Springfield City Group Pty Ltd v Pipe Networks Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Springfield City Group Pty Ltd v PIPE Networks Pty Ltd [2021] QSC 80

PARTIES:

SPRINGFIELD CITY GROUP PTY LTD

ACN 055 714 531

(plaintiff)

v

PIPE NETWORKS PTY LTD

ACN 099 104 122

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 2798 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

21 April 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 April 2021

JUDGE:

Bond J

ORDER:

The orders of the Court are:

1.   The plaintiff has leave to amend the fourth further amended statement of claim in the manner identified in the draft fifth further amended statement of claim which is exhibit 2 and as further particularised in exhibit 3.

2.   The plaintiff must provide the defendant further particulars of paragraph 2AAAAR of the fifth further amended statement of claim.

3.   The plaintiff has leave to tender at the trial of this proceeding –

a)       the report from Mr O’Shea dated 5 February 2021 (CFI 116);

b)      the Excel workbook setting out the KM Model (exhibit 1);

c)       the supplementary report from Mr O’Shea dated 13 April 2021 (exhibit JGR-10 to the affidavit of Joshua Galvin Robson CFI 125).

4.   Insofar as the defendant advanced objections to the admissibility of parts of the reports based on the insufficiency of the statement of reasons by Mr O’Shea, those objections are overruled.

5.   I will hear the parties on costs and on any further directions which should be made in relation to this proceeding, including in relation to –

a)       the time by which the plaintiff must comply with order 2;

b)      the time by which any further pleadings must be delivered;

c)       any expert opinion evidence to be adduced by the defendant;

d)      joint expert conferences;

e)       the production of a joint expert report; and

f)       further trial dates.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – where the plaintiff seeks leave to amend its fourth further amended statement of claim – where the plaintiff provided a further document which is to be regarded as particulars of the proposed pleading – where, save for one paragraph of the proposed pleading, the defendant did not object to a grant of leave to amend the pleading in the form sought by the plaintiff – where the defendant conceded that its concerns as to the paragraph to which it objected could be remedied by requiring the plaintiff to provide further particulars

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – OPINION EVIDENCE – EXPERT OPINION – GENERALLY – where the plaintiff was previously given leave to file and serve a further report from its expert – where the plaintiff later provided a further “addendum” report from the subject expert – where the defendant agreed in oral argument not to press several of the objections advanced in writing – where the defendant maintained an objection to the admissibility of the reports on the ground that they provided an insufficient statement of the reasoning by which the expert had reached his conclusions – whether the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Springfield City Group Pty Ltd v Pipe Networks Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Springfield City Group Pty Ltd v Pipe Networks Pty Ltd, the plaintiff sought leave to amend its pleadings, specifically its fourth further amended statement of claim, in order to incorporate a new document as particulars of the proposed pleading. The defendant did not object to the grant of leave except for one paragraph of the proposed pleading. The defendant conceded that any concerns about this paragraph could be addressed by requiring the plaintiff to provide further particulars. The court was also required to decide on the admissibility of expert opinion evidence provided by the plaintiff’s expert, Mr O’Shea. The defendant objected to the admissibility of the reports on the grounds that they did not sufficiently explain the reasoning by which the expert reached his conclusions.

The court reasoned that the plaintiff needed to amend its pleadings to reflect the new document, and it granted leave for the amendment with the condition that the plaintiff provide further particulars for the contested paragraph. The court found that the defendant's objections to the expert reports were overruled because the defendant agreed in oral argument not to press several of the written objections. The court concluded that the expert reports did not fail to comply with the statement of reasoning rule, and thus they were admissible.

The court's orders included granting the plaintiff leave to amend its pleadings and to provide further particulars for a specific paragraph. It also allowed the plaintiff to tender the expert reports and the KM Model as evidence. The court overruled the defendant's objections to the admissibility of the reports. Finally, the court scheduled further discussions on costs and additional directions regarding the trial, including deadlines for pleadings, expert evidence, and trial dates.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders of the Court are:

1. The plaintiff has leave to amend the fourth further amended statement of claim in the manner identified in the draft fifth further amended statement of claim which is exhibit 2 and as further particularised in exhibit 3.

2. The plaintiff must provide the defendant further particulars of paragraph 2AAAAR of the fifth further amended statement of claim.

3. The plaintiff has leave to tender at the trial of this proceeding –

a) the report from Mr O’Shea dated 5 February 2021 (CFI 116);

b) the Excel workbook setting out the KM Model (exhibit 1);

c) the supplementary report from Mr O’Shea dated 13 April 2021 (exhibit JGR-10 to the affidavit of Joshua Galvin Robson CFI 125).

4. Insofar as the defendant advanced objections to the admissibility of parts of the reports based on the insufficiency of the statement of reasons by Mr O’Shea, those objections are overruled.

5. I will hear the parties on costs and on any further directions which should be made in relation to this proceeding, including in relation to –

a) the time by which the plaintiff must comply with order 2;

b) the time by which any further pleadings must be delivered;

c) any expert opinion evidence to be adduced by the defendant;

d) joint expert conferences;

e) the production of a joint expert report; and

f) further trial dates.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I explained the nature of the issues which arise in the present proceeding in Springfield City Group Pty Ltd v Pipe Networks Pty Ltd [2020] QSC 395, delivered ex tempore on 20 November 2020. The present reasons will assume the reader is familiar with that judgment (my previous judgment). As I explained in my previous judgment, the plaintiff sought to prove the quantum of its claims for damages and for account of profits by way of the expert opinion evidence of Mr O’Shea, a chartered accountant. Mr O’Shea had appropriate professional qualifications and experience. In order to elicit admissible expert opinion evidence of the nature sought, the plaintiff necessarily had to ask Mr O’Shea to make assumptions about the operational and financial performance of the fibre optic networks concerned, and then to address the questions asked of him by reference to those assumptions. As I explained in my previous judgment, one problem was that a 2019 report of Mr O’Shea proceeded by reference to a particular set of assumptions, but, after the report was produced, the plaintiff made the forensic decision to prove the underlying facts in a completely different way. As a result, the defendant objected to the admissibility of the 2019 report and to relevant parts of the joint report on the basis that the report should be regarded as almost entirely based on obsolete assumptions. I accepted that submission in my previous judgment. The way in which the plaintiff sought to proceed was to ask Mr O’Shea to make assumptions concerning the operational and financial performance of the fibre optic networks concerned by reference to a Scott Schedule entitled “Revenue Data Schedule”. I explained the nature of the Revenue Data Schedule and the information contained in it in my previous judgment and annexed an extract from it. Mr O’Shea prepared a further expert report dated 15 November 2020 based on the instructions that he should assume the truth of the information contained in the Revenue Data Schedule. He used the Revenue Data Schedule as the source of inputs which he made into the mathematical model which he had used for the 2019 report and the joint expert report (albeit based on a different set of inputs). He and the defendant’s expert had previously reached agreement that the mathematical model was to be regarded as a broad framework which was suitable for loss and account of profits calculation purposes. The model, which may be referred to as the KM Model, took the form of an Excel workbook containing a series of individual spreadsheets used to calculate various outcomes. The Revenue Data Schedule was only itself completed on the last working day before the commencement of the trial and Mr O’Shea’s 15 November 2020 report was only produced halfway through the trial. The plaintiff needed leave to rely on that report (and the KM Model which formed part of it) because of the lateness of its production. Leave was opposed, including on the basis of objection to the admissibility of various parts of the report.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.