Legal Services Commissioner v Pennisi

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Legal Services Commissioner v Pennisi [2023] QCAT 118

PARTIES:

LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER
(applicant)

v

VINCENT PENNISI

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR004-21

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

17 April 2023

HEARING DATES:

18 August 2022; 4 October 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Hon Peter Lyons KC, Judicial Member

Assisted by:
Mr Ross Perrett, Practitioner Panel Member
Ms Patrice Lorraine McKay, Lay Panel Member

ORDERS:

1.   Charge 1 is dismissed;

2.   It is declared that the respondent’s conduct the subject of Charge 2 amounts to unsatisfactory professional conduct;

3.   The respondent is publicly reprimanded in respect of the conduct the subject of Charge 2;

4.   The respondent is ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty of $5,000; and

5.   The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT – NEGLECT AND DELAY  – where the applicant alleged that the respondent failed to maintain reasonable standards of competence and diligence in preparing a will and an enduring power of attorney, in particular, by failing to take steps with respect to his client’s capacity to execute these documents – whether the circumstances disclosed serious concerns about his client’s capacity – whether the applicant took sufficient steps to establish his client’s capacity – where the applicant further alleged that the respondent engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct by failing, when acting for the executors of an estate, to advise them of available distributions from an investment fund and to seek instructions in respect of same, resulting in undue delay in the finalisation of the estate – where the respondent had previously been found not to have conducted his practice with proper care – where there were mitigating factors – whether the pecuniary penalty sought by the applicant and a reprimand is an appropriate sanction

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS  – QUEENSLAND – ORDERS – where the respondent was found to have engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct – where the complainant sought compensation for apparently engaging another lawyer to pursue the investment fund matter – whether it is possible to relate the work conducted by the other lawyer to the conduct of the respondent which has been found to be unsatisfactory professional conduct – whether compensation could be awarded

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – QUEENSLAND – ORDERS – where there was no dispute as to an order for costs in favour of the applicant insofar as Charge 2 was concerned, the only charge made out – where the respondent submitted that there were exceptional circumstances which warranted an order that the respondent only pay a proportion of the applicant’s costs as Charge 1 was the only contested charge – whether exceptional circumstances existed in accordance with s 462 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v Pennisi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Legal Services Commissioner v Pennisi, the Legal Services Commissioner brought an application against the respondent, a solicitor, alleging unsatisfactory professional conduct in relation to the administration of two estates. The court was required to determine whether the respondent's conduct fell below the standard expected of a solicitor. The primary focus of the case was on the respondent's handling of the estates of Mrs Mary Lilian Hunter and Mrs Mazucco.

The court examined the respondent's handling of the Hunter estate, where he admitted to failing to communicate with the executors, failing to seek instructions about an investment, and not advising on the redemption of units in a fund. This resulted in undue delay in finalising the estate. The court also considered the respondent's conduct in relation to Mrs Mazucco's estate, where the respondent met with her to discuss changes to her will and enduring power of attorney. The court assessed whether the respondent's conduct in both cases fell below the expected professional standards.

The court concluded that the respondent's conduct in relation to the Hunter estate was indeed unsatisfactory professional conduct. The respondent's failure to communicate with the executors and seek instructions about an investment, coupled with his failure to advise on the redemption of units, led to undue delay in finalising the estate. However, the court found that the respondent's notes of his dealings with Mrs Mazucco were sufficient, and therefore, his conduct did not fall below the expected standard. As a result, the charge in relation to Mrs Mazucco's estate was dismissed.

