Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Purnell

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read
CITATION: Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Purnell [2016] QCAT 282
PARTIES: Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes
(Applicant)
v
Stewart Brett
Sarah Purnell
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: BDL117-14
MATTER TYPE: Building matters
HEARING DATE: 13 October 2015, 10 November 2015
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Member Paratz
DELIVERED ON: 5 August 2016
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The date for filing of Submissions in Reply by Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes is extended to 4:00pm on 6 April 2016.

2.    The Tribunal declares that the Contract between Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes and Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell dated 29 November 2013 was validly terminated by Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell on 28 April 2014.

CATCHWORDS:

BUILDING – Where the owners terminated a building contract – whether the termination by the owners was valid – where the builder amended the plans and then installed a roof material different to the amended plans – where the required Development Approval was not obtained prior to the builder installing the roof material

Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld)

Thompson Residential Pty Ltd v Hart & Anor [2014] QDC 132

APPEARANCES:

APPLICANT: D. C. Kissane of Counsel
Instructed by Gadens
RESPONDENT: B.J.Saal (Saal and Associates)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Mr Brett and Ms Purnell (‘the owners’) entered into a Contract with Mr Manson (‘the builder’) to renovate a property at 16 Lind Street, Newmarket, in Brisbane.

  2. A dispute arose, and the owners terminated the Contract on 28 April 2014.

  3. A preliminary question has arisen as to whether the Contract was validly terminated by the owners.

  4. The primary issue in the matter relates to the roof material of the house. The house originally had a tile roof. That roof was replaced with a metal roof in the course of construction. The proper approvals were not obtained for the change of roof material.

  5. The questions at the heart of this matter are:

    (a)   who was responsible for obtaining the proper development approvals; and

    (b)   whether there was an agreement between the owners and the builder as to installation of the metal roof.

  6. I heard evidence on 13 October 2015 and 10 November 2015. Extensive submissions were made following the hearing, through until April 2016.

  7. There are significant disputes of fact between the owners and the builder, and considerable legal argument as to the legal results that flow depending upon what findings of fact are accepted.

  8. This is the decision on the preliminary question.

    History of the proceedings

  9. The builder filed an Application for domestic building dispute in the Tribunal on 26 May 2014 seeking the following orders:

    1.    A declaration that the purported termination of the contract on 28 April 2014 was invalid.

    2.    Further, an order that the Respondents pay the Applicant the sum of $96,932 for work performed.

    3.    Further, an order that the Respondents pay the Applicant damages in the sum of $50,077 for breach of contract;

    4.    Further, an order that the Respondents pay the Applicant interest on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Purnell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCAT 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lee Manson t/as Manson Homes v Brett & Purnell involved a dispute between a building contractor and the owners of a property regarding the termination of a building contract. The builder, Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes, was contracted to construct a home for the owners, Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell. The dispute arose when the owners terminated the contract, alleging that the builder had failed to obtain necessary approvals and had installed a roof material different to that specified in the amended plans. The case was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the tribunal were whether the owners were justified in terminating the building contract and whether the builder had breached the contract by not obtaining necessary approvals and installing a different roof material. The builder argued that the owners' termination was wrongful as they had failed to follow the contractual notice requirements and that they were also in breach of the contract. The owners, on the other hand, contended that the builder had substantially breached the contract by not obtaining the necessary approvals and by installing a roof material different to that specified in the amended plans.

The tribunal found that the builder had indeed breached the contract by failing to obtain the required approvals and by installing a roof material different to that specified in the amended plans. The tribunal held that the owners were entitled to terminate the contract as the builder had not completed the works required to meet the enclosed stage and had not obtained the necessary approvals for the roof material. The tribunal further found that the owners' termination of the contract was valid as the builder had failed to comply with the notice to remedy breach and had suspended work without justification. The tribunal declared that the contract was validly terminated by the owners on 28 April 2014.

The tribunal's final orders included extending the deadline for filing submissions in reply by the builder and declaring that the contract between the builder and the owners was validly terminated by the owners on 28 April 2014.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The date for filing of Submissions in Reply by Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes is extended to 4:00pm on 6 April 2016.

