [2023] QCATA 77.

Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] QCA 39.

Tamawood Ltd v Paans [2005] 2 Qd R 101

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

Applicant:

Mr C Wilson of counsel –

Respondent:

All Building Law

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. After a lengthy history in the Tribunal, including an appeal, the appellant homeowners were ordered to pay the respondent builder $25,254.00. The appellants successfully appealed the decision and the respondent was ordered to pay the appellants $20,103.00.[1]

  2. The costs of the appeal fall to be determined.

    The dispute and the decision of the Appeal Tribunal

  3. The dispute between the parties has been the subject of comprehensive tribunal consideration.[2] The respondent undertook…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Purnell v Manson t/as Manson Homes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCATA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was between the appellants, Sarah Purnell and Stewart Brett, and the respondent, Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes. The dispute arose from a renovation contract for the appellants' home, which was terminated before completion. The tribunal found the termination to be lawful but awarded the respondent $25,254.00. The appellants appealed the tribunal's decision on several grounds, including the assessment of costs and quantum meruit claims. The appeal tribunal found the respondent was not entitled to recover on a quantum meruit and ordered a rehearing, resulting in the appellants being awarded damages for the cost of completing the works and late completion damages.

The court was required to determine the costs of the appeal, considering the appellants' partial success and the rejection of their settlement offer. The appeal tribunal's discretion to award costs in building dispute proceedings was also a matter for consideration. The court had to weigh the successful party's legal costs against the interests of justice, taking into account the complexity of the appeal and the partial success of the appellants. The court had to determine whether the respondent's rejection of the settlement offer was reasonable and whether the appellants were entitled to indemnity costs.

The appeal tribunal had the discretion to award costs in building dispute proceedings, but the court considered it appropriate to award costs on the standard basis rather than the indemnity basis. The court found that the appeal tribunal did not err in its discretion when it rejected the appellants' offer to settle. The appellants' partial success did not warrant depriving them of their costs, and the rejection of the settlement offer was reasonable given the circumstances. The court concluded that the costs of the appeal should be awarded on the standard basis, to be agreed upon by the parties or assessed on the Magistrates Court scale if agreement could not be reached.

Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes must pay Sarah Purnell’s and Stewart Brett’s costs of the appeal on the standard basis to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the Magistrates Courts Scale, Schedule 2 Part 3 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1991 as if the proceeding had been brought in that court. The proceeding is remitted to enable the determination of costs in proceeding BDL117-14.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes must pay Sarah Purnell’s and Stewart Brett’s costs of the appeal on the standard basis to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the Magistrates Courts Scale, Schedule 2 Part 3 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1991 as if the proceeding had been brought in that court.