The court ordered that the respondent's unsatisfactory professional conduct in relation to the Hunter estate be publicly reprimanded. Additionally, the respondent was ordered to pay costs in the amount of $2,000. The court's decision highlights the importance of solicitors maintaining proper communication and diligence in the administration of estates and the consequences of failing to do so.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent was engaged to act in the administration of the estate of the late Mrs Mary Lilian Hunter by the executors of her will. The applicant alleged that the respondent failed to maintain reasonable standards of competence and diligence in carrying out this role. This is the subject of Charge 2 in the discipline application.Background to Mazucco charge Mrs Mazucco was born in Italy. She migrated to Australia in 1954. She was apparently a close friend of the respondent’s sister, and thus came to know the respondent; but she and the respondent had not been in contact for about 9 years before 2018. On 24 February 1994, Mrs Mazucco executed a will and an enduring power of attorney (“EPOA”), both prepared by the respondent. On 9 January 2014, Mrs Mazucco executed an EPOA appointing her son, Dr Roy Mazucco, as her attorney for financial, personal and health matters. The circumstances in which this document was executed are not apparent, but there is no suggestion that it was prepared by the respondent. Mrs Mazucco’s husband, Mr Aurelio Mazucco, died on 9 January 2018. Dr Mazucco contacted the respondent asking whether the respondent held Mr Mazucco’s will, and making some enquiries about the finalisation of the estate. He arranged to meet the respondent. Shortly after, Dr Mazucco decided to retain other solicitors to deal with the matter. The respondent issued a tax invoice for work done to that stage. On 9 February 2018, Mrs Mazucco spoke by telephone with the respondent. She stated that she did not fully trust her son. They also discussed the topic of the respondent acting in relation to the estate of Mr Mazucco. On 10 February 2018 (a Saturday), the respondent attended at the home of Mrs Mazucco. The respondent gave an unchallenged account of what then occurred. According to the respondent, Mrs Mazucco told the respondent that she wanted him to deal with her husband’s estate, and to make changes to her will and existing EPOA. They discussed the purpose of a will, and considerations associated with making a will, including the need to decide who would benefit from her estate, and who would act as her executor. He explained the requisite qualities for an executor. Mrs Mazucco was able to explain concepts they discussed. She described the estate as monies in the bank and the home. He explained some matters in Italian. He asked questions directed to establishing Mrs Mazucco’s understanding of the concepts they discussed. Mrs Mazucco was attentive throughout the meeting. She gave instructions to include a specific legacy in her will in favour of her granddaughter. She said that she no longer completely trusted her son. She suggested that the respondent might replace her son as executor of the will and as her attorney. The respondent agreed to act as executor, but was not prepared to act as sole attorney. He suggested that her concern could be managed if he acted as her attorney together with her son. He identified reasons for the immediate appointment of an attorney. He also explained that the appointment would remain in effect until it was revoked. He then asked Mrs Mazucco to explain her understanding of the nature and purpose of a will and an EPOA, and the difference between them. She said that she understood that the will was to distribute her assets after her death, and the EPOA was to give someone the responsibility to make decisions during her lifetime, if necessary, in relation to her finances and her health care.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant has not established that the applicant’s notes of his dealings with Mrs Mazucco are such that his conduct has fallen below the standard to be expected of a solicitor.Conclusion on Charge 1 The applicant has failed to establish that the conduct of the respondent fell short of the standard to be expected of a solicitor. The charge is not made out.The Hunter estate charge The respondent was retained to act in the administration of Mrs Hunter’s estate. The allegations in the discipline application were admitted by the respondent. The following matters were thus admitted. The engagement had commenced by July 2011. Final distributions of the estate (or what in truth were wrongly thought to be final distributions) were made on 27 November 2012. The assets of the estate included units in what came to be known as the Charter Hall Direct PFA Fund. The respondent’s client file contained Unitholder Investment Statements for these units dated 31 December 2014, 30 June 2015, 30 June 2016, 31 December 2016, and 28 July 2017. It also contained a quarterly report dated December 2015, which included a notice that investors might participate in a semi-annual withdrawal offer closing on 26 February 2016. The file also included a letter from Charter Hall dated 27 March 2017 stating that monthly distributions could not be paid because valid bank account details had not been provided; and enclosing a form to be completed and returned, setting out that information. The obvious inference is that the respondent’s legal practice received these documents shortly after the dates they bear. On 24 April 2018, one of the executors, Mr Hunter, received an email from the respondent’s firm, advising that units in the fund, not previously available for redemption, could be redeemed up to 27 April 2018. This was the first communication from the respondent’s firm to the executors since 2012. The respondent admitted that he failed to advise the executors about the correspondence received by his office referred to earlier; he failed to advise them of the distributions and to seek instructions about the investment in the Fund; and he failed to give advice and seek instructions about redeeming or withdrawing the investments. This resulted in undue delay in the finalisation of the estate. The applicant contended, and the respondent accepted, that the conduct of the respondent the subject of Charge 2 should be characterised as unsatisfactory professional conduct. Mr Hunter, who appeared at the hearing as a complainant seeking compensation, did not suggest otherwise. The respondent’s failure to attend properly to this matter extended over a number of years, with fresh correspondence obviously arriving on a number of occasions. That is quite concerning. However the hearing has been conducted on the basis that this conduct should be regarded as unsatisfactory professional conduct. In those circumstances, and not without reservation, the conduct will be so characterised.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.