2. The Tribunal declares that the Contract between Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes and Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell dated 29 November 2013 was validly terminated by Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell on 28 April 2014.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Thornley addressed the enclosed stage question more particularly as follows:In relation to the enclosed stage the roof covering required to meet the approved plans has not been installed, the lower level brickwork to the external walls has not been installed and the windows and doors shown on the plans including the high light windows have not been installed and therefore the requirement of the enclosed stage may not have been met.Evidence The owners did not obtain a statement from, or call, the certifier Mr Laa Tay. They said that they have been unable to locate him. The builder also did not or obtain a statement from him, or call him. Neither party took issue with the course of events involving Mr Laa Tay, and I do not take any inference from his not being called by either party, particularly when it appears that he cannot be located. Similarly, neither the owners or the builder called the designer, Mr McPhee. The emails and communication from McPhee were not in contention. I do not take any inference from his not being called by either party.The Builders submissions The builder submits that there were two reasons why the termination of the Contract was wrongful:[26]8. The first reason that the termination was wrongful is that the respondents failed to satisfy the requirements of Clause 27.4 of the Contract. This is because the Notice to Remedy Breach document that the respondents gave to the Applicant was ineffective pursuant to Clause 27.7 of the Contract because the Respondents were themselves in substantial breach of the Contract, and that they were not permitted to issue the Notice to remedy breach to the Applicant.9. The second reason that the termination was wrongful is that, as a matter of fact, the Applicant was not in substantial breach of the Contract.[26]Applicant’s submissions filed 27 January 2016 at 4. The builder gave the owners a progress claim for the 5th stage (Enclosed Stage) on 23 March 2014. The owners did not pay that claim within 5 working days of receiving it. There is a dispute as to whether the builder had reached the enclosed stage. The builder submits that the requirements for the enclosed stage have been completed.The Owners submissions The owners submit that it is obvious that the work required by the Contract required a Development Approval and a Building Approval,[27] and that it is uncontroversial that the builder did not:[28]i)Advertise pursuant to the Demolition Code and obtain approval from the Brisbane City Council to replace the tile roof with a steel roof;ii)Obtain a development permit, by way of Development Approval or Building Approval, from the Brisbane City Council or the Certifier, Matrix Certification Services, to commence work and install a steel roof on the property.[27]Respondents’ closing submissions filed 25 February 2016 at [31].[28]Ibid at [33]. The owners submit that obtaining Development Approval falls within the things described by Item 5A of Schedule 1 and clause 2.3 of the Contract as having to be obtained by the nominated person, and that it is an approval (or consent or permit) required by a ‘statutory or other authority’ as defined in clause 37 of the Contract.[29][29]Respondents’ closing submissions filed 25 February 2016 at [49].

Decision

Reasons for decision

I find that the builder was in substantial breach of the Contract by failing to comply with his obligations under clauses 1.1 and 11.1; that the owners were entitled to give a notice to remedy breach under clause 27.1 of the Contract; and that the owners were entitled to terminate under clause 27.4 upon non-compliance with it.Conclusion I find that:(a) It was the duty of the builder pursuant to clauses 1.1 and 11.1 of the Contract to obtain all required approvals and consents, and that he failed to do so in relation to the metal roof which he installed.(b) The failure of the builder to obtain all required approvals and consents was a substantial breach of the contract.(c) The builder had not properly completed the works required to complete the Enclosed Stage, and was not entitled to claim for the Enclosed Stage.(d) The owners were not required to pay the progress claim for the Enclosed Stage Claim at the time it was made.(e) The builder was not entitled to issue the Notice of Suspension of works on 2 April 2014.(f) The owners were entitled to issue the Notice to Remedy Breach dated 4 April 2014.(g) The builder did not comply with the Notice to Remedy Breach. I accordingly find that the owners were entitled to terminate the contract on 28 April 2014 based upon:-(a) The breach of the contract by the builder as to obtaining relevant consents or approvals; and (b) The suspension of work by the builder when he was not entitled to do so because the Enclosed Stage had not been reached (due to the failure to conduct the works that fell within the definition of Enclosed Stage in a complete and good and proper manner as to the roof covering, the internal flooring, and the external windows and doors); and(c) The failure of the builder to comply with the Notice to Remedy Breach dated 4 April 2014. I accordingly declare that the Contract, between Lee Manson trading as Manson Homes and Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell dated 29 November 2013, was validly terminated by Stewart Brett and Sarah Purnell on 28 April 2014.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established