2. The proceeding is remitted to enable the determination of costs in proceeding BDL117-14.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The costs of the appeal fall to be determined. The dispute and the decision of the Appeal Tribunal The dispute between the parties has been the subject of comprehensive tribunal consideration.[2] The respondent undertook renovation works to the appellants’ home. The appellants terminated the contract before the enclosed stage of works had been completed by the respondent. The tribunal found the appellants’ termination to have been lawful. The respondent unsuccessfully appealed this decision (the first appeal proceedings). The proceeding was returned to the tribunal to decide the remaining issues relevant to the appellants’ termination. The tribunal ordered the appellants to pay the respondent $25,254.00. The appellants appealed on a number of grounds: the tribunal erred in assessing the appellants costs of completing the works; the tribunal erred in allowing the respondent to recover on a quantum meruit for the enclosed stage of works and further works completed by the respondent; the tribunal erred when dealing with a particular item of building work relating to bi-fold doors and in allowing the respondent to recover an amount in respect of the item; the tribunal erred in assessing the appellants’ claim for payment of rent. [2]Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Purnell [2016] QCAT 282; Lee Mason t/as Lee Manson Homes v Brett & Anor [2017] QCATA 124; Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Anor [2018] QCATA 109; Manson v Brett & Anor (No. 2) [2019] QCAT 411. The appellants sought a stay of the decision of the tribunal. That application was refused.[3] [3]Brett & Anor v Manson t/as Manson Homes [2020] QCATA 122. We found that the tribunal had erred in allowing the respondent’s quantum meruit claim. As this error was one of mixed law and fact, the appeal was determined by way of rehearing as required by s 147 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld). We found that:(a)The respondent was not entitled to recover, on a quantum meruit, an amount in respect of the enclosed stage of works, or an amount in respect of work completed beyond the enclosed stage;(b)The appellants were entitled to recover $143,300 for the cost of completing the building works;(c)The appellants were entitled to recover $10,920 for late completion damages;(d)The respondent was not entitled to recover an amount for the work relating to the bi-fold doors;(e)The appellants’ entitlement to damages, including the costs of completing the works, totalled $167,190 less the balance payable to the respondent under the contract of $147,087 being a nett assessment of $20,103.What do the parties say about the costs of the appeal? Before considering the parties’ submissions on costs, it is appropriate to say something about the costs of the proceedings below and of the first appeal. No costs order was made by the tribunal following the initial determination that the appellants had lawfully terminated the contract. Following the first appeal proceedings, the respondent was ordered to pay the appellants’ costs of the first appeal. In the resumed proceeding below, both parties submitted that they be heard on the question of costs after the tribunal’s final decision. The costs of the proceeding below remain unresolved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent says that although the appellants had a measure of success, they were not entirely successful in the appeal. The respondent agrees that, if costs are awarded, the appropriate scale is the Magistrates Court scale, Schedule 2 Part 3 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1991. However, the respondent says that there should be no order for costs. As to the appellants’ offer to settle, the respondent says that it was reasonable for it not to accept the appellants’ offer to settle because: the appellants refused to pay the amount awarded by the tribunal below; the appellants’ stay application had been refused casting doubt on the appellants’ prospects of success; the offer was ‘all up’ meaning it was difficult for the respondent to assess whether the settlement was reasonable. Consideration By s 77(3)(h) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) the tribunal may award costs in a proceeding for a building dispute. This power extends to appeal proceedings.[5] The power to award costs requires the exercise of a discretion. In exercising the discretion, the appeal tribunal must act judicially.[6][5]Partington & Anor v Urquhart (No 4) [2019] QCATA 96.[6]Ibid at [12]. Unlike in the courts, costs do not follow the event in a building dispute proceeding. Nevertheless, the erosion of the fruits of litigation by the legal costs incurred by the successful party is a relevant matter when considering whether the interests of justice weigh in favour of a costs award.[7] The appeal proceedings were complex both legally and factually. It was reasonable for the parties to be legally represented. Leave for the parties to be legally represented was granted early in the appeal proceeding. [7]Tamawood Ltd v Paans [2005] 2 Qd R 101. Nor does the appellants’ partial success mean that the approach to costs should be fragmented by reference to the success or otherwise of the various grounds of appeal. In Speets Investment Pty Ltd v Bencol Pty Ltd (No 2)[8] the Court of Appeal stated:It is important to recognise, however, that it does not follow from the foregoing that the application of the general rule should usually lead to costs orders which reflect different results on separate events or issues. The Court is given a broad discretion and is specifically empowered to determine that some other order is more appropriate. In practice, courts often take the approach of identifying heads of controversy or ‘units of litigation’ (rather than what might technically be regarded as issues on the pleadings) regarding success or failure on the head of controversy or unit of litigation as the criterion for awarding costs: see Thiess v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 5) at 207–8 and Chief Executive, Department of Transport and Main Roads v Cidneo Pty Ltd [2015] QCA 168 at [1]. The general approach is that there must be special or exceptional circumstances to warrant depriving a successful party of its costs and the mere fact that the successful party has been unsuccessful on some issues will ordinarily not be sufficient to do so: Courtney v Chalfen [2021] QCA 25 at [5]. On an appeal, for example, where a party has succeeded on one of two ways to the same outcome, the Court of Appeal might well regard the costs of the second way on which that party failed as not so distinct conceptually or practically as to warrant making a costs order which reflected that party’s failure: Chief Executive, Department of Transport and Main Roads v Cidneo Pty Ltd at [1] . On the other hand, one circumstance in which it might be appropriate to award costs of a particular question or part of a proceeding is where that matter is definable and severable and has occupied a significant part of the proceeding…[9][8][2021] QCA 39.[9]Ibid at [14] to [16].